Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘Telling off’ from a teacher?

111 replies

Thistledew · 14/06/2022 21:42

DS is in year 1.
Summer born so not yet 6yrs old. He is being investigated for potential ADHD.

He was the last one out of the classroom and then had to go back in because he had forgotten his water bottle. His teacher stopped him as he was finally coming out and told him that if he had been paying more attention and not messing around then he could have been out of the classroom much earlier.

Would you think the teacher was being unfair and could have approached the situation in a way to better help DS learn?

OP posts:
SpidersAreShitheads · 15/06/2022 02:56

Katya213 · 15/06/2022 00:56

I understand what you're saying but I went to school in the 80s, I really don't remember any children like this and if a child was naughty, they were disciplined and behaved. There's seems to be classes full of ADHD today, why is that? I haven't researched so it's a genuine question..

Sorry, just realised I didn't address part of your question.

You say when you were at school, naughty kids were just disciplined and then "behaved".

There are three types of ADHD - hyperactive, inattentive and combined. Inattentive ADHD is much harder to spot. It is just as disabling and again, see my previous comments re brain chemistry and the effect that stimulants have on us.

I wasn't diagnosed as school. I was a high achiever. Generally a "good girl". Really good grades. Behaved in class. You would never have known.

And yet. Horribly disorganised. Lost everything. Constantly late. Struggled remembering what I needed to have and when. Struggled to concentrate/focus. Struggled to know what to do in unstructured settings. Overwhelmed by anxiety. Just overwhelmed. So, so overwhelmed.

You. Wouldn't. Have. Known.

You would just have seen a quiet, pleasant girl who got on with her circle of friends, got her head down and seemed to do OK in school. You wouldn't have seen the constant turmoil that went on inside trying to navigate the most basic stuff that other kids seems to do without even thinking. You wouldn't have known how utterly USELESS I felt all of the time because basic life skills seemed so bloody impossible. I had to work so sodding hard just to get by, while constantly being criticised for messiness, being disorganised, arriving late to class, leaving homework until the very, very last minute (poor time management skills and inability to focus).

I developed really unhealthy coping mechanisms which have stayed with me for life, and have caused so many problems.

I'm a professional now and have a good career. If you met me and you knew nothing about ADHD other than the stereotype of loud, disruptive boys who misbehave, you'd never know. But privately, life is an uphill battle. I struggle so much in so many ways but only those who are very very close to me know.

But the thing is, there are lots of ADHDers just like me. You probably went to school with lots of us, and just never noticed how hard we found things. Like me, they probably weren't diagnosed but even if they were, you probably wouldn't have realised.

SpidersAreShitheads · 15/06/2022 02:42

Katya213 · 15/06/2022 00:56

I understand what you're saying but I went to school in the 80s, I really don't remember any children like this and if a child was naughty, they were disciplined and behaved. There's seems to be classes full of ADHD today, why is that? I haven't researched so it's a genuine question..

I went to school in the 80s as well. To answer your question, there are lots of possible reasons why there's "more" ADHD today:

  • Better understanding of the condition due to more research
  • Greater acceptance of neurodiversity
  • Greater awareness of neurodiversity
  • Less shame around neurodiversity - and more openness. In the 80s, would people have openly shared diagnoses? It wouldn't have happened where I went to school, not unless it was unavoidable.
  • When you were a child you probably wouldn't have noticed it because you were just growing up yourself!
  • Greater appetite to seek a diagnosis
  • Better understanding that there are multiple types of ADHD - being loud, disruptive and rude is the stereotype (which can be true of some) but there are other types of ADHD as well.
Also, just to correct your post - there absolutely are NOT "classes full of ADHD". There really really isn't. It's incredibly hard to get a diagnosis of either autism or ADHD and lots of younger children (7 yrs old or below) are frequently told that they'll be re-assessed again when they're older. A diagnosis is really not easy to get.

