Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Be concerned about the spread of red pill ideology?

187 replies

SigmaFlags · 15/06/2022 12:44

A younger male relative that I am close to has recently fallen under the influance of certain online male commentators or activists who preach red pill ideology, which appears to be extrapolated from evolutionary psychology and reduces relationships between the sexes to something purely transactional and women to little more than sex objects whose only value is their repoductive use, beauty and youth. I did do some investigating reading some forums, watching youtube videos of men who are mgtow (going their own way), pick up artists and men who just seem to live for hating women. I've heard statements that women are not really people the way that men are, that women are not capable of rational thought and operate purely on instinct to gain the most resources for themselves and their children and so on.

There is a channel on youtube which can't go a minute without refering to women as 304's which is code for "Hoe" and they openly use that language about women in the videos and the misogyny was awful. I reported these videos to youtube and to ebay who had their adverts running before them but have heard nothing back. According to many of these channels women are worthless beyond the age of 25, 35, 40. There are attitudes that women should not be allowed to work, to vote to hold political office and that all the evils of the world are due to the stupidity and inate badness of women (where have a heard this before I wonder?).

Some of it does appear to be the result of trauma in men who may have been badly treated by a specific women or had their heartbroken which leads them to say they are done with women and relationships. Thats totally fine, I see it on here are well that there are women, perhaps lots of women who decide to opt out of relationships after suffering abuse or broken trust or even just deciding coupled life isn't for them, and obviously men have that right as well (I believe women only communities and even political lesbianisim has been a thing in radfem circles since the 70s). What I don't see is women making 1000's of youtube videos that obsess about women, that stir up misogyny, encourage extremist views, that feed certain mens hatred and fear of women. Also while these men claim to want to have nothing to do with women they are still for the most part obsessed with gaining access to sex with women especially very young women, admittedly I can't imagine they are having much success here but the whole attitude is malign and predetory and there appears to be real rage towards women they perceive as rejecting them or not having sex with them. They say women's standards are too high and that they should lower them to find a man ignoring the fact that many women would often choose to stay single rather than be with a man she doesn't want to be with, surely that kind of freedom is a basic human right for both sexes?

I do think that men are in a difficult phase at the moment, that some of them are struggling to adapt to women's continuing emancipation, that there are areas where men and boys are being failed in education for example. I don't think its a bad thing that men what to be able to talk about their issues and how to be a good man, have a good life, the freedom to choose different paths in life that might not involve being a husband or father that is fine, I don't believe it needs to be a zero sum game. The problem is that in the online space it seems impossible to have that without it degenerating outright hatred of women, dehumanising of women and threats against women.

Its tempting to ignore this as it feels like its something that just happens in dark corners of the internet but when you actually look its massive and probably popping up on the social media feeds of your sons, brothers, husbands and friends.

OP posts:
Thehonestybox · 15/06/2022 17:53

Yes I'm seeing a lot more of this recently. I honestly think it comes from porn and the rise of stuff like Only Fans where real girls are even more accessible, but still just out of reach.

I believe the guys who say women's standards are too high are the same ones who are looking for porn star levels of attractiveness in women.

SaskiaRembrandt · 15/06/2022 17:53

OneTC · 15/06/2022 15:15

Nope, sorry. Women have been conditioned for so long to help and support men to their own detriment. I will not empathise with these vile woman haters, I will not feel sorry for them, not poor any emotional energy into them. It’s the women they hurt that have my support and compassion. Its like asking black people to empathise with white supremacy.

👍

Absolutely!

FilterWash · 15/06/2022 17:51

good people don't do bad things - when we all know they do.

This just doesn't mean anything or make any sense. What does it mean to say someone "is a good person" if they do terrible things? In what sense are they a good person? Is this a religious belief?

Floogal · 15/06/2022 17:51

Whenever the subject of extreme mysogony comes up why is the fact that there is a skewed gender imbalance get overlooked? Even by these Incels themselves? Admittedly the ratio is not as bad as China, the Middle East or India (where you hear about rape murders on a different scale). Fact is there is a surplus of men, some of them may feel aggrieved or frustrated.

Also, when I think of an Incel Richard Richard from Bottom or Kevin the teenager come to mind. But women can also be Incels as well along with LGBTQ (see femcels or gaycels). Just the extreme mysogonists get noticed

Fairislefandango · 15/06/2022 17:51

I think the point they make is that in a random group of 10 men and 10 women, most of the men would date most of the women whereas most of the women would only date 3 or 4 of the men.

