Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not lend ds savings?

220 replies

FanFanFanFee · 16/06/2022 00:07

Ex gave ds money for Xmas and ds has saved it, and added to it by also saving all of his pocket money, so that he currently has a good amount saved. He has been considering spending some of it recently but so far hasn't.

Ds lives with me and sees ex once a month (exs choice) and I look after his savings for him.

Ex has just texted me asking lots of questions about ds savings, how much it is, is he saving for anything specific etc, and how much did he give ds for Xmas (I don't know - he also gave the other dc random amounts of money and just transferred a lump sum to me for them all which I shared out into their savings at the time but didn't keep any record of - I just keep each dc current total updated as the money sits in my account because they are too young to have their own yet)

He has then said he has received an unexpected utility bill and he has to borrow the money from ds but ds mustn't know about it. He says he can get the money from his own savings at the end of the month and will then pay ds back. He is demanding £150 tomorrow and says that it is his money because he gave it to ds and ds hasn't spent it.

I'm very reluctant to do this because
A) it is ds money and I don't think doing it behind his back is right
B) I don't have the money myself so if I lend it to ex and then ds wants to spend it he won't be able to until ex pays it back - which would be very unfair and basically penalising ds for having been sensible and saving his money
C) ex has form for being very unreliable re. Money. He was financially abusive while we were together and also borrowed thousands from my parents which he has never and will never pay back

Surely his utility company would be open to waiting until the end of the month for him to pay if he explains that he needs to give that much notice to withdraw the money from his savings account?

AIBU to not feel comfortable lending ds money in this way?

OP posts:
familyissues12345 · 16/06/2022 07:57

What. A. Prick!!

Sounds like the sort of stunt my ex would play.

Pleased you're going to stand up to him!

Herejustforthisone · 16/06/2022 07:55

At the risk of being rude, don’t be so bloody stupid.

He won’t pay it back.

LizzieSiddal · 16/06/2022 07:53

Tell your ex the money is in an account that you can’t get to at short notice.

or alternatively just tell him to Fuck Off.

SBAM · 16/06/2022 07:52

Glad you’re saying no.

I have kids accounts with Halifax, and as I’m the adult who opened it they appear on my online banking, I can transfer money in really easily, and there’s no minimum age. You can also deposit cheques just by taking a photo of which is helpful at birthdays/Christmas.
I’d really recommend it, saves any issues if your pocket money tally gets tampered with/deleted/you’re flustered and forget to update it one day.

SkadoodleLou · 16/06/2022 07:52

Please check with the bank what type of account you would be opening in your children's names. You absolutely do not want one that transfers over to them at 18 as you have no idea if they will blow thousands of pounds. There have been many threads on here about Child Trust Fund accounts and no parental control over those once 18.

We had a child saving's account in our name. We assumed it would transfer to Ds at 18 but it didn't. Fortunately he is sensible but we approached the bank who told us that they set up accounts that don't automatically transfer over and instead remain under the control of the parents. We moved the money out of that account to Ds but it was good to know that it wasn't automatic.

AmaryIlis · 16/06/2022 07:51

JuneJubilee · 16/06/2022 00:20

send the test the dictionary definition of 'gave'

keep asking him when he's going to pay your parents back!!

All of this.

speakout · 16/06/2022 07:50

I am gobsmacked you are even posting this question .

GetThatHelmetOn · 16/06/2022 07:49

Problem with the kids having their own accounts and a father like this is that the pressure the OP is feeling to handover the money, would go straight to the kids instead.

For the sake of protecting the kids from dad putting them in that position I would keep it in my own account. Such behaviour can really damage the kids.

TwoBlueFish · 16/06/2022 07:43

No, don’t lend him money. You should also open accounts for your children with you as a trustee that way they each have their own savings pots are should be gaining interest.

RockinHorseShit · 16/06/2022 07:43

No!!

He should be ashamed of himself for bloody asking too🤮

KatherineJaneway · 16/06/2022 07:42

LordEmsworth · 16/06/2022 00:12

Why are you even asking? It would be massively unreasonable of you to do it... You and DS would never see the money again. Ignore ignore ignore...