Just to say, I appreciate how I'm probably coming across here but I'm not trying to be pissy - honest 😊 It's just so unbelievably frustrating to hear the same incorrect information repeated so many times - and people believe it.

In the past there were lots of things that weren't acknowledged or treated as just plain naughtiness. I mean, we used to lock women up in sanatoriums and label them as hysterical..... Just because ADHD wasn't as well-known about before doesn't mean that it's not genuine.

To put all of this in context, if you give someone with ADHD a stimulant, their brain does not react in the same way. If you take a stimulant, you'll be buzzed off your tits and hyper. If I take the stimulant, I feel relaxed and drowsy. Our brains are chemically and neurologically different. ADHD isn't just some airy-fairy notion. And yet, snarky comments (not yours) keep continuing about "well, in my day we just dealt with naughty kids" or whispers of "bad parenting" and "discipline".

You have no idea what it's like to stand in our shoes and hear this constant shit from people who literally have no concept of what ADHD feels like, and how disabling it can be. And yet, we're constantly spoken over. Just look at this thread - you have people who actually have ADHD telling you what it's like - but there's a whole heap of people sneering at the idea and insisting that kids are just naughty and need to learn. Again, not aimed at you - I really appreciate you taking the time to ask an honest question.

SakuraSky · 15/06/2022 01:45

My first piece of advice is to critically consider any advice you are given from people without experience of ADHD.

The second piece of advice is to read this tweet.
mobile.twitter.com/The_Weed/status/1534592771792572418

Kids with adhd don't need the same reminders that neurotypical kids need. That's like chastising a deaf kid for not trying hard enough to listen.

SurfBox · 15/06/2022 01:38

I understand what you're saying but I went to school in the 80s, I really don't remember any children like this and if a child was naughty, they were disciplined and behaved.

Agreed.

HerRoyalNotness · 15/06/2022 01:13

I would wonder why she’d make the comment in the first place. So what if he’s last one out. I’d think “oh great you found your water bottle, have a nice evening/see you tomorrow”

my son has ADHD and I see when he makes mistakes associated with it how it effects him, he groans and goes into himself but I know he can’t help it so it’s not worth mentioning, but looking for something to praise to build self esteem instead

Trifecta · 15/06/2022 01:03

My son had/has ADD and I don’t feel the teacher’s done anything wrong.

Trifecta · 15/06/2022 01:01

This is OTT. Let the teacher do her job and stop being one of “those” parents?

Katya213 · 15/06/2022 00:56

SpidersAreShitheads · 15/06/2022 00:49

I'm autistic and have ADHD and I have two DC who are autistic/ADHD. All diagnosed formally, just for those who are cynical.

@MissHavershamReturns @ForestFae @SherbertLemonDrop @LillyDeValley I agree with everything you've said. Threads like this genuinely make me feel a bit sick.

Everyone queueing up on here to point out that ADHD kids can behave when they choose to, and that we shouldn't be making excuses for them because THEY SHOULD JUST PAY ATTENTION and then they'd be fine.

It shows a absolute failure to understand the brain chemistry and neurology of ADHD etc. If we could just remember and pay attention, then we bloody well would. Kids are done so much damage with the constant and casual reprimands about how shit they're being. Comments like this will come streaming in over the years and it fundamentally affects how you view yourself. You end up just feeling like a failure because you can't "just" do the things that come so easily to everyone else, no matter how much you bloody well try.

Kids who are neurodiverse can misbehave and of course they need pulling up. ADHD isn't a magic get out of jail free card. However, when the issue relates to the neurodiversity, then it's a different matter.

Would people say to someone in a wheelchair "well if you would only try a bit harder to walk you'd be OK"? Clearly not. That would be awful and cruel. Executive dysfunction is a very large part of ADHD and can be extremely disabling. Just blithely telling them to pay attention and remember things is no different than suggesting someone can "just" overcome a physical disability. Kids with ADHD need proper support mechanisms which are tailored specifically to them. A general reminder to the class at large isn't going to work.

