Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to being backup childcare?

196 replies

Lolabear38 · 16/06/2022 05:16

I’m a SAHM. I have two children - one 4 and one under 1. Most of my friends work and their kids are in school/ daycare of some sort. My dd (4) goes to nursery part time and ds (1) is at home with me.

In the past, if close friends’ childcare plans have fallen through/ there’s been some kind of emergency, they’ve called me knowing I’ll likely be free to help out and I’ve happily done so, assuming it was a one-off. My issue is that recently I feel like they’ve been taking advantage a bit and calling me more and more frequently to help out with childcare. In the last 2 weeks alone I’ve been called 3 times by two different friends to help out with childcare - one time was picking up from school and dropping home but twice involved having their kids for the whole afternoon.

I feel like I’m being taken advantage of here - if it’s a genuine emergency then of course I would help out like anyone else would, but I never signed up for or offered to be a backup childcare person! I feel like it’s a slippery slope… the more I say yes when they call the more they start relying on me and assuming I can do it.

However… and here’s where I’m wondering if IABU - I am a SAHM and I am often at home with my kids, and able to help out if needed (not saying anything about other sahm’s here, literally just talking about my own situation). If a friend called and said they needed childcare for their kids and technically I could do it then I would feel bad saying no… but sometimes I just don’t want to 🤷🏻‍♀️ especially as it seems to be getting more and more frequent. I like being at home with my kids and sometimes having someone else’s around too is a pain in the bum.

One ‘frequent flyer’ mum has half heartedly said that she’ll have my kids for a bit on a weekend if I wanted to go out with DH or something but ds is bf on demand so it’s not that easy for me to go out at the moment anyway.

I’m toying with the idea of telling them I’m not happy to be a backup childcare option unless it’s a genuine emergency (like someone’s in hospital etc!) but I really was just wondering if I’m being unreasonable here!? Interested to hear some thoughts on this.

I know how lucky I am to be a sahm and I can see how hard it is for working parents to organize childcare, and sometimes things come up. But I also feel like it’s not very fair to just assume I will look after their kids whenever they need it just because I’m not in a paid job at the moment 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
Islandgirl68 · 17/06/2022 09:10

Gosh this is a tricky one. I don't see a problem with helping out, if they are grateful and return the favour, like maybe babysit one night or at the weekend. Once you are not BF, you coukd take up the offers. I have had friends take advantage of my good nature in similar situations and a very good friend that wanted to pay me, but I refused, as our kids were friends, we were friends, and my child had a playmate for the afternoon every week. But at the end of each term she would give me a white stuff voucher, which meant I felt appreciated for helping out. But if it is all one sided, maybe you need to say something. Good luck

JudgeRindersMinder · 17/06/2022 09:03

TeenPlusCat · 16/06/2022 05:54

YANBU. You are a SAHM. You take a financial hit for the good of your family, not to be a regular backup childcare. If you want to help occasionally that's up to you, but you should not feel obliged.

I came to say exactly this. I had similar when my kids were young (I worked evenings rather than SAHM but it’s the same principle)

I hit my limit when a neighbour’s kid was sent home unwell, I was the backup because she couldn’t be contacted by school. I then saw her photos and post on FB about her lovely day out with her boyfriend with their phones switched off. I actually contacted the school to make sure I was removed as her kids’ emergency contact

LookItsMeAgain · 17/06/2022 08:59

@Lolabear38 - let us know how you get on when you get your next request to look after someone's kids and you remember the advice on this thread and say no to them. Hopefully all they will say is "Ok then".

namnamnam22 · 17/06/2022 08:34

@WimpoleHat absolutely!!!! The funny thing is, I’ve just been made redundant and currently can’t find another job because my baby hasn’t gotten a nursery place yet hence being a SAHM for a while! Whereas old job was very flexible with hours, unfortunate they were just sending all the jobs offshore

WimpoleHat · 17/06/2022 08:19

namnamnam22 · 16/06/2022 23:58

@Lolabear38 im in a similar situation, just recently became a SAHM and my SIL has exhausted all her other babysitting options and is hinting for me to take our niece 3 days a week during summer, niece is VERY high maintenance for a 4 year old so I’ve made up a lot of imaginary weekly plans for me and my baby 😂 and I do NOT feel guilty at all!

Let me guess @namnamnam22 - your SIL
works three days a week? So basically she
expects you to work for her for free while she goes and gets paid to do something else? Think of it like that and you’ll see just how egregious that is. That’s not an emergency, that’s deliberate piss taking. How is that any different from you saying to her “Money will be tight over the summer as I’m not working now - please will you give me £100 a week?”.

