Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the whole idea of retirement is going to become unrealistic

209 replies

worksmartandfast · 15/06/2022 20:27

I am sad writing this as I think it is a truely nice idea that people get to take some time out to enjoy life but my practical head says it can't continue. When the age was set to retire that was a policy made for a totally different era, people started work at 15 and died at 65 in general society has completely changed since then. It was never envisaged that education would last so long for children/young people it is really an accident of history that for the last decades it has been possible to effectively stop working in their early 60s/late 50s despite being perfectly capable adults and spend potentially 15/20 years living a life of pure leisure. While I'm sure this idea will be unpopular in reality I can't see how in a world with ever better medical care increasing life expentancy it can be expected that it will be possible for it to be the norm that most people can spend the final quater of their lives retired even if they are perfectly able to work. Aibu?

OP posts:
minipie · 16/06/2022 20:40

Nobody wants to abolish anything Confused we are saying it will become unaffordable for most people to have a long retirement.

iwishiwasafish · 16/06/2022 20:39

I can’t quite get my head around this thread. Are people genuinely suggesting that all savings or passive income sources be confiscated from people when they reach 67, or is it “just” the state pension people want to abolish?

DuesToTheDirt · 16/06/2022 20:28

Sandcastles24 · 16/06/2022 19:03

ANBU

This generation is so entitled to think they deserve decades of retirement. When the state pensions were initially created they where only supposed to fund 3 years on average THREE. People are living way longer even if life expectancy are finally stalling. Why should the younger generation be funding the decades of retirement when they can't even save a fraction of that for their own. They will never get that because it is unsustainable

Let me repeat. The taxes from 40 years of working does not cover decades of retirement. You have not earned it!!

Absolutely. Pensions were supposed to prevent people becoming destitute in old age, or financial burdens to their families. They were never intended to fund 30 years of cruises, and new cars every few years.

pfills · 16/06/2022 20:15

@ancientgran 🤞🏼

ancientgran · 16/06/2022 20:12

Dishwashersaurous · 16/06/2022 20:10

And the state pension is not an investment fund. Payments are made out of current contributions.

There is no individual pot which people save. It goes into a general pot

I think we all know that but if you are going to value our contributions it is reasonable to include notional interest, if the govt hadn't had our money it would have had to borrow it and pay interest.

Dishwashersaurous · 16/06/2022 20:10

And the state pension is not an investment fund. Payments are made out of current contributions.

There is no individual pot which people save. It goes into a general pot

ancientgran · 16/06/2022 20:09

pfills · 16/06/2022 20:01

Of course I don't pay NI now, still paying tax though.

From next year you will pay the h&s levy as that won't cease upon pension age.

I probably won't as I think I will retire at 70 although my boss says he won't let me!

pfills · 16/06/2022 20:07

I’ve not taken anything I wasn’t entitled to.

You're aware you are one individual & when talking about millions of people there will be differences. If everyone paid millions in tax then none of this would be an issue.

Dishwashersaurous · 16/06/2022 20:07

And I know that my calculation was very basic but it's illustrated the

ancientgran · 16/06/2022 20:07

kitcat15 · 15/06/2022 23:38

I’m 57 and a nurse…most of my colleagues and me have taken retirement in their 50s …. I retired then returned on 2 days…i don’t pick up much less than when I was working 5 days…l will retire completely at 59….very standard still to leave before 60 in nhs where i am

One nurse in Devon was still working in her 80s. I think that was reported about 4 years ago. Just googled her, she retired in 2018 at 86. She was an NHS nurse for 66 years. Amazing record. She did my weight/height/BP when I was admitted a few years ago. She easily seemed 20 years younger than her actual age, very positive cheerful woman.

iwishiwasafish · 16/06/2022 20:04

@Dishwashersaurous your calculation is flawed. You are not taking interest into account, which would be considerable over a 40 year period.

Dishwashersaurous · 16/06/2022 20:04

And figures not adjusted for inflation etc for simplicity.

State pension is paid out of current NI contributions. It's not an investment fund.

pfills · 16/06/2022 20:01

Of course I don't pay NI now, still paying tax though.

From next year you will pay the h&s levy as that won't cease upon pension age.

pfills · 16/06/2022 20:00

Also the cost of the NHS, free prescriptions, social care etc. Obviously this crosses all ages but need increases with age.

ancientgran · 16/06/2022 20:00

Wouldn't the contributions grow if invested or if Govt using the money then a notional interest rate should be added.

