Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the renters reform bill is going to kill people with allergies?

335 replies

Petallergysufferer · 16/06/2022 07:29

Just that really. I know many people will see this as a good thing. I know too that the severity of allergy to pets which means they can kill you is rare. But it does happen. I am that severely allergic. So if landlords can't give a blanket ban then there are no pet-free properties for me to move into.

For those who don't know - antihistamines make no difference and the only way to get all allergens out of the place is to remove all soft furnishings including carpets and underlay. Deep cleaning things does not work. So unless the landlords change all carpets, curtains, sofas etc. in between tenants, then it still has enough allergens to trigger a life-threatening reaction. For me that reaction is asthma and I already see a hospital specialist so there is no further treatment that can be offered. Avoiding allergens is the key advice. I'm really worried that the full implications have not been thought through.

OP posts:
PAFMO · 16/06/2022 08:32

rivierliedje · 16/06/2022 08:17

I genuinly think it would be better if there was a ban on carpeted rentals (and ideally with a lot of rules in place about how well insulated the flat/house is etc]. It would make such a big difference to asthma/allergy problems which are so numerous here.

Actually, allergy specialists point out constantly that unless hard flooring is kept spotless (as in special vacuuming and washing more than once a day) far more allergens are released into the air than from carpet as carpet (minging though it sounds) kind of absorbs them.

SW1amp · 16/06/2022 08:31

Presumably allergies as severe as yours are incredibly rare, and already mean you can’t ever use public transport, visit pubs, a lot of shops etc

So as inconvenient as it is, you are used to seeking specific (and specialist?) ways to get through day to day life, which would include living in places with hard floors (as most allergy sufferers do anyway) rather than going with the standard way and expecting a small risk of death..?

RedPlumbob · 16/06/2022 08:30

Won’t happen.

They’re not allowed to discriminate against single mothers, but they will always choose the working couples with kids over the working single mothers, and there’s fuck all anyone can do about it.

They’ll just do the same with people with pets. Choose the ones without pets.

eurochick · 16/06/2022 08:29

Studies show growing up with pets reduces the incidence of allergies so maybe think of it as being a benefit for the allergy community overall.

riesenrad · 16/06/2022 08:29

I think it's wrong that landlords will be more or less compelled to accept pets. Their house, their rules (within reason but I don't think it's unreasonable for people not to want pets, or certain types of pets, in their properties). It also depends ln the type of property. If you are renting out a large house with a big garden it is more unreasonable to say no pets than if you are renting out a flat with no outside space.

But there may be some landlords who have long-term tenants whose policy is no pets, but the tenant wants a pet, and they may allow it because they trust those tenants and have a good relationship with them.

Guide dogs are different anyway because they are very well trained. That doesn't necessarily help the allergy issue but you do know they won't trash the place. I'd allow rabbits and guinea pigs too. You can't really ban cats as they adopt people Grin

Thehop · 16/06/2022 08:29

Itsbackagain · 16/06/2022 07:36

You should be more worried about the amount of LL that are about to sell up tbh.

This.

m we had rented out the small terraces we lived in before we moved in together. Small terraces in Yorkshire, cheap rent and looked after them really well. Remnants had pets, decorated and were made to feel it was their home.

we’ve had to sell as the new laws (not just this one) have frightened us enough thy we just don’t feel we can afford to keep up. So that’s 2 lovely 3 bed houses for less than £500 a month gone from the rental pool that’s already decimated.

Eeksteek · 16/06/2022 08:28

Petallergysufferer · 16/06/2022 07:39

The renters reform bill will stop them being able to have a blanket pet-free clause so they will have no choice.

Of course they will have a choice. They can’t advertise ‘no pets’ but they can choose renters without pets over those with. All things being equal, many would.

But even then, there’s no guarantees. Landlords don’t replace everything when they buy a property. And even people who didn’t have their own pets will often have had visiting ones.

