Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the whole idea of retirement is going to become unrealistic

209 replies

worksmartandfast · 15/06/2022 20:27

I am sad writing this as I think it is a truely nice idea that people get to take some time out to enjoy life but my practical head says it can't continue. When the age was set to retire that was a policy made for a totally different era, people started work at 15 and died at 65 in general society has completely changed since then. It was never envisaged that education would last so long for children/young people it is really an accident of history that for the last decades it has been possible to effectively stop working in their early 60s/late 50s despite being perfectly capable adults and spend potentially 15/20 years living a life of pure leisure. While I'm sure this idea will be unpopular in reality I can't see how in a world with ever better medical care increasing life expentancy it can be expected that it will be possible for it to be the norm that most people can spend the final quater of their lives retired even if they are perfectly able to work. Aibu?

OP posts:
CounsellorTroi · 16/06/2022 19:33

Let me repeat. The taxes from 40 years of working does not cover decades of retirement. You have not earned it!!

I paid into an occupational pension for 40 years as well as 40 years of income tax and NI. And never claimed child benefit or tax credits.

gegs73 · 16/06/2022 19:30

Sandcastles24 · 16/06/2022 19:03

ANBU

This generation is so entitled to think they deserve decades of retirement. When the state pensions were initially created they where only supposed to fund 3 years on average THREE. People are living way longer even if life expectancy are finally stalling. Why should the younger generation be funding the decades of retirement when they can't even save a fraction of that for their own. They will never get that because it is unsustainable

Let me repeat. The taxes from 40 years of working does not cover decades of retirement. You have not earned it!!

But how else are many people going to survive without a state pension. I'm not there yet but my private pension is predicted to be ridiculously small (£500 a year!) despite paying in for 20 years. DH has a company (not final salary) pension he has been paying in for 25 years and it's small even with him and the company contributing at a decent rate. It’s worth less than one person minimum full time wage with both of us combined. We can't afford to pay anymore in 🤷‍♀️ Payments we make are in line with our salaries. We may get decades of state pension or may not, who knows. If so, we are most definitely not going to be living in luxury. If we can continue to work or earn money in some way we will, but who knows how our health will be. Many people are not able to work into their 70s due to chronic health problems. Some can, but many physically wouldn't be able to do it even with office type work. It would be very unusual for a 70 year old to be able to work full time in a physical job.

Since the state pension started, it has always been the case that younger generations have financed pensions with their taxes, they then in turn get the same when they are old. I see no reason to believe this won't continue. What other solution would there be other than letting old people starve homeless on the streets? Worst case scenario if state pensions were abolished, I would have thought is that people could claim universal credit though this once again would be funded by younger tax payers.

OompaLoompaa · 16/06/2022 19:09

Let me repeat. The taxes from 40 years of working does not cover decades of retirement. You have not earned it!!
I don’t understand this, my DH and I have 1.5 million in our pension pots, our mega taxes has paid many peoples child benefit etc. We are early to mid 50’s and haven’t even factored state pensions into our calculations when we retired earlier this year.

Sandcastles24 · 16/06/2022 19:03

ANBU

This generation is so entitled to think they deserve decades of retirement. When the state pensions were initially created they where only supposed to fund 3 years on average THREE. People are living way longer even if life expectancy are finally stalling. Why should the younger generation be funding the decades of retirement when they can't even save a fraction of that for their own. They will never get that because it is unsustainable

Let me repeat. The taxes from 40 years of working does not cover decades of retirement. You have not earned it!!

theleafandnotthetree · 16/06/2022 18:42

minipie · 15/06/2022 22:22

I think the current era where many people are able to enjoy a long retirement, a lot of it in good health, is going to be a historical blip.

I agree, how people have lived GENERALLY in the last 50 to 60 years is an anomoly in the long span of human history, largely artificially created by drawing down the earths resources for the now. I fully expect correction of that, if people think that the average person in 2060 will get 20+ years to go on cruises, play golf and go out for lunch after they retire, they're dreaming.

theleafandnotthetree · 16/06/2022 18:34

bakebeans · 15/06/2022 21:21

Definitely. They want u to be ready for your coffin or at least lost your marbles by the time u retire so you cannot claim state pension that you have been paying into all your life. You cannot even opt out of national insurance contributions anymore.

