Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand what the RMT are in a snit about?

130 replies

Sistanotcista · 15/06/2022 15:38

Going to try and post a link to this article, but it might not work. This is the important extract: “If you earned, on average, £44,000 a year, wouldn’t you put up and shut up just now and thank your lucky stars that you’re fortunate enough to have a job which pays at least ten grand more than the UK’s median annual income of £31,772 (to the Office of National Statistics).”

Why on earth are they striking for better pay? I get that we would all like more (of course!) but their salaries seem pretty fair. What have I missed?

OP posts:
CanaryShoulderedThorn · 15/06/2022 23:53

£44k
That is top of band 7 in the NHS, so maybe a matron in charge of a ward, an advanced specialist physio, or the manager of a whole team of paramedics.
All of which require a degree, probably a masters degree and many years of experience.
I agree it's not race to the bottom, but many other sectors also require pay rises, no wonder they can't retain staff.

Campervangirl · 15/06/2022 23:43

Carreterra · 15/06/2022 21:52

@Sallycinnamum
Spot on ! Do you remember Bob Crow, the RMT leader who died a few years ago? I remember an argument during a radio programme, where a presenter asked Bob how he could justify train drivers being paid so well, and why he wasn't representing nurses and doctors, to push for NHS staff to be paid equally well. Bob replied that although he thought NHS staff should be paid more, it was not his area of knowledge, and he he asked the radio presenter how much he earned ! Bob's knowledge of the railway network and the responsibility of the train drivers was excellent, but the stress he was under to constantly justify the RMT members' wages may have led to his heart problems. Rest in peace, Bob.

Totally agree, I met Bob about 18 yrs ago at a union meeting, a very passionate man who actually cared about the rail workers and was vilified by the press.
RIP Bob

Chaoslatte · 15/06/2022 23:15

ClinicallyProven · 15/06/2022 17:23

Has striking ever resulted in saved jobs?

I’m pretty sure it has yes but I don’t have the data. But regardless, why not strike? If you’re facing redundancy you have noticing to lose and it’s better than taking it lying down.

OddsandSods · 15/06/2022 22:54

Yes let’s cut safety critical workforce to skeleton levels and then pay a them a minimum wage.

Never fails to amaze, all the bellyaching on this site about the people in jobs that are actually important daring to ask for a fair wage.

Not so much noise being made about shareholders skimming off all the profits, and the tiny group of individuals who hoard all the money in this country.

Gilead · 15/06/2022 22:50

Years!

Gilead · 15/06/2022 22:50

ears of pay freezes are unfair. Job losses put the safety of the public at risk. Managing Directors, Chief Execs are not subject to pay freezes.

RJnomore1 · 15/06/2022 22:39

squashedalmondcroissant · 15/06/2022 21:43

I do feel sorry for everyone affected by the strike but the vast, vast majority of railway workers are on way less than the very good salary always quoted by the media and their conditions are terrible. Saying that all the railway workers are on a great salary by quoting a driver's salary is like saying that anyone who works in a care home is on the same wage as the owner of the home.

My Dp works on the railways and has been verbally and physically assaulted at work, has had to talk down potential suicides and liase with the police to clean up remains of people. He Monitors incidents on board and at other stations and calls out the BTP to deal with anything that passes through his area. Has to deal with medical emergencies, signal failures, delays, cancellations, staff shortages - all of which he has absolutely no control over and gets him even more abuse from disgruntled customers. He also gets randomly drug tested.

As part of job he is also expected to work rest days with no overtime or extra pay in order to keep everything running.

They have had 3 staff leave recently and they are not recruiting to replace them. Their plan is, apparently, to have no manned stations in the whole county so his job is at risk in the next few years. Many days he is on his own dealing with all the incoming/outgoing trains and with anything that occurs on platform or anyone who needs assistance. It's an impossible task.

And all for a salary which is less than my manager at work (retail), when his job can sometimes literally be the difference between life and death.

So, yeah I absolutely support the strike!

My husband has had very similar experiences. From someone trying to cut their own throat on a train, to dealing with epileptic seizures, to comforting drivers who have just literally watched someone smash across their windscreen.

The BTP are a joke and less likely to turn up than the local police.

Hes due as a witness in court as he was assaulted by a young person. One of several staff assaulted which is why charges were actually bought.

Coupled with practically no covid safeguards enforced or allowed to be enforced on trains. Not being allowed to sell tickets on trains for almost two years despite having to be crowded on them with countless others not wearing masks. So no revenue for the company because they weren’t allowed to sell, and yes he caught covid at work and yes him and I were seriously ill.

Now people don’t want to pay for trains. They keep saying passengers numbers are down. Locally they aren’t - ticket sales are down which is totally different. Unlike London there’s no enforcement for tickets in Scotland. Staff are constantly verbally abused. Last time I was on a train the guard told me he was racially abused. They report it and no one does anything. Seriously. Nowhere else would you be subjected to the level of abuse rail staff are while often effectively line working with no support.