I know there's this idea that children with ADHD are just naughty and it's poor parenting - I really thought we'd started to move past this but apparently not.

I understand what you're saying but I went to school in the 80s, I really don't remember any children like this and if a child was naughty, they were disciplined and behaved. There's seems to be classes full of ADHD today, why is that? I haven't researched so it's a genuine question..

SpidersAreShitheads · 15/06/2022 00:49

ForestFae · 14/06/2022 23:29

yep, I’m an adhder with 3 adhd kids and the comments and votes here bother me as well.

I'm autistic and have ADHD and I have two DC who are autistic/ADHD. All diagnosed formally, just for those who are cynical.

@MissHavershamReturns @ForestFae @SherbertLemonDrop @LillyDeValley I agree with everything you've said. Threads like this genuinely make me feel a bit sick.

Everyone queueing up on here to point out that ADHD kids can behave when they choose to, and that we shouldn't be making excuses for them because THEY SHOULD JUST PAY ATTENTION and then they'd be fine.

It shows a absolute failure to understand the brain chemistry and neurology of ADHD etc. If we could just remember and pay attention, then we bloody well would. Kids are done so much damage with the constant and casual reprimands about how shit they're being. Comments like this will come streaming in over the years and it fundamentally affects how you view yourself. You end up just feeling like a failure because you can't "just" do the things that come so easily to everyone else, no matter how much you bloody well try.

Kids who are neurodiverse can misbehave and of course they need pulling up. ADHD isn't a magic get out of jail free card. However, when the issue relates to the neurodiversity, then it's a different matter.

Would people say to someone in a wheelchair "well if you would only try a bit harder to walk you'd be OK"? Clearly not. That would be awful and cruel. Executive dysfunction is a very large part of ADHD and can be extremely disabling. Just blithely telling them to pay attention and remember things is no different than suggesting someone can "just" overcome a physical disability. Kids with ADHD need proper support mechanisms which are tailored specifically to them. A general reminder to the class at large isn't going to work.

I know there's this idea that children with ADHD are just naughty and it's poor parenting - I really thought we'd started to move past this but apparently not.

SurfBox · 15/06/2022 00:42

If I’d heard one of my teachers saying this, I wouldn’t tell them off but I would ask them to perhaps be mindful of what they say

that is a telling off.

Onceuponatimethen · 15/06/2022 00:25

@LooksLikeImStuckHere that kind of scaffolding is great. My dc does well using a checklist

Onceuponatimethen · 15/06/2022 00:24

The posts on here are hilarious. How about we leave a discussion of what is and isn’t down to Adhd to the experts? Neurologists, psychs and paeds. My child’s report says it’s vital he isn’t shamed for his adhd. Not complex. That includes disorganisation and distraction.

There is a reason for the higher suicidal ideation among NT children and young adults.

LooksLikeImStuckHere · 15/06/2022 00:23

I think it was a standard kind of remark that teachers make, intending to be helpful. But I don’t think that your MIL is unreasonable for thinking that it is unsupportive.

’If you had been paying attention…’ is the key phrase. It’s not that he won’t pay attention, it’s that he can’t whilst he is processing all the other things at the end of the day. Comments like this, whilst well intentioned, are extremely unhelpful for students with ADHD.

I say this as a SENCO. If I’d heard one of my teachers saying this, I wouldn’t tell them off but I would ask them to perhaps be mindful of what they say. I’d also ask them to provide something that would help your DS to remember what he needs to take at the end of the day - a visual reminder. This will help reduce the need to listen to verbal instructions and increase independence.

SurfBox · 15/06/2022 00:16

You can't blame everything on 'ADHD

schools and parents often do this to shield the worst offenders. I don't mean to sound harsh or offend anybody but I used to often have kids misbehave, slt would tell us ''he's getting tested for adhd, he's got x,y or z''

And yet I'd observe the kid in other lessons with a different cohort of kids or a firmer member of staff and they'd be fine. Kids generally know right from wrong regardless of homelife,adhd etc.

