Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to drive my friends car

308 replies

Sundaycoffee · 15/06/2022 11:46

I am going on holiday next week with friends (within the UK).
The holiday is booked and paid for and we were going to use my friends car to do the 4 hour drive.
I am the only other driver in the party of 4 and now it has been sprung upon me that the drive needs to be split between me and my friend.
I drive a small car and hers is bigger so it's not an option to use mine and generally I am quite nervous in cars I am not familiar with, especially for such a long drive.
I would honestly rather drive the full way in my own car but it is not big enough for us all to fit in.
I have mentioned that I really don't feel comfortable driving the car. There will also be two other people plus a dog in the car.
We did a trip earlier this year year and I drove us there and back (albeit a shorter 2 hour journey each way) so it's not like I haven't done my share before.

Since I've mentioned it my other friend attending (non driver!) She has told me I'm being unreasonable and it's not fair to expect me not to split the drive and its caused a bit of awkwardness.

I just wish this had been discussed before booking and now I feel a little trapped into doing something I don't feel comfortable doing.

AIBU?

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 15/06/2022 16:00

I think your attitude to being asked to do something you’re uncomfortable with as your unfamiliar is really, really poor.

So you aren’t used to it - not surprising or unreasonable to be uncomfortable with that. But not a reason to not do it. Why haven’t you just asked for an opportunity to get used it? At least then you’ll know if it’s actually going to be awful.

Is there more to this? Because if that’s your general approach to things you’ve not done that might be a bit challenging it’s kind of cowardly and makes you inflexible and a bit limited as a friend.

Ilovetea33 · 15/06/2022 15:59

This needed to be discussed at the planning stage. What kind of friends are these that try to bully you into something you're not comfortable with? Depending on how close you are to them, I would seriously reconsider this holiday.

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 15/06/2022 15:58

This is irking you because it's pushing against your boundaries and it's fine to have boundaries and it's fine to not want to do something that makes you uncomfortable. You are not being unreasonable to be bothered by this for several reasons:

a) If anything goes wrong with the car while you're driving, e.g. it breaks down, they will probably expect you to foot the bill on the basis that "you were driving it at the time so it must be your fault".
b) You are probably not insured, at which point you need to sort this out properly. Don't let your friend fob you off, it's not them that will get done for driving without insurance if you get stopped by police.
c) A long-distance drive is absolutely NOT the way to get started driving a big car that you're not comfortable driving.
d) They sound like the sort of CFs who will conveniently be too drunk or too ill or too lazy to do their share of the driving at which point you could face being lumbered doing all of the driving.
e) If you crash their car (heaven forbid), what sort of reaction do you think you would get? Would they understand you're in an unfamiliar vehicle or would they hold it against you forever more?

I really wouldn't want to go on holiday with anyone who just randomly pushes something like this on you at the last minute without even troubling themselves about whether it's legal. It's a recipe for disaster.

Topseyt123 · 15/06/2022 15:51

I would just totally refuse to do this, but I dislike driving anyway even though I can.

I'd tell her that I was not on her insurance and had no wish to be on it. I'd also tell her that I was not happy to go with the third party option even if it was available.

That's me. To be honest, I'd rather not go on the break. I might be better if I could go in my own car or on public transport.

Ponderingwindow · 15/06/2022 15:44

At 4 hours, sharing the drive is fair. That presumes working out the insurance.

I would just make sure you take the easier part of the drive. Your friend should be navigating anything complicated. You should cover the boring stretch if there is one.

SpeckledlyHen · 15/06/2022 15:42

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 15/06/2022 15:05

Oh grow up. The amount of posters on this site who will absolutely not push themselves out of their comfort zone for anything is absolutely astonishing. And then we wonder why so many people are claiming anxiety for getting out of the most mundane of tasks.

Sure if you're happy trundling along never improving or enhancing your life, or making someone else's that tiny bit easier because it might make you nervy for ten minutes, then crack on. But it's not 'nasty' or being an arsehole to point out that this is making a mountain out of a molehill.

