Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend and very overweight daughter

141 replies

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 15/06/2022 16:51

As a big caveat if friend didn’t keep complaining about other people raising concerns I’d be keeping my beak out.
I’ll also add the child in question is NT. As I know that will come up straight away.

My friend has an adult daughter she had in her teens (relevant for context later) and a 6 year old.

The six year old is really overweight. I’d not seen her for about a year and she was always a chubby kid, but saw her recently and she is really obviously VERY overweight and it seems to be getting worse. She has a big double chin, rolls of fat on her ankles/wrists/elbows like you’d expect to see on a baby, not an older child. Really not puppy fat territory. Friend eats out a lot and it’s not uncommon for her 6 year old to eat a whole pizza, share the adults sides and eat a whole adults desert portion, at home food is always very calorie dense, so they would never have tomato pasta, it would be Mac and cheese with garlic bread, for example. Every time they leave the house (no exaggeration) there is a treat: cake from a bakery, ice cream, meal out, cone of chips etc.

The adult daughter has tried to bring up that this is not good and she is worried for her sisters health and also because other children can be mean, if it will lead to issues at school. Friends response is generally that her adult daughter is jealous as when they were a child they were dirt broke so never got to go out.

When I saw my friend recently she was upset that in the last few months, a few fellow parents, the school and a GP have raised serious concerns about her daughters size and weight gain and she genuinely doesn’t see a problem. If she’d not mentioned this I’d not say anything but she seems in complete denial and now myself and another friend are wondering if we should in fact have a kind word and mention her daughter really is overweight and maybe needs to take her back to the GP to discuss how to approach it.
I do suspect a bit of it is making up for what she couldn’t offer her adult daughter as a very young mum, so needs addressing carefully but I am concerned about the implications of her current behaviour on her younger daughter.
WWYD?

OP posts:
fUNNYfACE36 · 15/06/2022 20:03

WeAreBob · 15/06/2022 17:02

An abused child is everyone's business.

A child being starved is abuse.
A child being seriously over fed is abuse.

This child is going to have a life long struggle with food and weight and healthy. Life long.

That is everyone's business.

NO
Flagging up abuse to the authorities might arguably be everyone's business.But that's as far as it goes
Tackling the "abuser' certainly isnt

Geneviev · 15/06/2022 20:03

i wouldn’t say anything. Just be there and support her.

it’s in hand. The school etc are aware. You don’t need to address it. If the school or GP thinks social service referral is necessary then let them deal with that. Just be a pal.

Darbs76 · 15/06/2022 20:01

Next time she raises it with you then yes I’d be honest and say that she needs to approach the GP for help. I suspect a lot of it is as she wasn’t able to offer much to her elder child she’s over compensating. She needs help with advice on cooking lower calorie meals and cutting back on treats / takeaways

CafeCremeMerci · 15/06/2022 19:59

mosesbassist · 15/06/2022 18:05

I really believe that once the fat cells are produced, to accommodate the excess, it is a life time of struggling to lose weight. Those fat cells have a memory and want filling

This!!!

@Lastqueenofscotland2

Do you have a child of a similar age?

Do they/could they do an activity/club/group that they'd enjoy that FFD might enjoy too? Or regular afternoons at a trampoline park, or he'll, just the play park.

it would depend which of my friends how I'd handle it , tbh. Sadly I've been unable to help two of my god kids as those friends acknowledge the kids are overweight, but have never changed family meals/takeaway:snacks & have in fact always praised them for being big eaters and been kind of proud about the kids appetites. Hard to explain.

the kids are now older teenagers, do not exercise/play sport or walk anywhere.

they've never been allowed to join active clubs (always some excuse) and either parent will take them/pick them up from school every day despite it being within east walking distance (maybe a mile)

it's heart breaking for health, social & life.

I have other. god children and their parents would all have been easier to talk to.

goodcall101 · 15/06/2022 19:58

rosewater20 · 15/06/2022 19:10

There is a lot that I agree with in your post but wanted to point out that OP described what this child eats regularly: "Friend eats out a lot and it’s not uncommon for her 6 year old to eat a whole pizza, share the adults sides and eat a whole adults desert portion, at home food is always very calorie dense, so they would never have tomato pasta, it would be Mac and cheese with garlic bread, for example. Every time they leave the house (no exaggeration) there is a treat: cake from a bakery, ice cream, meal out, cone of chips etc."

Genetic causes are rarely the ONLY reason for something (obviously there are some cases where one gene will always 100% cause a disease, etc). If she does have a genetic predisposition to obesity that is all the more reason to not be eating the way she is/and the portions that she is. It is really easy to just give up and blame everything wrong with our bodies on our genetic makeup but what we put in our bodies, how much we move, our stress levels and environment are extremely important as well.

