Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to drive my friends car

308 replies

Sundaycoffee · 15/06/2022 11:46

I am going on holiday next week with friends (within the UK).
The holiday is booked and paid for and we were going to use my friends car to do the 4 hour drive.
I am the only other driver in the party of 4 and now it has been sprung upon me that the drive needs to be split between me and my friend.
I drive a small car and hers is bigger so it's not an option to use mine and generally I am quite nervous in cars I am not familiar with, especially for such a long drive.
I would honestly rather drive the full way in my own car but it is not big enough for us all to fit in.
I have mentioned that I really don't feel comfortable driving the car. There will also be two other people plus a dog in the car.
We did a trip earlier this year year and I drove us there and back (albeit a shorter 2 hour journey each way) so it's not like I haven't done my share before.

Since I've mentioned it my other friend attending (non driver!) She has told me I'm being unreasonable and it's not fair to expect me not to split the drive and its caused a bit of awkwardness.

I just wish this had been discussed before booking and now I feel a little trapped into doing something I don't feel comfortable doing.

AIBU?

OP posts:
movemyshed · 15/06/2022 13:50

Funny how some people think OP is unreasonable for not wanting to drive a larger car, new to her and full of passengers, yet the owner of the larger car is apparently not unreasonable for being unwilling to drive four hours.

And I'm not sure I would trust the others to contribute to any cost if the car got damaged for any reason.

Adamantspants · 15/06/2022 13:49

I understand OP, there is no way I would drive a bigger car than my own. I would not feel confident, it would give me immense anxiety and I don't give a shit if that makes me sound like a weirdo.
I am too long in the tooth to put myself in uncomfortable situations that affect my mental health. It might not be a huge deal to some people but it would be for me and you know what? That is ok! Not everyone is the same. OP, I am sure you could do things that others on here would be terrified to do. Making less of your fear of driving another car is bang out of order, it is a real fear and it is valid.

Ignore the gobshites saying you are unreasonable and you are not driving a bus.......the sheer dismissal of how you feel and trying to make you look stupid is unnecessary.

OneTC · 15/06/2022 13:49

In this situation I'd explain I didn't feel comfortable driving the larger car and offer to do the motorway sections, which IME anyway, vehicle size makes very little difference to.

In our group we always have 2 drivers but it's always prearranged and we have a pool of drivers to choose from

Luredbyapomegranate · 15/06/2022 13:48

You need to get familiar with the car, so she needs to make time for you to do that - a couple of sessions -don’t let her bat that off.

But other than that - I can totally understand you feeling nervous, but it will do you the world of good to do it.

It’s so easy to let our lives shrink as we get older, by being too sacred to do quite straight forward things.

Feeling nervous is normal, with a bit of prep it shouldn’t put you off doing it. It won’t be anywhere near as hard as you think - cars aren’t all that different these days. She can jump in to do any parking.

SandAndSea · 15/06/2022 13:48

OP, your feelings and opinions are as important as everyone else's.

Another solution: you could offer to do all the driving in your car like you did before. Maybe the non-drivers could get the train?

londonrach · 15/06/2022 13:47

Yanbu and I'm shocked anyone thinks yabu. You don't know the car. It be my worse nightmare and I know it be alot of others. Why they think you driving as well. What do the none drivers think should happen

Inertia · 15/06/2022 13:46

If you do agree to share the driving, you need to negotiate that you’ll do a motorway/ dual carriageway stretch in the middle, services to services- we do this, as I don’t like driving DH’s car.

Your friend needs to add you as a named driver to her policy, and you need to see this because as the driver you hold responsibility for what happens.

