Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the whole idea of retirement is going to become unrealistic

209 replies

worksmartandfast · 15/06/2022 20:27

I am sad writing this as I think it is a truely nice idea that people get to take some time out to enjoy life but my practical head says it can't continue. When the age was set to retire that was a policy made for a totally different era, people started work at 15 and died at 65 in general society has completely changed since then. It was never envisaged that education would last so long for children/young people it is really an accident of history that for the last decades it has been possible to effectively stop working in their early 60s/late 50s despite being perfectly capable adults and spend potentially 15/20 years living a life of pure leisure. While I'm sure this idea will be unpopular in reality I can't see how in a world with ever better medical care increasing life expentancy it can be expected that it will be possible for it to be the norm that most people can spend the final quater of their lives retired even if they are perfectly able to work. Aibu?

OP posts:
dolphinsarentcommon · 16/06/2022 08:37

Justkeeppedaling · 16/06/2022 08:03

My DM started working in mid 20s (doctor, lots of training). She retired at 55 and she's 90 this year and shows no signs of dying 😀. She's already been retired for onger than she worked.

That's brilliant! How fabulous, she must have been a bit of a trail blazer in her younger days.. so glad she's had a long retirement.

Eeksteek · 16/06/2022 08:35

Isn’t life expectancy now declining? So it might be a self-liming problem. Not that that’s a good thing….

InChocolateWeTrust · 16/06/2022 08:33

Also, if no one retires, where do young people get their jobs? How do people progress in their careers?

Young people get their jobs because we actually have a labour shortage in many areas. We need more working people.

People progress in their careers but more slowly reflecting a longer working life. This is already happening.years ago in careers like accountancy or law people expected to make partner in 10 years, now it's at least 15, and firms don't let most partners stay at that level for more than about 15 years unless you are very exceptional - you are expected to move on and do something else, lots will scale back and do some part time consultancies etc from their mid 50s onwards for example.

AntlerRose · 16/06/2022 08:29

Reistically wealthy people will do whatever they want just like always.

Poorer people will work until they cant and there will be either unemployment benefits whilst they fruitlessly search for a job or disability benefits. These will replace pensions, cost the same but make the elite feel better than noone is having any fun.

InChocolateWeTrust · 16/06/2022 08:28

Tootiredtocare

I think most people under 50 simply don't realise their DC pots won't buy anything like the annuity they are expecting. People are quite shit at maths. Most people even with private pots just won't be able to afford it - annuity providers will increasingly be pricing in that someone retiring late 60s may draw the pension for 30+ years so you will need a huge huge pot to buy a decent annuity.

Ferrarilover · 16/06/2022 08:25

Unfortunately, a 65 year old body is very often creaky, with disabilities. I'm not saying that this is the norm - there are people who are fit and healthy at that age, but many of us are not.
I'm 69 and there is no way I could make my body go to work. I can't even walk properly.

InChocolateWeTrust · 16/06/2022 08:24

I definitely think there needs to be a change from the idea that you can a) not really start your career/pension contribs until approaching 25 (having done a degree, a masters, a gap year, often another year or two "working out what you want to do", then b) retire at 65 and start a 30 year retirement. It makes no sense to spend around half your adult life essentially in leisure or unpaid education/other pursuits.

However, I do think there's an issue with the fact that people live too long in a state of health where actually they arent really fit to work.

I think where we need to land is a) most people need to be working part time from 16 alongside studies, and trying to encourage people to be saving even a little from an earlier age as this is the saving that compounds and grows the most and b) planning to not fully retire but continue some work in lower responsibility roles for longer, into 70s. I think keeping doing something is good for you, keeps you young!

My mum was a teacher and retired basically at 60 - in reality, she could have been great as a TA for another 10 years or so.

I'm sure there are lots of professions where there are lower responsibility roles people could move into as they age. I think people struggle to accept the reduction in rate of pay however, and feel it "isnt worth it".

I don't think younger generations will get a choice. My parents had great defined benefit pension schemes but people my age don't and we just won't be able to afford long retirements. I work in a complicated finance role now but as I age I plan to move into doing a more simple bookkeeper type role to keep a bit of income.

tootiredtoocare · 16/06/2022 08:23

Depends on the job, fair enough if you're in an office at a desk. Not so much if you're a carer, a mechanic, a childcare worker, work in a factory. Also, if no one retires, where do young people get their jobs? How do people progress in their careers? The state pension won't be worth the time it takes to claim it by the time I retire even, so if we have our own pension pots that we've contributed to since we were 18, we deserve to enjoy them. We can't afford for people not to retire. I don't know why you're so against people finishing their working lives and enjoying their old age.

thefamilyupstairs · 16/06/2022 08:19

I'm 40 and very much agree with a pp that we have to value and prioritise leisure time more when you are young. We could lead a much more lavish lifestyle than we do (we have average house, 2 old but functioning cars, don't spend much money on house or clothes) but we choose to work LTFT so that we can holiday lots and generally do the pursuits we want to NOW.
All of my DMs friends have retired and are doing at least 2 days per week childcare, no one is idling sitting around watching TV all day.