Meraas · 17/06/2022 08:11

Pheasantplucker2 · 17/06/2022 05:22

As someone who was a sahm for years and now has kids at secondary, please be aware that, in many cases, the mum friends you make at primary school gate are situational. Yes there will be the odd friend who becomes a genuine lifelong friend, but as playground allegiances change, it’s surprising how your child falling out with another can lead to a massive distancing from the parents.

The friendships when your kids are small feel like genuine, often quite intense friendships, but as the years go on and kids go off to different schools and friends, they fade or sometimes are abruptly severed.

I thought it was just me but having chatted to quite a few people now, it’s rare to keep those adult friendships going as everyone moves on to different stages in life.

So enjoy the time with your kids, put your own boundaries in place and say no without guilt. These people are unlikely to be in your life long term. If they are, and it’s a genuine friendship, they won’t mind you saying no. But from the lack of reciprocity or acknowledgment that it’s a big ask, I suspect they’re transactional friends - they see you as a convenient help. When you say no several times they’ll get the message and move onto someone else.

Very sensible advice.

N1no · 17/06/2022 08:03

I think it’s best to have an open discussion and to give your friends the opportunity to find appropriate childcare rather than wait until a situation arises where they need picking up and saying that you are unavailable.
You could also offer it as a paid emergency services or by letting them look after your DC. You don’t need to go out. I find it very helpful to have a few hours to do uninterrupted paperwork or cleaning and tidying.

ZekeZeke · 17/06/2022 08:00

namnamnam22 · 16/06/2022 23:58

@Lolabear38 im in a similar situation, just recently became a SAHM and my SIL has exhausted all her other babysitting options and is hinting for me to take our niece 3 days a week during summer, niece is VERY high maintenance for a 4 year old so I’ve made up a lot of imaginary weekly plans for me and my baby 😂 and I do NOT feel guilty at all!

3 days a week isn't babysitting. That's childcare.
The hinting would drive me bonkers.
Don't even suggest you can help in an emergency, this is a CF in the making.

howshouldibehave · 17/06/2022 07:46

namnamnam22 · 16/06/2022 23:58

@Lolabear38 im in a similar situation, just recently became a SAHM and my SIL has exhausted all her other babysitting options and is hinting for me to take our niece 3 days a week during summer, niece is VERY high maintenance for a 4 year old so I’ve made up a lot of imaginary weekly plans for me and my baby 😂 and I do NOT feel guilty at all!

3 days a week?!

Has she ever thought of investigating..oh, what’s it called…-paid childcare?!

KittyKittyKat · 17/06/2022 07:46

You will damage the friendship if you’re seen to refuse to help. So I’d go with “we’re just off swimming, sorry I won’t be able to do pick up”.

ImAvingOops · 17/06/2022 07:23

YY to what @Pheasantplucker2 said. I am only genuine friends with one of the numerous women I used to speak to every day at Primary school, now that my dd is in secondary. And she has a completely different friend group to the kids she was close to when little.

Pheasantplucker2 · 17/06/2022 05:22

As someone who was a sahm for years and now has kids at secondary, please be aware that, in many cases, the mum friends you make at primary school gate are situational. Yes there will be the odd friend who becomes a genuine lifelong friend, but as playground allegiances change, it’s surprising how your child falling out with another can lead to a massive distancing from the parents.

The friendships when your kids are small feel like genuine, often quite intense friendships, but as the years go on and kids go off to different schools and friends, they fade or sometimes are abruptly severed.

I thought it was just me but having chatted to quite a few people now, it’s rare to keep those adult friendships going as everyone moves on to different stages in life.

So enjoy the time with your kids, put your own boundaries in place and say no without guilt. These people are unlikely to be in your life long term. If they are, and it’s a genuine friendship, they won’t mind you saying no. But from the lack of reciprocity or acknowledgment that it’s a big ask, I suspect they’re transactional friends - they see you as a convenient help. When you say no several times they’ll get the message and move onto someone else.

sleepingophelia · 17/06/2022 00:15

Hell to the NO to being an unofficial childminder for one-way streets who don't have your best interests in mind and are leeching off your good nature!

Lunarpsychobitch · 17/06/2022 00:13

They are taking liberties and saving themselves a fortune on childcare into the bargain. I assume you also provide refreshments for their children when you look after them.

