Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Be concerned about the spread of red pill ideology?

187 replies

SigmaFlags · 15/06/2022 12:44

A younger male relative that I am close to has recently fallen under the influance of certain online male commentators or activists who preach red pill ideology, which appears to be extrapolated from evolutionary psychology and reduces relationships between the sexes to something purely transactional and women to little more than sex objects whose only value is their repoductive use, beauty and youth. I did do some investigating reading some forums, watching youtube videos of men who are mgtow (going their own way), pick up artists and men who just seem to live for hating women. I've heard statements that women are not really people the way that men are, that women are not capable of rational thought and operate purely on instinct to gain the most resources for themselves and their children and so on.

There is a channel on youtube which can't go a minute without refering to women as 304's which is code for "Hoe" and they openly use that language about women in the videos and the misogyny was awful. I reported these videos to youtube and to ebay who had their adverts running before them but have heard nothing back. According to many of these channels women are worthless beyond the age of 25, 35, 40. There are attitudes that women should not be allowed to work, to vote to hold political office and that all the evils of the world are due to the stupidity and inate badness of women (where have a heard this before I wonder?).

Some of it does appear to be the result of trauma in men who may have been badly treated by a specific women or had their heartbroken which leads them to say they are done with women and relationships. Thats totally fine, I see it on here are well that there are women, perhaps lots of women who decide to opt out of relationships after suffering abuse or broken trust or even just deciding coupled life isn't for them, and obviously men have that right as well (I believe women only communities and even political lesbianisim has been a thing in radfem circles since the 70s). What I don't see is women making 1000's of youtube videos that obsess about women, that stir up misogyny, encourage extremist views, that feed certain mens hatred and fear of women. Also while these men claim to want to have nothing to do with women they are still for the most part obsessed with gaining access to sex with women especially very young women, admittedly I can't imagine they are having much success here but the whole attitude is malign and predetory and there appears to be real rage towards women they perceive as rejecting them or not having sex with them. They say women's standards are too high and that they should lower them to find a man ignoring the fact that many women would often choose to stay single rather than be with a man she doesn't want to be with, surely that kind of freedom is a basic human right for both sexes?

I do think that men are in a difficult phase at the moment, that some of them are struggling to adapt to women's continuing emancipation, that there are areas where men and boys are being failed in education for example. I don't think its a bad thing that men what to be able to talk about their issues and how to be a good man, have a good life, the freedom to choose different paths in life that might not involve being a husband or father that is fine, I don't believe it needs to be a zero sum game. The problem is that in the online space it seems impossible to have that without it degenerating outright hatred of women, dehumanising of women and threats against women.

Its tempting to ignore this as it feels like its something that just happens in dark corners of the internet but when you actually look its massive and probably popping up on the social media feeds of your sons, brothers, husbands and friends.

OP posts:
Naunet · 15/06/2022 15:57

entropynow · 15/06/2022 15:53

@Naunet
Works for Trumpists, Brexiteers and Corbynists too.

Absolutely! Othering is a known tool that armies around the world have been known to use. Train your soldiers to believe the other side are less than human, evil, unfeeling etc, makes it easier to kill them.

SigmaFlags · 15/06/2022 15:55

@EmmaH2022 I agree of course but the awful red pills stuff is so ubiquitous that it uses the self improvement stuff or fairly dubious ideas about how to be successful with women to draw men in and then they follow it up with hate speech they like to call red pill truth about women. I really am not trying to excuse it. I want platforms like youtube and TikTok to delete these channels.

OP posts:
twoblackdogs · 15/06/2022 15:55

I would say this is sense of entitlement. Probably often starts in the family where a child always gets what he wants as long as he screams loud and long enough. Those who just want something and get very angry if they are not given that immediately. Entitlement and no delayed gratification during childhood. And then it rolls along from there, they grow up and see lots of good things and beautiful women and want it all, and then get angry when they can't get it. These are people to whom nobody has said no and then suddenly someone does, and then that someone becomes an enemy.

entropynow · 15/06/2022 15:53

@Naunet
Works for Trumpists, Brexiteers and Corbynists too.

DeaconBoo · 15/06/2022 15:53

To a certain degree I can see you're point. I'd see them as analogous to the people roped in by Trump, Q anon, GB news, Alex Jones and Any other culture war bullshit campaigns.

Totally.
I think a big part of it as well is if you haven't reached the American Dream - which you've been told from birth you are entitled to have if you 'work hard enough' - then instead of realising all the inequality in the world and your own shortcomings, it must be incredibly attractive to have someone else to blame (immigrants, "immoral" people, women, people on benefits) - that absolves you from your own faults and focuses.

Mayorquimby2 · 15/06/2022 15:52

The problem is leaving them to our doesn't work.