There's some people on this thread I strongly suspect are among the verbal abusers in real life.

And yes many of these jobs are safety critical. Do you have any idea how dangerous trains are and how little it takes for it to go wrong? The fact it doesn’t is massive testament to the work force and the training.

justfiveminutes · 15/06/2022 22:01

I'm impressed by a union that is actually protecting the interests of its members. That is what it is supposed to do. I wish other unions would step up and do the same. It might be inconvenient, but what is the point of a strike if no one notices.

Carreterra · 15/06/2022 21:52

Sallycinnamum · 15/06/2022 17:15

Well it's not really hard to understand why drivers are paid well. Would you want the responsibility of carrying hundreds of people every day knowing one mistake could cause death and injury?

@Sallycinnamum
Spot on ! Do you remember Bob Crow, the RMT leader who died a few years ago? I remember an argument during a radio programme, where a presenter asked Bob how he could justify train drivers being paid so well, and why he wasn't representing nurses and doctors, to push for NHS staff to be paid equally well. Bob replied that although he thought NHS staff should be paid more, it was not his area of knowledge, and he he asked the radio presenter how much he earned ! Bob's knowledge of the railway network and the responsibility of the train drivers was excellent, but the stress he was under to constantly justify the RMT members' wages may have led to his heart problems. Rest in peace, Bob.

squashedalmondcroissant · 15/06/2022 21:43

I do feel sorry for everyone affected by the strike but the vast, vast majority of railway workers are on way less than the very good salary always quoted by the media and their conditions are terrible. Saying that all the railway workers are on a great salary by quoting a driver's salary is like saying that anyone who works in a care home is on the same wage as the owner of the home.

My Dp works on the railways and has been verbally and physically assaulted at work, has had to talk down potential suicides and liase with the police to clean up remains of people. He Monitors incidents on board and at other stations and calls out the BTP to deal with anything that passes through his area. Has to deal with medical emergencies, signal failures, delays, cancellations, staff shortages - all of which he has absolutely no control over and gets him even more abuse from disgruntled customers. He also gets randomly drug tested.

As part of job he is also expected to work rest days with no overtime or extra pay in order to keep everything running.

They have had 3 staff leave recently and they are not recruiting to replace them. Their plan is, apparently, to have no manned stations in the whole county so his job is at risk in the next few years. Many days he is on his own dealing with all the incoming/outgoing trains and with anything that occurs on platform or anyone who needs assistance. It's an impossible task.

And all for a salary which is less than my manager at work (retail), when his job can sometimes literally be the difference between life and death.

So, yeah I absolutely support the strike!

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 15/06/2022 21:43

roarfeckingroarr · 15/06/2022 16:58

Pretty sure that's £44k for a four day week too. Much more with overtime.

They're bastards and cost us all money with their greed.

Tell me you base you're entire world view on the first 5 articles in the daily mail without telling me you base you're entire world view in the first 5 articles in the daily mail.

Speaking of which I noticed they were reporting on the median salary of rail workers the other day, wonder why they deviated from the usual average salary they like to trot out, couldn't possibly be to try and reinforce their narrative could it? 🤔

Finally as others have said repeatedly but slower since so many are having great difficulty understanding this it... is... not... train... drivers... who... are... striking!!

mdinbc · 15/06/2022 21:42

This from a BBC article:

"The TSSA is demanding a guarantee of no compulsory redundancies for 2022, no unagreed changes to terms and conditions, and a pay increase which reflects the rising cost of living.
It said NR staff last had a pay rise between two and three years ago, although it varies between grades, and also worked throughout the coronavirus pandemic as key workers."

I'm not even in your country, but i can find some info from the union's point of view. Some people hold very narrow views about worker's rights, and only complain about the inconvenience to themselves.

If it were not for labour unions, you would be sending your children down the mines at the age of 12, and buying your food at the company store.

luckylavender · 15/06/2022 21:08

Sharrowgirl · 15/06/2022 17:17

The government spent billions of taxpayers’ money keeping the railways afloat during the pandemic. Billions. No staff were made redundant and none was furloughed.

Pandemic is over but passenger numbers have not recovered. The government have told the railway to make savings as they’re not prepared to keep bankrolling it at the level they have done.

No one has said how these savings will be made, job losses and pay freezes have not even been mentioned, yet the unions have called a strike just because they think it might happen.

Then the government needs to talk to them. That's literally the job of government. And they need to address all their concerns - pay, redundancies, security and fire and rehire.

luckylavender · 15/06/2022 21:06

ClinicallyProven · 15/06/2022 17:13

I think it's very difficult to understand why train drivers are so well paid and it is, afterall we, the passengers who pay their wages.