Who is 'they'? This wasn't planned by anybody, the fact that we now live substantially longer and healthy lives is a social good but creates a massive financial time-bomb in the context of demographic imbalance. That is simply a reality regardless of political persuasion, system of government or who is in power at a particular time.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 16/06/2022 18:28

@AclowncalledAlice however with the new trucks - already semi automated,
and the fully automated road trains due soon those issue are negated. It doesn’t matter about eyesight and reaction times. The truck does it for you. (Imo I hate them but that’s modernisation for you).
the drivers causing accidents or dying behind the wheel or committing suicide are the 40-50 year olds. The older drivers are in many ways a lot safer. As for hip/ knee problems - they don’t happen to the same degree due to automatic gearboxes. But these age related issues can also happen in any industry at any age even office work. My pony is at least there are medical checks in place - I would prefer a 70 year old lorry driver to be in work over a 70 year old carer or nurse who have no such checks either for their own safety or for the safety of others.

Ginisnnice · 16/06/2022 18:14

We managed to re frame it. We took our work.pensions at 55 58 ( which meant reduced ,but started early) we then work in our non stressful job s to supplement our income until.state pension but will.probably still.need some work. This means we feel semi retired as normal.jobs for us are easier than our challenging careers.( physical but not stressful) and we have also got a smaller house, reduced our outgoings, eat v simply. So its a bit like the poster who.said old idea of rerirement may be goñe but to replace with part time work ongoing which i think they do in some.cultures.

AclowncalledAlice · 16/06/2022 18:09

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 16/06/2022 18:01

It’s quite common though. At least they have medical checks annually. Car drivers self certify. Anymore drivers leaving haulage will only exacerbate the acute lack of them meaning even higher prices/shortages.

My dad was a trucker for most of his life....apart from 7 years in the army where he got his licence. By the time he retired he had hip and knee problems which reduced his ability to react quickly to situations. The medicals just checked his eyesight, blood pressure heart etc, but never his reaction times. It's a very common problem amongst those that spend most of their adult working life behind a wheel and/or clambering up into a trailer.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 16/06/2022 18:01

AclowncalledAlice · 16/06/2022 17:32

Some jobs are just not safe enough to carry on doing when you reach the current retirement age though. I mean 70 year olds driving huge lorries and buses....I mean what could possibly go wrong?

It’s quite common though. At least they have medical checks annually. Car drivers self certify. Anymore drivers leaving haulage will only exacerbate the acute lack of them meaning even higher prices/shortages.

Getoff · 16/06/2022 17:49

On the other hand, if they don’t retire then there won’t be enough jobs for young people. I had this argument with a friend who thinks it’s great that his Dad is still able to work at 84. I pointed out that he was depriving a young person of that job, a person who wanted to use that salary to get a mortgage and have kids. Who was probably broke and stuck renting because his Dad was hogging that secure well paid job instead of passing it on.

This argument is wrong. There are not a fixed number of jobs in the economy, and there is no reason every able adult who needs or wants to should not be doing something useful, all of the time.

Every person who goes to work adds to GDP, everyone who opts out decreases it. In the above scenario, if the young person is not better qualified to do the old persons job, there will be something else they can do, and if the pay isn't enough to induce them to do it, then it's probably because politics is sticking it oar in and overriding the economic incentives that would otherwise exist.

AclowncalledAlice · 16/06/2022 17:32

Some jobs are just not safe enough to carry on doing when you reach the current retirement age though. I mean 70 year olds driving huge lorries and buses....I mean what could possibly go wrong?

IceScreamIcecreamFaB99 · 16/06/2022 16:46

Ref
most people need to be working part time from 16 alongside studies

I started PT work & studied from 16

So if I retire at state pension age, it will be 52 years of working

thecatsthecats · 16/06/2022 16:32

One thing I wonder about is the use of the wisdom of older workers without the continuous need to stay up to date with the latest methods.

I work in an IT/Ops role, and even forty year old seem to struggle to adapt to the most basic and intuitive changes in technology (like MFA). I think more thought could go into how to use older staff wisely without requiring them to keep up to date constantly.

DarkCharlotte · 16/06/2022 16:29

And yet this is a valid point.
The elderly in our society are often not valued the same way that they are in other cultures.

Is it? What do elderly people with no family do? What do people with no parents do for childcare? I don't think society should be set up on the assumption that elderly parents will be cared for by their children or that grandparents will be childcarers for their grandkids.

DarkCharlotte · 16/06/2022 16:23

most people need to be working part time from 16 alongside studies

Wow. Retire later, start working earlier. Who would want this life? Awful.

