Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the renters reform bill is going to kill people with allergies?

335 replies

Petallergysufferer · 16/06/2022 07:29

Just that really. I know many people will see this as a good thing. I know too that the severity of allergy to pets which means they can kill you is rare. But it does happen. I am that severely allergic. So if landlords can't give a blanket ban then there are no pet-free properties for me to move into.

For those who don't know - antihistamines make no difference and the only way to get all allergens out of the place is to remove all soft furnishings including carpets and underlay. Deep cleaning things does not work. So unless the landlords change all carpets, curtains, sofas etc. in between tenants, then it still has enough allergens to trigger a life-threatening reaction. For me that reaction is asthma and I already see a hospital specialist so there is no further treatment that can be offered. Avoiding allergens is the key advice. I'm really worried that the full implications have not been thought through.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GCRich · 21/06/2022 17:43

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/06/2022 21:03

That’s not how my ds or dss did it,

They graduated, got job, came home, saved for deposit, and now can’t get anything because of landlords and investors.

It sound like they are lucky that your home is ner good graduate jobs - that isn;t true of many people. Also many kids have been brought up to be independent and cannot think of anything worse than living with their parents when they have experienced independent life - in some ways yours are lucky to have been brought up like they have, in others I pity them.

I would blame the deliberate enrichment of the rich at the expense of poor people and the lower and upper middle classes, by the Tories, since 1980, for your children's plight personally.

Petallergysufferer · 20/06/2022 13:00

Oh no it did not come off badly and sorry if my reply made it feel like it did. I think therapy for anyone who is living with a condition which could kill them is never a bad thing to mull over. I just meant that in addition there need to be practical solutions to manage the real risk. I feel guilty more than anything after admissions or outpatient usage as I worry that I could have done something differently and avoided using out stretched NHS as much as I did. It is always a tricky call and I'm glad to have specialists helping me think through when is the time to come in. I just do my best to follow their advice to the letter. My adherence to meds is second to none which is a great start. Nothing like a life-threatening deterioration to keep you on track with that though! I hope your therapy is helpful for you. It sounds like you have a great deal to process.

OP posts:
Innocenta · 20/06/2022 10:25

I truly do not mean to suggest therapy as a bad thing, though of course it's also fine to decide against it - I am in therapy myself with a private therapist to help me cope with my conditions, including the impact of how traumatic it can be to have life threatening impacts arise suddenly. I truly know where you're coming from about under estimating the dangers at times because you feel like you can deal with it, as you're used to self managing. That happens to me too and I've also been told I ought to come in sooner. Often I end up feeling really bad (emotionally/mentally) after my admissions when the extent of the danger hits me, so that's part of why I suggested therapy. I'm so sorry if it came off badly because I genuinely didn't mean it in any negative way xx

Petallergysufferer · 20/06/2022 10:10

Innocenta · 20/06/2022 08:56

Reading between the lines... you've never actually been intubated for allergy or asthma. I believe you that your allergy is severe, but I don't think from what you've described that your actual medical history warrants the level of anxiety you're expressing. Speaking as someone with severe asthma and multiple allergies myself (including anaphylaxis). Of course I agree you need to avoid the allergens, but I would also encourage you to seek some support (maybe a private psychotherapist), because dealing with the stress of conditions like these that you don't have control over is really hard. I wonder if this bill has kind of brought things to a head for you? x

I think this is a kind post, thank you. It has made me hugely anxious. You're right I've never been intubated - I have said that before on this thread but I know it's very long now. I don't think I need therapy. I know I have a condition which could kill me but probably won't as long as I can avoid allergens. That said, my asthma hospital specialist has said that I have been at risk of death before and that I needed to seek treatment more quickly. Apparently those who die most from asthma are not actually the ones who are chronically unwell on a day to day basis but the ones with brittle asthma who have self-managed most symptoms for years and therefore tend to get to hospital too late to do anything. I've been following my asthma plan more closely since hearing that and I think she's right tbh. When you've lived for 40 years with a condition which causes your peak flow to halve on a regular basis, you tend to see that as a run of the mill attack and not the life threatening situation that it is. I.e. my hospital consultant thinks it does level this level of anxiety.

I do this automatically throughout life now and the biggest issue with that is dealing with the 'friends' reactions when it's clear they think I've over-reacting by turning down a dinner invite because they have a cat, for example. However, if I can't find a place to live which is animal free than no amount of therapy is going to make any difference. For me the issue is that society does not see the need to build in some 'blanket ban' places in order to protect tenants. It's not OK imo to rely on tenants being able to find a place which has exemption because of landlord health or to expect us all to move to places where housing stock allows hard floors as run of the mill.

