Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Be concerned about the spread of red pill ideology?

187 replies

SigmaFlags · 15/06/2022 12:44

A younger male relative that I am close to has recently fallen under the influance of certain online male commentators or activists who preach red pill ideology, which appears to be extrapolated from evolutionary psychology and reduces relationships between the sexes to something purely transactional and women to little more than sex objects whose only value is their repoductive use, beauty and youth. I did do some investigating reading some forums, watching youtube videos of men who are mgtow (going their own way), pick up artists and men who just seem to live for hating women. I've heard statements that women are not really people the way that men are, that women are not capable of rational thought and operate purely on instinct to gain the most resources for themselves and their children and so on.

There is a channel on youtube which can't go a minute without refering to women as 304's which is code for "Hoe" and they openly use that language about women in the videos and the misogyny was awful. I reported these videos to youtube and to ebay who had their adverts running before them but have heard nothing back. According to many of these channels women are worthless beyond the age of 25, 35, 40. There are attitudes that women should not be allowed to work, to vote to hold political office and that all the evils of the world are due to the stupidity and inate badness of women (where have a heard this before I wonder?).

Some of it does appear to be the result of trauma in men who may have been badly treated by a specific women or had their heartbroken which leads them to say they are done with women and relationships. Thats totally fine, I see it on here are well that there are women, perhaps lots of women who decide to opt out of relationships after suffering abuse or broken trust or even just deciding coupled life isn't for them, and obviously men have that right as well (I believe women only communities and even political lesbianisim has been a thing in radfem circles since the 70s). What I don't see is women making 1000's of youtube videos that obsess about women, that stir up misogyny, encourage extremist views, that feed certain mens hatred and fear of women. Also while these men claim to want to have nothing to do with women they are still for the most part obsessed with gaining access to sex with women especially very young women, admittedly I can't imagine they are having much success here but the whole attitude is malign and predetory and there appears to be real rage towards women they perceive as rejecting them or not having sex with them. They say women's standards are too high and that they should lower them to find a man ignoring the fact that many women would often choose to stay single rather than be with a man she doesn't want to be with, surely that kind of freedom is a basic human right for both sexes?

I do think that men are in a difficult phase at the moment, that some of them are struggling to adapt to women's continuing emancipation, that there are areas where men and boys are being failed in education for example. I don't think its a bad thing that men what to be able to talk about their issues and how to be a good man, have a good life, the freedom to choose different paths in life that might not involve being a husband or father that is fine, I don't believe it needs to be a zero sum game. The problem is that in the online space it seems impossible to have that without it degenerating outright hatred of women, dehumanising of women and threats against women.

Its tempting to ignore this as it feels like its something that just happens in dark corners of the internet but when you actually look its massive and probably popping up on the social media feeds of your sons, brothers, husbands and friends.

OP posts:
LooseGoose22 · 16/06/2022 18:00

Anyway, yes they are generally calling women hypergsmous and shallow, while they rate them out of 1 on looks, say women fall off a cliff at anything from 21 to 30, are worthless other than their youth, sexual value and fertility, should remain virgjns b4 marriage etc etc

I've also seen the "women getting the vote being able to vote, gaming power etc has causedcthe downfall of society. The fundamental Islamic societies have it right. We need to get back to that."

We never had that, but they don't seem keen on (real). History.

LooseGoose22 · 16/06/2022 17:55

...roosh v

Ah yes, he's the one who argued publicly that rape should be legal on private premises.

That is, that it should not be defined as rape in private premises... because if a woman entered so eager private with a man, she should know what he was expecting, and her entry into private premises with him was her consent to sex.

Not sure if he thknls the same about himself with other men, who may or may nor be gay .... that he mist about about being in private with them, or if they forced anal sex on him, it couldn't abd shouldn't be rape. 🙄

MsTSwift · 16/06/2022 17:41

I disagree that their standards are low. They seem to feel entitled to have sexual access to young supermodels and are furious when this doesn’t happen. They are not interested sexually in their female equivalents. That’s part of the problem.

Ponoka7 · 16/06/2022 17:36

"Why is it exempt from discussion?"

It's covered under the religious section of the Equality Act, so unless it can be legally defined as hate speech, it's legally allowed.

I don't know if anyone is following the white supremacists, Christopher Gibbons and Tyrone Patten-Walsh, the two who targeted the Harry and Meghan, but also said of the Manchester Arena bombing "They start screaming and that’s the bit that really pleases me because I hate those people.", They called the victims sluts and said "it's a sign of masculine, even though it was done by a sand n***, masculine terror against women is always a good thing".

