Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think women should be free to choose whatever pain relief in labour suits them without having to consider the environment

90 replies

FannyCann · 14/06/2022 23:34

A colleague brought this article in to work today and it made me furious.

Apparently if women in labour would base their choice of analgesia in labour on the environment they should choose an epidural which has a far lower carbon footprint.
Using Entonox for four hours is the equivalent of driving 850 miles whilst an epidural is equivalent to just four.

It just reads like male doctors scolding women for wanting a simple safe form of pain relief when instead they could burn up manpower resources by demanding epidurals. They haven't considered where all the anaesthetists are meant to come from to provide epidurals for all!

Three female obstetric anaesthetists quite rightly responded in the letters that mothers shouldn't be guilt tripped about their choice of analgesia in labour.

Gas and air in labour ‘harms the planet’.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3d011450-e354-11ec-8bdd-c253e043f5f0?shareToken=3d20235d87acf65d1bda38d59ef587e11_

To think women should be free to choose whatever pain relief in labour suits them without having to consider the environment
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TeaWithFlorence · 15/06/2022 14:12

How many gas and air portions equates to a flight on a private jet?

Penguinsaregreat · 15/06/2022 13:47

2 words; fuck that.

NerdyBird · 15/06/2022 13:44

Well by the time I got to hospital I was at 10cm and ready to push. I could only have gas and air at that point, and jolly glad I was of it too. Choice doesn't always come into it!

OperationRinka · 15/06/2022 13:00

Thejoyfulstar · 15/06/2022 12:23

I dont understand this, though. Surely he had seen women labouring in all states of distress prior to his wife giving birth. It seems strange that his empathy and professionalism only went up a notch after seeing someone he loved in pain. Just think it's a bit odd that he only had some kind of epiphany at the birth if his own child.

By definition he won't have seen how long a half hour wait for the anaesthetist feels when you've only called because you've reached the limits of your endurance.

Tompariswasmyfavorite · 15/06/2022 12:46

Discovereads · 15/06/2022 12:21

Its only pregnant women who are expected to have to consider this.

Not really, my best friend just got her hip replaced and she chose a more expensive ceramic implant over a traditional polyethylene (plastic) implant for environmental reasons.

In fairness I did put a space between paragraphs here so it wasnt a block of text but that is taking my words out if the context of the sentence above.

My point was that gas and air is less environmentally impactful than other gases which are used in, for example from the article, operating theatres. But, according to the article, in operating theatres medical and scientific professionals will work together to come up with solutions. But pregnant women will be expected to choose their health care with the environment in mind, no one else in the context of anasthetic

I guess my point, which may not have been clearly made is:

Gas and air is easily available
Epidurals are not always due to lack of staff

No one else is getting told 'when you go into surgery you can have freely available pain relief with lower risks, but its bad for the environment, or you can have a different type with higher risks and theres no guarantee it will work properly or that you will even get it at all but its better for the environment '

Its more akin to being told 'you can choose a more environmentally friendly replacement joint but theres a possibility when you come round from surgery your hip wont have been replaced because we didnt have the specialist staff needed so you will be sent home in pain, but yay go environmentally friendly...'

Or when you go into the operating room you may or may not get given an anastheitc depending on whether we have someone trained in the more environmentally friendly version available, but you have to have the surgery or you can have a definitely available anasthetic but its less environmentally friendly, who would go for the first option...

ApplesandBunions · 15/06/2022 12:24

Thelnebriati · 15/06/2022 11:26

I don't think the original article was intended as an attack on women but I have seen it being used to shame women.

There is a solution, its possible to harvest gases from the air. I remember seeing an article in a back copy of New Scientist describing a manufactured gravel that would trap specific molecules. It could be used in an air conditioning system, the gas could then be harvested from the gravel.

I don't think it's intended as an attack, but there's a cultural context regarding women's pain, cross cultural really. And it's a man doing the framing and talking here. It's quite understandable that women react with suspicion. Neither the medical profession nor patriarchy in general have done anything to deserve the benefit of the doubt on this.