TBH I would offer to drive my own car , split the passengers / luggage for more comfortable journeys. Insurance cost vs increased fuel costs may well balance out. 4 hours with a break in the middle should be manageable.

latetothefisting · 15/06/2022 13:46

Everyone saying its not a big issue....YOU might not have an issue witn driving all different types of cars but can't you put yourself in the position whereby you ARE being asked to do something you're not comfortable with and is new to tou (public speaking/coasteering/first aid) and imagine someone saying to you
"Why are you being so pathetic? You know how to talk so just go out there and give a speech to those 300 people." "You know how to swim so just jump off this big rock into the sea"
"Um...Can't I have a practice first?"
"No just do it, I've done it lots of times and it's easy, if you're scared it's pathetic!"

I have driven a lot of different cars (drive for work so used to not knowing what I'll be driving for 4 hours until I get the keys that day) and its true that most people can drive most cars....but it is also true that a manual fiesta handles pretty fucking differently to an automatically range rover and most people need a little while to get used to it....and it's really not ideal for that first "little while" to be pulling out of a service station straight onto a motorway with 2/3 other people and dogs in the car! All it takes is for OP to accidentally press the wrong button (e.g. one car I drove had a button for a handbreak!) and she's caused a pile up for which her friends car isn't even insured! Great idea....

Also as a caveat to that, as a very short person there were one or two cars i was given that I physically could not drive safely because I couldn't adjust the seat enough, which is why I've said most cars, not all.

personally I'd be happy either driving 4 hours OR driving someone else's car but I am fully aware there are other things other people would find easy I would be absolutely terrified and terrible at, so why be a dick just because you are a confident driver?

CockSpadget · 15/06/2022 13:46

Unless she has a disability of some sort, why on earth would a 4 hour drive need to be split in the first place? How does she think the millions of people who drive full time for a living carry on?

Sundaycoffee · 15/06/2022 13:44

MotherofTerriers · 15/06/2022 13:12

Unless her insurance covers any driver, you would be driving on your insurance which won't cover any damage to her car. I think thats how it works, if I was you I'd check with your own insurance first and then ask her to check with hers

And say if I had an accident in her car, would my insurance premiums increase on my own car?

OP posts:
mam0918 · 15/06/2022 13:42

no idea why my compute keeps changing can't to can lol

mam0918 · 15/06/2022 13:42

mam0918 · 15/06/2022 13:41

I can even drive my DH car because Im not insured too, we can afford it.

It cost's my parents £200 to add my sibling to their insurance and this was an amazingly low quote based on their 40 years of good driving and was cheaper than taking out a temporary policy for a second driver.

It utterly insane all these people suggesting you can just drive someone elses car, I wonder if they drive because that is not how any of this works.

*can't even drive

mam0918 · 15/06/2022 13:41

I can even drive my DH car because Im not insured too, we can afford it.

It cost's my parents £200 to add my sibling to their insurance and this was an amazingly low quote based on their 40 years of good driving and was cheaper than taking out a temporary policy for a second driver.

It utterly insane all these people suggesting you can just drive someone elses car, I wonder if they drive because that is not how any of this works.

Everydaydayisaschoolday · 15/06/2022 13:41

I'm with you OP. I hate driving and whether the friends car was bigger or smaller would be irrelevant to me. The thought of driving someone else's car is too much responsibility for me. I like driving my own car where the only person who will be pissed off if I reserve it into a wall or inconvenienced of some lunatic drives into me at 50 mph is me. Having to drive someone else's car would be an ordeal. The fear and anticipation would spoil the holiday for me.

DotDotaDash · 15/06/2022 13:41

In the dim and distant past the car owners insurance company would often pop you on the cover for a few days no extra charge.

No need to be frightened of a bigger car per way but a practice would be nice.

Did you say why the driver doesn’t want to do the lot? It’s not exactly that long is it!

Hallyup89 · 15/06/2022 13:39

All the people who are saying you're being selfish can fuck off. We have two cars. A small hatchback and a 7-seater van. For ages, I drove the van while my husband took the smaller car to work. It was fine until I scraped someone else's car, trying to park. It was at that point that I realised that my spatial awareness is shit and I've hated driving it ever since. Fortunately, covid has meant that I now have access to the smaller car.

It's not just as simple as driving another car if you're not comfortable.