OP posts:
Innocenta · 20/06/2022 08:56

Reading between the lines... you've never actually been intubated for allergy or asthma. I believe you that your allergy is severe, but I don't think from what you've described that your actual medical history warrants the level of anxiety you're expressing. Speaking as someone with severe asthma and multiple allergies myself (including anaphylaxis). Of course I agree you need to avoid the allergens, but I would also encourage you to seek some support (maybe a private psychotherapist), because dealing with the stress of conditions like these that you don't have control over is really hard. I wonder if this bill has kind of brought things to a head for you? x

Petallergysufferer · 20/06/2022 08:49

@gonnascreamsoon Your post is so patronising. Some people have posted ridiculously silly suggestions and not to take them is not evidence of not taking responsibility. You posted unhelpful links and are now hiding behind some silly 'there must be better links out there if you have the time to find them '. Well I have looked and I don't believe there is any help out there though I'd be delighted if someone knew something I didn't and shared actually helpful 'help'. Your assumption that if I've not found anything that means I've not done the work is not pleasant. What makes you assume that suitable resources are out there?

Are you suggesting btw that if someone is living in a place full of allergens and is repeatedly admitted and saved by medical treatment, this makes their situation OK? This means there is no problem in a housing market which does not protect some homes for renters with allergies? Bit of a roger irrelevant comment tbh.

Just because you want to believe there is a simple answer out there and the world is full of people who just refuse to find them, that does not make it true.

OP posts:
gonnascreamsoon · 20/06/2022 06:51

@Petallergysufferer

My first post was posted to encourage you to take responsibility in finding solutions for yourself to help with your housing worries. I.e Put your big girl pants on and start trying to find solutions instead of having a 'pity party' about it, and lots of other posters have been trying to give you the same advice.

However you appear hell bent on dismissing 95% of 'suggestions' or 'help' as 'useless' and keep bleating 'you don't get it' or 'you don't understand' etc which isn't helping yourself, is it ?

I apologize if the links were not suitable for you, but they were only the result of a 30 second Google (as I have never had to look for this kind of help for myself, and people who need this kind of financial help either find it themselves (through citizens advice etc who could certainly help you find any help available for you locally), or have social workers etc to signpost them to available resources) I had stated that you would need to put in the 'legwork' to find suitable resources (which are out there) in your area. (As everyone with any kind of 'disability' or housing issue has to do for themselves unfortunately)

I can also reassure you that I DO soo get it (as you put it), and as I am a fellow 'sufferer' of severe allergies, and I also work as a medical professional, I so 'get' the differences between Status/Anaphylaxis etc and understand the differences in 'severity' of cases with 'seconds' to live if not given correct treatment, and more common or 'basic' emergency treatment with IV Aminophylline for a severe exacerbation of symptoms etc

As I said in my previous post, I hope you find a lovely place to live, and that you can source the financial help you need locally.

dollybird · 19/06/2022 06:59

DuggeeHugPlease · 18/06/2022 22:32

My first flat (which I mortgaged) had a condition in the leasehold that no pets were allowed. That applies to all residents whether they rented or bought so presumably any landlords with flats in buildings like this could still state no pets as that is not their decision but a condition of the leasehold.

I wonder whether the proposed changes mean that leaseholds would not be able to have a blanket ban on pets also? Our doesn't. It says unless agreed with the landlord, and then certain stipulations might apply.

DuggeeHugPlease · 18/06/2022 22:32

My first flat (which I mortgaged) had a condition in the leasehold that no pets were allowed. That applies to all residents whether they rented or bought so presumably any landlords with flats in buildings like this could still state no pets as that is not their decision but a condition of the leasehold.

Petallergysufferer · 18/06/2022 22:15

I'm not sure that helps as the difficulties don't arise as much unless around allergens. I can't move to a place infested with dander and and ask for help as by then it's too late. But I'll look into the disabled persons grant foe future reference though it does say to continue to live there and not before you move in there

OP posts:
TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 18/06/2022 21:27

If you have any condition that is causing significant difficulties in everyday life (ie existing in your own home) you are entitled to help. You would have medical records from your GP and hospital proving how severe your allergies are and the risks you face if it is not cleaned/furnished the way you need. You would get in touch with your council and present this evidence. We don't all have the same easy tick box disabilities, there is no special fund for ramps for example. Each time someone is helped by the council to be housed suitably due to disability it is looked at individually. There are all manner of adaptions and help that people need just to live in their homes. They are all assessed individually.

I can't say how your particular council will deal with your needs, but if they're unhelpful you can take it to your MP or ask your doctors for further reports or letters, citizens advice bureau may help and shelter. It's not always easy, people with disabilities are sometimes waiting a long time for help that never comes unfortunately. But if you need it, you need it and it's your council's responsibility to help you get it.