Ballcactus · 16/06/2022 17:33

Laura Bates is brilliant but I have to say it’s also terrifying. She is campaigning to have the “mani sphere” which is this ideology- treated as terrorism. Which when you look at the definition- is what this is.
the insidious nature of how it is infiltrating young males lives is where I worry.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 16/06/2022 17:25

@Tompariswasmyfavorite that's the Nice Guy thing, isn't it? The idea that you earn Brownie points by being a friend, helping someone, being a shoulder to cry on etc and one day you've earned enough points to cash in for your prize. Your friend sees it that someone swanned off with his prize at the last moment.

How on Earth these men think that women are the equivalent of a Legoland day out paid for in Clubcard points, escapes me.

TrickyD · 16/06/2022 16:49

Male entitlement is also seen in much of the culture of Islam. But any criticism of that provokes cries of ‘racism’.
Why is it exempt from discussion?

DeaconBoo · 16/06/2022 16:37

Isn’t it normal on here though for people to be told that they should not lower their standards, that they “deserve” the best, and that it’s better to be single than to be with someone that doesn’t measure up?

You're being disingenuous. This is usually when the partner is abusive, racist, an addict, sexist, lazy etc. Not that they're not pretty enough.

The odd thread that is started about 'I don't fancy him as much since he put on weight' you get strong opinions from both sides...

NotKevinTurvey · 16/06/2022 16:34

myuterusistryingtokillme · 16/06/2022 08:48

I've noticed this too, plenty of average men seem to think that they 'deserve' a stunning woman with brains and a good job, are quick to reject anyone that doesn't meet the unrealistic bar they have set and then get bitter about being single

They don't seem to realise that the stunning women with brains and a good job will also have a bar and they are very unlikely to get anywhere near it

If they had more realistic expectations then maybe they would have a girlfriend

Isn’t it normal on here though for people to be told that they should not lower their standards, that they “deserve” the best, and that it’s better to be single than to be with someone that doesn’t measure up?

Is this guy not just doing what women on here are told to do all the time, and holding out for what he wants?

Valeriekat · 16/06/2022 15:00

EmmaH2022 · 15/06/2022 17:48

I nearly said this about the title...I don't consider red pill to = incel.

I can't keep up with the constantly changing definitions but I don't think it's right to link, for example, JP to incels.

Jordon Peterson should not be included. While you may not enjoy all his viewpoints he is actually the opposite of the "red pill" and is trying to address the causes.

Valeriekat · 16/06/2022 14:51

DianaRossshair · 15/06/2022 13:55

Isn't it all connected to the rise of extreme right wing / proud boys type mentality? Are incels more commonly white men? Is is just another facet of a general white / male / right extremist / gun toting / Trump supporting toxicity in the West?

Also porn I think which makes them believe that women must be young, hot and sexually available to them.

Tompariswasmyfavorite · 16/06/2022 12:08

myuterusistryingtokillme · 16/06/2022 08:48

I've noticed this too, plenty of average men seem to think that they 'deserve' a stunning woman with brains and a good job, are quick to reject anyone that doesn't meet the unrealistic bar they have set and then get bitter about being single

They don't seem to realise that the stunning women with brains and a good job will also have a bar and they are very unlikely to get anywhere near it

If they had more realistic expectations then maybe they would have a girlfriend

I used to have a male friend, Rob, he made it quite clear over the years he wanted more and I politely made it clear I wasn't interested.

I then married my DH who also happened to be a close friend of mine. Rob fell out with me and hasn't spoken to me since I got married.

Apparently I had just been messing around with the guys I had dated before, getting the 'girls want bad boys' thing out of my system and when I was ready to settle down with a 'nice man' I should have settled down with him, because we had been friends longer, he had paid his dues being my friend and now he deserved his reward and my DH had essentially 'skipped the queue'.

He was totally oblivious to the fact that our lifestyles were incompatible, our future plans were incompatible, I didn't fancy him etc etc. As far as he was concerned his friendship with me was a down payment and I had cheated him out of the end product.

