Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Train and tube strikes

178 replies

uneffingbelievable · 15/06/2022 23:03

I can not work from home and my job is fairly essential.

To get to work next week - I have now along with many of my colleagues had to:

  1. Book a hotel on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday nights
  2. Pay for parking at the station for 4 full days
  3. Organise extra child care and a taxi to pick DCS up from school ( too far to walk and no bus)
  4. Will have to pay to eat out for those days
If the rail unions had not noticed we are ALL facing a cost of living crisis - wasting the best part of £500 to get to work is not endearing me to your cause.

The alternative of drive in and out each day in the traffic and pay for parking in London and then walk miles comes in at around £350 and exceedingly high BP.

Your actions are selfish beyond belief and hurt the innocent hardworking majority.

That is the polite version - selfish beyond belief

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DdraigGoch · 17/06/2022 19:23

Frankly the DfT needs to stop dreaming about powering trains with bionic duckweed and it needs to start a rolling electrification programme. I can't stand the SNP but at least they've done one good thing, they've got a realistic plan to completely electrify all mainline in Scotland. Looks like I'll be able to catch an electric train to Inverness before I'll be able to catch one to bloody Bristol.

If people want to know why the UK railway is so expensive, here's part of the answer: we're still heavily reliant upon diesel trains. If you compare the subsidies required by each operator (pre-pamdemic) with the proportion of electrified services they operate, there is a pattern.

HeyBearILoveYou · 17/06/2022 16:03

@DdraigGoch I totally agree. Human nature. But you can't ask for change, and then reject it.

I'm more track based, and we could learn an awful lot from Europe - things like remote controlled TCODS. They are filtering slowly in to Uk use, but this is what I mean by people not wanting to accept things - despite the safety, time and cost benefits, they're still regarded with massive suspicion despite being all over Europe 🤷🏻‍♀️

I don't think anyone quite knows what they're up to with diesel VS electric VS bastard hydrogen. I kinda wish someone would pick a bloody fuel and then we can all get on with making the necessary conversions! 😂

DdraigGoch · 17/06/2022 15:37

HeyBearILoveYou · 17/06/2022 15:16

Wouldn't say it is solely for management @DdraigGoch... it was actually set up by NR track division to encourage boot on ballast teams to get out and see new kit, so they could then feed back TO management the stuff that they wanted to be working with. A focus on safety, innovation and collaboration (Three of NRs favourite words eh?)

All of these conferences and awards events seem to roll in to one, as far as I'm concerned. I don't know of any member of operating staff who goes.

I did go on holiday to Switzerland though, and saw plenty of things we ought to consider in rolling stock design. Things like having a small, card lined bin installed within every table. Strengthening trains on a whim, rather than praying that a two-car class 150 can cope with a few thousand racegoers. Having passcomms and call for aid activations display on the screens so that the guard knows instantly where the issue is. Most importantly of all, they've electrified their entire network. Not that management are interested in the views of those of us who actually run trains and deal with the public on a daily basis. No, they believe that a two car train on X route is entirely sufficient in spite of the fact that even the four car ones sometimes leave passengers behind. I'm not on about being forced by circumstances to make the best of what we've got with the existing fleet, I'm referring to a new order of rolling stock where as soon as it was announced as a mixture of two and three car trains, the messroom groaned.

We on the other hand are messing around trying to fit diesel engines to electric trains (with mixed results) because Chris Grayling is a numpty. The DfT were boasting about the money saved by cancelling the GWML wiring to Bristol and Oxford. Completely overlooking that as a result they'd had to pay far more than they saved in contract variations to Hitachi so that the latter could fit diesel engines.

DdraigGoch · 17/06/2022 15:22

And it's quite natural @HeyBearILoveYou for people to be sceptical of change, when they've seen the wheel reinvented umpteen times and most change is for the worse.

At every fares round the system is made more complex - it suits the management to have it this way because they have all sorts of pitfalls available to trip up unwary passengers to fleece them. Front line staff and passengers alike on the other hand just want a simple system so that passengers get a fair deal and we can avoid arguments.

