Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To approach this mum with this warning?

365 replies

swimmingwiththefishes · 15/06/2022 17:20

Ok so I would NEVER normally approach a mum and 'point something out' BUT,

It's a hot day here (26 when I went to the park earlier) and I took the dog out for a walk in my local park. Took DS2 who's 6 months.

As I walked around the park and across some fields, there were two mums sat having a picnic of some sorts in the sun (no shade).

One of the mums obviously had a baby for a nap in the pram (I assume baby as bassinet attachment). To create some shade she had taken two muslins and draped them over the opening of the bassinet and clipped them with pram clips across the openings.

I'm pretty sure that this creates a hothouse type effect and can be quite dangerous. I actually had DS2 also napping and had a snuzshade draped over to stop the sunlight creeping in (black thin material with air holes to create shade but let the air flow).

I ummed and errd but decided I had to say something so really thought about the least offensive way to say it (I'm sure I could have found better!!).

Below is the convo. My friend thinks I was totally out of order to do this but I think I couldn't in good conscious not say anything

Me; gosh, it's soooo hot today isn't it? Nice to have some sun but poor little ones get so hot
Mum: oh yes, we're enjoying being able to get some sun!
Me: I'm not sure if it's helpful but I've found these snuzshade things really good as they let the air in so much more lightweight and breathable than muslins.
Mum: what do you mean?
Me: sorry, it's just I've read that muslins don't let the air through so can make babies hotter so I just thought I'd mention how great I've found this product as not sure if you're aware?
Mum: tell you what? Why don't you fuck right off and leave us the fuck alone
Me: ok, I'm literally trying to stop your child from overheating, that's all. Look it up.

I told my friend about the above convo and she said I probably came across as patronising and interfering. Yup, I probably did come across like that but that poor baby was probably roasting in there!

I'm sure I could have approached it better but WIBU?

OP posts:
Ace56 · 15/06/2022 19:37

Oh for the love of God!

Just came on to comment on the dog thing - people saying 26 degrees is ‘too hot’ to walk a dog. For goodness sake, what do you think dogs do in the majority of the world (which is hotter than the UK?) Do they all just keel over from heatstroke? I’ve just come back from Mexico and there are dogs everywhere, half feral, just wandering around happily. It’s over 26 degrees there every day for most of the year! Fair enough maybe don’t go on a massive hike or run a marathon with your dog, but a simple walk? Honestly.

Anyway OP, YANBU for approaching her.

StarFlecks · 15/06/2022 19:37

I've done this once, then looked it up and yes, you are right. Babies can over heat. I think you were right to say something as it's not something that intuitively is known (I'd thought the muslin would save the baby from sun burnt. Bad idea).

I think it would have been better though if you had just said it outright (ie baby can overheat behind the muslin screen) rather than start with small talk and then how good your own method is. You did sound patronising. There's no guarantee thhoughbgg that she would have received that better. At the end of the day though I hope she will look it up and stop doing it

MRex · 15/06/2022 19:33

It's always ok to try to help, but people get snippy if they're told they are doing the wrong thing. I've done similar, but started by saying that a health visitor told us that muslins or blankets actually increase the temperature in the pram and just letting them know. Pause for response, which was usually "but you have a blanket" and explain the snoozeshade is apparently ok, would they like to stick their hand in each pram to feel the difference. Every time, the person stuck a hand in each, and said "Oh wow, that is cooler", but also noticed their own pram was hotter than outside.

Actually, I might have just stopped one or two to say "sorry to interrupt, but I'm excited by how much cooler this snoozeshade is for my baby, would you like to feel the temperature in my pram" and had the exact same effect. Clearly we're all scientists at heart, evidence works.

Vikinga · 15/06/2022 19:33

I think it is better you said something but I would have said something like I didn't realise this until someone told me, that babies can overheat blah blah.

I remember a friend's mum telling me about her friend's daughter dying because she choked on a cherry tomato when she was me giving whole big grapes to my toddler. (I thought they were fine as they were big and long so not round but once I looked into it I was horrified). She may have thought better of telling me and I went on to have a few more kids and fed my kids a lot of grapes and cherry tomatoes. So glad she told me.

PaddingtonBearStareAgain · 15/06/2022 19:31

SafeMove · 15/06/2022 19:13

Walking a dog in 26 degree heat is not 'just as bad' as causing a baby to overheat ffs. MN is so strange sometimes.

I don't think anyone has said it is. What people have said is maybe get your own house in order before 'lecturing others'

IsThisNormal123 · 15/06/2022 19:31

YANBU
I didn’t know muslins were not breathable, although I didn’t ever clip it on to DC’s pram.

It’s a shame the mum was so offended about something that could have affected her child’s safety.

Hotnashsummerday · 15/06/2022 19:30

Yep, you were patronising! And what about your dog, poor thing.

HotWashCycle · 15/06/2022 19:29

You did the right thing OP. Sometimes its necessary to take a chance and a risk if it is in a good cause about something important like the baby. Good on you for doing it, and I am sorry she was so rude - probably defensive as knew she was not taking enough care of her baby.