He is exactly the kind of guy who could end up an incel and did come out with red pill/incel type comments over the years. Because he really believed that him being 'nice' = 'sex' and that therefore women were cheating him out of his rights.

myuterusistryingtokillme · 16/06/2022 08:48

Ahgoonyegirlye · 16/06/2022 07:35

It’s worrying. I have a younger colleague - nice bloke on the surface, decent job, own house, successful - who has been single for the 10 years I have known him because if his ridiculous standards in ‘beauty’ when it come to women. He’s pretty average, balding, short for a man but the women he’ll entertain dating pretty much have to look like super models, and have brains too.
so the few chances he’s had with girls from work he’s dodged because they don’t meet his looks standard - I.e. they’re smart, and lovely but ‘average’ in looks. A bit like him.
he’s starting to get bitter about it, and has come out with some phrases that are straight from the incel handbook - tho he is more careful in work, on drinks out when he’s had a couple the poor me attitude comes out.
the women, gays, non-whites get all the opportunities now and white, MC men are ignored etc.
given that anyone above a detail level in our company are ALL white, MC men this is clearly rubbish but he’s having none of it.

I've noticed this too, plenty of average men seem to think that they 'deserve' a stunning woman with brains and a good job, are quick to reject anyone that doesn't meet the unrealistic bar they have set and then get bitter about being single

They don't seem to realise that the stunning women with brains and a good job will also have a bar and they are very unlikely to get anywhere near it

If they had more realistic expectations then maybe they would have a girlfriend

StEthelburgaRose · 16/06/2022 08:45

Ahgoonyegirlye · 16/06/2022 07:35

It’s worrying. I have a younger colleague - nice bloke on the surface, decent job, own house, successful - who has been single for the 10 years I have known him because if his ridiculous standards in ‘beauty’ when it come to women. He’s pretty average, balding, short for a man but the women he’ll entertain dating pretty much have to look like super models, and have brains too.
so the few chances he’s had with girls from work he’s dodged because they don’t meet his looks standard - I.e. they’re smart, and lovely but ‘average’ in looks. A bit like him.
he’s starting to get bitter about it, and has come out with some phrases that are straight from the incel handbook - tho he is more careful in work, on drinks out when he’s had a couple the poor me attitude comes out.
the women, gays, non-whites get all the opportunities now and white, MC men are ignored etc.
given that anyone above a detail level in our company are ALL white, MC men this is clearly rubbish but he’s having none of it.

Yes. I think men are more choosy with looks than women are, and yet these people are claiming men would date any woman but women will only date the top 20%.

Ahgoonyegirlye · 16/06/2022 07:35

It’s worrying. I have a younger colleague - nice bloke on the surface, decent job, own house, successful - who has been single for the 10 years I have known him because if his ridiculous standards in ‘beauty’ when it come to women. He’s pretty average, balding, short for a man but the women he’ll entertain dating pretty much have to look like super models, and have brains too.
so the few chances he’s had with girls from work he’s dodged because they don’t meet his looks standard - I.e. they’re smart, and lovely but ‘average’ in looks. A bit like him.
he’s starting to get bitter about it, and has come out with some phrases that are straight from the incel handbook - tho he is more careful in work, on drinks out when he’s had a couple the poor me attitude comes out.
the women, gays, non-whites get all the opportunities now and white, MC men are ignored etc.
given that anyone above a detail level in our company are ALL white, MC men this is clearly rubbish but he’s having none of it.

Lunar27 · 16/06/2022 07:19

MangyInseam · 16/06/2022 03:47

Yes, it's concerning.

From what I understand, red pi;;ing is actually not just about this sort of thing, it also often refers to other kinds of political ideas, some of which aren't really related to this.

I think it's worth trying to understand what its really responding to. There is something missing in western liberal culture that is leaving a really significant hole for a lot of young men. And when that happens something will jump in to fill it. Some of the things they are responding to in this stuff are based in ideas that have some validity, but they don't treat it in the right way. So whe you see young men who are looking at this stuff, it's maybe worth trying to give them some other options that are intellectually and spiritually and practically more satisfying that can try and fill in those missing links. ANd NOT stuff like Laura Bates.

Definitely this.

To be honest, I've never heard of red pill ideology and don't know what it's about, but from the snippets discussed here, doubt it'd interest me in the slightest (I'm a man btw).

But you're right about holes and the need to fill them. Jordan Petersen is one such man who has become an icon for right wingers and men who feel lost in a changing world where machismo and traditional maleness is getting progressively less acceptable. The voice of a generation allegedly.

Men like JP seem quite reasonable, have very convincing arguments, are able to debate incredibly well and are highly charismatic. I can see how he is like a saviour to men who are looking for something as he has all the answers.