Agree

AnotherForumUser · 16/06/2022 07:42

I'm glad you are going to refuse this demand. For your son's sake and for yours. Stay string. Your ex is clearly used to scrounging off others under the guise of borrowing. It's time He paid his own way. It's hard to imagine a parent prepared to leech off his own young child. There's some useful advice from other posters on types of savings accounts. Good luck.

saraclara · 16/06/2022 07:40

Has JUST said, even

MRex · 16/06/2022 07:40

Individual child accounts are the best way to go. For the ex, no excuses nor explanations just say "No." If he wants to control money he gives the DC then he needs to put that into separate accounts.

saraclara · 16/06/2022 07:40

carefullycourageous · 16/06/2022 07:17

It sounds like you are judging others by your own standards - you are being incredibly judgemental here - for years I had my children's money in my account for simplicity fo access as I was rural and didn't want to have to travel to a bank everytime they wanted to use some. It was never frittered and is very simple - I kept a written record of how much they had.

Maybe you would spend your own children's money, but many people would not!

Why on earth do you get from my post that I would spend my children's money? They had their own accounts virtually from birth, which was when relatives wanted to give money for their futures. Which is exactly why I thought it was odd that OP hasn't.
You have very strange thought processes.

Anyway, OP has some said that her children's money is kept in a separate (presumably linked) account, so that's good to hear, and I take back my suspicions that she hadn't fully accounted for it.

Ragruggers · 16/06/2022 07:37

I also don’t believe he has a savings account with money in it.No is the answer to ever asking for money.Somepeople ie him have no shame.

balalake · 16/06/2022 07:35

I am glad you have decided to say no.

My first thought was that an 'unexpected utility bill' was a lie. Expected all along but chosen as a way to get money from you via your DS.

Spanielsarepainless · 16/06/2022 07:33

Unexpected utility bill? What rubbish. Don't do it, OP.

carefullycourageous · 16/06/2022 07:19

@FanFanFanFee If your ex is going to put pressure on the kids around money, the money may be better with you for longer rather than accessible to them alone. Depends how old they are and how pressuring their dad is, but someone who can financially abuse an adult can financially abuse a child.

carefullycourageous · 16/06/2022 07:17

saraclara · 16/06/2022 07:02

No he can't have it, but nor am I entirely convinced that your children's money from him is safe from you.

Do you honestly have it still? There is absolutely no reason for you not have put it in accounts for them, and having it in your account is high risk for it being frittered away. Have you actually written down how much each child has, and have you honestly not spent a penny of it?

It sounds like you are judging others by your own standards - you are being incredibly judgemental here - for years I had my children's money in my account for simplicity fo access as I was rural and didn't want to have to travel to a bank everytime they wanted to use some. It was never frittered and is very simple - I kept a written record of how much they had.

Maybe you would spend your own children's money, but many people would not!

Washaday · 16/06/2022 07:11

No, it's not his money.

FawnFrenchieMum · 16/06/2022 07:10

You need to look into the type of accounts you can open for children. Especially if they are old enough to decide for themselves when they want to spend it.
Both mine have one that I control until they are 18, this is longer term savings but both also have an account they get their spending money etc into that for the youngest I can view and for the teen, it’s his to own. No need to have the money sat in your account or to manually ‘track’ what’s in there. Plus your missing out on kids getting a higher tax free interest rate.

picklemewalnuts · 16/06/2022 07:09

Get it into a delayed access account in their own names.

FanFanFanFee · 16/06/2022 07:09

The money is in a separate account - not with my day to day money. I can transfer it into my main account easily whenever my son wants to spend it.

I have not got a spare £150 in my budget - so if I had leant ds money to ex and then ds decided he wanted to spend it I wouldn't be able to easily just take £150 from my budget for him to use.

Regardless - I have got my answer and I will be saying no to ex. Whoever asked - yes financial was not the only abuse, no we're not in a relationship, having been very very low contact with ex for years I have recently went trying to be more open in communication for the sake of the children, but I still obviously have some issues in being confident and sure that my instincts and boundaries are correct.

This way to manage the dc money arose because my eldest has fairly severe behavioural issues and is not NT, and we cannot keep cash in the house safely. So I keep a record on my phone of the dc pocket money, which is a note on my notes app that I update each week with each dc pocket money but I only keep the current total - not a history of what has come in and gone out. It works for us right now, because I always have to hand how much each has, and if they want to spend some I just pay and update their total (none yet go out alone).

It may be time to look at individual savings accounts for them - ds has been umming and erring about spending his money on various large Lego sets etc since Xmas but has so far not decided on anything so his savings total has crept up and up as he's not spending, but in general it's only small amounts in my pocket money note.

OP posts:
stepuporshutup · 16/06/2022 07:09

Op it is not your money to lend, and why does ex want you to keep it quiet from your son?
Could it be because he would never pay it back and you would have to explain why you stole your owns sons money.
Tell your ex to fuck right off and as pp have said the utility company will accept plan payments.
Please Please op do not take your sons money