Have sex with rather than date, I think. The incels think this is because women are shallow, grasping bitches who are only interested in the best-looking and/or wealthiest men. Whereas actually it's almost certainly more that women don't see men as sex slot machines and don't prioritise getting laid over meeting someone they actually like and have a connection with.

FilterWash · 15/06/2022 17:50

Kerrangutan · 15/06/2022 17:46

@FilterWash because complex things like human beings and their relationships aren't black and white and it rarely does anyone good to pretend they are?

The fact they've bought into ideologies doesn't mean they weren't good people or are capable of being good people again.

Was everyone in early 1900s Germany just born evil? Or where they probably a more realistic mix of good and bad who bought into an evil ideology because it looked good or offered them something on the surface?

People will be lead into believing things for as long as we are people. Writing them off as 'always was, always will be bad' means we make the mistake of thinking bad things can't happen because good people don't do bad things - when we all know they do.

You've misunderstood me. I don't believe that most people are 'always' good or bad. The point is they do good or bad things, and referring to some kind of essential 'soul' as good or bad is unhelpful.

Many German (and Polish, and Bulgarian, and Austrian) people did not buy into Nazi ideology. Many of them even lost their own lives in their attempts at resistance.

Those who went along with it and did terrible things - it's not a question of saying they were intrinsically bad people. But the things they did and believed and perpetuated were terrible, and it doesn't make sense to keep saying "they were basically good people".

Look at what people actually do and say, not what you'd like to believe they 'are' in some essential core.

EmmaH2022 · 15/06/2022 17:48

FigTreeInEurope · 15/06/2022 17:35

I mean under the mantle of red pill, you could put roosh v, who is essentially a rape apologist, and then rich cooper, who is more about traditional conservative values, or Jordan Peterson, who is a dubious, but accessable psychologist. It's a very broad body of content, and as such you have to discern what is a popular male view, and what is batshit crazy. Red pill is here to stay though, and the vast majority of men can identify with at least some of the content. That's how it gains credibility. I'm happily married for 15 years, and I've consumed a lot of red pill content, if only to contextualise what my life would be like not married. It provokes me to be grateful for what I have, and has reminded me of that when we've passed through rough patches.

I nearly said this about the title...I don't consider red pill to = incel.

I can't keep up with the constantly changing definitions but I don't think it's right to link, for example, JP to incels.

Kerrangutan · 15/06/2022 17:46

@FilterWash because complex things like human beings and their relationships aren't black and white and it rarely does anyone good to pretend they are?

The fact they've bought into ideologies doesn't mean they weren't good people or are capable of being good people again.

Was everyone in early 1900s Germany just born evil? Or where they probably a more realistic mix of good and bad who bought into an evil ideology because it looked good or offered them something on the surface?

People will be lead into believing things for as long as we are people. Writing them off as 'always was, always will be bad' means we make the mistake of thinking bad things can't happen because good people don't do bad things - when we all know they do.

Thereisnolight · 15/06/2022 17:42

NotKevinTurvey · 15/06/2022 17:36

I think that this is probably true in late tweens and through people’s twenties, but starts to swap around after that.

True, but incels tend to be young….
though by the time they do get older they take pleasure in seeing women becoming “devalued” as they age…”see how you like it” kind of thing.

NotKevinTurvey · 15/06/2022 17:36

Thereisnolight · 15/06/2022 13:43

I think the point they make is that in a random group of 10 men and 10 women, most of the men would date most of the women whereas most of the women would only date 3 or 4 of the men.

I think that this is probably true in late tweens and through people’s twenties, but starts to swap around after that.

FigTreeInEurope · 15/06/2022 17:35

I mean under the mantle of red pill, you could put roosh v, who is essentially a rape apologist, and then rich cooper, who is more about traditional conservative values, or Jordan Peterson, who is a dubious, but accessable psychologist. It's a very broad body of content, and as such you have to discern what is a popular male view, and what is batshit crazy. Red pill is here to stay though, and the vast majority of men can identify with at least some of the content. That's how it gains credibility. I'm happily married for 15 years, and I've consumed a lot of red pill content, if only to contextualise what my life would be like not married. It provokes me to be grateful for what I have, and has reminded me of that when we've passed through rough patches.

justasking111 · 15/06/2022 17:33

This has been brewing for decades. Read Marilyn French "The women's Room"" that caused uproar back in the day. Cosmopolitan magazine. My mother married in 1955 sacked when she became pregnant at a solicitor office. Ten years later she cut her hair short, raised her hemlines and started what became a series of flirtations.

