Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think women should be free to choose whatever pain relief in labour suits them without having to consider the environment

90 replies

FannyCann · 14/06/2022 23:34

A colleague brought this article in to work today and it made me furious.

Apparently if women in labour would base their choice of analgesia in labour on the environment they should choose an epidural which has a far lower carbon footprint.
Using Entonox for four hours is the equivalent of driving 850 miles whilst an epidural is equivalent to just four.

It just reads like male doctors scolding women for wanting a simple safe form of pain relief when instead they could burn up manpower resources by demanding epidurals. They haven't considered where all the anaesthetists are meant to come from to provide epidurals for all!

Three female obstetric anaesthetists quite rightly responded in the letters that mothers shouldn't be guilt tripped about their choice of analgesia in labour.

Gas and air in labour ‘harms the planet’.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3d011450-e354-11ec-8bdd-c253e043f5f0?shareToken=3d20235d87acf65d1bda38d59ef587e11_

To think women should be free to choose whatever pain relief in labour suits them without having to consider the environment
OP posts:
Tryagain2020 · 15/06/2022 08:56

I heard this a few years ago and I refused gas and air as a result. So I have no problem with the information being available. It's not like I was forced to make that choice.

Ended up having an emergency spinal and would definitely consider an epidural in future.

OneForTheRoadThen · 15/06/2022 08:53

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 14/06/2022 23:51

850 miles you say? That's the equivalent of driving to visit to my mother. I didn't have any pain relief as DS was born in the street but I'm more than happy to not visit my mother to offset someone else's gas and air use.

🤣

LookItsMeAgain · 15/06/2022 08:47

My mother who had 4 children (of which I'm one of them) was always told, while she was in labour, to "offer it up". When she enquired as to what she was to be offering up and to whom, it was her pain and to God.
This was in the 1960's and '70's in good old Catholic Ireland.

I agree with the OP - if a woman needs pain relief, give her the pain relief. End of.

FannyCann · 15/06/2022 08:45

That said, I don’t have a problem with the information being out there. Not so women can have their choices restricted, but it might be relevant to certain women in what choices they make. For most, I suspect it’s irrelevant but I don’t think it was wrong to do a study on it.

Yes it's fine to look at the use of medical gases generally and their impact, and regarding entonox in maternity I had thought the scavenging systems were widely used not so much for environmental reasons but for health and safety to protect midwives from breathing it in continuously as they care for their patients but maybe I thought wrong?

It was the tone of the article that annoyed me as it really felt like men scolding women for their choices. It's also ridiculous to suggest that women should choose epidurals instead of entonox to protect the environment due to the other factors relating to epidurals including requiring more anaesthetists, closer monitoring, increased intervention. By all means look at the impact of entonox but don't tell women they should have an epidural instead. Although epidurals are generally very safe they are not without risk and entonox is very safe and simple to use.

OP posts:
riesenrad · 15/06/2022 08:36

Women seem to be expected to put up with pain generally

yes and by other women. See also painful periods and slagging off other women for being "too posh to push".

PurpleWisteria · 15/06/2022 08:35

I get very pissed off with individual "save the planet" propaganda.

It's governments and companies who should be changing their ways. The difference I can make is marginal. I'm not going to make my life less comfortable until I see large organisations doing something that may damage their profits but will save the planet.

riesenrad · 15/06/2022 08:35

Notcoolright · 14/06/2022 23:36

I think people commonly underestimate just how important the environment is.

They do, but it always seems to be women who have the most pressure on them to change their behaviour - eg sanitary protection too.

Nobody will tell men that they should choose different pain relief for the sake of the environment.

Anyway I drive a hybrid, not a full petrol car so I suspect over the life of the car so far I've offset the gas and air when having ds.

Having a baby is bad for the environment, and condoms are throw-away so maybe we just need to have less sex?

There are easy wins for the environment but pain relief is not one of them.

Natsku · 15/06/2022 08:32

FiveNineFive · 15/06/2022 01:09

I mean, I'm sure lots of women have gas and air and an epidural? I did.

I did too, my epidural failed after the first (glorious) dose so had to use gas and air as well as the 2 or 3 more epidural doses I had, for 25 hours plus maybe a couple of hours after the birth because I had a pph and them sorting that out was more painful than most of the labour, then they forgot to take it off me.
That's probably a lot of driving miles but I don't drive at all so maybe it's balanced out.

Snowflakes1122 · 15/06/2022 08:30

When we start doing operations on mens balls without pain relief, then I will take this seriously.

Women seem to be expected to put up with pain generally.

ErrolTheDragon · 15/06/2022 08:26

SilverDragonfly1 · 15/06/2022 08:08

In a situation like this, the onus is on scientists to come up with equally effective and more environmentally friendly pain relief, not on women to just suffer for the good of the world.

The piece mentioned some new bit of kit which destroyed the exhaled nitrous oxide rather than venting it. That sounds like a good way forward.