I started work at 15 and at 69 I'm still working. No idea how much NI I've paid but for many years was earning well above the average. Of course I don't pay NI now, still paying tax though.

Dishwashersaurous · 16/06/2022 19:54

Average salary in UK £26,000.
Annual national insurance payment £1867 per year.

Work for 40 years. Pay NI £74,680 over working life.

State pension £9, 627.

Pension age 67
Average life expectancy 84.

Pension paid for 17 years.

Total pension payment. £163, 659.

Therefore the pension payment is more than double the contributions.

Government has to make decisions on averages. Many many more people will pay in lots more. But many many people will pay in lots less.

So if wanted to balance the books for the average person then would need to more than double the amount that is paid in NI .

ancientgran · 16/06/2022 19:52

maddiemookins16mum · 15/06/2022 21:07

Things have changed since people retired at 60/65. We have (in the main) a better standard of living than even in the 80s.
That said, DH and I still have 10 years to retirement and we’re shattered. We often comment that surely we weren’t meant to work from 15 to nearly 70 (we both started work straight from School at 15 in 1979 and 1980). It does make me a little sad that unless we live a long life we might only see 10-15 years of retirement.

The school leaving age was 16 in 1979. I left school at 15 but it changed in 1971 I think.

CounsellorTroi · 16/06/2022 19:47

pfills · 16/06/2022 19:39

I paid into an occupational pension for 40 years as well as 40 years of income tax and NI. And never claimed child benefit or tax credits.

I don't think that makes you unique does it? I have paid NI since I was 17 & a pp since I was in my 20s. My retirement age is 68, that's a lot of NI contributions plus the new h&s levy is an additional one.

My state pension age is 67. My occupational pension age was 60. I retired on a voluntary early retirement scheme at age 58. I’ve not taken anything I wasn’t entitled to.

iwishiwasafish · 16/06/2022 19:46

Let me repeat. The taxes from 40 years of working does not cover decades of retirement. You have not earned it!!

I dispute that. By the time I retire, by a rough calculation I will have paid over £400k in NI (not to mention over £3M in taxes).

Let’s assume that the NI payment is split 50:50 pension and health care (so £200k over 40 years), and is the equivalent to investment at the point it was deducted. It would have grown to a pension pot of approx £500k after 40 years, and would give an annuity of £21kpa.

State pension is only £7kpa, so yes I think I have more than earned it!

Dishwashersaurous · 16/06/2022 19:44

In essence if people don't want to work, for whatever reason, then they need to save enough to be able to live their life without income.

If you work for 40 years and then have 30 years in retirement, then you are going to have to save significantly more to be able to afford it.

Sacrifice spending today for spending in the future.

Everyone could make that choice bit most people don't want to save enough. Very understandably when the cost of living is so high

pfills · 16/06/2022 19:42

I don’t understand this, my DH and I have 1.5 million in our pension pots, our mega taxes has paid many peoples child benefit etc. We are early to mid 50’s and haven’t even factored state pensions into our calculations when we retired earlier this year.

But surely you are aware most couples don't have million pound pensions?

Anxiernie · 16/06/2022 19:39

The concept of time to enjoy yourself between ending work and infirmity is a very recent one really.

But it's how it should be. Why should people spend their whole lives in education, work, or ill-health? We absolutely should have time to retire and enjoy life without working.

pfills · 16/06/2022 19:39

I paid into an occupational pension for 40 years as well as 40 years of income tax and NI. And never claimed child benefit or tax credits.

I don't think that makes you unique does it? I have paid NI since I was 17 & a pp since I was in my 20s. My retirement age is 68, that's a lot of NI contributions plus the new h&s levy is an additional one.

Dishwashersaurous · 16/06/2022 19:36

The very original concept of a pension was to provide subsistence living for people too old and infirm to work anymore who hadn't yet died. The very first retirement age was set after the average life expectancy. It was expected that the majority of people would die before retirement age.

The concept of time to enjoy yourself between ending work and infirmity is a very recent one really. Last 70 to 50 years maximum.

The retirement age and average life expectancy are 67 and 84. That's a long time.

Alexandra2001 · 16/06/2022 19:33

The vast majority don't live decades, retire at 67 and the average life span is around 80, so 13 years, barely ONE decade... its not very long is it? especially as much of it may well be with ill health.

If you die before retiring, nothing or very little will go to a surviving partner.