Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the whole idea of retirement is going to become unrealistic

209 replies

worksmartandfast · 15/06/2022 20:27

I am sad writing this as I think it is a truely nice idea that people get to take some time out to enjoy life but my practical head says it can't continue. When the age was set to retire that was a policy made for a totally different era, people started work at 15 and died at 65 in general society has completely changed since then. It was never envisaged that education would last so long for children/young people it is really an accident of history that for the last decades it has been possible to effectively stop working in their early 60s/late 50s despite being perfectly capable adults and spend potentially 15/20 years living a life of pure leisure. While I'm sure this idea will be unpopular in reality I can't see how in a world with ever better medical care increasing life expentancy it can be expected that it will be possible for it to be the norm that most people can spend the final quater of their lives retired even if they are perfectly able to work. Aibu?

OP posts:
dolphinsarentcommon · 15/06/2022 22:19

Having worked for almost 40 years in the nhs in a very stressful job I'm retired and hoping for many more years, thank you. Contrary to popular belief I don't have a pension big enough to live on (my DH thankfully does) because I've worked most of it part time. No free child care when mine were young.

I very much feel burnt out and exhausted from working and I make no apologises

pfills · 15/06/2022 22:17

We have a massive demographic shift coming so things are going to get very expensive.

Clymene · 15/06/2022 22:16

Yes I think a better work-life balance is the way forward. People can't just keep working longer and longer. Retirement used to be something that happened when you were still relatively fit.

There's also still an expectation that retired parents will help out with childcare. If people are working until their children are in their 40s or 50s, that's just not going to happen

Suddha · 15/06/2022 22:16

On one hand I think people might find it very difficult to retire in future. Spending longer in education means they perhaps didn’t start paying into a pension until 25 or even 30. Low salaries mean people can barely even afford to pay the minimum into their pension, which isn’t enough. Most of the cushy pension schemes are gone. People won’t have the money to retire.

On the other hand, if they don’t retire then there won’t be enough jobs for young people. I had this argument with a friend who thinks it’s great that his Dad is still able to work at 84. I pointed out that he was depriving a young person of that job, a person who wanted to use that salary to get a mortgage and have kids. Who was probably broke and stuck renting because his Dad was hogging that secure well paid job instead of passing it on.

Discovereads · 15/06/2022 22:13

glowbabe · 15/06/2022 22:11

I believe that people will have to go before a panel who will then decide if you are still fit to carry on working . People are living much longer .

We already do?! Well it’s several panels and assessments now, but how do you think people are determined to be permanently disabled and put on disability benefits/get disability pensions?

Helenloveslee4eva · 15/06/2022 22:12

Logan’s run ..

and other similar Sci-fi

Discovereads · 15/06/2022 22:12

I’m hoping that one day robots and AI will do all the work and everyone can live a life of leisure with a universal basic income allowing them to pursue their passions. Of course, it won’t be in my lifetime. But I do think “work” will become obsolete in the future.

NOTANUM · 15/06/2022 22:11

In recent times retirement is seen as a reward for a long working life during rather than a recognition of a failing body or mind as was originally the case.
The only issue is that most can’t afford to live 10-30 years post retirement in any comfort.
We are going to have to adapt sadly by working longer than we might want to.

glowbabe · 15/06/2022 22:11

I believe that people will have to go before a panel who will then decide if you are still fit to carry on working . People are living much longer .

Cazzawazzalazza · 15/06/2022 22:10

SkyLarkDescending · 15/06/2022 21:47

I've been reading a book I saw recommended on here and one of the ideas is that we need to enjoy the here and now rather than saving up for a future time when we might enjoy ourselves. I think retirement as it is now seems like a reward for a life time of hard work.

I think we need to rebalance things so that work is part of our lives but there is time for family and health and leisure pursuits. Then we would have a better chance of working into older age, hopefully part time, giving meaning back to people at that stage of life.

I actually agree with this. I think retirement as we knew it is a thing of the past. I'm in my 40s and don't expect to retire TBH.

My parents are in their 70s. Mum doesn't work and never has since having us kids TBH. My DF still works albeit PT and has admitted he doesn't want to stop working.

StoneofDestiny · 15/06/2022 22:04

Whether you can keep working passed your mid 60's very much depends on what you do for a living. It's not just manual work that is challenging as you get older, but high stress jobs that can involve huge mental challenge or/as well as physical challenge.
Many people go on to do voluntary work on retirement - but they do limited hours. They may have great mental capabilities and underused skills, but long hours, long commutes and just a weariness from a long life of full time work may have taken its toll in many ways.

Really, as a society we need to value leisure time more. If the older people keep working into their 70's, how do the younger people get their feet on the ladder? Maybe shorter working weekend more flexible working arrangements is the way to go instead of thinking we need to work til the coffin turns up!

FindingMeno · 15/06/2022 22:02

SkyLarkDescending · 15/06/2022 21:47

I've been reading a book I saw recommended on here and one of the ideas is that we need to enjoy the here and now rather than saving up for a future time when we might enjoy ourselves. I think retirement as it is now seems like a reward for a life time of hard work.