Anxiernie · 16/06/2022 16:21

I know someone who lived to age 90+ who had 32 years of retirement.

Which is lovely for them and I wouldn't begrudge anyone that.

HollaHolla · 16/06/2022 14:44

God, I'd love to think I'll have much of a retirement. I'm single and childless, so only my income to take into account. I'm 46, and my pensionable age is currently 67.5. I'll have been in the scheme for 43 years by then. I don't know how I can continue to work at this intensity for another 20 years. My pension scheme is going through significant changes which will be detrimental to my payments.
I'd like to marry money, but I can't see that being likely.....

BeyondMyWits · 16/06/2022 14:30

I semi retired 3 years ago... after a heart attack. Do not see myself getting to 67, so thought I'd take early retirement from a stressful IT post- on call 24hrs etc- and work part time in a less stressful environment... gives me around the same amount of cash as I would have at 67. So no big round the world cruise money. But enough to muddle on with.

People with a big paying career can probably afford to do what I am, others... not so lucky.

Wheretheskyisblue · 16/06/2022 14:21

Discovereads · 16/06/2022 07:39

Unless we start upping immigration substantially we are going to experience a rapidly aging population with a lack of working young people to support the elderly.

The data doesn’t support this. You’d be right if we had a bow wave of middle aged people about to retire and need elder care. But demographics by age are pretty much an even column- meaning that our age distribution population wise shows no evidence that scenario would happen. We don’t actually need more working age people.

Dont forget, people die off as they get older in all age brackets. The entire top of the chart from age 70+ are the baby boomers. The largest generation ever born. But even though later generations are smaller you can see there are still enough of us to care for this generation (who are the current elderly).

www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/birthsdeathsandmarriages/ageing/articles/livinglongerhowourpopulationischangingandwhyitmatters/2018-08-13

'Through the latter half of the 20th Century, the UK population has been steadily getting older and this trend is projected to continue in the future. In 2016, there were 11.8 million UK residents aged 65 years and over, representing 18% of the total population – 25 years before, there were 9.1 million, accounting for 15.8% of the population.

Looking ahead 25 years to 2041, the 1960s baby boomers (aged in their 50s now) will have moved into older age and by 2066 there will be a further 8.6 million projected UK residents aged 65 years and over, taking the total number in this group to 20.4 million and making up 26% of the total population. This increase in numbers is broadly equivalent to the size of the population of London today.

The fastest increase will be seen in the 85 years and over age group. In mid-2016, there were 1.6 million people aged 85 years and over (2% of the total population); by mid-2041 this is projected to double to 3.2 million (4% of the population) and by 2066 to treble, by which time there will be 5.1 million people aged 85 years and over making up 7% of the total UK population. In contrast, the population aged 16 to 64 years is projected to increase by only 2% over the next 25 years and by 5% by 2066 (Figure 2).'

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 16/06/2022 13:58

lljkk · 16/06/2022 13:50

I'll believe that when the robots learn to navigate stairs and are cheap, adaptable and safe enough to be deployed wiping bottoms in care homes.

I hope those same robots are self repairing when the residents decide to smack them with a stick/frame/trip them up/throw stuff at them/hit them/fall on them.
Given care home bosses renowned stinginess, people will still be caring for others for decades.

lljkk · 16/06/2022 13:50

I'll believe that when the robots learn to navigate stairs and are cheap, adaptable and safe enough to be deployed wiping bottoms in care homes.

CounsellorTroi · 16/06/2022 13:34

Society will need to find a way to deal with a huge number of unemployed people of all ages - it will become abnormal to be in work, not out of it.

There’s a chilling little short story by J G Ballard, called Wish You Were Here, dealing with that very theme.

WhateverHappenedToMe · 16/06/2022 13:24

Just a thought, but aren't those older people working into their late 60s and 70s occupying jobs that could be taken by younger people? And, on the whole, don't older people need less government support than younger people (mortgage paid off, no dependent children)? Obviously excluding those older people needing high-level care, but they're unlikely to be working.

So wouldn't it be a good idea to let those older people retire, even if it does mean paying a pension, and allow younger people to move upwards?

Dotjones · 16/06/2022 13:13

While common sense might suggest people will have to work longer and longer, this won't actually be feasible. Not because older people are incapable of working, but simply because most jobs currently done by humans will be replaced by computers and robots before long. Society will need to find a way to deal with a huge number of unemployed people of all ages - it will become abnormal to be in work, not out of it.