To keep teaching them otherwise is helping nobody in the long run-especially the child.

Shinyballs · 15/06/2022 00:15

I'm going against the grain here. Was he actually messing around or is he struggling with his executive function and memory? My daughter was always the last one out because it took her ages to pack her bag and remember all her stuff. She would likely have to go back to get a water bottle as well. If the teacher is presuming he was messing about, that is an unfair assumption, particularly for a child that may need help with organisation and memory.

If he was 'messing about' then yeah, this will slow him down even more.

SurfBox · 15/06/2022 00:09

She has 30 six year olds all day & so does have to be firm otherwise they would all be messing her around

you aren't allowed to be firm these days, it's build relationships etc. Ofcourse the people who tell you this are those who left the classroom themselves or never taught a day in their lives...

cansu · 15/06/2022 00:09

You are being very precious and utterly ridiculous. Unfortunately, when your ds is at school the teacher will be the one to tell him what he needs to do. Yes, he probably was faffing around and not doing what he should do. Yes, it is common and yes he will be told about it. How is this any different to a parent telling their kid to stop messing around and get their shoes and coat on? You are going to really struggle with school life.

SurfBox · 15/06/2022 00:05

I think that MiL lacks a sense of proportion and/or has a not too subtle campaign to try to get us to send DS to a private school that is nearer where she lives so that she has to be the one to pick him up each day

but if you think this then why even consider mil's view over a non issue?

Chances are your son will have a new teacher anyways after a month so really that makes it even less of an issue for you. Sorry op, I used to teach for years and seriously it was people like your mil was 1 of the big reasons I left in the end; simply because they wouldn't fuck off and allow me to do my job.

dustandroses · 14/06/2022 23:48

Oh I get it @Thistledew from your MIL point of view your DS did not mess about on purpose, he struggles to concentrate with ADHD and will probably often forget stuff. And in her view doesn’t need to be told he wasn’t listening and mucking around. Maybe your MIL thought the teacher was being unduly critical.

A child with ADHD does not constantly need to be berated and reminded how poor their concentration or organisation is, it does nothing for their confidence and self esteem.

However if you know the teacher and trust that she knows the difference between him actually mucking around and just being forgetful then I wouldn’t be concerned. ADHD doesn’t negate the need for discipline and boundaries.

ForestFae · 14/06/2022 23:36

Onceuponatimethen · 14/06/2022 23:33

@ForestFae your Family sounds quite like mine! I tell my dc often that it’sbrilliant just to be who we are

Me too. My DC all know we are ND and that being ND isnt bad it’s just different, but that people sometimes don’t understand us. DS1 had a horrible experience at mainstream school, I pulled him out but he still sometimes asks me “why didn’t they like me?” YEARS later. It was 3 years ago! Stuff like this, over and over again, really disproportionately targets ND people and it’s so unfair. NTs don’t see it and don’t get it.

Etinoxaurus · 14/06/2022 23:36

Yep. Mil has an agenda. Be very careful what she says around ds

Onceuponatimethen · 14/06/2022 23:33

@ForestFae your Family sounds quite like mine! I tell my dc often that it’sbrilliant just to be who we are

ForestFae · 14/06/2022 23:31

Onceuponatimethen · 14/06/2022 23:30

@ForestFae i really feel for children with ADHD where no adult has it. My dc have me to advocate for them.

Yes me too. Both me and DH have ADHD, (and I have dyspraxia too), my dad does also and my mum is autistic. I hope it’s enough to protect them from how hostile everyone else is to ND people.

Onceuponatimethen · 14/06/2022 23:30

@ForestFae I meant in families where no adult has it. Must be awful not to be understood and have your parents actually agreeing it’s your own fault.

springisaroundthecorner · 14/06/2022 23:30

My DS is 15 and has just left school. He has ADHD and they are constantly being reminded by teachers. Let the teachers do their job