Music, cinema, TV reflected this revolution .

My father was left baffled and confused . My mother too. She said she was born too early

Kerrangutan · 15/06/2022 17:31

Is it new though? I mean we were literally property for many, many years because of men like this.

While that was the law and I'm sure affected a lot of women over the last 500 years, wasn't it only really the wealthy ones who (for example) couldn't inherit or would become 'the property' of their brother's until they married etc?

I mean the vast, vast majority of people were basically serfs who worked the fields all day (or cotton mills etc) and lived in cottages owned by their employers, with half a day off on Sunday to attend church. While Mary the 1832 crofter might have been the property of her father or husband, we shouldn't pretend like it would have been any different for the vast majority of them if they weren't.

Not an expert on history, this is just from high school. And maybe a little bit of Starz's Harlots haha 😆. No but in all seriousness, I doubt the average man (or woman) back then gave it much thought. They'd have been preoccupied with the shite harvest and their youngest having tuberculosis and the fact they're down to their last molar.

All of these ideological problems seem to be a very modern phenomenon imo, probably because we all have so much time to sit around and consume them.

FilterWash · 15/06/2022 17:29

Naunet · 15/06/2022 17:02

Is it new though? I mean we were literally property for many, many years because of men like this.

Well, I can see it either way. Obviously it's pretty much the oldest hatred (being both female and Jewish, I get to be on the receiving end of two of them Grin )

The format is different. But yeah - men hating and resenting women and wanting to fuck us and also to kill us and control us is not new.

FilterWash · 15/06/2022 17:28

SigmaFlags · 15/06/2022 17:06

@Kerrangutan Thank you for your post and I agree with you, i think all this does take on a different complexion when someone you love and know to be a basically good person gets taken in my it. You do get a bit more interested in the why, I think the speed of change most of it positive but not all probably is a big part of it.

I think a more interesting, but obviously tougher, question is: why do people still insist that someone is 'basically a good person' when they have bought into truly hateful ideologies, such as extreme misogyny, anti-semitism, white supremacy etc.?

MontanaMountains · 15/06/2022 17:27

Women have ALWAYS tried to understand and help men, we’ve always supported them. I’m not convinced it’s helped much you're not wrong. Just look at the ridiculous gender movement - women expected to capitulate, budge up, relinquish our hard won rights etc. And anyone who thinks that this push against women is a right wing males phenomenon is very naïve. Left wing men are equally as misogynistic (if not a lot more so when it comes to gender ideology and removing sex based rights).

alwaysontheloo · 15/06/2022 17:15

Jesus who exactly are the 11% who think YABU? Hmm
Red pill-ers I'm guessing. I feel for the women young and older who live or are in relationships with these types. I know a guy who thinks in this toxic way.
He dated a friend of my brother and when she ended it with him (nicely I might add) he threw £20 notes at her and called her a whore Angry
She had a lucky escape that's for sure. He's still single and bitter.

CaveMum · 15/06/2022 17:12

I read something interesting a while back that stated that with every push forward in feminism/women’s rights there is a corresponding backlash from men’s rights activists and I think right now that is what we are seeing with regards to the current rise in Incels/MRAs.

We’ve recently had the push forward from the Me Too movement, the steps forward in terms of making coercive control a crime, more awareness around domestic violence, etc. Sadly that upsets a certain type of man.

SigmaFlags · 15/06/2022 17:06

@Kerrangutan Thank you for your post and I agree with you, i think all this does take on a different complexion when someone you love and know to be a basically good person gets taken in my it. You do get a bit more interested in the why, I think the speed of change most of it positive but not all probably is a big part of it.

OP posts:
Emotionalsupportviper · 15/06/2022 17:05

I've never heard of "red pill" before - but this mindset explains much

tootiredtobother · 15/06/2022 17:04

I read the book and was shocked.. So much of society today made sense the way Laura recounts it
The hatred is on the rise due to algorithms which with every click from these sad little losers puts then in touch with yet more material in the same vein. self perpetuating.. Big Teck had to be held accountable , we have no power in this, but I hold out little hope.. they wont even police the internet for child porn

Naunet · 15/06/2022 17:02

FilterWash · 15/06/2022 16:30

It is though. Social media is new. Indoctrination without ever needing to leave your bedroom is new. School shootings and other mass shootings in the USA are up thousands of percent.