It’s a very complex problem typically with many contributing variables. It’s generally accepted that 40-70% of all obesity is attributable to genetic factors. I have no doubt this contribution rises significantly for obesity in the under 10s. Beyond genetics you have, very broadly, environment, hormonal factors, and behaviour. My point is the inclination to blame parenting and feeding behaviour from the outside perspective is generally wrong, you are right that it doesn’t sound like all that healthy of a diet but also when you expect to see an unhealthy diet that’s likely what you will attend to. If the child was slim and particularly fit OP would probably view these the diet differently too or not notice it. Most children tend to eat/want to eat until they are no longer hungry, for most children that will be after they have something like a normal child-sized portion, but sometimes children will have a far greater appetite, or a normal appetite but with a “better” ability to extract and store calories from the food. Calling obesity in children a sign of abuse is irresponsible and highly likely to be incorrect.

Obesity is a health policy issue largely, a very complex one at that, and it’s unclear what the main contributing factor is but it’s almost certainly not down to lax individuals choosing to be a bit indulgent with their children or themselves. We know this because it’s a cross-country, cross-culture phenomenon which no country has yet successfully turned the tide on, despite 40 years or more of fairly reasonable healthy eating and physical activity advice and countless child focused interventions and initiatives. To say nothing of the population research and research around areas of genetic and bio-psychological causes of the condition.
Yes of course home food environment and parenting choices matter, but a whole lot of other things do too, and unless it’s you or your child you are worried about it’s just not appropriate to make a judgement on it and give advice in my opinion.

In fact, I’d say the more familiarity you have with this topic, the less likely you are to judge or be tempted to intervene.

greatblueheron · 15/06/2022 19:56

It's child abuse. Poor girl, they're setting her up for a lifetime of issues with food, weight and poor health.

But the family will probably decline to engage with social services if they're referred as it won't be a high enough 'threat' to her health and well being to be a mandatory intervention.

drpet49 · 15/06/2022 19:55

This is child abuse. You wouldn’t ignore it if she was starving her child.

CherryReid · 15/06/2022 19:45

I think mental health support for the friend should be arranged. As mentioned previously.
But imv blaming the sad time she had when she couldn't provide for DD1 is a bit convenient. It doesn't really stack up.
Thirdly eating out cheap crap is v lazy imv. Pizza is not suitable for DCs -a slice of pizza with a big helping of salad, yes , a slice of pizza with s big helping of greens , yes,. But she's too lazy to wash salad, boil veg.
So a supportive dietician could hello, maybe GP can help there.

HermioneWeasley · 15/06/2022 19:43

I feel for you OP, it’s hard to watch. My friend has always been larger and for many years was the fittest and most active of any of us. Now she’s older she has a bad hip, can’t walk uphill and gets out of breath very easily. I can’t believe she’s happy to set her daughter up for a similar life, but I don’t know if she even sees that she’s fat. Not puppy fat, she’s obese. Drinks seem to be as big an issue as food - endless cans of full sugar drinks (friend thinks sweeteners are very harmful), Frappuccinos, bubble tea etc. I dread the day she ever asks me whether I think she’s overweight, or tells me that someone has said she is. What do you say? I would never want to damage our friendship or hurt her feelings.

Whitehorsegirl · 15/06/2022 19:41

Some rather odd responses on this thread...

This is affecting this kid's health. It is a form of neglect too.

It is not just about the fact that this kid might be bullied because of her weight, it is also about her not getting the right food to develop a healthy body as she is growing up.

So, no you should not just ''leave it alone'' or ''mind your own business''...

If your friend has been told by people around her and healthcare professionals that there is an issue and she is refusing to do anything, then it is perfectly right to report this.

What matters here is the welfare of the kid.

As people have pointed out if the kid was starved, it would be reported. Same here, this kid's health is being damaged.

I would suggest you try to speak to the adult daughter and both of you can decide whether you want to involve social services.

It is in the best interest of the child, which always needs to come first.

Everyone who just suggests turning a blind eye, have a word with yourself...neglects come in many forms.

mam0918 · 15/06/2022 19:41

TBF my DS is over the 100% for height and weight.

The school weight checkers flagged him for being over the BMI for his age at 8 and the school suggested he do sports (already was out of school, 2 days a weel) but he joined all the school sports teams aswell (so 5 days of after school sports + 2 non school sports teams).

I am not the healthest eater ever (Im hardly chowing down on organic home grown cous-cous stuffed peppers for dinner, we shock horror sometimes even have takeaways or mcdonalds) but I am perfectly healthy weight as is dad and his sibling, my DS eats the same as us in the same amount.

He is still 4 years later (although granted sports stopped for covid) over the 100% and by far the biggest in his class height wise (taller than teacher) and still chunky.

I have no idea where it gets it from (both me and DH are tall but not chunky) but its clearly how he is built.

georgarina · 15/06/2022 19:40

If she asks you outright I couldn't NOT say something.
That poor child.
Just point out the obvious, gently, and maybe it will get through. After all she is coming to you saying everyone else is saying it.

Spinfit · 15/06/2022 19:37

rosewater20 · 15/06/2022 19:10

There is a lot that I agree with in your post but wanted to point out that OP described what this child eats regularly: "Friend eats out a lot and it’s not uncommon for her 6 year old to eat a whole pizza, share the adults sides and eat a whole adults desert portion, at home food is always very calorie dense, so they would never have tomato pasta, it would be Mac and cheese with garlic bread, for example. Every time they leave the house (no exaggeration) there is a treat: cake from a bakery, ice cream, meal out, cone of chips etc."

