Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think women should be free to choose whatever pain relief in labour suits them without having to consider the environment

90 replies

FannyCann · 14/06/2022 23:34

A colleague brought this article in to work today and it made me furious.

Apparently if women in labour would base their choice of analgesia in labour on the environment they should choose an epidural which has a far lower carbon footprint.
Using Entonox for four hours is the equivalent of driving 850 miles whilst an epidural is equivalent to just four.

It just reads like male doctors scolding women for wanting a simple safe form of pain relief when instead they could burn up manpower resources by demanding epidurals. They haven't considered where all the anaesthetists are meant to come from to provide epidurals for all!

Three female obstetric anaesthetists quite rightly responded in the letters that mothers shouldn't be guilt tripped about their choice of analgesia in labour.

Gas and air in labour ‘harms the planet’.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3d011450-e354-11ec-8bdd-c253e043f5f0?shareToken=3d20235d87acf65d1bda38d59ef587e11_

To think women should be free to choose whatever pain relief in labour suits them without having to consider the environment
OP posts:
WheresTheLambSauce · 15/06/2022 11:22

I sincerely hope this research is used to develop less environmentally-impactful methods, instead of whacking people about with the shame hammer. Big corporations produce more emissions per year than many of us will ever produce in our entire lives, epidural or not.

12BottlesOfVintageChampagne · 15/06/2022 11:20

I wonder whether you could offset the use of Entonox against all the other occasions that women are denied appropriate levels of pain relief?

ComDummings · 15/06/2022 11:11

Snowflakes1122 · 15/06/2022 08:30

When we start doing operations on mens balls without pain relief, then I will take this seriously.

Women seem to be expected to put up with pain generally.

This ^

Wykid · 15/06/2022 11:09

An epidural puts you at a much higher risk of needing a more medicalised birth though

that obviously puts both mum and baby at a higher risk of complications

babyjellyfish · 15/06/2022 11:05

Chouah · 15/06/2022 11:02

I had to stay in hospital for 10 extra days after an epidural, botched of course. I doubt there was no carbon footprint for all the effort dealing with me. I wish I'd stuck to gas and air. All very well giving the facts but it's dangerous not to say "you can save the planet by having an epidural instead of gas, but your knackered anaesthetist might kill you in the process ".

Sadly I think epidurals are more likely to be botched in countries like the UK where they do far fewer of them and maternity units don't have their own dedicated anaesthetists.

Tompariswasmyfavorite · 15/06/2022 11:05

MackenCheese · 15/06/2022 09:13

Yeah if women were really that bothered about the environment, they wouldn't be having a baby in the first place!!

Men being entirely uninvolved in the process?

Chouah · 15/06/2022 11:02

I had to stay in hospital for 10 extra days after an epidural, botched of course. I doubt there was no carbon footprint for all the effort dealing with me. I wish I'd stuck to gas and air. All very well giving the facts but it's dangerous not to say "you can save the planet by having an epidural instead of gas, but your knackered anaesthetist might kill you in the process ".

babyjellyfish · 15/06/2022 10:55

FannyCann · 15/06/2022 10:51

What happened to Michel Odent and the Pithiviers unit @babyjellyfish ?

He was all the fashion in the 80's which is literally the olden days.

I do think there's an inbetween place, where ideally safety and mother's choice meet. Or there should be.

Many women have straightforward and quite quick births with no intervention and I'm lucky to be one of those. It would be a huge waste of resources to impose and medicalised birth on those women, quite apart from their needs and choices.

Doesn't appear to have made a big impact in France!

Discovereads · 15/06/2022 10:55

Babdoc · 14/06/2022 23:47

Speaking as a retired anaesthetist, I believe the article in question was written by some Dutch anaesthetists. They were quite correctly stating the relative environmental impact of different methods of analgesia in labour.
Far more nitrous oxide used to be used in operating theatres, as it was the default carrier gas, along with oxygen, to deliver the anaesthetic vapour (sevoflurane, isoflurane, etc).
Being aware of the environmental damage is important, as it leads to better methods of scavenging the nitrous oxide instead of releasing it to the atmosphere, or developing alternative methods of analgesia, such as epidurals, remifentanil infusions, etc.
I don’t think you need to view it as an attack on women’s choices - it wouldn’t have been intended as such.

I agree with this. I am past childbearing, but being green I would have welcomed there being information available on the environmental impacts of different birth choices. There wasn’t much information at the time other than breastfeeding and cloth nappies being more environmentally conscious choices compared to formula and disposable nappies. I don’t think that having this information or giving it to women is to attack their choices. It’s really more about making those choices better informed.

FannyCann · 15/06/2022 10:51

What happened to Michel Odent and the Pithiviers unit @babyjellyfish ?

He was all the fashion in the 80's which is literally the olden days.

I do think there's an inbetween place, where ideally safety and mother's choice meet. Or there should be.

Many women have straightforward and quite quick births with no intervention and I'm lucky to be one of those. It would be a huge waste of resources to impose and medicalised birth on those women, quite apart from their needs and choices.

OP posts:
LeavesOnTrees · 15/06/2022 10:48

babyjellyfish

same here, I gave birth in epidural friendly France.
I got a red button to push to call for one when the pain got too much.
Maximum wait 1/2 hour.
Team of dedicated anaesthetists in the maternity section.