Totally agree. Surely, when you learn to drive, you learn to drive, which means you can drive a car, any car. I honestly wonder too how many people manage to get on in life when they are so scared of everything. However, I have never wanted to be reliant on anyone so I just tend to go out and do things. If that includes hiring a van (done it many times), or pulling a trailer or driving a new car I just get on and do it, yes it might take a few miles to get used to a new vehicle but essentially they all work the same way which you were taught when you learnt to drive.

riesenrad · 15/06/2022 15:40

Oh grow up. The amount of posters on this site who will absolutely not push themselves out of their comfort zone for anything is absolutely astonishing. And then we wonder why so many people are claiming anxiety for getting out of the most mundane of tasks. Sure if you're happy trundling along never improving or enhancing your life, or making someone else's that tiny bit easier because it might make you nervy for ten minutes, then crack on. But it's not 'nasty' or being an arsehole to point out that this is making a mountain out of a molehill

I don't think you've read all the very sensible suggestions on this thread about why this might not be a good idea particularly relating to insurance. Driving an Aygo is a very different proposition to driving a large car with 3 other people and a dog in it.

And I'd rather someone drive to their abilities, rather than "pushing themselves outside their comfort zone". We're all more likely to live longer that way. Of course you have to drive to get more confident, but it is entirely possible to manage to live your entire life without driving a large car.

XelaM · 15/06/2022 15:38

oldstudentmum · 15/06/2022 14:39

I can drive other cars with owner’s consent however it’s only third party. I got thirty years experience but I wouldn’t drive someone else’s car with a dog in on a motorway, and the non drivers probably all chatting away ( unless it was a emergency or a make of car I have driven before a lot)

Why not? Motorway driving is just driving forward in a straight line. What is so scary about that? And presumably the dog will be restrained (as that's the law).

PeopleRStrange · 15/06/2022 15:27

Sundaycoffee · 15/06/2022 13:44

And say if I had an accident in her car, would my insurance premiums increase on my own car?

Yes, your premiums could increase. You should check your insurance, as not all policies include third party on other cars any more. That's probably the solution, tell her your insurance won't cover it, so she will have to add you to her policy.

Even if yours covers third party, that would only cover damage you caused to other vehicles, not the one you were driving. If another driver is responsible she would have to claim against their policy.

Dixiechickonhols · 15/06/2022 15:26

I’ve never driven 3rd party. Those who are happy to do so do you not worry? I suppose if you are wealthy and could easily bank transfer £££ to friend to cover damage it’s ok but what if not. Do you take view they knew you were 3rd party and if you damage it it’s their problem even if they are £15,000 out of pocket. I’d feel awful.

AryaStarkWolf · 15/06/2022 15:19

OneTC · 15/06/2022 14:26

Do not take the risk, the driving other cars extension used to be incredibly common, it is now as rare as rocking horse shit.

It's on my "cheap as I'm willing to go" insurance as standard, and had been standard in every insurance I've ever held

Mine too, I specifically ask that question too each time I renew 💁

GoldenSongbird · 15/06/2022 15:17

And I agree with a PP - I would never assume someone was comfortable driving someone else's car. I have friends and family who'll happily drive whatever car I have. There are others who won't regardless of the size of the car. You're not in the minority. I think it's a pretty even split between drivers who drive anything and ones who much prefer to stick to their own vehicles.

soupey1 · 15/06/2022 15:16

I agree I wouldn’t be comfortable driving someone else’s car - just keep saying you did all the driving last time, this was never discussed and that you cannot drive her car. End of conversation.

WisherWood · 15/06/2022 15:15

Last year the MOT on my car took longer than expected so the garage kindly leant me a car. It was a bit like the loaner car in The Mask. Actually smaller than my car but way more difficult to drive. Gear stick half way up the dash board, had to floor it to get it to move off anywhere, wouldn't have done more than 40 unless you'd chucked it off a cliff. But sometimes you have to adapt.

I would just practise in the other car, checking your insurance first. My insurance covers me for third party whatever car I drive, so long as it's with the owner's permission. You may find a bigger car easier than you think. Personally I find other drivers give you a bit more respect for a start. It is easier to have another driver around. May be quite unlikely but otherwise all the designated has to do is sprain an ankle, and you're all stranded.

gogogadgetgo · 15/06/2022 15:14

Jesus. The people on here... The driving is a moot point really.

It's the attitude of the rest of the group and having it sprung on the op at the last minute.

