Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To approach this mum with this warning?

365 replies

swimmingwiththefishes · 15/06/2022 17:20

Ok so I would NEVER normally approach a mum and 'point something out' BUT,

It's a hot day here (26 when I went to the park earlier) and I took the dog out for a walk in my local park. Took DS2 who's 6 months.

As I walked around the park and across some fields, there were two mums sat having a picnic of some sorts in the sun (no shade).

One of the mums obviously had a baby for a nap in the pram (I assume baby as bassinet attachment). To create some shade she had taken two muslins and draped them over the opening of the bassinet and clipped them with pram clips across the openings.

I'm pretty sure that this creates a hothouse type effect and can be quite dangerous. I actually had DS2 also napping and had a snuzshade draped over to stop the sunlight creeping in (black thin material with air holes to create shade but let the air flow).

I ummed and errd but decided I had to say something so really thought about the least offensive way to say it (I'm sure I could have found better!!).

Below is the convo. My friend thinks I was totally out of order to do this but I think I couldn't in good conscious not say anything

Me; gosh, it's soooo hot today isn't it? Nice to have some sun but poor little ones get so hot
Mum: oh yes, we're enjoying being able to get some sun!
Me: I'm not sure if it's helpful but I've found these snuzshade things really good as they let the air in so much more lightweight and breathable than muslins.
Mum: what do you mean?
Me: sorry, it's just I've read that muslins don't let the air through so can make babies hotter so I just thought I'd mention how great I've found this product as not sure if you're aware?
Mum: tell you what? Why don't you fuck right off and leave us the fuck alone
Me: ok, I'm literally trying to stop your child from overheating, that's all. Look it up.

I told my friend about the above convo and she said I probably came across as patronising and interfering. Yup, I probably did come across like that but that poor baby was probably roasting in there!

I'm sure I could have approached it better but WIBU?

OP posts:
Minimalme · 15/06/2022 19:07

Nah, you were fine.

If you had been the other Mum and posted:

"We were having a picnic when a woman came up and said that Muslims clipped together could cause baby to overheat. She had the audacity to suggest a sage solution so I told her to fuck off."

Now that would be rude and MN would be equally rude in explaining why.

You did a good thing.

TheGoogleMum · 15/06/2022 19:05

You meant well, nobody likes having their parenting criticised even if you're right! I think its good you mentioned it overall

oakleaffy · 15/06/2022 19:03

PaddingtonBearStareAgain · 15/06/2022 18:51

It isn't just about them getting hot. Thete have been horrendous incidents of burnt paws.

On grass?? or Earth?

Unless it’s on fire I doubt grass or earth gets hot enough.
If a human can comfortably walk, barefoot a dog can.
Common sense.
A closed- mouth dog isn’t hot.
Always carry water.

galvanizethis · 15/06/2022 19:02

I had a lady approach me in M&S over the same thing - and it was a cold day. I just said thanks for letting me know and I'd let some air in.
They were rude CF's and I would have probably given them a mouthful if they'd responded like that to me. Some people are pigs.

almostmummyof2 · 15/06/2022 19:00

I think you did the right thing. Child's safety first 100%

namechangetheworld · 15/06/2022 18:56

I'm normally firmly in the "don't get involved" camp but YWNBU. Seeing babies prams draped with muslins makes me shiver, poor little things.

mnahmnah · 15/06/2022 18:54

@JudgeJ

She was hardly ramming opinions down someone’s throat! This is a now we’ll-known safety issue where babies have been harmed. OP was trying to be helpful in a polite and friendly way. Big difference!

It’s interesting to see a big divide in here between people who generally chat to other mums and share ideas, helpful advice etc and see that as the norm. And others who are defensive and hostile to anyone who dare point out something helpful. OP was hardly having a go or being judgemental about a parenting style. This was about safety.

swimmingwiththefishes · 15/06/2022 18:54

For those insisting a Muslin was 'fine' as it's hardly a thick blanket, I post AGAIN this snippet from news article linked in earlier post

Over a period of seven minutes, when left open and uncovered, the pram heated up from 23.3 degrees to 29.9 degrees - an increase of just over 6.5 degrees.
But over the same amount of time, when covered by a muslin cloth, the pram heated up from 22.0 degrees to a sweltering 35.1 degrees - heating up by 13 degrees

@HearMeSnore Yes, thanks. Another poster posted something similar so I'll definitely stick to an uncovered pram from now on!

OP posts:
Greyarea12 · 15/06/2022 18:53

I would of appreciated the advice. Guaranteed she will look it up and will be secretly glad you told her despite how rude she was.

Bentley123 · 15/06/2022 18:52

I would have want to have been told- anything to do with a baby’s safety trumps worrying about feeling or being patronised- I would have been pleased for the advice!

