Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To approach this mum with this warning?

365 replies

swimmingwiththefishes · 15/06/2022 17:20

Ok so I would NEVER normally approach a mum and 'point something out' BUT,

It's a hot day here (26 when I went to the park earlier) and I took the dog out for a walk in my local park. Took DS2 who's 6 months.

As I walked around the park and across some fields, there were two mums sat having a picnic of some sorts in the sun (no shade).

One of the mums obviously had a baby for a nap in the pram (I assume baby as bassinet attachment). To create some shade she had taken two muslins and draped them over the opening of the bassinet and clipped them with pram clips across the openings.

I'm pretty sure that this creates a hothouse type effect and can be quite dangerous. I actually had DS2 also napping and had a snuzshade draped over to stop the sunlight creeping in (black thin material with air holes to create shade but let the air flow).

I ummed and errd but decided I had to say something so really thought about the least offensive way to say it (I'm sure I could have found better!!).

Below is the convo. My friend thinks I was totally out of order to do this but I think I couldn't in good conscious not say anything

Me; gosh, it's soooo hot today isn't it? Nice to have some sun but poor little ones get so hot
Mum: oh yes, we're enjoying being able to get some sun!
Me: I'm not sure if it's helpful but I've found these snuzshade things really good as they let the air in so much more lightweight and breathable than muslins.
Mum: what do you mean?
Me: sorry, it's just I've read that muslins don't let the air through so can make babies hotter so I just thought I'd mention how great I've found this product as not sure if you're aware?
Mum: tell you what? Why don't you fuck right off and leave us the fuck alone
Me: ok, I'm literally trying to stop your child from overheating, that's all. Look it up.

I told my friend about the above convo and she said I probably came across as patronising and interfering. Yup, I probably did come across like that but that poor baby was probably roasting in there!

I'm sure I could have approached it better but WIBU?

OP posts:
SmartCarDriver · 15/06/2022 20:52

swimmingwiththefishes · 15/06/2022 20:48

@SmartCarDriver I'm not irritated. I have accepted this and at no point said it was the right thing to do. But I knew it was the only opportunity and knew he would be mostly walking in the river so decided as a one off it'd be ok. And if another dog walkerhad stopped me and pointed this out, I wouldn't have told them to fuck off...as I have said before

What is irritating me is people are saying BECAUSE I did not have 'hands clean' I therefore had no right to approach this mum. I disagree. And whilst I admit my wording was clumsy, I think warning someone of how dangerous this is (just as another dog walker may have rightly said this to me) is not unreasonable

Do you not agree?

Sorry you should your ignorance about dog walking in heat early on!

Perhaps the other mother only had muslins today and not some commercial MLM contraption and decided as a one off it was ok?

Don't give unsolicited advise, unless you're happy to take it!

WeAreBob · 15/06/2022 20:50

But the little chart you posted shows that your shade thing is just as dangerous, if not more so.

You recommended her something even more dangerous.
You had a dog out in heat it should not have been in, regardless of walking in a river.

And then you told her to do some research!! Why don't you? You clearly didn't actually research the thing you were

swimmingwiththefishes · 15/06/2022 20:49

I always knew there was a reason I loved you @saraclara

OP posts:
swimmingwiththefishes · 15/06/2022 20:48

@SmartCarDriver I'm not irritated. I have accepted this and at no point said it was the right thing to do. But I knew it was the only opportunity and knew he would be mostly walking in the river so decided as a one off it'd be ok. And if another dog walkerhad stopped me and pointed this out, I wouldn't have told them to fuck off...as I have said before

What is irritating me is people are saying BECAUSE I did not have 'hands clean' I therefore had no right to approach this mum. I disagree. And whilst I admit my wording was clumsy, I think warning someone of how dangerous this is (just as another dog walker may have rightly said this to me) is not unreasonable

Do you not agree?

OP posts:
saraclara · 15/06/2022 20:47

SmartCarDriver · 15/06/2022 20:42

You seem irritated at being corrected about the dog? Why's that?

Maybe for the same reason as many of us? Because the OP's not about the F-ing dog! (who can look after himself in hot weather infinitely more easily than the baby)

When posters respond ONLY to reference the dog, and ignoring the actual subject of the OP, they look bonkers.

Tilltheend99 · 15/06/2022 20:46

MassiveSalad22 · 15/06/2022 20:34

Thread is 11 pages long but FWIW I did this today - hood of pram has gaps all around where is attaches to rest of pram and the muslin doesn’t cover all of the hood opening. So I’d risk assessed it myself. Third child. Maybe this woman had too. She was vile the way she spoke to you though!

Hmm I think maybe people are getting confused about what the dangers or covering a pram are. It’s not that baby will necessarily get heatstroke or die of heat, it’s that sleeping in increased temperature increases the risk of SIDS just as in a hot cot or car seat. The idea is to keep the area as cool as possible, ideally 20c or less. If choosing to cover the pram while baby sleeps maybe take mitigating steps like removing a layer of baby’s clothing or attaching a pram fan to increase air circulation.

it’s really hot here tonight, I’m going to try and get some fans on myself.

SmartCarDriver · 15/06/2022 20:42

swimmingwiththefishes · 15/06/2022 19:50

@PaddingtonBearStareAgain Ah, ok so because I was (admittedly) doing the wrong thing with my dog, I should not have approached her about something she was doing which has increase risk of SIDS and overheating?

So only ever step in on a situation you deem harmful to a baby or child if you are completely 'hands clean'?