Is it new though? I mean we were literally property for many, many years because of men like this.

SigmaFlags · 15/06/2022 16:59

@DeaconBoo Sorry I'm not suggesting that women should take on all the childrearing (along with everything else), only pointing out the massive holes in their argument against the existance of the gender pay gap.

They just seem to have a mental block when it comes to seeing women as full human beings with complex needs and desires. If childrearing and the family work load was evenly divided women would be able hopefully to have their own pension savings. Its a deep cultural issue though as even many employers baulk at male employees being as available for childcare as women are although I hope that is changing. The red pillers also say that women then end up finding men who do share the domestic work load unattractive which in my experiance couldn't be further from the truth, perhaps that just suits them to believe because they don't want to do that sort of work, shitwork its sometimes called.

I had a male flatmate at university once who when I confronted him about never doing his share of the cleaning in the flat appeared to be genuinely bafffled and claimed he just left it for me to do because I "enjoyed" doing it, yeah I totally loved wiping up his pee drips and pubes off the bathroom floor😡

OP posts:
Mumoblue · 15/06/2022 16:53

Personally I think it has a lot to do with men not knowing how to interact with other people. They resent women, and objectify them at the same time- and they often can’t relate to other men outside of their shared spaces to bitch about the fact that women don’t want to touch them.

Lots of men have few or no friends and end up placing all their eggs in one basket- aka putting things on their partner or potential partner for all their emotional fulfilment. No wonder most women dont want that job.

And it may sound harsh but I do not feel the least bit sorry for redpillers. I know loads of women who have had truly awful experiences with men but they don’t start YouTube channels about how much they both want and hate them. These men are making choices, and it’s in womens best interest to keep avoiding them.

Kerrangutan · 15/06/2022 16:47

I'm going to anwer myself here and say that perhaps something in the red pill message about what it means to be a successful man, even a good man is resonating with young men who perhaps can't find that elsewhere and that draws them in although they are perhaps unaware its it shot through with toxicity that for the most part only poisons themselves.

I agree with this.

I also think so many of the 'social problems' (for want of a better term) is just the sheer amount of progress that's being made in what is a relatively short period of time in human history.

While some of it will be a case of it just going unnoticed, I think it would be naive to say there isn't some sort of widespread social "crisis" happening. I'm only 30 and already know so many young men who've taken their lives.

Depression. Suicides. Rife amounts of drug-taking - especially cocaine. Violent porn. The red pill. School shootings. Gangs and stabbings. Radicalised via religion. Trans ideology. Political extremism.

If I had to take a guess I'd say a lot of people are struggling to find their place or purpose in this modern age and these things, on the surface, appear to offer that. A community of sorts, wether it's joining the orange lodge or a gang or a church or an adhd community on tiktok or a red pill discord server, it seems to be plugging a gap that's not being filled by an actual community.

My grandad, in his 70s now, was one of five brothers and I guess going from school to the coal pits, then marrying in your early twenties and working to provide for a family in the same place you grew up probably gave you a good sense of purpose, support and identity.

We are 'luckier' now of course, we get to work from home from screens and can chat to people all over the world, and we get to travel and have fun and build careers in our twenties, and we get to be whatever we want to be - including the opposite sex - but what do we do about all the people who can't afford to live in their communities, who can't afford to have ivf in their 30s, who don't have miners clubs filled with old men to act as the fathers they never had, who would never go to university or gap years in Thailand etc?

You can tell I've thought a lot about this because I "lost" my brother to this in his late teens. We never had a dad. He was never going to uni. He'd have been one of those men who went to the mine everyday and doted on his children but that's just not an option these days - and when it is tends to be frowned upon. He got into drink and drugs and struggled with suicide and the only thing that turned him around was lightning striking a couple years later when he was offered a job in a place not unlike the mines and met a girl who wanted to be a housewife and inherited a home in the place he grew up. Happy to say he is 'A Good Man' now but I can easily see how I'd have lost him to the first "thing" that came along promising him a solution to his problems. And lightning doesn't strike for a lot of people, they just go through the motions but become even more disenfranchised in their online communities or behind closed doors.

You can tell I've thought a lot about this over the years but I don't claim to have any answers. I think most people are happy in 2022 with zero desire to go back to the 1950s (including myself).

Swipe left for the next trending thread