At a low level they try to recruit and radicalize other young and vulnerable men, at the extreme end some mass shooters have been strongly linked to incel culture

entropynow · 15/06/2022 15:52

Thereisnolight · 15/06/2022 13:43

I think the point they make is that in a random group of 10 men and 10 women, most of the men would date most of the women whereas most of the women would only date 3 or 4 of the men.

If you spell date f u c k, maybe. Anyhow, just bc women have standards they are bitches? Hmm.

TheWayoftheLeaf · 15/06/2022 15:52

Although personally I think men are failing themselves when it comes to education. I don't know of any female specific education aid out there. We're beating them in academics because we simply try harder.

TheWayoftheLeaf · 15/06/2022 15:49

Yeah it's all over TikTok. It's very dehumanising.

Naunet · 15/06/2022 15:49

It gives them a get out. What isn’t appealing about hearing that all your problems are someone else’s fault? That the odds are stacked against you, that your a poor victims and there’s no way your life could turn out any differently because the Others have been working against you, taking everything you’re entitled to. It’s very appealing to a certain type of person.

inmyslippers · 15/06/2022 15:47

Just leave them to it I reckon. Most of them have nothing to offer women anyway so what’s the loss? They can stay in their basements.

^^ agreed if they turned their attention inward I'm sure life would be better for them.

EmmaH2022 · 15/06/2022 15:45

SigmaFlags · 15/06/2022 15:42

"I think its valid to want to question the unquestioned spread of this sort of content and to ask why men and boys are so vulnerable to it."

I'm going to anwer myself here and say that perhaps something in the red pill message about what it means to be a successful man, even a good man is resonating with young men who perhaps can't find that elsewhere and that draws them in although they are perhaps unaware its it shot through with toxicity that for the most part only poisons themselves.

We can all be attracted to things that feed the baser aspects of ourselves (gossip for example) so I think its possible to see how attractive some men might find this sort of content.

Cross posting everywhere

material about being successful can be found everywhere, that doesn't seem a reason to lean to incel stuff.

EmmaH2022 · 15/06/2022 15:44

Username "I genuinely find it terrifying that there’s so many of them out in the open in such a small town, that it makes me wonder how many more there are."

how does that work in a small town? Do they have any friends apart from each other?

SigmaFlags · 15/06/2022 15:42

"I think its valid to want to question the unquestioned spread of this sort of content and to ask why men and boys are so vulnerable to it."

I'm going to anwer myself here and say that perhaps something in the red pill message about what it means to be a successful man, even a good man is resonating with young men who perhaps can't find that elsewhere and that draws them in although they are perhaps unaware its it shot through with toxicity that for the most part only poisons themselves.

We can all be attracted to things that feed the baser aspects of ourselves (gossip for example) so I think its possible to see how attractive some men might find this sort of content.

OP posts:
EmmaH2022 · 15/06/2022 15:42

OP I thought there might be a personal note here. Must be awful having a brother do this.

I tend to ignore it but recently met someone at a group social who made a comment which he thought was a joke about red pill stuff, I thought was serious, and it ended up with him being (scarily) angry IMHO, saying it was obviously a joke.

But that's such an easy get out for so many things. Many a true word etc.

Mayorquimby2 · 15/06/2022 15:40

"While I totally see the temptation to dismiss these men in that way I don't think its ultimately helpful, I think these men are most likely confused and in pain, it doesn't excuse their behaviour of course but I think that some compassion is valuable."

To a certain degree I can see you're point. I'd see them as analogous to the people roped in by Trump, Q anon, GB news, Alex Jones and Any other culture war bullshit campaigns.

They're being grifted and weaponized for the benefit and profit of people who couldn't give a shit about them and will abandon them at the first sight of having to face the consequences of they're actions.

But just as with the groups above, they are choosing to prop up ideologies and groups which target and villify others, to create division and they're doing so because they want to blame groups they perceive as inferior for their own short comings. So while they may be vulnerable people who have been targeted, or they may be damaged due to past trauma and that had made them susceptible to these groups, that is true of countless people and the majority (or at least I'd like to hope it is the vast majority) don't choose hatred, racism and misogyny as their crutch. So fuck then.

DontBlameMe79 · 15/06/2022 15:38

Just leave them to it I reckon. Most of them have nothing to offer women anyway so what’s the loss? They can stay in their basements.

On whether it’s on the rise, I’m not sure it is. Maybe just better reported now so it seems to be increasing even though it’s no more common. Like extreme weather.

UsernameNotAvailableApparently · 15/06/2022 15:34

YANBU op

I live in a small quiet town where I know there are at least 4-5 of these red pill men and they don’t care who knows it.

Agree with PPs who said this ties in with far right ideology as well. They constantly spout abuse at us ‘sheeple’ in community Facebook groups and were eventually thrown out for saying the most disgusting sexual abusive threats and racist remarks to a lovely local woman (honestly, they were horrific with their comments).

The police did go over to talk to one of them about that and he filmed them for his little red pill buddies on YouTube all goading him on.