New trains? Often poorly designed, lacking in passenger/luggage/bike capacity, rock hard seats, noisy underfloor engines, lots of gadgets to go wrong, bins placed where no one can find them... Compare that to some of the older trains we recently got rid of, plenty of bike space, massive luggage racks, seventy comfortable seats per carriage (mostly grouped around tables). The old sets were worn out, but their replacements are far from an improvement.

Timetable changes - God, I've seen some really daft decisions where these are concerned.

What was it Gerry Fiennes said? "When we reorganise, we bleed".

HeyBearILoveYou · 17/06/2022 15:16

Wouldn't say it is solely for management @DdraigGoch... it was actually set up by NR track division to encourage boot on ballast teams to get out and see new kit, so they could then feed back TO management the stuff that they wanted to be working with. A focus on safety, innovation and collaboration (Three of NRs favourite words eh?)

Chesneyhawkes1 · 17/06/2022 14:58

@DdraigGoch I've never even heard of it before!

DdraigGoch · 17/06/2022 14:57

HeyBearILoveYou · 17/06/2022 10:34

I work in the rail industry (currently on maternity).

Across the board in rail, salaries are decent. This strike is absolutely taking the piss. The industry is full of people that love to bitch and whinge, push against/reject change and wrap everything up in red tape. It's a joke.

And I'd bet that they'll all manage to scrape together the funds to get to Rail Live, the annual rail piss up in Stratford Avon (yes, I'm bitter not to be going)!

You won't find many RMT grades there. I'm sure that it's a good time for management though.

nickthefox · 17/06/2022 13:36

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 16/06/2022 08:19

Don't be dramatic.

When's the last time one of them has died on the job?

the rail includes maintenance. Where men go and work on the railway track manually. Digging the stones and leaving them, replacing the track, stressing it to keep it straight. there are accidents all the time. Manual look outs, where men are ON A TRAIN TRACK with people looking out for TRAINS!!!!
People do die, It is sad. There are also close calls, broken bones and everything.

Just like the road maintenance workers who have now put up big signs saying 'please drive safely so my daddy comes home' on the motor way.

They do deserve a pay increase, firstly they were promised one.

Would you accept working for 60-70 hours a week, excluding travel (4-6 hours a day or you will be staying away from your family and homes) just so you can come home and stress about money, use food banks, get into debt? Despite working 20hrs more than others a week with relentless commutes?
Oh and it's dangerous
the over head wired for Instance will boil your blood and then you explode.

But yeah, the CEO can get the pay increase.

nickthefox · 17/06/2022 13:16

lol they aren't going to give a shit if you are endeared to their cause, unless of course you will be giving out the pay rises? no? then good we are glad you're late for work, complain to network rail and let's get the job done faster

Flapjacker48 · 17/06/2022 13:11

@HeyBearILoveYou Frankly most of the managers and directors that descend on Rail Live to have a love in with Nigel Harris could easily be cut and hence actually give operational staff a pay rise. Would love to know what your role is.

frydae · 17/06/2022 12:34

Sorry I got that wrong

Comefromaway · 17/06/2022 12:34

Also my husband who is a teacher won't be able to get to work for two days next week. There are numerous children who will struggle to get to their GCSE and A level exams.

Comefromaway · 17/06/2022 12:32

But it's not 1 shift, it's 4 shifts. Tuesday, Thursday and a double shift on Saturday. She's just finishing a postgraduate course so also has to get to uni in the day. There are many people who can't afford to lose 4 shifts pay (she works 6 shifts a week).

frydae · 17/06/2022 12:28

Comefromaway · 17/06/2022 12:13

My dd on £10.05 per hour in central London who finished work at 10.30apm at night has no way of getting home.

She doesn't work, she doesn't eat. I'm really worried about her, it takes over an hour to cycle back home late at night through some not very nice areas.

This is an awful situation for your DD to be in but I can't say it's anything to do with the strikes. Yes the impact of them is awful for her but it sounds like she is already in a critical situation if she is t going to be able to eat sure to missing her shift.

Comefromaway · 17/06/2022 12:13

My dd on £10.05 per hour in central London who finished work at 10.30apm at night has no way of getting home.

She doesn't work, she doesn't eat. I'm really worried about her, it takes over an hour to cycle back home late at night through some not very nice areas.