I think we need to rebalance things so that work is part of our lives but there is time for family and health and leisure pursuits. Then we would have a better chance of working into older age, hopefully part time, giving meaning back to people at that stage of life.

I like this thinking!

Isthisreasonable · 15/06/2022 22:02

Generation Rent may not be able to retire because of the cost of renting their homes.

When Bismarck originally introduced a retirement age it was set at one year less than the average age of death. This was to enable people to stop work and get their affairs in order before they died. Definitely not to enjoy yourself. It feels a short retirement could become more normal.

Namenic · 15/06/2022 21:59

I think the retirement age will inevitably go up. I would like to see more flexible jobs - PT, diversity in age. Better carer’s allowance or tax credits for those who look after elderly relatives or childcare for grandkids. Better provision for those unable to work on health grounds - which affects manual workers more.

rookiemere · 15/06/2022 21:59

State retirement age is 67.

My DPs were hale and hearty in their 60s and early 70s but quickly started developing minor and major health complaints.

I don't know what job you expect someone in their late 60s to reasonably do. Is the idea that people should work until they drop ?

The issue is life expectancy- but not quality of life - is longer than it used to be. Frankly give me a pill at 85 if it means I can retire at 60.

JaninaDuszejko · 15/06/2022 21:58

I suppose the trouble is everyone varies so much. My grandparents all lived independently into their 90s, my Mum is fit and healthy at 76 and I've got a primary aged child while in my early 50s. I'm not thinking about retiring at all (still enjoying the post baby energy boost) but I have slightly older colleagues who are on the final salary scheme who are talking about retiring soon. Since life expectancy is mid 80s they are looking at 30 years of retirement in a career that only started in their mid 20s (all have PhDs). It will be interesting to see how attitudes at work to older workers change as we stop being able to take early retirement.

iwishiwasafish · 15/06/2022 21:54

What do you propose as an alternative OP? Banning retirement? Forcing people to work even if they have saved enough to provide themselves with an income?

How would you define that? Would it apply only to defined pensions? SIPPS? What about someone who was drawing a passive income from property? Would they be allowed to continue, or should they start a paper round alongside?

Or are you “just” talking about going away with the state pension? Thereby disproportionately affecting those who are most likely to be physically in need of retirement after (statistically) a higher burden of manual work?

RaininSummer · 15/06/2022 21:52

I will have worked for almost 50 years by retirement and doubt I will be capable of going on much longer past 67. Already I find the getting to and from work pretty knackering. Also with a large and growing population, I think it makes sense to make way for younger people.

SkyLarkDescending · 15/06/2022 21:47

I've been reading a book I saw recommended on here and one of the ideas is that we need to enjoy the here and now rather than saving up for a future time when we might enjoy ourselves. I think retirement as it is now seems like a reward for a life time of hard work.

I think we need to rebalance things so that work is part of our lives but there is time for family and health and leisure pursuits. Then we would have a better chance of working into older age, hopefully part time, giving meaning back to people at that stage of life.

Shelby2010 · 15/06/2022 21:46

The problem is that as you get older (in general), your eye sight deteriorates, fine motor skills are lost, reaction time is slowed and physical fitness decreases. Previous posters already mentioned fire fighters but a lot of jobs become more difficult or dangerous as your body becomes older.

I don’t think I’ll be physically able to do my job at 65y, but if I can’t retire, does that mean I’ll have to move to a lower skilled, lower paid position? Pretty depressing prospect really.

I don’t know what the answer is, but I really want to stop work while I can still enjoy life. But I also want enough money to be comfortable.

Given the younger generations are likely to have difficulty getting on the property ladder, maybe we are going to see an increase in extended families living together. And instead of peaceful days in the garden we’ll retire to provide childcare for grandchildren.

OompaLoompaa · 15/06/2022 21:44

I think about this I lot , my DH and I retired at 52 and 55 so could well have longer in retirement than working.

Clymene · 15/06/2022 21:37

it’s not unusual for someone to spend as many years retired as they spend working

Yes it is! Even if you retire at 60, for most people, that's 40 yeas of working. The number of people who live to 100 is tiny.

While people are living longer, many of them are only having the same 15 or so years of good retirement and then a load more years of ill health. Not sure what the solution is. Ability to press an off switch?

RachelGreep87 · 15/06/2022 21:27

Yes, I agree. I actually find it a bit of a relief though as ageism is rife in the private sector and hopefully this may change and older people will have to be thought of as viable options

SingingSands · 15/06/2022 21:23

I work in an office based role and two of my colleagues have been discussing retirement. One of them is adamant she won't retire yet, but I think she should. She is no longer capable of keeping up with the job role, the technology is beyond her. She "downsized" her role last year and even with that I am having to redo a lot of her work, fix mistakes, talk her through steps and processes that I've already explained 50 times and generally I feel that she's now only capable of the most basic of tasks. And that's really worrying because in less than 20 years I can see myself being the same.

We might be living longer but it doesn't mean we are capable of continuing with the same output.

bakebeans · 15/06/2022 21:21

Definitely. They want u to be ready for your coffin or at least lost your marbles by the time u retire so you cannot claim state pension that you have been paying into all your life. You cannot even opt out of national insurance contributions anymore.

Swipe left for the next trending thread