Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Be concerned about the spread of red pill ideology?

187 replies

SigmaFlags · 15/06/2022 12:44

A younger male relative that I am close to has recently fallen under the influance of certain online male commentators or activists who preach red pill ideology, which appears to be extrapolated from evolutionary psychology and reduces relationships between the sexes to something purely transactional and women to little more than sex objects whose only value is their repoductive use, beauty and youth. I did do some investigating reading some forums, watching youtube videos of men who are mgtow (going their own way), pick up artists and men who just seem to live for hating women. I've heard statements that women are not really people the way that men are, that women are not capable of rational thought and operate purely on instinct to gain the most resources for themselves and their children and so on.

There is a channel on youtube which can't go a minute without refering to women as 304's which is code for "Hoe" and they openly use that language about women in the videos and the misogyny was awful. I reported these videos to youtube and to ebay who had their adverts running before them but have heard nothing back. According to many of these channels women are worthless beyond the age of 25, 35, 40. There are attitudes that women should not be allowed to work, to vote to hold political office and that all the evils of the world are due to the stupidity and inate badness of women (where have a heard this before I wonder?).

Some of it does appear to be the result of trauma in men who may have been badly treated by a specific women or had their heartbroken which leads them to say they are done with women and relationships. Thats totally fine, I see it on here are well that there are women, perhaps lots of women who decide to opt out of relationships after suffering abuse or broken trust or even just deciding coupled life isn't for them, and obviously men have that right as well (I believe women only communities and even political lesbianisim has been a thing in radfem circles since the 70s). What I don't see is women making 1000's of youtube videos that obsess about women, that stir up misogyny, encourage extremist views, that feed certain mens hatred and fear of women. Also while these men claim to want to have nothing to do with women they are still for the most part obsessed with gaining access to sex with women especially very young women, admittedly I can't imagine they are having much success here but the whole attitude is malign and predetory and there appears to be real rage towards women they perceive as rejecting them or not having sex with them. They say women's standards are too high and that they should lower them to find a man ignoring the fact that many women would often choose to stay single rather than be with a man she doesn't want to be with, surely that kind of freedom is a basic human right for both sexes?

I do think that men are in a difficult phase at the moment, that some of them are struggling to adapt to women's continuing emancipation, that there are areas where men and boys are being failed in education for example. I don't think its a bad thing that men what to be able to talk about their issues and how to be a good man, have a good life, the freedom to choose different paths in life that might not involve being a husband or father that is fine, I don't believe it needs to be a zero sum game. The problem is that in the online space it seems impossible to have that without it degenerating outright hatred of women, dehumanising of women and threats against women.

Its tempting to ignore this as it feels like its something that just happens in dark corners of the internet but when you actually look its massive and probably popping up on the social media feeds of your sons, brothers, husbands and friends.

OP posts:
Naunet · 15/06/2022 15:12

SigmaFlags · 15/06/2022 15:10

@Naunet Of course thats true but I also don't see the point in not having the conversation, we all have to live together and I prefer cooperation over polarisation.

I do understand where you’re coming from, but I just think it’s a waste of energy, you’ll never change their minds, and it takes a lot of investment to try. They don’t give a damn about you, in fact some of them will actively want to hurt you. I feel women's energy is better spent on encouraging other women to have high standards and never give a man like that the time of day.

SigmaFlags · 15/06/2022 15:10

@Naunet Of course thats true but I also don't see the point in not having the conversation, we all have to live together and I prefer cooperation over polarisation.

OP posts:
DirtyDuchess · 15/06/2022 15:09

They are also the driving force pushing the TRA/MRA movement. Dangerous bunch!

Naunet · 15/06/2022 15:07

But we don’t exist to improve things for them 🤷‍♀️

SigmaFlags · 15/06/2022 15:06

@Naunet I can see why you would feel that way and I do respect it, I've had that feeling myself at times but I suppose i don't really see how it improves anything. I don't think that is pandering, its keeping an open conversation.

OP posts:
Naunet · 15/06/2022 14:59

@Naunet "They're pathetic, entitled, weak little men that need breeding out anyway."

While I totally see the temptation to dismiss these men in that way I don't think its ultimately helpful, I think these men are most likely confused and in pain, it doesn't excuse their behaviour of course but I think that some compassion is valuable.

Nope, sorry. Women have been conditioned for so long to help and support men to their own detriment. I will not empathise with these vile woman haters, I will not feel sorry for them, not poor any emotional energy into them. It’s the women they hurt that have my support and compassion. Its like asking black people to empathise with white supremacy.

puddingandsun · 15/06/2022 14:55

"While I totally see the temptation to dismiss these men in that way I don't think its ultimately helpful, I think these men are most likely confused and in pain, it doesn't excuse their behaviour of course but I think that some compassion is valuable."

Absolutely. I mean these are children of women. Yes, some neglected by parents, etc. but almost always cared for and brought up by women.

The problem needs to be discussed much more and we need to start dealing with it from childhood.