Acidburn · 17/06/2022 12:08

@BorisJohnsonsvomitbucket my friend is also a customer assistant at the station. She says she does nothing thr whole day, just standing near the gates. The whole day, everyday. But paid more than a nurse.

HeyBearILoveYou · 17/06/2022 10:34

I work in the rail industry (currently on maternity).

Across the board in rail, salaries are decent. This strike is absolutely taking the piss. The industry is full of people that love to bitch and whinge, push against/reject change and wrap everything up in red tape. It's a joke.

And I'd bet that they'll all manage to scrape together the funds to get to Rail Live, the annual rail piss up in Stratford Avon (yes, I'm bitter not to be going)!

PaddingtonBearStareAgain · 16/06/2022 23:49

frydae · 16/06/2022 23:31

I'm glad you haven't had an issue, but as a wheelchair user I certainly have. Assistance booked but not actually avalible when I arrive isn't unusual.

Do you think this is as a PP suggested staff are talking to each other, or is it maybe a communication/organisation failure that needs a bit of upgrading, investment in staff training?

Mixture of both. I have been 'ignored' by talking staff which as someone in a wheelchair isn't unusual and some situations where computer says no and it has actually been other passengers that have helped me.

frydae · 16/06/2022 23:31

I'm glad you haven't had an issue, but as a wheelchair user I certainly have. Assistance booked but not actually avalible when I arrive isn't unusual.

Do you think this is as a PP suggested staff are talking to each other, or is it maybe a communication/organisation failure that needs a bit of upgrading, investment in staff training?

Cetrion · 16/06/2022 23:28

...I really hope you're just ignorant to what these strikes are really about because if you've actually done your research and feel this way then that makes you seem like such a harsh, hateful person OP...

Chazzagirl2 · 16/06/2022 23:23

lightisnotwhite · 16/06/2022 23:07

Yeah but that’s the problem.
People ( customers) want manned ticket counters - for when the internet fucks up). They want guards to stop drunk lads and loud ladies ruining a journey.
They want staff who can help with stuff.

What we get is closed ticket offices, crowded rowdy carriages and platforms and no staff randomly or outside of peak hours.

Strike but for a better service not inflation. If peoples wages rise then inflation interest rates, borrowing, goes up. Who loses out then

You don’t get a better service by not investing in staff properly. You get disengaged, overworked and demoralised staff. Some of whom are doing extremely dangerous jobs.

Absolutely strike for pay and conditions.

PaddingtonBearStareAgain · 16/06/2022 23:22

frydae · 16/06/2022 23:19

I'm a disabled traveller, without humans I would not travel. It's so very simple. The person who said the station staff are talking when she passes them, I presume she isn't needing assistance. I have asked for assistance several times when travelling without issue. I often travel without booking assistance but am reassured that if something goes wrong there are staff on board who can help me. I almost had a meltdown once when my train got held for over 2 hours and we didn't know if we were getting home or not. The only thing that made that disruption bearable for me was the presence of staff who could not have been more helpful once they were aware of my needs.

I'm glad you haven't had an issue, but as a wheelchair user I certainly have. Assistance booked but not actually avalible when I arrive isn't unusual.

lightisnotwhite · 16/06/2022 23:22

DdraigGoch · 16/06/2022 23:10

If peoples wages rise then inflation interest rates, borrowing, goes up. Who loses out then

Certainly not MPs, IPSO are quite happy to suggest pay rises for them every year.

The amount of flack MP wage increases get is immense! There’s no point in getting a wage increase if it just puts the price of everything else up. You’ll never catch up unless the people that make stuff get paid the same as the people that just add value to stuff, not the other way round.

Ghetto66 · 16/06/2022 23:20

Please can you point to the evidence that union bosses are paid hundreds of thousands?

ilovesooty · 16/06/2022 23:19

Ghetto66 · 16/06/2022 23:14

You do realise that the strikes could be averted if the government spoke to the unions? It’s also unions that fought for things like minimum wages, employee rights, maternity leave, pensions… honestly I’m really sick of uneducated entitled people moaning.

Yes, but the government is quite happy for all those hard fought for rights to be eroded.