CounsellorTroi · 16/06/2022 08:16

A lot of my child-free friends express envy and say 'I wish I could go part time'. But why can't they? Financially it's a hit but they don't have children to pay for so they could have a really nice balance to their lives. It's just not seen as acceptable though, and the idea that we must grind all the time until we retire and finally get a rest or time to focus on other things seems really unhealthy to me.

Childfree women who want to work part time are judged though. They are seen as lazy. Where I worked, if you had no school aged children there was little chance of having a request to go part time approved unless you were very senior and had a lot of clout.

Undecided111 · 16/06/2022 08:09

I potentially agree about government funded retirement but for many people (our family included) I can see a time when the mortgage is paid off and our children have left home when our income requirement is a fraction of what it is now (we put about half our income into the mortgage as it for instance).

So once we have a much cheaper life we may be able to live on retirement savings that we are now accruing.

FourTeaFallOut · 16/06/2022 08:05

The are places in the UK where average healthy life expectancy fall so short compared to pensionable age that it seems like a cruel joke.

The place with the lowest male healthy life expectancy at birth is Blackpool (53.7 years), followed by Belfast (54.4 years) and Glasgow (54.6 years).

I'm not sure what the answer is but I think it needs a strategy to include the staggering differences in health equality across the country.

Justkeeppedaling · 16/06/2022 08:03

My DM started working in mid 20s (doctor, lots of training). She retired at 55 and she's 90 this year and shows no signs of dying 😀. She's already been retired for onger than she worked.

Discovereads · 16/06/2022 07:49

Alexandra2001 · 16/06/2022 07:43

Employers will just throw it in the bin, D.O.B is a key fact to put on a CV.

My former employer called folk in their 50s "Grey Tops" unsuitable for on going training or advancement.

Ageism is rife in the workplace and thats from a SeeTec advisor, working with the DWP, to try and get longer term unemployed into work, she said once they see the applicant is late 50s or older, they know its a waste of time.

God no, never put your date of birth on a CV.
And no employers don’t throw those CVs in the bin.
My DH (over 50) lost his job during Covid and it was only after he’d age proofed his CV that he started to get interviews..,.which led to a really good job. Literally, the changes he made to his CV were what I listed above. So a CV showing less work experience was better than his CV showing all his work experience. Because ageism.
The changes he did were advised to him by the Job Centre work coach as well. So it’s not like we came up with this ourselves.

maddiemookins16mum · 16/06/2022 07:48

SingingSands · 15/06/2022 21:23

I work in an office based role and two of my colleagues have been discussing retirement. One of them is adamant she won't retire yet, but I think she should. She is no longer capable of keeping up with the job role, the technology is beyond her. She "downsized" her role last year and even with that I am having to redo a lot of her work, fix mistakes, talk her through steps and processes that I've already explained 50 times and generally I feel that she's now only capable of the most basic of tasks. And that's really worrying because in less than 20 years I can see myself being the same.

We might be living longer but it doesn't mean we are capable of continuing with the same output.

I think we might work in the same team! We have a lady who is 67 (no intention of retiring), can’t (won’t) use Teams, can’t (won’t) learn a new system we have and we can’t see how otherwise she can do her job for the foreseeable future. She is no longer able to do a lot of her role due to her age (she simply cannot grasp anything beyond the stuff she was doing 15-20 years ago).

Discovereads · 16/06/2022 07:45

Blimeyherewegoagain · 16/06/2022 07:30

Leave your age and some dates off your CV .

Yes you do have to age proof your CV.


  • Drop dates for all education/degrees/qualifications

  • If qualifications names have changed, use the current equivalent to what you have.

  • Only include the last 15yrs of job experience if you are using dates doing a chronological type CV

  • Or do a functional CV that lists ~ 15 yrs of positions by relevancy to the job advert.

  • Don’t do any video CVs

onlythreenow · 16/06/2022 07:44

Leave your age and some dates off your CV.

Thanks, but my age isn't on my CV, and as I have only had two full time jobs if I leave off the first one they will think I am 20 years younger than I am - until they see me!!

Alexandra2001 · 16/06/2022 07:43

Blimeyherewegoagain · 16/06/2022 07:30

Leave your age and some dates off your CV .

Employers will just throw it in the bin, D.O.B is a key fact to put on a CV.

My former employer called folk in their 50s "Grey Tops" unsuitable for on going training or advancement.

Ageism is rife in the workplace and thats from a SeeTec advisor, working with the DWP, to try and get longer term unemployed into work, she said once they see the applicant is late 50s or older, they know its a waste of time.