Huge chunk of problems in society can be solved by bringing up children better - that's where we need to put more efforts + resources.
Massive thing to do, obvs.

SigmaFlags · 15/06/2022 14:53

@EmmaH2022 I really agree with you that money is a significant factor. There is one red pill guru Donovan Sharpe who makes money from these bitter, unhappy men online advocating you stay single and "spin plates" which is lingo for having multiple hot young women you sleep with on the go at any one time. He makes hateful videos about older women and single mothers while he himself is fairly recently married to an older women who was herself a single mother. Does he or his wife actually believe anything they say online or do they just spot an easy target, a soft touch? There message seems to be don't "simp" for women simp for me instead. I guess the men who send them money are to blinded by their issues to see the reality of what is going on.

OP posts:
OneTC · 15/06/2022 14:45

No they are weirdly entitled fucking losers who've failed at one of the basic facets of life

SigmaFlags · 15/06/2022 14:44

@inmyslippers I do think that more women are choosing to be single for reasons that are varied and complex. I think as women have the freedom to support themselves they will choose to be single rather than just be with a man for the sake of it. Perhaps online dating does foster more mercenary behaviour in both men and women, where men sometimes use the apps as a sort of sexual ubereats or at least attempt to and women attempt to date the most desireable men. I don't find this mirrored in real life where attraction is much more nuanced and not so easily reduced to a shopping list of requirements.

I'm not sure about the concept of "Hypergamy" while on paper it sounds plausible its another one that I don't see playing out around me in real life. Since I've been with my husband I've been asked out / pursued by wealthier, more successful / higher status men than him and if Hypergamy were so natural to women then surely I would have jumped ship for the bigger fish? I didn't and it never crossed my mind to do so because I love my Husband, hes the one I share my life with. I see that reflected across the relationships I see in the real world. But red pill men really love this concept, they claim that a woman cannot actually love any man and instead only value men for their wealth and the security and status they afford them. I assume this theory may mitigate some of the pain some of these men feel from being rejected and unloved.

@Naunet "They're pathetic, entitled, weak little men that need breeding out anyway."

While I totally see the temptation to dismiss these men in that way I don't think its ultimately helpful, I think these men are most likely confused and in pain, it doesn't excuse their behaviour of course but I think that some compassion is valuable.

OP posts:
EmmaH2022 · 15/06/2022 14:40

I increasingly wonder if the sellers believe it or just find it the easiest way for them to make money. Like many things online!

LakieLady · 15/06/2022 14:36

It's a bit of an arms race. We can keep helping women to critically evaluate the shit they come out with and they will find new ways to trick, hurt or kill women.

This. Women daring to enter into what were traditionally male fields of employment, having their own money, buying their own houses etc has made a certain type of man feel threatened and disadvantaged imo. They're trying to reclaim the territory they believe is rightfully theirs and don't give a shit about how much they harm others in the process.

I often wonder if there's a significant overlap of misogyny and racism, too.

DeaconBoo · 15/06/2022 14:28

I have ordered Laura Bates Book and Nina Powers "What do Men Want". I listened to podcasts with both women discussing their books and I am interested in both takes. I get the impression that Laura's book goes more into the "what" and that Nina's asks more about the "why". I think they would both be a good read. Nina was once a lecturer of mine and I have huge respect for her as a human and an intellectal although I gather she is something of a controversial figure these days.

Thanks for the other recommendation! I will see if I can get from the library.

DeaconBoo · 15/06/2022 14:27

Whitesapphire · 15/06/2022 14:03

It is frustrating, I try to think that men can waste their time embarrassing themselves with this nonsense and women as a social class will just keep moving forward.

It's a bit of an arms race. We can keep helping women to critically evaluate the shit they come out with and they will find new ways to trick, hurt or kill women.

(Two women a week are killed by their current or former partners in England and Wales; this has remained fairly consistent for as long as I can remember).

SigmaFlags · 15/06/2022 14:23

@DeaconBoo I have ordered Laura Bates Book and Nina Powers "What do Men Want". I listened to podcasts with both women discussing their books and I am interested in both takes. I get the impression that Laura's book goes more into the "what" and that Nina's asks more about the "why". I think they would both be a good read. Nina was once a lecturer of mine and I have huge respect for her as a human and an intellectal although I gather she is something of a controversial figure these days.

@SilverDragonfly1 I do remember stumling on the manosphere (roosh v, love shy men (todays incels) and mgtow) about 10 years ago and discussing it with a male friend who was very dismissive of the whole thing and didn't recognise any of it in his own attitudes or his friends. In the end I found it so negative and toxic that I did just try to forget about it and hoped it would burn itself out as a movement but it only seems to have become more pervasive and nasty as time has gone on. I'm noticing that it is also an industry where certain men and even some women are feeding the base aspects of these mens misery and then milk them for patreon or youtube subscriptions, donations, courses that promise to teach them how to manipulate women into sex. I also notice that very few of these red pill gurus actually live a mgtow life or are shacked up with a harem of 20 something babes which leads me to believe that much of the content is a cynical ploy for financial gain but the harm that the content does is real. I almost feel that it is a form of self harm for the men who consume such content and absorb its toxicity.