Thejoyfulstar · 15/06/2022 12:23

thelastshadowpuppet · 15/06/2022 00:09

@Mamai90 I got my epidural within 15 mins if asking.

When he was done I thanked him for coming so quickly. He told me his wife had had their first baby a couple of weeks before and it had opened his eyes and put a rocket up his arse 😂

I dont understand this, though. Surely he had seen women labouring in all states of distress prior to his wife giving birth. It seems strange that his empathy and professionalism only went up a notch after seeing someone he loved in pain. Just think it's a bit odd that he only had some kind of epiphany at the birth if his own child.

Discovereads · 15/06/2022 12:21

Its only pregnant women who are expected to have to consider this.

Not really, my best friend just got her hip replaced and she chose a more expensive ceramic implant over a traditional polyethylene (plastic) implant for environmental reasons.

Ylvamoon · 15/06/2022 12:17

Where do we stop?
Why do we always attack women? Maternity services are a tiny fraction of the bigger picture.

The whole healthcare sector is full of single use plastics, wrapped up in single use plastics...

iCouldSleepForAYear · 15/06/2022 12:09

OperationRinka · 15/06/2022 12:05

What I do find a bit sinister here is that moves to improve scavenging are all being sold in terms of the non-zero but tiny impact on climate change, and the very real impact of leaked nitrous oxide on midwives' health is being tucked away deep in the small print.

It's almost as if they don't want every midwife with fertility problems to sue the life out of them.

Wonder why The Times went with the CO2e emissions angle rather than that, then...

iCouldSleepForAYear · 15/06/2022 12:08

It's not about choices as though it's an a la carte menu that you're browsing at your leisure between contractions. It's about grabbing the intervention you need when you need it.

One baby would not have come out if I hadn't been able to grab a few hours rest. The other baby would not have come out if I hadn't been able to deeply breathe and keep calm during the entire event.

In both circumstances, neither girl would have come out without scalpel or forceps unless I'd been able to kneel upright and lean forward.

Can't do that very well with an epidural.

Also have two different friends whose epidurals took on just one side. So they still needed extra pain relief because the lower footprint one didn't work that well!

Curious to know who funded the Dutch analysis. It's well known that the emphasis on personal carbon footprint is promoted by the oil industry, so that it can pass the buck on its responsibilities.

Thelnebriati · 15/06/2022 12:06

Again, there are ways to mitigate the impact. Every company should have to treat/recycle/reuse its own waste and preferably on site; we should have implemented that decades ago but many industries were resistant and no Govt wanted to challenge them.

OperationRinka · 15/06/2022 12:05

What I do find a bit sinister here is that moves to improve scavenging are all being sold in terms of the non-zero but tiny impact on climate change, and the very real impact of leaked nitrous oxide on midwives' health is being tucked away deep in the small print.

It's almost as if they don't want every midwife with fertility problems to sue the life out of them.

Daftasabroom · 15/06/2022 11:59

Every sector, organisation, industry and community needs to plan how to get to net zero, the first step is to measure the carbon footprint of every product and process. Health care is going to be really tough to decarbonise and this is a start.

I'd also be really cautious of the interpretation by some of the media, particularly those with a strong political bias.

Tompariswasmyfavorite · 15/06/2022 11:58

I mean it would be more environmentally friendly not to replace peoples joints when they wear out, or replace peoples organs if they need transplants. Chemotherapy is terrible for the environment, as are waste products from mri scanners etc....

Its one thing to do the research to understand the impacts and come up with medical improvements. Its another to suggest women should should be told to choose their pain relief personally based on the environmental impact, as suggested by the times article.

Especially given, as per the article, the gas and air used in labour isnt as environmentally damging as anasthetic gases used in different medical situations succh as in operating theatres. But in those situations it is implied that medical professionals will come up with alternative solutions.