Lunar27 · 15/06/2022 08:19

I think it greatly depends on how this fits in with the overall environmental objectives of any medical/hospital organisation surely?

I have no idea how this relates or contributes to the carbon footprint of a regular NHS hospital and doubt many do either. If it's significant in achieving targets then it's not unreasonable. If it's not significant, it's still not unreasonable to consider the environment but unreasonable if other aspects have greater impacts and they're not being addressed.

Sadly, choice of pain relief doesn't trump how bad a chemical may be. Especially when thousands of babies are born every year. If it's genuinely bad to produce/use then it'll be outlawed and rightly so. If this is just some blokes being dicks to women then it'll come out.

Cantanka · 15/06/2022 08:13

I absolutely agree women should be entitled to whatever pain relief they want, and should not feel guilty. There are lots of things we could do better on with the environment without subjecting women to even more suffering in birth.

That said, I don’t have a problem with the information being out there. Not so women can have their choices restricted, but it might be relevant to certain women in what choices they make. For most, I suspect it’s irrelevant but I don’t think it was wrong to do a study on it.

HaveringWavering · 15/06/2022 08:08

Mamai90 · 14/06/2022 23:47

Does anyone ever actually get an epidural when they ask? Seems to me (anecdotally) that it's not that often!

Yes. My midwife said “the anaesthetist is passing, if you want one let me know”.
I had been induced perhaps 3 or 4 hours previously. Was finding it all quite painful but it wasn’t unbearable.

This was 2016. It was the right decision for me. I had no idea they were so hard to come by for so many people!

SilverDragonfly1 · 15/06/2022 08:08

In a situation like this, the onus is on scientists to come up with equally effective and more environmentally friendly pain relief, not on women to just suffer for the good of the world.

ApplesandBunions · 15/06/2022 08:07

I recall a male midwife writing something to the effect that western women didn't know how lucky they were using multiple gallons of water for a water birth whilst in Africa women walked miles every day to carry a small pot of water back to the home for cooking and drinking.

What a surprise that it was a bloke.

ApplesandBunions · 15/06/2022 08:06

As if the NHS is going to be providing epidurals in the same numbers as it provides gas and air. I wonder how many of us there are who desperately wanted an epidural, were denied and instead were forced to rely on less effective gas and air for pain relief? Bet it's a fair few.

FannyCann · 15/06/2022 08:04

I had no pain relief in either of my two labours but I did have water births and being in the pool helped a lot. At the time (about 24 years ago) I recall a male midwife writing something to the effect that western women didn't know how lucky they were using multiple gallons of water for a water birth whilst in Africa women walked miles every day to carry a small pot of water back to the home for cooking and drinking.
It's really time someone looked at the environmental effect of water births.

While they're at it they can calculate the cost to the environment of HCPs washing their hands. Hmm

OP posts:
DoinMeDriving · 15/06/2022 01:26

I think anyone who comments about the carbon footprint of other individual people's activities and/or other individual people's very existence (which I seem to hear a lot in reference to children these days) should be handed the keys to a euthanasia suite and told to get on with it, for the good of the planet.

MrsTerryPratchett · 15/06/2022 01:14

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 14/06/2022 23:51

850 miles you say? That's the equivalent of driving to visit to my mother. I didn't have any pain relief as DS was born in the street but I'm more than happy to not visit my mother to offset someone else's gas and air use.

I have to get a flight to visit mine.

I'm in. I can offset a few gas and air mothers.

FiveNineFive · 15/06/2022 01:09

I mean, I'm sure lots of women have gas and air and an epidural? I did.

nocoolnamesleft · 15/06/2022 00:13

The carbon footprint of any pain relief choice in labour is going to be a drop in the ocean compared to the carbon footprint of having a child. So it seems a strange aspect to worry about.

thelastshadowpuppet · 15/06/2022 00:09

@Mamai90 I got my epidural within 15 mins if asking.

When he was done I thanked him for coming so quickly. He told me his wife had had their first baby a couple of weeks before and it had opened his eyes and put a rocket up his arse 😂

x2boys · 15/06/2022 00:07

Mamai90 · 14/06/2022 23:47

Does anyone ever actually get an epidural when they ask? Seems to me (anecdotally) that it's not that often!

My boys are 15 and 12 now so no recent experience, but I had an epidural during both labours ,I was induced both times however

ventreàterre · 15/06/2022 00:06

I'd be intensely displeased if someone tried to make me feel guilty about any pain relief I wanted, no matter what was wrong with me.

FourTeaFallOut · 15/06/2022 00:03

LeavesOnTrees · 14/06/2022 23:53

If they want to be really environmentally friendly then they should close the hospitals and just let people die.

Why are these things only talked about for women only issues.

How much electricity is used by someone on a life support machine?

Quite It's fucking ridiculous.