Its not unreasonable for the op to assume seeing as how she did ALL the driving last time one person would do all the driving this time. And if the plan was to share that should have been made clear before so the op can make her own decision.

Their attitude stinks. And If this has caused bad feeling then id worry the whole trip would be like this.

Wonder if they're hoping you can drive so the car owner can have a drink every night too.

And I don't know enough about insurance to comment. But fucked if I was getting in a car I wasn't comfortable with and said I didn't want to drive and it had long term repercussions.

GoldenSongbird · 15/06/2022 15:13

It wouldn't bother me to drive my friend's car but what matters is that it bothers you. I think driving is too important to feel coerced into it. You need to be comfortable and confident. They shouldn't have assumed you would do. A 4-hr drive isn't an insurmountable amount of driving so it wasn't unreasonable for you to think they were going to do all the driving.
It's all a bit awkward now but it's not your fault. Flowers

BluebellField · 15/06/2022 15:06

They don't sound like very good friends tbh. Not everyone who drives is comfortable driving long distances, places they don't know or in cars that aren't their own. It's rude to assume that you will drive another car and a long way too.

I would stick firm if I was you. You're not comfortable driving your friend's car. Full stop. It's also strange that they would try and convince you. Why do they want someone to be responsible for the car who is nervous and uncomfortable?

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 15/06/2022 15:05

Adamantspants · 15/06/2022 14:12

What an absolutely nasty thing to say, uncalled for.

Have no no fears? Nothing at all that you are nervous of or that would give you anxiety?

You are making OP out to be a fucking idiot because she feels uncomfortable and nervous driving a big car that is not her own.

You would be better out "figuring out" how not to be a complete arsehole.

Oh grow up. The amount of posters on this site who will absolutely not push themselves out of their comfort zone for anything is absolutely astonishing. And then we wonder why so many people are claiming anxiety for getting out of the most mundane of tasks.

Sure if you're happy trundling along never improving or enhancing your life, or making someone else's that tiny bit easier because it might make you nervy for ten minutes, then crack on. But it's not 'nasty' or being an arsehole to point out that this is making a mountain out of a molehill.

Mariposista · 15/06/2022 15:04

Hugasauras · 15/06/2022 12:00

Could you just take both cars? Obviously extra cost with petrol but then means there's more flexibility when you're there too.

agree with this

Dixiechickonhols · 15/06/2022 14:43

It’s not just a day though it’s there and back - . Op’s friend could price stand alone policy v adding Op to her fully comp policy but if I was Op I wouldn’t be doing running getting quotes around when I didn’t want to drive in first place.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 15/06/2022 14:42

Insurance third party, no way would I do that, what if you crash?

LittleOwl153 · 15/06/2022 14:42

Sundaycoffee · 15/06/2022 13:44

And say if I had an accident in her car, would my insurance premiums increase on my own car?

Yes.

Her insurance would increase because it is her insurance that paid the claim (assuming she added you as a named driver - as said above I wouldnt drive it otherwise) She would loose no claims bonus and then some more I'd guess.

and YOUR own car insurance would increase - because you as a driver had a recent accident - which you would need to make them aware of. You'd probably be looking at a 15-25% increase or more depending your age/ driving record.

Both your and her insurances would be 'loaded' for 5 years due to the claim.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 15/06/2022 14:42

If it were me and it were sprung on me then yes, I wouldn't be happy.

I drive a fairly small car (Alfa Mito) and I'd be struggling to drive anything bigger without much practice.

When DB asks his DW (rare) to drive his Mercedes C class she often refuses as she's just got an old Vauxhall Corsa. He drives that more often than not!

Assuming is a pain too that someone will drive.

I've lost count of the amount of times someone assumed I would drive abroad (hate doing it but will do it if need be) if with friends. But I've had a South Korean friend and French, both who hadn't driven for a while and we shared driving together.

OneTC · 15/06/2022 14:39

When I was added as a named driver to a friend's policy who I car share often with on holiday it actually was cheaper to add me permanently than it was to add me for a month, and it also brought the renewal down the following year

oldstudentmum · 15/06/2022 14:39

I can drive other cars with owner’s consent however it’s only third party. I got thirty years experience but I wouldn’t drive someone else’s car with a dog in on a motorway, and the non drivers probably all chatting away ( unless it was a emergency or a make of car I have driven before a lot)