Staffy1 · 15/06/2022 19:29

Wow, what a rude and uncalled for response. Even if you did put it a bit awkwardly, I would have just said, oh really, thanks for sharing, or something along those lines.

StarDolphins · 15/06/2022 19:29

TakeMeToYourLiar · 15/06/2022 17:24

I mean you should t have been walking your dog in that heat either so…

@TakeMeToYourLiar agree!

I’d have said thank you for your advice but you shouldn’t be walking your dog in it either.

swimmingwiththefishes · 15/06/2022 19:28

@ShirleyPhallus There absolutely is as I've quoted twice: increase in temp of 13 degrees in the sun. Increase risks of SIDS...

And as I said, muslin was clipped tightly around all sides.

OP posts:
swimlyn · 15/06/2022 19:25

What it comes down to is intelligence versus stupidity. You rock!

This thread also illustrates the problem beautifully...

Don't ever give up.

JanisMoplin · 15/06/2022 19:24

I would have been very annoyed at you because I come from a country where it is 40 in the shade, not a measly 26, and babies manage to survive. I also would have thought you were trying to sell me something.

I wouldn't have told you to fuck off.

ShirleyPhallus · 15/06/2022 19:23

Bombshell101 · 15/06/2022 19:14

I wonder if the posters jumping down your throat are the ones who cover/ed their prams with Muslims or blankets.

You meant well, you weren't trying to be spiteful. Like some others have said perhaps she felt silly and reacted badly she might look it up now

There is absolutely nothing wrong with covering your pram with a Muslin, as long as it isn’t tightly covered on all sides and has some air circulating

Bournetilly · 15/06/2022 19:22

YANBU it’s really dangerous and she shouldn’t of been so rude

Popsicle33 · 15/06/2022 19:18

You were being patronising and interfering. It also sounded as though you were going to launch into a MLM pitch! She overreacted bit I would've thought you were a twat

CaraSayer · 15/06/2022 19:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

IcedMatcha · 15/06/2022 19:15

If I was doing something that could harm my baby without realising then I’d be so grateful if someone warned me!

coffeecupsandfairylights · 15/06/2022 19:14

oakleaffy · 15/06/2022 18:50

Hardly!
Depends on dog breed.
A fine coated slim , Long nosed fit Sighthound type breed is absolutely fine at 26degs c
A fat, unfit, heavy coated breed will struggle, as will any puggy squashy faced dog.
Every case on it’s merits.

Actually, the risk of heatstroke in ANY breed kicks in at around 24 degrees. For overweight or flat-faced breeds, that risk kicks in at around 18-20 degrees, sometimes even lower.

I'm a dog walker and I won't walk fit, healthy dogs once it hits about 22 degrees. For puppies, older dogs, unfit dogs, thick-coated and flat-faced breeds, I start cutting walks down at around 17-18 degrees.

It was 19 degrees here at lunchtime and my hour walks were cut to 45 minutes, and the wolfdog I was walking only got 30 minutes instead of her usual hour.

Exclusionquestions · 15/06/2022 19:14

I wish there was stronger, more public messaging around this.

The same as there are with other baby campaigns about carrying in slings.

When mine were born there were no such safety warnings, and it took the death of a baby being carried in a sling for proper guidance to be released.

I wish they'd be proactive with covering pushchairs - use approved sunshades, avoid blocking air passage, keep in the shade etc rather than relying on people reading a news snippet.

Bombshell101 · 15/06/2022 19:14

I wonder if the posters jumping down your throat are the ones who cover/ed their prams with Muslims or blankets.

You meant well, you weren't trying to be spiteful. Like some others have said perhaps she felt silly and reacted badly she might look it up now

SafeMove · 15/06/2022 19:13

Walking a dog in 26 degree heat is not 'just as bad' as causing a baby to overheat ffs. MN is so strange sometimes.

Walkingalot · 15/06/2022 19:11

I was stuck in slow moving traffic and kept up with a Mum with a toddler in a pushchair (on the pavement beside me) - who was screaming her head off and kept turning her head to the side. She was full on in the sun with no shade, hat or glasses. I really felt for her. The traffic started to clear and as I was about to move off I yelled out of my window - ffs, give her some shade - and drove off! A bit cowardly of me I know.
OP, I think you did the right thing. Sure, she didn't appreciate it but I bet it will make her think twice about doing it again! Result, yes.

PaddingtonBearStareAgain · 15/06/2022 19:10

oakleaffy · 15/06/2022 19:03

On grass?? or Earth?

Unless it’s on fire I doubt grass or earth gets hot enough.
If a human can comfortably walk, barefoot a dog can.
Common sense.
A closed- mouth dog isn’t hot.
Always carry water.

Well most people have use pavements and tarmac to get to the grass and earth.

Advice from the RSPCA....

We recommend walking your dog in the morning or evening when it's cooler to reduce the risk of heatstroke and burning their paws on the pavement.

Minimalme · 15/06/2022 19:08

Muslins...sorry