I am allergic to grass. I’ve been hospitalised with it, and so has my daughter. And I cannot be on any higher medication than I am. Should I be insisting there are lawn free properties available? It’s not reasonable to accept society to accommodate me, here. I just have to accept that I will have to modify a garden and put it back as I found it. It sucks, but there it is.

I do sympathise, but it’s a social norm and the people who will benefit from the no pets clause far outnumber yourself. You are, quite literally, the only person I’ve ever heard of with pet allergies so severe that deep cleaning won’t suffice, so to expect a whole country to accolade them is not reasonable or even possible.

startrek90 · 16/06/2022 08:28

I have a question for the landlords on here.... Why do landlords ban children/kick tenants out if they get pregnant? I have never understood that one and would genuinely want to know. A ban on pets I can kind of see but honestly the ban on children baffles me.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 16/06/2022 08:27

No I don't think it will kill anyone. Landlords can still choose to go with people without pets, if they wish to. There will still be a property for you to rent. If your allergy is that severe though I do wonder how you manage to work etc, as dog owners especially, usually have pet hairs on them. You could be next to someone with pet hairs on the train/bus or in the queue at a shop etc.

Hugasauras · 16/06/2022 08:25

I think you never really know whether pets have been in a house or not. Plenty of people have pets in rental properties even though it says no pets. Cats/small animals in particular are easy to get rid of for an hour or so for inspections just by sticking them in a cat box in the car or something!

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 16/06/2022 08:23

If your allergy is that bad, what do you do about working alongside people who do own animals? I own animals, I know no matter how much I clean my clothes their damn hairs still stick to them. That would surely be enough to set your allergy off given how bad it sounds?

PAFMO · 16/06/2022 08:22

Jalisco · 16/06/2022 08:14

Actually, I'm sorry to say that you are coming across as rather nasty. I'm sorry that you have a serious allergy. Lot's of people have serious health conditions, but they recognise that everything doesn't revolve around their personal circumstances. If you had bothered to read the information available the intention is to end the blanket ban on pets, not refusing landlords the right to refuse pets. They can still refuse pets, but they must have considered reasons. The exact same applies to children - which you claimed otherwise. If a landlord wishes to ban children they must have a good reason. So there will still be plenty of properties for you to rent.

What it seems is that you are not prepared to allow for anyone to have rights if those rights even theoretically impinge on your own perceptions of what you might want. That's selfish. I am sorry you have a serious health condition. So do I. But I don't expect the world to revolve around me.

Well said.

If the OP's allergy is that severe (as others have said, to be so allergic you can't even live in a property that once had a cat in it is as rare as a very rare thing) then appropriate housing would be facilitated by the local authorities

SilverPeacock · 16/06/2022 08:21

That must be difficult OP. As PP have pointed out though how is it possible to guarantee that there has not been a pet somewhere? I know people who had pets in rented properties when they were not supposed to.

Catfeatured · 16/06/2022 08:18

No, it just says there has to be a good reason to refuse rather than a blanket ban.

If you think people in apparently pet free homes now, don’t sneakily keep pets or have pet visitors you are mistaken.

Sorry to hear about your life threatening allergy but unfortunately the rest of society can’t stop keeping much loved animals because of you.

rivierliedje · 16/06/2022 08:17

I genuinly think it would be better if there was a ban on carpeted rentals (and ideally with a lot of rules in place about how well insulated the flat/house is etc]. It would make such a big difference to asthma/allergy problems which are so numerous here.

Jalisco · 16/06/2022 08:14

Petallergysufferer · 16/06/2022 07:58

Well fine but that's clearly not what I saying is it? But you carry on feeling superior.

Actually, I'm sorry to say that you are coming across as rather nasty. I'm sorry that you have a serious allergy. Lot's of people have serious health conditions, but they recognise that everything doesn't revolve around their personal circumstances. If you had bothered to read the information available the intention is to end the blanket ban on pets, not refusing landlords the right to refuse pets. They can still refuse pets, but they must have considered reasons. The exact same applies to children - which you claimed otherwise. If a landlord wishes to ban children they must have a good reason. So there will still be plenty of properties for you to rent.