Of course in a perfect world everyone would be incredibly well paid, but the customer (or the taxpayer) has to pay.

Although most of your money goes to the European owners who subsidise their own railways with it.

luckylavender · 15/06/2022 21:04

roarfeckingroarr · 15/06/2022 16:58

Pretty sure that's £44k for a four day week too. Much more with overtime.

They're bastards and cost us all money with their greed.

You shouldn't believe everything you read in the Murdoch Press.

Fidodidit · 15/06/2022 21:02

I used to work in fund management. The pay was way higher and much of it based on ability to bullshit.

Villagewaspbyke · 15/06/2022 21:00

GodneySaysWorkBitch · 15/06/2022 20:43

They're exploiting the fiscal incompetence of people running the country in order to broker a better deal for their members. We could all do likewise, if we organised ourselves. Who is responsible for your wages being lower than a train driver's? The train driver? Or your employer?

The fact that their industry is a state funded monopoly is why they have disproportionate bargaining power. It costs us all in a lack of efficiency and high ticket prices.

Villagewaspbyke · 15/06/2022 20:56

It’s a joke. They are taking advantage of the fact that the railways are an essential monopoly in some parts of the country. They are paid way more than paramedics or nurses. The unions always say it’s about safety but it never is.

canyoutoleratethis · 15/06/2022 20:43

roarfeckingroarr · 15/06/2022 16:58

Pretty sure that's £44k for a four day week too. Much more with overtime.

They're bastards and cost us all money with their greed.

Wow. What a nasty individual you are. Do you even know any train drivers, you know, these people who you've just called greedy bastards for no reason other than what you've read in the Daily Mail. Try educating yourself a bit more. Oh, and try not to be so unkind to others

GodneySaysWorkBitch · 15/06/2022 20:43

They're exploiting the fiscal incompetence of people running the country in order to broker a better deal for their members. We could all do likewise, if we organised ourselves. Who is responsible for your wages being lower than a train driver's? The train driver? Or your employer?

littlepeas · 15/06/2022 20:41

bumblefeline · 15/06/2022 17:21

Yep or see the remains of the poor person who has just committed suicide in front of their train.

Any worker should be offered the right to a decent pay rise.

I have been on a tube train where this happened. The driver’s voice when he announced that we had to evacuate was really upsetting. The whole thing was horrible. I think they deserve to be paid very well.

Nothappyatwork · 15/06/2022 20:40

SofiaSoFar · 15/06/2022 20:29

I guess you're also hoping for even bigger tax increases to pay for it, too.

Well given that we pay a percentage of our wage is our in tax and national insurance again that will be a natural consequence.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 15/06/2022 20:38

Ah yes the cut in passenger numbers - yet still the complaints of overcrowding not enough seats. Yes wfh has probably meant a cut in numbers but this hasn't transferred to better conditions. Plenty of staff still having to have time off (like everywhere else) due to covid or covid symptoms has meant less carriages, less trains, and this will continue to be a reality if they make redundancies.

itsgettingweird · 15/06/2022 20:35

AlternativePerspective · 15/06/2022 17:25

it’s not just about money. It’s about cuts to services, not trains but actual services. Significant job losses, the closure of all ticket offices which will have an impact on travellers.

And the reality is that train staff have better wages precisely because they’re prepared to walk out. More people should do the same, then maybe the government will actually do something to enable people to earn a decent living.

Well said.

The issue isn't whether people are or are not striking.

The issue is far more deep seated and go back to wages not come wrong the cost of living and the increased cost of living.

And we won't get a solution all the while we are governed by people who think if it's illegal to do something - you just change the law.

Until a government has a policy and can win an election in that policy for long term solutions we are all going to have to do what we can. Therefore I support the RMT for doing what they think is best.

SSDDagain · 15/06/2022 20:32

Campervangirl · 15/06/2022 17:25

I work in the rail industry and its really annoying when these supposed high wages are quoted because most of us don't get paid anywhere near that.
Yes, train drivers get a pretty decent wage but imagine the responsibility they have.
The people who work on track, who are ensuring that the rail network is safe for the customers absolutely do not get anywhere near £40k plus.
These "boots on ballast" people work hard, long hours in all weather's in a very dangerous job and they haven't had a pay rise for 4 years.
They work alongside contractors who are paid significantly more than them for doing the same job.
The rail employees worked all through the pandemic but you don't hear us mentioned when people talked about key workers.
The strike action however is not only about pay, it's about working conditions and improving safety.
I could quote the pay scales but everyone has their mind made up that we're all a bunch of money grabbers holding the country to ransom.
Such a shame that the country doesn't stand behind us.
Funny thing is the general concensus in the rail industry is we'd forgo a payrise if the government gave the NHS staff a decent payrise.

This. A million times this.
Fellow railway worker here

Swipe left for the next trending thread