Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the whole idea of retirement is going to become unrealistic

209 replies

worksmartandfast · 15/06/2022 20:27

I am sad writing this as I think it is a truely nice idea that people get to take some time out to enjoy life but my practical head says it can't continue. When the age was set to retire that was a policy made for a totally different era, people started work at 15 and died at 65 in general society has completely changed since then. It was never envisaged that education would last so long for children/young people it is really an accident of history that for the last decades it has been possible to effectively stop working in their early 60s/late 50s despite being perfectly capable adults and spend potentially 15/20 years living a life of pure leisure. While I'm sure this idea will be unpopular in reality I can't see how in a world with ever better medical care increasing life expentancy it can be expected that it will be possible for it to be the norm that most people can spend the final quater of their lives retired even if they are perfectly able to work. Aibu?

OP posts:
Schoolchoicesucks · 15/06/2022 23:50

I agree, OP. For the more than 50% of people who go to university, they won't work full-time jobs until 21. If they retire at 61, they could realistically need to fund close to 40 years of retirement on close to 40 years of income. Even if they work to 70, it's still funding 20+ years off the back of 50 years working. Economically you'd need to be saving 30% of salary for the whole working life to pay for that.

I work with people a lot younger than me (I'm mid 40s) and many of them speak of wanting to retire at 50 or 55. I don't see how that's possible for anyone other than the absolute highest earners.

I think a pp had the right idea about living in the moment, taking time out to travel, reduce work hours to make space for hobbies, to prioritise health (including mental health) rather than saving up for some mythical retirement golden time.

gingersplodgecat · 15/06/2022 23:48

When I retire in 7 years' time at the age of 67, I will have been working for 51 years. I think that's quite enough thanks very much.

Hawkins001 · 15/06/2022 23:46

Live for the moment rather than doing x when "retirement" is ment to be .

CounsellorTroi · 15/06/2022 23:43

I retired at 58. By that time I had in inflammatory arthritic condition which flares up periodically and when that happens I feel generally unwell and tired and I just have to rest both physically and mentally. I can now do that without feeling guilty about work.

kitcat15 · 15/06/2022 23:38

I’m 57 and a nurse…most of my colleagues and me have taken retirement in their 50s …. I retired then returned on 2 days…i don’t pick up much less than when I was working 5 days…l will retire completely at 59….very standard still to leave before 60 in nhs where i am

Gruffling · 15/06/2022 23:34

Yabu to suggest that most people over 65 are 'perfectly able to work'.

I'm 40 and it's already noticeable that my energy and stamina at work have decreased since my 20s and 30s. My health is awful and I honestly don't know how I will make it to retirement.

What I would like is some kind of earlier phased retirement, so to make it easier to work part time and shorter days from an earlier age.

There are so many graduates and capable young people chomping at the bit. Until employment in under 25s is much higher, it makes no sense to be keeping older people in the workforce for so long.

Bluebellbike · 15/06/2022 23:27

My state pension age is 66, just less than 4 years away. (If I had been born 2 days later it would be 67). I am a widow and retired last August. Two adult DC both have their own homes now.

I downsized my home and have sufficient equity remaining to top up a small NHS pension each month, which gives me a reasonable income. I could have stayed alone in the big family home and carried on working but I have several health issues and didn't want to risk working for 4 more years to then be too unwell to appreciate retirement. The large house was too much for me to cope with anyway.

CounsellorTroi · 15/06/2022 23:23

Really, as a society we need to value leisure time more. If the older people keep working into their 70's, how do the younger people get their feet on the ladder?

Exactly this. There won’t be enough jobs to go around. And is it realistic for surgeons, airline pilots, etc to keep working into their 70s?

RedPlumbob · 15/06/2022 23:15

I dunno.

Both Great Grandmothers on my paternal side lived until their late 90s; both developed Alzheimers in their late 80s. Not a way I want to live. Both retired at 60.

My paternal Grandparents are 80, have been retired for 20 years, no serious health issues as of yet.

All 4 were mortgage free by 40 and had/have significant private pensions and other savings. Luxury is definitely the word for them.

Meanwhile, I’m 35, still renting, will probably never get a mortgage let alone own a home outright because I’m single and my earnings are kneecapped by 3DC (including a disabled child).

The thought of me retiring is a fucking joke, won’t happen.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 15/06/2022 23:06

I’m not sure that the living longer and better medical care to live well is necessarily going to continue. This only happens due to good nutrition, good housing and access to medical care. The cost of living has put paid to the first two and who can even get a GP appointment for the latter? I won’t be surprised if life expectancy falls sharply as the rise in the chronically and seriously unwell rises. This may be a self solving problem.

Discovereads · 15/06/2022 23:05

@Suddha
I pointed out that he was depriving a young person of that job, a person who wanted to use that salary to get a mortgage and have kids. Who was probably broke and stuck renting because his Dad was hogging that secure well paid job instead of passing it on.

