Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not lend ds savings?

220 replies

FanFanFanFee · 16/06/2022 00:07

Ex gave ds money for Xmas and ds has saved it, and added to it by also saving all of his pocket money, so that he currently has a good amount saved. He has been considering spending some of it recently but so far hasn't.

Ds lives with me and sees ex once a month (exs choice) and I look after his savings for him.

Ex has just texted me asking lots of questions about ds savings, how much it is, is he saving for anything specific etc, and how much did he give ds for Xmas (I don't know - he also gave the other dc random amounts of money and just transferred a lump sum to me for them all which I shared out into their savings at the time but didn't keep any record of - I just keep each dc current total updated as the money sits in my account because they are too young to have their own yet)

He has then said he has received an unexpected utility bill and he has to borrow the money from ds but ds mustn't know about it. He says he can get the money from his own savings at the end of the month and will then pay ds back. He is demanding £150 tomorrow and says that it is his money because he gave it to ds and ds hasn't spent it.

I'm very reluctant to do this because
A) it is ds money and I don't think doing it behind his back is right
B) I don't have the money myself so if I lend it to ex and then ds wants to spend it he won't be able to until ex pays it back - which would be very unfair and basically penalising ds for having been sensible and saving his money
C) ex has form for being very unreliable re. Money. He was financially abusive while we were together and also borrowed thousands from my parents which he has never and will never pay back

Surely his utility company would be open to waiting until the end of the month for him to pay if he explains that he needs to give that much notice to withdraw the money from his savings account?

AIBU to not feel comfortable lending ds money in this way?

OP posts:
saraclara · 16/06/2022 07:05

I'm now imagining an OP where someone has given an ex money for their child's savings and has just found out that they never opened the savings accounts and have that money on their own account still.

MzHz · 16/06/2022 07:03

LordEmsworth · 16/06/2022 00:12

Why are you even asking? It would be massively unreasonable of you to do it... You and DS would never see the money again. Ignore ignore ignore...

this!

why are you even engaging in any texting back and forth with him?

shut him down, say no and remind him he fleeced your parents

EarringsandLipstick · 16/06/2022 07:02

KangFang · 16/06/2022 00:31

He'll never, ever pay it back.
Ever.

This will also be a way to control you and your DS.

Exactly this.

I felt like I was reading about my own ex here who also 'borrowed' from my parents & never repaid; was - still is - massively financially abusive; and uses money to control us.

This week he took money my two DS were given by a relative of his as well as birthday money from his mother to one DS. It will never be seen again.

Do not give him anything; don't even discuss it. And well done to your DS for being so sensible!

saraclara · 16/06/2022 07:02

No he can't have it, but nor am I entirely convinced that your children's money from him is safe from you.

Do you honestly have it still? There is absolutely no reason for you not have put it in accounts for them, and having it in your account is high risk for it being frittered away. Have you actually written down how much each child has, and have you honestly not spent a penny of it?

Robinni · 16/06/2022 06:58

Needless to say, don’t lend him the money.

Robinni · 16/06/2022 06:57

I just keep each dc current total updated as the money sits in my account because they are too young to have their own yet)

Open an account in trust, DC had them from they were babies.

www.santander.co.uk/personal/current-accounts/123-mini-current-account

ErinAoife · 16/06/2022 06:46

First thing I would do is open your kids a bank account and No, I would not give it your ex because he can't budget properly, it is not like he had a huge medical bill it is an utility bill. Just curious what will happen if your son ask you for the money as you said you can't afford to give it to your ex, your son's money shouldn't be in your account.

clpsmum · 16/06/2022 06:40

I do not lend him the money

PinkButtercups · 16/06/2022 06:39

Nope. Absolutely not.

Inkyblue123 · 16/06/2022 06:38

No way. Tell him it’s invested in an ISA and you can’t access it. How much is in there is irrelevant. He is a CF. Send him a link to citizens advice debt and the open university free personal finance course. His life administration, or lack there of, is not your problem.

Fraaahnces · 16/06/2022 06:36

Tell him to take it out of his repayments to your parents…. No way!

AgentJohnson · 16/06/2022 06:35

You can’t lend someone else’s money without telling them, that called stealing. Tell this arsewipe to get lost.

jetadore · 16/06/2022 06:31

I think you probably could find out how much you transferred to each child from statements etc but that’s irrelevant.

Everything you’ve written suggests that if you ‘lend’ him the money you (your DC rather) will never see it again.

BackToTheTop · 16/06/2022 06:31

That would be a big fat no from me!