"If you’ve been assessed by your local council as needing care and support services, you may want to choose Direct Payments. They allow you to buy in and arrange help yourself instead of receiving it directly from your local council."

You would not be the first person to need help with cleaning.

"Disabled Facilities Grants are local council grants. It helps towards the cost of essential adaptations to your home to enable you to continue to live there"

Or the first person to need help with appropriate furnishings.

www.gov.uk/financial-help-disabled/home-and-housing

Petallergysufferer · 18/06/2022 18:14

OperationRinka · 18/06/2022 17:59

What you're missing OP is that you're still insisting that these proposals mean that it will be impossible to hire a formerly pet free home, when there's nothing whatsoever to make that the case.

There are specific provisions in the bill to enable some landlords to have permanently pet free properties. Or you can simply ask whether the previous tenants had pets when you look to hire a property. Yes you'll probably have less choice, as a trade off for pet owners having more choice, but you won't have no choice, and you're really not going to die.

It will be reassuring if that turns out to be the case as it's genuinely terrifying to hear that there is a blanket 'pets allowed' policy. I don't mind less choice, that's a reasonable compromise. No choice is terrifying.

OP posts:
Petallergysufferer · 18/06/2022 18:12

Can I share websites? This one which I think is a solicitors appears to say that severe life-threatening allergies (i.e. mine) are a disability

howarths-uk.com/2016/07/19/allergy-or-disability/

OP posts:
Petallergysufferer · 18/06/2022 18:09

Gooseberrypies · 18/06/2022 17:52

I actually am disabled and it’s not the same. Nice try though.

Can you tell me why not? genuinely interested and willing to change my view.

OP posts:
OperationRinka · 18/06/2022 17:59

What you're missing OP is that you're still insisting that these proposals mean that it will be impossible to hire a formerly pet free home, when there's nothing whatsoever to make that the case.

There are specific provisions in the bill to enable some landlords to have permanently pet free properties. Or you can simply ask whether the previous tenants had pets when you look to hire a property. Yes you'll probably have less choice, as a trade off for pet owners having more choice, but you won't have no choice, and you're really not going to die.

Gooseberrypies · 18/06/2022 17:52

Petallergysufferer · 16/06/2022 20:18

Would you use the term pander to talk about other adjustments for disabled people?

I actually am disabled and it’s not the same. Nice try though.

Petallergysufferer · 18/06/2022 17:42

I guess we could turn this on it's head and say that as people on this thread want to see re-flooring and deep anti-allergy cleaning, we could ask pet owners to do that when they leave a property.

OP posts:
Petallergysufferer · 18/06/2022 17:36

TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 18/06/2022 17:25

You don't need to be on benefits or out of work to get help finding a house that you medically need.

There should be a fund for people with serious allergies to claim for the cost of a deep clean when they move in if they're unable to fund that themselves (don't underestimate how much this would cost and don't confuse this with a normal end of lease clean). This sits alongside disability benefits as will be needed by many people who appropriately aren't entitled to usual disability benefits.

You mean like the fund the local authority could award you if you applied? You believe you will die if you rent the wrong house but you're also sure you don't have a disability.

Why do you so want this to be an everybody issue when it's clearly a you (and maybe 10 in this country) issue?

No that's not what I said. I think I do have a disability but I don't think the current system allows me to claim for this as it rightly expects me to take some personal responsibility and avoid allergens. The new proposals will, at face value, mean I can't any more.

I honestly can't find a fund which would allow cleaning of a property before I moved in but it you do know of one in England can you share a link? You may have solved the problem with this if I and others in my position are assessed as eligible! and if we're not maybe we need to try and persuade some allergy organisations to campaign for that to be the case.

You really think this is 10 people?! Really!!! Wow!!! This is 1000s of people.

OP posts:
TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 18/06/2022 17:25

You don't need to be on benefits or out of work to get help finding a house that you medically need.

There should be a fund for people with serious allergies to claim for the cost of a deep clean when they move in if they're unable to fund that themselves (don't underestimate how much this would cost and don't confuse this with a normal end of lease clean). This sits alongside disability benefits as will be needed by many people who appropriately aren't entitled to usual disability benefits.

You mean like the fund the local authority could award you if you applied? You believe you will die if you rent the wrong house but you're also sure you don't have a disability.

Why do you so want this to be an everybody issue when it's clearly a you (and maybe 10 in this country) issue?

monkeysox · 18/06/2022 17:12

I'm a former landlord who is allergic to pets and we.didnt allow pets due to that.

I wouldn't have been able to go into my own property.