Trouble is, society is full of holes nowadays and governments have no idea how to fill them in a meaningful way. People are slipping through but some groups are more concerning than others. We definitely need to try and understand them and how to give them more fulfilling lives, for all our sakes.

Carpy88999 · 16/06/2022 06:50

SilverDragonfly1 · 15/06/2022 13:36

(Incel is short for 'involuntarily celibate' ie can't have sex with the beautiful and successful women they prefer and feel they deserve, regardless of their own looks and jobs...)

No they feel they can't sex with anyone and they're worthless due to to the 80/20 rule they believe in.

Naan32 · 16/06/2022 05:14

But many people who are violent have been treated badly by society and therefore feel they owe society Jack shit.

I guess people who are violent should be treated well by society 🙄Not going out of your way to be a completely reprehensible misogynist has nothing to do with "owing society".

Which makes a lot of sense. And especially for men when they don't have any hope of a family life of their own.

Many, if not most, of these hateful men have families of their own because there are so many apologists that make excuses for and attempt to placate these types in their social circle instead of cutting them out.

MangyInseam · 16/06/2022 03:56

Thereisnolight · 15/06/2022 18:48

I don’t agree. I hear women say they won’t date (however you want to define that) men who are short, bald, earn less than a certain amount, don’t dress well, etc etc etc. This is their prerogative of course. But SOME women go on to humiliate these men and describe them as losers. (Just as SOME men are derogatory towards women, whether they be incels or alpha boors).

Not saying it excuses violence, as not all people who are bullied or treated badly go on to become violent. But many people who are violent have been treated badly by society and therefore feel they owe society Jack shit.

Research into radicalization shows that it flourishes when people don't have much to hope for. Which makes a lot of sense. And especially for men when they don't have any hope of a family life of their own.

MangyInseam · 16/06/2022 03:47

Yes, it's concerning.

From what I understand, red pi;;ing is actually not just about this sort of thing, it also often refers to other kinds of political ideas, some of which aren't really related to this.

I think it's worth trying to understand what its really responding to. There is something missing in western liberal culture that is leaving a really significant hole for a lot of young men. And when that happens something will jump in to fill it. Some of the things they are responding to in this stuff are based in ideas that have some validity, but they don't treat it in the right way. So whe you see young men who are looking at this stuff, it's maybe worth trying to give them some other options that are intellectually and spiritually and practically more satisfying that can try and fill in those missing links. ANd NOT stuff like Laura Bates.

Eeksteek · 16/06/2022 01:12

As a single woman I very occasionally come across a man who is clearly threatened by my single status. They generally start single mother-bashing, which is easy to shut down, since I’m widowed and therefore blameless in society’s eyes. (Single mothers should all be blameless, but of course are not, for broadly the same reasons). There will often be some sort of ridicule following that in the name of banter. I just disengage. How fragile does your ego have to be if someone you hardly know going it alone bothers you?! Two have turned out to be abusive. I’m assuming they don’t want their wives exposed to the idea that it’s possible to a fulfilled single woman. I suppose it’s dangerously subversive if you are invested in being a crappy husband and father.

I really do think the only way through this is for individual women not to stay with these individual men. The patriarchy (to which most men contribute unwittingly or not) must believe they need to step up or know they will be shipped out sharpish. Fewer women having fewer children (and that being accepted without question as an equally valid choice) will help. The Patriarchy really has to be shown they must earn the right to breed, now, by being decent people. They can’t force women into crappy relationships through lack alternatives any more. I challenge it online, not because I believe they will change, but to give other women the support to stand up to it. I suppose the whole red pill thing is the backlash. Twats.

Velvetcupcakes · 16/06/2022 00:52

To be clear, I think it’s a more diverse group of men than we realise.

Velvetcupcakes · 16/06/2022 00:37

@Eeksteek @DianaRossshair

I wouldn’t be so quick to assume race. My best friend (from the Caribbean) has two red-pilled brothers. She believes males from traditional (and becoming less so) machismo cultures are particularly vulnerable. They listen to Andrew Tate (more than 1.2 million followers on IG), Donovan Sharpe and I don’t know the other one she mentioned, but all three are BIPOC men.

EmmaH2022 · 15/06/2022 23:21

Usernames so how do they get along with others in the small town?

UsernameNotAvailableApparently · 15/06/2022 22:44

ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus · 15/06/2022 16:45

That's horrific, Username.Was this in the UK? USA? elsewhere?

This is, surprisingly, in a small town in SE England.

Swipe left for the next trending thread