Apparently something over 90% have epidurals, the ones who don't are too late and the British !

StarFlecks · 15/06/2022 10:46

When I was in labour if someone had told me they could fly in am anaesthetist from another galaxy to provide pain relief I'd have happily accepted. As it happened there was no anaesthetist available in my galaxy and no one to administer pethidine either so I didn't hsvr any pain relief. I didn't like entonox. Can I go and visit my mum now?

FannyCann · 15/06/2022 10:40

*I was going to try and say something serious, but on reflection offsetting is def the way forward.

So many twats we can all stop visiting AND be supporting labouring mothers. This needs to be a world-wide campaign!*

GrinGrinGrin

OP posts:
babyjellyfish · 15/06/2022 10:18

ofwarren · 15/06/2022 09:03

That would have meant I was allowed no pain relief at all in labour as my blood condition means I can't have epidural or any of the opiates.

I mean, I think it should be available in France for that reason.

I do think the lack of pain relief options other than epidurals is a negative rather than a positive thing. There are some hospitals in France, mostly in Paris, where they have gas and air and birthing pools to cater for the international community and the small but growing number of French women who wish to try for an unmedicated birth, but that's not much help if you don't live near one.

That said, I had a very negative view of epidurals, I wanted to try and manage without one, and I wasn't happy about the fact that no gas and air would be available. I think my feelings were very shaped by the fact that most of the information I was getting about childbirth was from UK sources, and I feel that there is a very strong message that the "best" way to give birth is with as little pain relief as possible, just a bit of gas and air. If that's what you actually want to do, having done your research, more power to you. If you're in the middle of a painful labour and you are refusing anything more than gas and air because you've been led to believe that epidurals are bad, that's not so good. If you're asking for an epidural and being told by a midwife that you don't need one, obviously that is completely unacceptable.

There does seem to be a bit of a cult of "natural childbirth" in the UK which leads to women either refusing or being denied stronger pain relief due to a systemic belief that it is bad. And having given birth in a country where they have the opposite belief, I'm not sure I agree with that.

LoveIsAFairyTale · 15/06/2022 10:04

LemonSwan · 14/06/2022 23:38

After having a baby you drive less anyway for at least the first 3 months.

So am going to call it even stevens.

I'm with you in this!

Ncwinc · 15/06/2022 09:59

What’s the carbon footprint of a patient being put under general anaesthesia? Surely men having genitourinary surgery could have an epidural instead? Think of the savings.

FeedMeSantiago · 15/06/2022 09:53

Surely a drop in the ocean compared the environmental impact of adding a new human to the planet!

No-one would expect men to undergo a major painful event like childbirth without pain relief.

You get this with asthma inhalers too. I take the one my consultant recommends for my difficult to control asthma. I need it to live. There's always someone who wants to wring their hands over the environmental impact of them though.

prettytoes · 15/06/2022 09:33

My understanding is that the wastage of nitrous oxide by NHS causes far more environmental damage that the actual usage.
So they can fix that before recommending that women have additional procedures with higher risk to 'save the planet'

sustainablehealthcare.org.uk/what-we-do/sustainable-specialties/anaesthetics/nitrous-oxide-project

PutinIsAWarCriminal · 15/06/2022 09:32

I didn't read it as an attack on women in labour, more just comparing the environmental impacts of different substances, which is interesting. I think though if somemanone had told me to think of the environment whilst in labour, then I would refer him back to @thelastshadowpuppet's question about the carbon footprint of a broken nose.

ApplesandBunions · 15/06/2022 09:20

Snowflakes1122 · 15/06/2022 08:30

When we start doing operations on mens balls without pain relief, then I will take this seriously.

Women seem to be expected to put up with pain generally.

Yes, there's a cultural context here that's very troubling.

heldinadream · 15/06/2022 09:19

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 14/06/2022 23:51

850 miles you say? That's the equivalent of driving to visit to my mother. I didn't have any pain relief as DS was born in the street but I'm more than happy to not visit my mother to offset someone else's gas and air use.

I was going to try and say something serious, but on reflection offsetting is def the way forward.

So many twats we can all stop visiting AND be supporting labouring mothers. This needs to be a world-wide campaign!

MackenCheese · 15/06/2022 09:13

Yeah if women were really that bothered about the environment, they wouldn't be having a baby in the first place!!

ZealAndArdour · 15/06/2022 09:07

Fear not, science is already on the case so that medical use of entonox can continue with reduced harm to the planet; www.medclair.com/en/mdu

ofwarren · 15/06/2022 09:03

babyjellyfish · 15/06/2022 08:59

In France they don't use gas and air because they think it's a complete waste of time. They don't understand why anyone would bother with it when proper pain relief is available. Having had an excellent epidural in labour, and then some very underwhelming gas and air in A&E a few months later, I'm inclined to agree.

That would have meant I was allowed no pain relief at all in labour as my blood condition means I can't have epidural or any of the opiates.

babyjellyfish · 15/06/2022 08:59

In France they don't use gas and air because they think it's a complete waste of time. They don't understand why anyone would bother with it when proper pain relief is available. Having had an excellent epidural in labour, and then some very underwhelming gas and air in A&E a few months later, I'm inclined to agree.