I accept I should have taken the dog out earlier and have said several times that it was on grass and along a river and not something I make a habit of but Jesus Christ does that mean I simply walk on by and let the child potentially overheat?

You seem irritated at being corrected about the dog? Why's that?

MassiveSalad22 · 15/06/2022 20:39

Oh my god so that chart actually shows that muslins are safer than your snooze shade? 🤣 whoops OP!

LuckyAmy1986 · 15/06/2022 20:39

I think you were fine to do what you did, but people don't like to be told they are doing something wrong, especially parenting! But at least you know you tried and hopefully she will do some research if the muslins are in fact bad for creating a hothouse.

stuntbubbles · 15/06/2022 20:38

I think it’s the fact you sidled in with the “haha, boy is it hot today, well well well” and tricked them into “just mums, having some mum chat in the sun” conversation. If you’re going to be a busybody, own it! A straightforward drive-by piece of advice, then onwards.

MassiveSalad22 · 15/06/2022 20:34

Thread is 11 pages long but FWIW I did this today - hood of pram has gaps all around where is attaches to rest of pram and the muslin doesn’t cover all of the hood opening. So I’d risk assessed it myself. Third child. Maybe this woman had too. She was vile the way she spoke to you though!

godmum56 · 15/06/2022 20:32

I'd have thought you were trying to sell something.....heart in right place maybe, but approach not good....and yes poor dog

LezzaTheBean · 15/06/2022 20:28

My mum thought I was being OTT about stuff 20 years ago when my DC were babies. But it never once occurred to me not to drape something over the pram on a hot/very sunny day. I dare say that I'll be thinking my DC are OTT in due course, too.

I don't think the other mother should have told you to fuck off, though, OP. If you had said this to me, OP, I would have been completely nonplussed and would have muttered "oh, ok, thanks", or some such, then carried on doing what I was doing. I'd just have thought you were either a busybody or a bit mad, but neither of those is any reason to swear at a stranger.

Tilltheend99 · 15/06/2022 20:23

BaaCake · 15/06/2022 20:12

Yes I too found this ironic.

But let’s face it, if it was a dog in a covered dog pram Mumsnetters would have probably called the police.

apapuchi · 15/06/2022 20:21

YANBU in my opinion. It smarts to be told you're doing something risky or inadvisable at any time when you've been trying to do 'right', never moreso than in motherhood, but you need to at least listen and hopefully she's gone away and done some research. She was a rude idiot.

WeAreBob · 15/06/2022 20:20

You should not have been walking your dog in that heat. I didnt any further than that because you were obviously about to go on about telling someone off for having their kid out in the heat when you should not have had your dog out.

Tilltheend99 · 15/06/2022 20:19

BiscoffSundae · 15/06/2022 17:23

I see so many parents do this, even thick blankets clicked on but I wouldn’t say anything personally

It is a tough one but people smash in car windows for a dog (rightly so) so why not warn people about covering prams?

According to the lullaby trust, overheating a baby by covering a pram can increase the risk of sids www.lullabytrust.org.uk/the-lullaby-trust-urges-parents-to-keep-babies-cool-during-the-heatwave/

Whoatealltheminieggs · 15/06/2022 20:17

Someone pointed something similar out to me once. I was pleased for the info. Embarrassed I hadn’t known but pleased regardless. It’s always difficult when you see things like this. You made a brave call with good intentions. I wouldn’t let the fact the mum kicked off make you feel bad.

ShirleyPhallus · 15/06/2022 20:16

Bethany7 · 15/06/2022 20:10

O.P. I'm shocked at the negative comments. You absolutely did the right thing as babies have literally died because people don't realise this. You were doing right by the baby.
I'm sorry the mum was so rude to you. Let's hope she did go home and Google what you said though. Well done for speaking up. It was one of those situations that you feel uncomfortable but have a moral duty to almost. I think if you didn't say anything you would feel guilty and be worrying now. So many good mums do not know this fact and we need to be sharing it.

Could you give a source for your claim that “babies have literally died” doing this? I’ve just googled and while the advice is not to do it as it COULD be fatal, there are no articles that give actual examples of this happening?

skybluee · 15/06/2022 20:15

God, what a nasty woman. There's ways to handle things and that's not telling someone to fuck off!

Darbs76 · 15/06/2022 20:14

She might have thought you were trying to sell something. Probably better to just keep out of it

SherbetDips · 15/06/2022 20:13

You are right of course but it’s not your business to tell others how to parent.

BaaCake · 15/06/2022 20:12

decayingmatter · 15/06/2022 20:06

You can hardly get snippy about unsolicited advice when the whole point of your thread is about you wanting to justify giving out unsolicited advice. Posters are only educating you, just like you were helpfully trying to educate the lady today

Yes I too found this ironic.

Bethany7 · 15/06/2022 20:10

O.P. I'm shocked at the negative comments. You absolutely did the right thing as babies have literally died because people don't realise this. You were doing right by the baby.
I'm sorry the mum was so rude to you. Let's hope she did go home and Google what you said though. Well done for speaking up. It was one of those situations that you feel uncomfortable but have a moral duty to almost. I think if you didn't say anything you would feel guilty and be worrying now. So many good mums do not know this fact and we need to be sharing it.

decayingmatter · 15/06/2022 20:06

swimmingwiththefishes · 15/06/2022 18:44

Have we reached 'cancel the cheque' peak status yet?

You can hardly get snippy about unsolicited advice when the whole point of your thread is about you wanting to justify giving out unsolicited advice. Posters are only educating you, just like you were helpfully trying to educate the lady today