Discovereads · 16/06/2022 07:39

Unless we start upping immigration substantially we are going to experience a rapidly aging population with a lack of working young people to support the elderly.

The data doesn’t support this. You’d be right if we had a bow wave of middle aged people about to retire and need elder care. But demographics by age are pretty much an even column- meaning that our age distribution population wise shows no evidence that scenario would happen. We don’t actually need more working age people.

Dont forget, people die off as they get older in all age brackets. The entire top of the chart from age 70+ are the baby boomers. The largest generation ever born. But even though later generations are smaller you can see there are still enough of us to care for this generation (who are the current elderly).

to think the whole idea of retirement is going to become unrealistic
idonthavetimeorhis · 16/06/2022 07:39

Retirement did not always mean you put on your slippers and did nothing from the day you stopped working until the day you died. There was once a very important sector of society who provided (often unpaid) childcare, worked in volunteering positions, helped out in their local communities and so on and so on. The idea that we need to have paid employment until we die is one that totally disregards the importance of that unpaid section of society.

Furthermore, although we are living longer, health problems connected to age are still prevalent. I am in my early sixties and, to be honest, I had totally accepted the fact that I would be working long past the time that I would be able to draw my old age pension. I did not mind. I love my work and I like the income. Then I was diagnosed with a progressive illness. It is an illness that creeps up on you and often manifests itself as you get older. Already, I tire easier and I cannot cope quite so well with stress. I have realised that in five years time, when I can draw my state pension, I will not be in a financial position to retire, yet I could very well be struggling to work.

So, yes, it is great to continue working for as long as you can, if this is something you want to do and you are still able to work. Yet, those people who can retire can still make a valuable contribution to society.

The nightmare scenario that I can see emerging is that there will be an increasing number of people who really should not be working either through age and/or failing health, who continue working because they cannot live on £185 (or less) a week.

Blimeyherewegoagain · 16/06/2022 07:30

onlythreenow · 16/06/2022 06:39

However, ageism is still rife in the workplace so where are the opportunities for older people going to come from

Exactly. I have been unemployed, other than a few temp/casual jobs since I was 59. My CV looks good, I have been highly valued for the temp/casual jobs - but will anyone give me a proper job? No, they won't and at now almost 63 I have lost hope.

Leave your age and some dates off your CV .

Discovereads · 16/06/2022 07:30

NotKevinTurvey · 16/06/2022 00:05

You can retire when you want, you just need to match your spending to your situation. There’s a whole movement based around retiring young called “FIRE” (financial independence, retire early) based on spending incredibly frugally while working in order to give up working young.

It’s worth looking up if a long retirement is your goal.

Oh yes, I followed this for awhile along with Money Moustache. But inevitability you have to make money to save money. These people all brag about living on say £20k a year expenses BUT earn upwards of £100k a year combined. So it’s no wonder that by pretending to live in poverty for ten years they get that £600k pot of money that allows them to be mortgage free. (Not to mention that every “disaster” that happens they have cash to cover it and complain about being set back by “months”). Then in another five years and they start getting passive income streams from second homes or investments. So that by 40 they’re getting pregnant and working PT “only” earning £70k/yr or so.

This doesn’t apply to the majority of people, but to the privileged middle class.

OctaviaC74 · 16/06/2022 06:57

IncompleteSenten · 15/06/2022 20:52

People are living longer and the retirement age needs to reflect that.

How many posters on here get furious about ageism and say how their parents are 60, 70+ and are far from elderly, still fit as fiddles, hiking etc.

These are not people who need to retire, clearly.

A system where you can get your pension early (say at 60-65 instead of 70) on medical grounds but if you are fit and healthy then you work until 70 if you haven't got a private pension that allows you to retire early.

Of course, that also requires massive input to stop employers age discrimination.

The state doesn't owe us all 20 or 30 years of retirement. There should be a medical element to retirement age imo.

Thats a very Tory view... work till you die, maybe have a crematorium in every office block?
I bet it wont apply to you though!

People pay in for their retirement and whilst folk may need to pay in more, i think 45 years of working is plenty long enough, how many people in their late 60s are really fit and healthy? among those who have done more physical roles, very few.

Many jobs are just not suitable for older workers to do, most forms of physical work, driving jobs, many medical ones etc

..and how are younger people supposed to get on if there is no where for them to go?

People maybe living longer (though i think that trend has reversed recently) but healthier?

Take look the next time you go to a hospital or a GP surgery, these places are packed with the over 50s.

onlythreenow · 16/06/2022 06:39

However, ageism is still rife in the workplace so where are the opportunities for older people going to come from

Exactly. I have been unemployed, other than a few temp/casual jobs since I was 59. My CV looks good, I have been highly valued for the temp/casual jobs - but will anyone give me a proper job? No, they won't and at now almost 63 I have lost hope.

lightand · 16/06/2022 06:33

They are all part of what the op is talking about!

Swipe left for the next trending thread