Its only pregnant women who are expected to have to consider this.

If an ex smoker doesnt need to care about the environmental impact of their chemotherapy for lung cancer then why the fuck should pregnant women be expected to directly make decisions based on it.

tootiredtoocare · 15/06/2022 11:58

Well, that would be great but they refused me an epidural, so... And, anyway, NO ONE should be trying to guilt women who are pushing a human from their vagina.

Mabelface · 15/06/2022 11:54

Entinox isn't just used for childbirth though. Typically targeting women's choices.

Discovereads · 15/06/2022 11:42

Tompariswasmyfavorite · 15/06/2022 11:05

Men being entirely uninvolved in the process?

Agree. It’s men and women deciding to have children.

And you can be very “bothered about the environment” and choose to have children.

Its only the eco-fascists that view humans as parasites and make spurious claims that by having children you are destroying the planet and don’t really care about the environment.

Moderate environmentalists recognise that humans are part of nature and the environment, that like every other life form we are worthy of continuing as a species, but as conscious beings it is our responsibility to live as lightly on the Earth as we can depending on our circumstances.

658Doyouknowwheremysparkis · 15/06/2022 11:41

And the carbon footprint of a vasectomy is?…. Drum roll..

i will only guilt trip ppl about pain relief in labour when all men have had vasectomies without pain relief… bet that will win some volunteers … not…

Veganmedic · 15/06/2022 11:40

'Sadly I think epidurals are more likely to be botched in countries like the UK where they do far fewer of them and maternity units don't have their own dedicated anaesthetists.'

All UK maternity wards have a dedicated obstetric anaesthetist (sometimes two although that's less common). It will be someone like me on call, middle grade registrar, and a consultant around in daylight hours. I do plenty of epidurals a shift so I'm not sure where people get the idea we don't do many! The problem comes when I am stuck in (obstetric) theatre with back to back emergencies and I can't find any of the other hospital anaesthetist to come and help if an epidural is waiting. It's not ideal but unfortunately as with most areas of NHS staff are leaving and rotas are not sufficient to meet the demands of the service.

In regards to the nitrous issue, no single woman should be taking the environmental impact of the use but a unit must do more to stop wastage of a resource that is harmful. I've entirely stopped using it as part of a general anaesthetic.

Hoppinggreen · 15/06/2022 11:35

I would personally have melted some ice caps and burnt down a shit load of trees if it had been necessary to get my epidural

ClinicallyProven · 15/06/2022 11:32

The nbest way to protect the environment is not to have the baby at all...

missdemeanors · 15/06/2022 11:29

Of course women should be able to have the pain relief they want.

I do think though, this thread highlights a point regarding expectations. It's interesting that in France, gas and air is considered a waste of time because it doesn't stop the pain. During my antenatal classes it was made very clear to us that g and a isn't a pain blocker; rather, it alters your perception so you sort of don't care about the pain as much. Epidurals were explained as a total pain blocker.

I had my first baby the same month as a close friend had hers. I had g and a and found it fantastic. Of course it still hurt like buggery but it really helped that I wasn't expecting total pain relief- I wanted something to take the edge off.

Conversely my friend had an epidural and was massively upset that it didn't 'take' all over so she had an area of pain on one side. She had expected total pain relief.

Thelnebriati · 15/06/2022 11:26

I don't think the original article was intended as an attack on women but I have seen it being used to shame women.

There is a solution, its possible to harvest gases from the air. I remember seeing an article in a back copy of New Scientist describing a manufactured gravel that would trap specific molecules. It could be used in an air conditioning system, the gas could then be harvested from the gravel.

ApplesandBunions · 15/06/2022 11:24

12BottlesOfVintageChampagne · 15/06/2022 11:20

I wonder whether you could offset the use of Entonox against all the other occasions that women are denied appropriate levels of pain relief?

Nah, easier to berate the bitches instead.

Swipe left for the next trending thread