Agree op. Even deep cleaning doesn't fully get rid of the allergens.
People without allergies don't understand

Petallergysufferer · 18/06/2022 17:10

dreamingofsun · 18/06/2022 13:20

petallergysufferer - some of your suggestions would contravene the leasehold of our flat - not having pets; and no hardwood floors on all but the ground floor ones. I think they have both been put in place to keep the block as quiet at possible for the other flatholders. So the leaseholds would all need to be updated and all the flatholders would potentially have to accept more noise, which might not be great for everyone

yes that would be a problem in older properties and not workable I think. Noise pollution should not be the solution as it's hugely impactful on people's wellbeing. There just seem to be a lot of people on this thread who think hard floors are an easy answer.

OP posts:
Petallergysufferer · 18/06/2022 17:09

And btw assuming that people have not nearly died because they've not suffered anaphylaxis or been intubated just makes you look ignorant.

OP posts:
Petallergysufferer · 18/06/2022 17:08

@gonnascreamsoon
You really need to stop shouting at people. it's hugely unpleasant. You soooo don't get this. I am very happy to take responsibility and have spent my life doing so. However, this new rule will make it impossible as I take responsibility by seeking out places which have a no pet rule. Not sure why that's so complicated for you to get.

Your links are a joke. One of them is in America. The allergy one says nothing useful and the BHF one makes it clear that I am not eligible as none of these apply:

You might be eligible to claim benefits if you meet one or more of the following criteria:
have care or mobility needs because of your lung condition
cannot work due to your lung condition
are thinking of giving up work because of your lung condition
care for someone with a lung condition.

The people with physical disabilities you mention are often eligible for benefits and rightly so.

People with allergies can often lead normal lives when they avoid allergens. Saying it is my responsibility to pay 1000's so other people can have a pet in any single rental home rather than keeping some for me and the 1000s of others this will be a problem for makes you look like a total dick tbh. what bubble are you living in where you can negotiate with a landlord?

OP posts:
orbitalcrisis · 18/06/2022 16:31

Could you not just find a rental that hasn't previously housed fluffy animals? Just an idea.

gonnascreamsoon · 18/06/2022 16:26

OP I think you're being a bit 'dramatic' about the whole thing tbh !

Yes, I get that your allergies impact your life.

But I think you're being ridiculous to suggest that 'society' needs to change things, simply to help you (And the very small numbers of people similarly affected).

YOU are responsible for FINDING a way to get round the issues you face.

i.e Save money to pay for deep clean pre moving in/replacing flooring, or move to live in an area where hard flooring/laminate is the 'norm' if you're having difficulty finding a flat without carpets !

The extra cost of this IS your 'responsibility' ffs ! Just as it's YOUR responsibility to pay for all your medications ! Because it's YOUR bloody HEALTH ! Not mine ! Or anybody else's ! It's YOURS !

Tens of thousands of people live their lives with disabilities/ allergies/ medical conditions that cost them more money every single bloody day !
e.g People who can't use stairs. Wheelchair bound people. Blind people. Deaf people. People who need help to eat/ sleep/ work/ toilet etc. People who can't use public transport. People who are allergic to pets/ foods/ chemicals/ materials etc. And they ALL have extra problems/ issues and costs. They ALL have to 'negotiate' difficulties in their daily lives. And most of them just crack on and get things sorted themselves.

And given you've never suffered an anaphylaxis or been ventilated, you're FAR from even being the worst affected with your allergies ! (But that's NOT said to 'minimize' your condition, because I know it IS serious. It just ain't as bad as it CAN get ! e.g Immediate anaphylaxis to ANY airborne particles !) But you seem set on the 'pity party'/ poor me/ you just don't understand...!

Lots of us (with conditions/disabilities/allergies) DO bloody well 'get it', and we DO 'understand', but you've got to accept that because WE are in a VERY small 'minority' of the population, we're never going to be able to access everything that most people take for granted ! It's NOT economically OR socially 'viable', and NEVER WILL BE ! (Also, severe/brittle asthma IS a disability. It affects your daily living and places restrictions on where you can go and what you can do !)

So, we have to help ourselves.

I'd advise you to find out about charities/ grants etc which may be available to you to help with the cost of replacing flooring/ cleaning etc so that you can start helping yourself to get suitable housing ? ( You may find that if you look for a flat with crappy/worn flooring, you could 'negotiate' with the landlord for a rent reduction if you replace the flooring etc, which may be doable with some financial help ? Then even if they want carpets in, they will be brand new with zero pet dander ?) You may also get benefits which would help you financially. Help for work (If a problem arises) etc etc A very quick Google throws up ;

www.allergyuk.org/

www.blf.org.uk/support-for-you/welfare-benefits

www.disability-benefits-help.org/disabling-conditions/allergies

Hopefully you will find/ be able to access some help by doing your research and applying for any help you may be eligible for. You may well have local organisations who can help you too, but you're going to have to put in the 'legwork' to find what's available for you.

I wish you the very best, and hope you can find somewhere lovely to live.