Ponderingwindow · 16/06/2022 06:24

Do not do this.

Do not let him pressure your son into lending him money, now or in the future. If he ever asks your any of the children, make it clear to them this is wrong. Don’t be polite about it. You have to teach them to stand up to him.

Lightsoutlondon · 16/06/2022 06:21

ZekeZeke · 16/06/2022 03:39

The money is sitting in your account?
Firstly, I would open junior accounts in the CS's own names.it shouldn't be sitting in your account.

Agree with this - you can open a bank account for a baby, there's no such thing as them being 'too young'.your ex shouldn't be asking for the money but if I were him I wouldn't be happy it's sitting in your account - like him you could be tempted to spend it, especially as you have commented you don't have a lot of spare money yourself.

HardRockOwl · 16/06/2022 06:21

Why are even having this sort of relationship with him? Where he feels he can even ask?

You need to sets boundaries quickly. Stop talking to him. And when you have to, keep it relevant to your child

The relationship is over isn't it? If so, act like it and cut him off from you as far as is possible

dancemom · 16/06/2022 06:20

Nope. It's not his money, he chose to give it to your DS.

ClinicallyProven · 16/06/2022 06:18

No you mustn't lend it, but you also need to get DC's money into accounts in their names. You might need to be named as trustee while they are young, but this needs to be in separate accounts. If, for example, you owed money, while it's in your account this would be considered your money and would need to be paid to your creditors.

lassof · 16/06/2022 06:17

Sorry ... your question is ... should I steal from my son to give the money to an ex-lover of mine?

Please get some counselling because even having to ask that is disturbing. There are some co-dependencies there that you haven't dealt with, but you really need to, or your next boyfriend will be just as exploitative.

Oh the answer is 'no, you shouldn't steal from your child'

lassof · 16/06/2022 06:17

Sorry ... your question is ... should I steal from my son to give the money to an ex-lover of mine?

Please get some counselling because even having to ask that is disturbing. There are some co-dependencies there that you haven't dealt with, but you really need to, or your next boyfriend will be just as exploitative.

Oh the answer is 'no, you shouldn't steal from your child'

mnnewbie111 · 16/06/2022 06:10

It's not for a utility bill.

lisavanderpumpscloset · 16/06/2022 06:05

AIBU to not feel comfortable lending ds money in this way?

Yes. YABU to feel anything at all.

It isn't your money. It isn't his money.

It's DS's money.

Say NO. What's he going to do? Rob the bank?

thatslow · 16/06/2022 06:00

NO! It’s not his money and it’s not your money to lend give. Also why is he insistent on keeping it secret from son? Is that for when he doesn’t pay it back and you end up having to explain where the money is gone?

SingleMomIreland · 16/06/2022 05:50

There are numerous things wrong with this post.

  1. it's a flat out no to lending your financially abusive EX any money.
You know full well he won't give it back for all the reasons you've listed. As a pp poster had said, No is a complete sentence and ask him when hes paying your parents back.
  1. Utility bills aren't unexpected, they arrive like clockwork. It maybe higher than he expected, but he is by far not the only person struggling to pay it, so they will wait until the end of the month. I'd be tempted to send him the number for MABS.
  2. It's not your money to lend, so you will be stealing from your son.
  3. Children can absolutely have their own bank accounts. My one year old has a bank account (she can't access until she's 16, but I can withdraw on her behalf,), premium bonds, which are a great option ad there's monthly prize draw and a children's ISA. The latter 2 options make it a bit more tricky to access savings, but if your son is inclined enough to save, they may suit him.
  4. You say 'he transferred a lump sum to me for them all which I shared out into their savings at the time', - you've said they don't have any savings account as they're too young!
You go on to say 'but didn't keep any record of - I just keep each dc current total updated' - that's a contradiction in itself. You didn't keep a record of it, but keep their total updated. I'd be very suprised if you know how much your children have saved.

The best thing would be to withdraw savings immediately and put into a piggy bank for each of them if you don't want to get them their own account.
If you are absolutely adamant to keep their money in your account, start a simple log in a notebook or excel spreadsheet about what each has.

I'm not sure what age your D.C. are, but a GoHenry card is another option.

I'm sorry to sound preachy, this isn't intended, but you're making this way more complicated than it needs to be, and your children are potentially missing out on their rightful savings.

Finally, your ex has NO right to the money he has gifted. I'd make sure in future he doesn't ask the children when they're old enough to lend money, because they may feel sorry for him and given It.