What it seems is that you are not prepared to allow for anyone to have rights if those rights even theoretically impinge on your own perceptions of what you might want. That's selfish. I am sorry you have a serious health condition. So do I. But I don't expect the world to revolve around me.

OperationRinka · 16/06/2022 08:13

SmileyClare · 16/06/2022 08:05

An allergy like yours is incredibly rare. The number of deaths due to pet allergy in the UK is zero.
It is possible to die from anaphylactic shock but again this is rarely triggered by pet allergy and sufferers should carry Epi pens and or take anti allergen medication if they're aware of their condition.

In summary, no I don't think anyone will be killed by the rental reform.

Also true. The number of hypothetical deaths from this measure are dwarfed by the equally hypothetical number of deaths prevented due to pets' mental health support or additional exercise imposed on vulnerable pet owners (sedentary lifestyles are one of the biggest killers in this country).

onthefencesitter · 16/06/2022 08:13

You can look for a flat which prohibits pets in the lease. We own a flat where animals are allowed but that's because the residents own the freehold (and most seem to be pet owners!) My DH doesn't like dogs and would probably prefer to live in a development where dogs are not allowed but I try to look for pet friendly developments as I have a hamster.

tabulahrasa · 16/06/2022 08:11

Why are you assuming lifting a blanket ban on pets means every rented property will have had a pet in it?

SaltandPepper22 · 16/06/2022 08:11

I feel for you OP and I do see your point. I have a pet allergy as does DP (nowhere near as severe as yours but it does make life uncomfortable) and we get frustrated when, for example, someone had clearly allowed a dog to sleep on a bed in a holiday let last year.

And whilst I totally get your concerns, what would you do if you were buying a house?

In reality I doubt very much that there won’t be a scenario where landlords can work around the new rules to still not allow pets so I wouldn’t worry about it too much - there will probable still be lots of pet free options.

onthefencesitter · 16/06/2022 08:10

You can look for a flat which prohibits

Lunar27 · 16/06/2022 08:06

Discovereads · 16/06/2022 08:00

I don’t think YABU as I am allergic to pets too. I think LLs should be able to specify no pets in their properties. Having an animal live with you isn’t a human right imho and shouldn’t be treated as such.

And it’s bonkers to me that LLs can still say no children, but can’t say no pets? Surely discrimination against children is objectively more of a problem than discrimination against dogs/cats/Guinea pigs? it’s not like you can rehome a child!

That said, I think you will have to look for rentals with hard flooring- tile, wood, and no carpets. We have allergies and asthma in our family too and that’s one thing we look for in a rental is no to minimum carpets.

Definitely this.

My tenants contacted me to advise that they were expecting. They were worried that I might kick them out as this had happened to their friends.

I knew about the rules but was still sad that they were so worried about it. It's a ridiculous situation TBH and the last thing you want to worry about when expecting.

OperationRinka · 16/06/2022 08:06

I'm not sure of the details about how this will operate. If you can't ask people about their pet plans or penalise them for lying then landlords can't discriminate in favour of pet less applicants. And I can't see any way to prevent people getting pets once they're in. (Except for exemptions as below).

It looks as if landlords will be able to get a certificate of exemption on the grounds of medical or religious requirement (either theirs or other tenants) or if the home is unsuitable for certain animals/breeds (so a seventh floor flat might state "nothing larger than a dachshund").

SmileyClare · 16/06/2022 08:05

An allergy like yours is incredibly rare. The number of deaths due to pet allergy in the UK is zero.
It is possible to die from anaphylactic shock but again this is rarely triggered by pet allergy and sufferers should carry Epi pens and or take anti allergen medication if they're aware of their condition.

In summary, no I don't think anyone will be killed by the rental reform.

FawnFrenchieMum · 16/06/2022 08:04

What happens if you sit next to someone at work / in a restaurant / on the bus who has just had their dog climbing all over them? Assume you also next holiday, travel in taxi etc as well in case they have had them there?

Swipe left for the next trending thread