I genuinely find it terrifying that there’s so many of them out in the open in such a small town, that it makes me wonder how many more there are.

Naunet · 15/06/2022 15:34

Kerrangutan · 15/06/2022 15:28

I feel women's energy is better spent on encouraging other women to have high standards and never give a man like that the time of day.

That's very easy to say but the reality is we live in a world where increasingly you need two incomes to cover the basics. I have two aunties who never married or had kids and I know they're lonely. That is NO WAY suggesting they should have lowered their standards and settled for one of these cretins, but I like OP feel it's spreading and I know so many of my friends are looking around at 30 and wondering where all the Good Men have gone.

I'm not talking about reaching out to incels - fuck them. But we're the same species, and a little understanding might actually help move things back in the right direction for the next generation of men and women.

I fell down this rabbit hole a wee while ago, a Kevin Samuels video on YouTube. Initially I was just fucking livid and rage watched another couple of videos. I believe he's sexist and has a very warped view of 90% of things, but there was some truth there. What I also saw was him 'helping' other men to do better by giving them cold hard home truths. A bit like a stern father they probably never had.

Women have ALWAYS tried to understand and help men, we’ve always supported them. I’m not convinced it’s helped much.

Naunet · 15/06/2022 15:32

SigmaFlags · 15/06/2022 15:26

@Naunet I suppose my feelings are coloured by the fact that my younger brother has swallowed some of this Kool aid and I know for a fact he's not irredeemable and from looking online lots of men do come out the other side of it. The sad old messed up red pill guys can stew in their own juices for all I care but its the proselytizing via social media that disturbs me. Its all over youtube and even good lads are vulnerable to this stuff. The hatred and violence is real from some of these content creators see Fit & Fresh on youtube but when I contacted them or the companies like ebay who are being advertised on these channels I was completely ignored.

I think its valid to want to question the unquestioned spread of this sort of content and to ask why men and boys are so vulnerable to it.

Absolutely it’s valid to want to know why, my guess is the amount of violent porn online leads to men dehumanising us, along with feeling sorry for themselves for not getting all the preferential treatment they believe they’re entitled to. But I struggle to believe good men can be seduced by it, I could never be seduced by white supremacy, no matter how many YouTube videos I watched and I think that applies to the majority.

Men need to take responsibility for their own lives instead of looking to blame everyone else. I do understand you wanting to save your brother from it all, I hope you can, genuinely!

Kerrangutan · 15/06/2022 15:28

I feel women's energy is better spent on encouraging other women to have high standards and never give a man like that the time of day.

That's very easy to say but the reality is we live in a world where increasingly you need two incomes to cover the basics. I have two aunties who never married or had kids and I know they're lonely. That is NO WAY suggesting they should have lowered their standards and settled for one of these cretins, but I like OP feel it's spreading and I know so many of my friends are looking around at 30 and wondering where all the Good Men have gone.

I'm not talking about reaching out to incels - fuck them. But we're the same species, and a little understanding might actually help move things back in the right direction for the next generation of men and women.

I fell down this rabbit hole a wee while ago, a Kevin Samuels video on YouTube. Initially I was just fucking livid and rage watched another couple of videos. I believe he's sexist and has a very warped view of 90% of things, but there was some truth there. What I also saw was him 'helping' other men to do better by giving them cold hard home truths. A bit like a stern father they probably never had.

SigmaFlags · 15/06/2022 15:26

@Naunet I suppose my feelings are coloured by the fact that my younger brother has swallowed some of this Kool aid and I know for a fact he's not irredeemable and from looking online lots of men do come out the other side of it. The sad old messed up red pill guys can stew in their own juices for all I care but its the proselytizing via social media that disturbs me. Its all over youtube and even good lads are vulnerable to this stuff. The hatred and violence is real from some of these content creators see Fit & Fresh on youtube but when I contacted them or the companies like ebay who are being advertised on these channels I was completely ignored.

I think its valid to want to question the unquestioned spread of this sort of content and to ask why men and boys are so vulnerable to it.

OP posts:
DirtyDuchess · 15/06/2022 15:24

It's a well worn tactic isn't it, used against people of colour during the 60s/70s and against jewish people by the Nazis. Dehumanise a group enough and you no longer have to feel empathy for them.

SigmaFlags · 15/06/2022 15:19

@DirtyDuchess I did wonder to what extent there was an overlap between these groups. I find it incredible the way they exclaim women have no empathy for them and yet literally say we aren't real people and reduce us to our sexual worth, it does seem to mirror the way other issue groups view women as a collection of dehumanised parts.

OP posts:
OneTC · 15/06/2022 15:15

Nope, sorry. Women have been conditioned for so long to help and support men to their own detriment. I will not empathise with these vile woman haters, I will not feel sorry for them, not poor any emotional energy into them. It’s the women they hurt that have my support and compassion. Its like asking black people to empathise with white supremacy.

👍

Swipe left for the next trending thread