I'd be 'unavailable' now and again or say you can have the children but only for a specified time as you've other plans later on, until they get the hint OR -

You could be really sneaky and say you're considering registering as a childminder to generate some additional income, and ask if they would use you 😉

namnamnam22 · 16/06/2022 23:58

@Lolabear38 im in a similar situation, just recently became a SAHM and my SIL has exhausted all her other babysitting options and is hinting for me to take our niece 3 days a week during summer, niece is VERY high maintenance for a 4 year old so I’ve made up a lot of imaginary weekly plans for me and my baby 😂 and I do NOT feel guilty at all!

KosherDill · 16/06/2022 23:40

"You know, I receive so many of these requests I've decided to turn it into a business. 20 an hour with an upfront deposit of 100. Would you like my bank details?"

KosherDill · 16/06/2022 23:31

Notcoolright · 16/06/2022 19:11

I looked after the children of another mother in one of my DD's classes 3 or 4 times a week for months after school from 3 until 6 as she really needed the help and couldn't afford the childcare. I couldn't do it one day and she hasn't spoken to me since. Cheeky fuckin bitch!

That's so galling.

One reason i no longer fall for those sob stories.

boxaround · 16/06/2022 22:44

YANBU. Could you ignore the call/messages? I'm a bit of a mug who finds it hard to say no so I'd be feeling a bit like you and would rather avoid saying no...I'd just ignore the call and text back later "oops sorry, had a busy day, just noticed the missed call!"

TinselTinsel · 16/06/2022 22:36

Just say no. I've done it myself when my friend's OH thought i was back up mum rather than help out himself. In a genuine emergency i will offer to have the kids but other than that , no. I had nobody to rely on when my son was younger and i managed so my 2 parent family friends can share the load.

Hmm1234 · 16/06/2022 21:52

You’re too nice. If I had a friend like this I’d have to help her back or give her something towards the childcare.

Hiphophippityskip1 · 16/06/2022 21:36

I just say “aw Im afraid we have plans today but I hope you manage to get sorted”. I do not apologise or say what my plans are or give any reasons. If i feel like helping out or it suits me or its an emergency then i will but only for a small group of very close friends who I know will return the favour. You stay at home to be there for your family and for them to be your priority not to be guilted into being free childcare.

MyLifeJourney · 16/06/2022 21:09

I’d definitely not have a conversation with them. Just have a ‘oh I can’t I’m due at the dentist , GP, hi giving blood etc visiting a family member, going to a funeral, doing my charity work, feel I’m coming down with something,
Then - You’ll never guess what I heard …gossip or nonsense talk.
just don’t do it!!

Reginaldina · 16/06/2022 20:00

You're not being unreasonable. You like spending your time with your child and that is your choice. As pp's have said, I would just have ready made excuses such as, can't today, we've got plans, or we've got family coming or we're out all day doing errands. They won't mind and anyone with kids should truly get just how much you've got on when you're at home. I'm sure they don't assume you're sat at home painting your nails all day or watching Homes Under the Hammer- they have probably started to rely on you without realising it.
Break the trend and only say yes when you genuinely want to do it and not feel obliged.

Luredbyapomegranate · 16/06/2022 19:46

Hillrunning · 16/06/2022 05:27

I am guessing you want to maintain the friendships? If so, I don't think you say that you can't be the back up option to them, I think you simply start saying no to specific requests. You have been saying yes so far. So from thier view you are happy. If it were me and you turned round and made me feel like I had pushed too far, I would be quite hurt. Being unavailable it fine.

I know the urge to offer to help. I used to be unable to notnoffer my time If I knew it would help someone. Now I bite my tongue and answer 'I'm not available today' when directly asked.

Yes - this is sensible

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 16/06/2022 19:40

I was a SAHM for a while due to redundancy, new baby, a sick teenager and aging parents who needed help. Moved to an area in Yr 3 and was at first happy to help people having difficulty as I knew what it was like.
However after a while, I was literally preyed on by a very determined nearby CF. It was always an "emergency", the implication was that I'd be guilty of leaving them in the lurch. At first, it was just taking to school, "It's on your way!" then he arrived earlier and earlier and it was literally getting in the way of dealing with my own DC.
I was ill in hospital and guess what, DH had to take a week off work as none of the CFs who had me on speed dial were willing or able to help.
I eventually said something in a polite and reasonable way but was blanked ever after. All the time of helping counted for nothing, as I was of no further use. Frankly, it was a massive relief for me and my DC. I still occasionally helped actual friends of my DC but no one outside that circle.
I think you need to withdraw but don't allow them to pound down your excuses, be ready to have The Talk too.. It can be done nicely. but you may lose some of the friendships - which just proves they weren't going to last anyway. Best of luck