OP posts:
DeaconBoo · 15/06/2022 14:23

I think part of the reason for it being on the rise is the relative new-ness of being able to find literally anything on the internet 100 times over.

We're yet to catch up with this, and we only have so much time to pay attention to things, so the crap that hits the sweet spot of being most attention-grabbing + confirms our existing misogynistic biases + is packaged in an appropriately edgy way + exploiting psychological biases means + Youtube algorithms means that people can become immersed in this with relatively little effort.

Combined with the lack of critical thinking that's encouraged by many in power (who would rather people didn't question what they say and do) and the fear of white males losing the lion's share of the power they do have in the face of any tiny movement towards more equal practices/diversity and you have the perfect gift for any little misogynist who wants to blame someone else for their own unhappiness.

OneTC · 15/06/2022 14:23

Why is it on the rise though?

I don't think it's on the rise as such, being a loser used to be a fairly solitary activity, now it's more connected and social and consequently more valid seeming

Naunet · 15/06/2022 14:16

inmyslippers · 15/06/2022 14:10

Why is it on the rise though?
Is it just a knee jerk reaction to rising feminism and equality or more sinister?

^^ I think more women are choosing to be single. Online dating is massively skewed. Women will swipe right on 5% of men and men will swipe right on 60%. The women on the sites are all trying to date the top men. Leaving lots of single sexless men angry that were hypergamous by nature. Whereas women will prefer to be single instead of lowering their standards.

For god sake, isn’t it convenient how they’re all about “nature” until it works against them? Of course women will be more fussy, most female animals are, it’s not our fault they’ll stick their dick in anything (human or not) 🙄

They're pathetic, entitled, weak little men that need breeding out anyway.

Freerangechildren · 15/06/2022 14:13

I have no idea how to stamp this out

With the political will a lot could be done through new laws and legal channels. It needs to be more highly publicised so that people are aware of how insidious it is, and how dangerous it will become allowed to erode at society.

Freerangechildren · 15/06/2022 14:11

We have noticed a few men (all married weirdly) definitely going down that road. Unfortunately they barely cover it up, in comes out in almost everything they say. It is unnerving and we have had to drop a few friends as a result.
One is married to a very strong capable woman and I wondered why he feels like he does, and more strangely why she is putting up with his views (she tells him off like a naughty school boy when he starts after a few drinks) It is very sad.

inmyslippers · 15/06/2022 14:10

Why is it on the rise though?
Is it just a knee jerk reaction to rising feminism and equality or more sinister?

^^ I think more women are choosing to be single. Online dating is massively skewed. Women will swipe right on 5% of men and men will swipe right on 60%. The women on the sites are all trying to date the top men. Leaving lots of single sexless men angry that were hypergamous by nature. Whereas women will prefer to be single instead of lowering their standards.

Eeksteek · 15/06/2022 14:04

Ah, the Disenfranchised White Male. Can’t get away with the misogyny and privilege of his forefathers and is pissed about it. He sees his lack of any sort of adult achievement not as his own failing, but because the success that is rightfully his has been stollen by women who have done nothing to deserve it. They are incredibly dangerous people. I read somewhere that they are the main perpetrator of school shootings in the states.

I have no idea how to stamp this out. It’s abhorrent. I’d always thought that although progress was slow, society was getting there. But just lately, I’m not so sure….

Whitesapphire · 15/06/2022 14:03

It is frustrating, I try to think that men can waste their time embarrassing themselves with this nonsense and women as a social class will just keep moving forward.

blacksax · 15/06/2022 13:58

Thereisnolight · 15/06/2022 13:43

I think the point they make is that in a random group of 10 men and 10 women, most of the men would date most of the women whereas most of the women would only date 3 or 4 of the men.

Well they need to take a good look at themselves and work out just why that is then. Women don't choose with their eyes in the same way that men do. Men don't have to be good looking, they just need to be a nice bloke.

Entitled self-absorbed misogynistic swines are not going to find it easy to get a woman to jump on their dick, are they?

DianaRossshair · 15/06/2022 13:55

JustTheOneSwan · 15/06/2022 13:50

Why is it on the rise though?
Is it just a knee jerk reaction to rising feminism and equality or more sinister?
a friend of my DS has fallen down this rabbit hole and is pretty much isolated from his old friend group, sending memes and complaints about female dating strategy etc but I've known him and his Mum, Aunts, sister for twenty years. He hasn't had any obvious bad experience and his brother isn't like this.

Isn't it all connected to the rise of extreme right wing / proud boys type mentality? Are incels more commonly white men? Is is just another facet of a general white / male / right extremist / gun toting / Trump supporting toxicity in the West?

Swipe left for the next trending thread