Genetic causes are rarely the ONLY reason for something (obviously there are some cases where one gene will always 100% cause a disease, etc). If she does have a genetic predisposition to obesity that is all the more reason to not be eating the way she is/and the portions that she is. It is really easy to just give up and blame everything wrong with our bodies on our genetic makeup but what we put in our bodies, how much we move, our stress levels and environment are extremely important as well.

Obesity as a chronic condition is very poorly understood by both the public and health professionals. There will be many genetic causes that have yet to be identified. How our bodies digest food and burn calories vary between individuals and blaming people for their body weight is dangerous. I did read that she often eats adult portions - perhaps this is because she lacks the hormone which signals satiety and therefore is unable to stop? Or perhaps her body is unable to burn through the food she eats in a similar amount of time to other children her age. We do not know. Anyway, I digress but we need to stop blaming people for being obese as it's a lot more than just "poor lifestyle choices".

Benjispruce4 · 15/06/2022 19:36

I’m surprised that when she told you she was upset about the comments that she didn’t ask you what you thought.

Freerangechildren · 15/06/2022 19:35

Over eating or over feeding is a mental health condition and will not be fixed with diet books and the brutal truth. Your friends needs professional intervention to unpick why this is happening and access to proper structured support to help them. I would stay well out of it, apart from being a kind non judgemental friend (if you want to be)

Staffy1 · 15/06/2022 19:34

I would bring it up. The more people that do, the more chance there is of her taking note.

Benjispruce4 · 15/06/2022 19:33

I agree with @worraliberty , it’s been said by those closest to her and a medical professional. Leave it .
If she asks your opinion then you could mention your surprise/concerns.

GryffindorWarrior · 15/06/2022 19:30

If ur friend specifically asks for ur opinion then be truthful even tho it’ll sting. Be prepared for ur friendship to cool off/breakdown tho.

otherwise I’d keep out of it. There’s plenty raised it already incl health professionals and she’s dead against them so u gtn involved when not asked isn’t going to be received well.

I feel sorry for the kid, lots of people trying to advocate but her mum is letting her down badly. Hope she sees sense soon!

Viviennemary · 15/06/2022 19:29

You need to stay out of this unless she specifically asks you for advice. Its a serious issue but don't wade in.

Trogbog · 15/06/2022 19:19

If she raises it again you can just factually state, ‘well she is very overweight’. The more people are honest the more she might slowly see that there is a problem.

Happyhappyday · 15/06/2022 19:18

When I think about my own close friends, if one of them had a very obese DC and brought it up with me I WOULD ask questions, along what PP said, are you worried etc. if you’re hearing this from a lot of places I personally would take it seriously etc. or even, it’s hard to hear but your DC IS overweight. I want to support you but you and DC are too important for me to pretend like it isn’t concerning etc. Do you want to talk about it?

if the friend didn’t further conversation I’d leave it though, if she isn’t receptive nothing you say is really going to sink in.

whynotwhatknot · 15/06/2022 19:14

Nexttime she brings up the gp or someone else saying something just say so do you thnnk theyre wrong, or why do you tnk they are saying that

they cant al be jealous can they

OperaStation · 15/06/2022 19:12

worraliberty · 15/06/2022 16:55

Stay out of it. You're not going to have more success than the school, the eldest daughter or the GP are you?

Given that the friend has brought it up with OP she clearly trusts OP’s judgement. I think OP agreeing with everyone else might be what finally makes her see sense. It’s very difficult to word it though.

rosewater20 · 15/06/2022 19:10

goodcall101 · 15/06/2022 18:54

Correct, and very good point about asking for a referral to a paediatrician, it’s likely a medical problem so better to recommend specialist help than getting into blaming it on the mother straight of the bat.

I hope the people insisting it’s “child abuse” read and understand this post. Medical professionals with many years of training can struggle to make the right diagnosis in these cases and it does often require quite a bit of history taking and diagnostic testing, so maybe take a beat before you decide to accuse some poor stranger of child abuse.

There is a lot that I agree with in your post but wanted to point out that OP described what this child eats regularly: "Friend eats out a lot and it’s not uncommon for her 6 year old to eat a whole pizza, share the adults sides and eat a whole adults desert portion, at home food is always very calorie dense, so they would never have tomato pasta, it would be Mac and cheese with garlic bread, for example. Every time they leave the house (no exaggeration) there is a treat: cake from a bakery, ice cream, meal out, cone of chips etc."

Genetic causes are rarely the ONLY reason for something (obviously there are some cases where one gene will always 100% cause a disease, etc). If she does have a genetic predisposition to obesity that is all the more reason to not be eating the way she is/and the portions that she is. It is really easy to just give up and blame everything wrong with our bodies on our genetic makeup but what we put in our bodies, how much we move, our stress levels and environment are extremely important as well.

SomewhereEast · 15/06/2022 19:09

I think you should definitely say something. People like that will take silence as you implicitly saying that everything is fine, and it really isn't. She's setting the poor DD up for a lifetime of ill-health & terrible self-esteem.