PaddingtonBearStareAgain · 15/06/2022 18:51

oakleaffy · 15/06/2022 18:50

Hardly!
Depends on dog breed.
A fine coated slim , Long nosed fit Sighthound type breed is absolutely fine at 26degs c
A fat, unfit, heavy coated breed will struggle, as will any puggy squashy faced dog.
Every case on it’s merits.

It isn't just about them getting hot. Thete have been horrendous incidents of burnt paws.

5128gap · 15/06/2022 18:51

If you felt that strongly you'd have been better off saying it straight out
"excuse me, I know I'm interfering here, but (whatever evidence you have for this) says your baby is in danger of overheating. (However many) babies each summer are made seriously ill or die due to this so I couldn't in all conscience not tell you. There is this product that you can use instead"
Faffing about pretending to drop it into conversation is patronising. If it needs saying, say it straight.

JudgeJ · 15/06/2022 18:50

mnahmnah · 15/06/2022 17:22

I think you were fine saying what you did. She was incredibly rude. If she didn’t want your advice she could have just smiled and said ‘ok’. I didn’t know this about muslins with my first ten years ago. If someone had said what you had, my response would have been ‘really?! Oh! Thanks’

So one opinion is preferable to another? The OP was incredibly rude trying to ram her views down someone's throat like that.

oakleaffy · 15/06/2022 18:50

Autumndays123 · 15/06/2022 18:36

Whilst I can't fault you trying to protect the baby you absolutely should not be walking your dog anywhere near 26'C. That is grossly cruel and neglectful on your part

Hardly!
Depends on dog breed.
A fine coated slim , Long nosed fit Sighthound type breed is absolutely fine at 26degs c
A fat, unfit, heavy coated breed will struggle, as will any puggy squashy faced dog.
Every case on it’s merits.

HearMeSnore · 15/06/2022 18:49

You might find this blog post interesting- by the inventor of the snoozeshade. (Perhaps the mum you spoke to had already read it. Who knows.)

www.snoozeshade.com/blogs/news/please-dont-be-scared-by-the-its-dangerous-to-cover-your-pram-story

beachbumlife · 15/06/2022 18:48

Someone came up to me to tell me to not walk our puppy in the heat a couple years ago and i was grateful they did so i do think she was unnecessarily rude.

Goldencarp · 15/06/2022 18:48

I think I would have told you to mind your own business. It wasn’t a thick blanket it was a muslin for one and secondly it’s really not your concern.

hellobeautifulsoul · 15/06/2022 18:45

I don't think you came across badly, I think they were rude with what they said and it makes them look worse than you. If I had unwanted advice from a stranger I would say, thank you for your concern but we are fine here. Have a good day.
I think your heart was in the right place, I've read about that and stopped doing it immediately with my youngest son.
Like others have said, you did your part and you tried. Don't bother in future it's obviously not appreciated and a lot of people don't like having randomers telling them to do/not to do something. Let them learn the hard way x

Holly60 · 15/06/2022 18:45

No you were fine - you can't just not say anything about an overheating baby because it might be seen as interfering.

Those people telling you, you shouldn't have walked your dog have totally missed the point. It's not about never doing anything wrong, it's about passing on important information if you have it and you think someone else doesn't.

If someone had stopped you and told you you shouldn't be walking your dog, I'm sure you, like me, would have said 'oh ok thanks I didn't realise that' and taken the dog home.

It's called being a community.

swimmingwiththefishes · 15/06/2022 18:44

Have we reached 'cancel the cheque' peak status yet?

OP posts:
RestingMurderousFace · 15/06/2022 18:44

This is really useful if you're ever unsure.

To approach this mum with this warning?
orbitalcrisis · 15/06/2022 18:44

This was actually debunked by the inventor of snoozeshade, it's on the snoozeshade website.

Canyouanswermyquestion · 15/06/2022 18:44

Ive not rtft but your just as bad taking a dog out in that heat and you have the audacity to patronise someone else 🙄 i would have told you to fuck off aswell

swimmingwiththefishes · 15/06/2022 18:43

@starfishmummy I've addressed the dog comments numerous times but he wasnt on the lead (not sure where you got that from). I live literally behind the park. DDog was alongside the pram across the field then in the river while we walked along the bank. He wouldn't be happy on the lead in his lovely park.

OP posts:
SouperNoodle · 15/06/2022 18:42

waveyourpompoms · 15/06/2022 18:40

Her reaction is aggressive because she doesn’t like being told she’s doing something unsafe with her baby. So instead of being grateful, taking it on board and thanking you — because we all make mistakes — she got nasty and defensive instead.

It’s exactly the same when you tell parents they’re risking giving their babies IBS and Crohns in adulthood by weaning before 6 months, or when you tell them they should be rear facing until age 4 minimum else they risk paralysis or internal decapitation.

They're not interested in actually keeping their baby safe, they just don’t want it pointed out that they’re not doing so.

You absolutely did the right thing.

This.