Damn this is so ageist!

mistermagpie · 15/06/2022 23:04

SkyLarkDescending · 15/06/2022 21:47

I've been reading a book I saw recommended on here and one of the ideas is that we need to enjoy the here and now rather than saving up for a future time when we might enjoy ourselves. I think retirement as it is now seems like a reward for a life time of hard work.

I think we need to rebalance things so that work is part of our lives but there is time for family and health and leisure pursuits. Then we would have a better chance of working into older age, hopefully part time, giving meaning back to people at that stage of life.

I couldn't agree with this more. I have three little kids and no family so work part time to look after them. A lot of my child-free friends express envy and say 'I wish I could go part time'. But why can't they? Financially it's a hit but they don't have children to pay for so they could have a really nice balance to their lives. It's just not seen as acceptable though, and the idea that we must grind all the time until we retire and finally get a rest or time to focus on other things seems really unhealthy to me.

Realistically I might not live to retirement age. Some people don't. So you work like a dog and then never even get the reward? It just doesn't seem fair.

flowerycurtain · 15/06/2022 23:03

I love what @SkyLarkDescending has been reading.

I agree traditional retirement is on its way out. Or retirement of the last 50 years. I'm in farming and although it's physical a lot of full timers "retire" when they get their pension but return for harvest or part time hours to help out. It helps the farmers massively and also keeps them fit and healthy for longer on a far more flexible basis.

Zeppdraft · 15/06/2022 22:56

Expected retirement age is being pushed further and further out that's for sure. We are still planning to retire by 50, so another 10 or so years of work. Maybe even earlier depending what's going on then.

mocktail · 15/06/2022 22:46

Suddha · 15/06/2022 22:16

On one hand I think people might find it very difficult to retire in future. Spending longer in education means they perhaps didn’t start paying into a pension until 25 or even 30. Low salaries mean people can barely even afford to pay the minimum into their pension, which isn’t enough. Most of the cushy pension schemes are gone. People won’t have the money to retire.

On the other hand, if they don’t retire then there won’t be enough jobs for young people. I had this argument with a friend who thinks it’s great that his Dad is still able to work at 84. I pointed out that he was depriving a young person of that job, a person who wanted to use that salary to get a mortgage and have kids. Who was probably broke and stuck renting because his Dad was hogging that secure well paid job instead of passing it on.

There's a labour shortage at the moment and over a million unfilled vacancies in England and Wales. I've heard no suggestion (until now) that the working elderly are keeping young people out of jobs?

Luredbyapomegranate · 15/06/2022 22:44

I think how we see life will change. Working lives will be longer, and they’ll be more variety of shapes to them.

A friend of mine is an NHS psychologist and tells me that full retirement is very bad for brain function, so to hold off dementia perhaps we should all stay working PT

CurlsandCurves · 15/06/2022 22:37

The idea of a traditional retirement certainly has changed in recent years.

People are living longer and are in better health. They don’t necessarily want to retire even if they could. I know of several people well into their 70s who are still working in some capacity. One gentleman I know is in his 80s and has found work that suits him for a couple of days a week

i honestly don’t think my dad would cope with nothing to occupy his day and mind with. Fortunately he had been able to keep working part time from home within the industry he was part of.

GodneySaysWorkBitch · 15/06/2022 22:32

People may have been living longer (until the last five years or so) than they did 30 years ago but that doesn't mean they're able to work full time at the same level they did as a younger adult. This includes non manual jobs. Most people by the time they are mid sixties will have picked up a couple of health conditions that won't get better as such, and by seventy this applies to pretty much everyone. In addition there is cognitive, sight and motor skills decline all of which are absolutely normal but don't necessarily make for high performing employees. In some parts of the UK especially in deprived areas the average age that health starts to notably decline is as young as 50.

As the birth rate continues to drop we do need to think about solutions but I don't think that having people work until they die will do anyone any favours.

pfills · 15/06/2022 22:31

Do you think life expectancy will drop in future?

It has since the pandemic

"However, the Covid-19 pandemic caused life expectancy in 2020 to fall to 78.6 years for males and to 82.6 years for females, the level of a decade ago."

and it hadn't really increased since the 08 crash.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 15/06/2022 22:29

My dad didn't make retirement, died at 63.
My state pension age is currently 67, 13 years away. If I make it, I'll have been working 51 years. I'm chucking everything I can into pension savings. But I'm still not convinced it won't be raised again.

Blimeyherewegoagain · 15/06/2022 22:25

It’s interesting- we’ve increased life expectancy but for those last 10-20 years we’re likely to be dependent on something or someone. It raises an interesting debate on quality of life over quantity. Eg is it worth having invasive treatment to extend one’s life by say 6 months. Who decides? How to we value life? Who decides if we should keep working til we’re very old? Do we need to have shorter hours for the elderly? What if we’re just too bloody done in when we get to that age? Do you think life expectancy will drop in future?

pfills · 15/06/2022 22:24

There will be greater inequality with people who inherit more able to buy houses & retire.

minipie · 15/06/2022 22:22

I think the current era where many people are able to enjoy a long retirement, a lot of it in good health, is going to be a historical blip.

pfills · 15/06/2022 22:21

Life expectancy has stalled in the UK though despite pension age increasing