Devotedcatslave · 15/06/2022 13:36

I'd be saying no due to the insurance rather than the car size. I'd imagine if her car gets damaged she would expect you to cough up to cover it. Third party is legal to drive with, but could be very expensive if for example you misjudge the size of the bigger car and clip another one!

LemonSwan · 15/06/2022 13:34

Really weird. DP and I both drive and are both equally comfortable in our own car (obviously). We wouldn’t share on a 4 hr journey - 6 or 8 maybe but 4 is just a faff of changing seat distance, heights, wing mirrors, rear view etc.

Not worth it

No way would I want a friend driving my car for the sake of 2 hours - let alone when they expressed lack of confidence / experience in driving a larger car.

super weird and makes me think she hates driving her car - which wouldn’t inspire confidence in it being a nice experience for me either.

ItWasAParty · 15/06/2022 13:34

www.theaa.com/car-insurance/advice/driving-other-cars-insurance

Some years ago fully comprehensive policies often covered people to drive others' vehicles third party, but this has changed. It is not difficult for her to add you as a named driver to her policy, if you decide you are willing to drive it. There would obviously be a cost, but I assume she would want you covered for damage to her vehicle?

I would share your annoyance at the assumption you'd share the driving without being asked, particularly coming from one of the non-drivers...

As others have said, if you try driving the bigger car, you may find it easier than you think. Are there parts of the route you might feel more comfortable driving than others?

LateAF · 15/06/2022 13:34

Just say no and point out you did the driving last time without any sharing. Say you are happy to drive but it will need to be your car.

I’m assuming that on a night out etc you will be getting taxis, so I don’t see the problem with one person being responsible for driving as long as it doesn’t mean they can’t drink all holiday.

WhenDovesFly · 15/06/2022 13:33

Triffid1 · 15/06/2022 13:19

I am going to look unsympathetic here but honestly, suck it up. If you have a drivers license, you should be able to drive any car within the category for which your license is. Sure, you're probably not going to want to do tight manoeuvring and parking in small spaces, but getting in the car and driving on the motorway should be no big deal.

What a load of nonsense. Just because your licence will allow you to drive an agricultural tractor or a minibus up to 16 passengers towing a trailer, doesn't mean you should be able to just jump in one and immediately be happy driving it.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 15/06/2022 13:33

This is one of those things where I think you're being unreasonable.

You're already a driver. You're not a new driver. This isn't like pushing you to do something you really fundamentally disagree with - it's just a different car.

Ask your friend if you can have a couple of practice runs if you like - but honestly, this is such a mountain out of a molehill. You're pushing yourself very slightly outside of your comfort zone.

Shade17 · 15/06/2022 13:33

The driving other cars extension is only ever third party only cover.

That’s not strictly true, third party only is the norm but policies are available which include DOC fully comp.

NoSquirrels · 15/06/2022 13:33

Honestly, say you’ll drive your car, or you’ll not go. Don’t be an anxious nervous wreck in someone else’s car with 3 passengers & dogs. It’s not fair on anyone!

rookiemere · 15/06/2022 13:31

Eeksteek · 15/06/2022 13:29

I thin you are being a bit unreasonable. It’s not like she’s asking to you drive a lorry. But then, I jumped in a 7M new-to-me motorhome and bombed round Europe for six weeks on my own with only a ten year old for a co-pilot (she was rubbish!). Twice. I was a bit nervous, but it was a piece of cake. No man has ever asked me if I can park it. Every single woman I know has asked how I manage to.

It’s just driving. Bigger cars aren’t any different, apart from daft things like where the lights are, and your friend can help you there. Unless she’s talking about a Hummer or something, or you’re a very new driver, you’re being pretty precious about it. I really think women are still being told by the patriarchy that they are poor drivers. Ladies, you are not. You can do it. If it fits in a parking space, it’s really just a car.

Good for you.
I don't want to drive a motor home or a huge car. It shouldn't damage my feminist credentials, it's just a personal choice.