Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How have the court of appeal allowed the Rwanda thing to go ahead?

214 replies

rwandanothanks · 14/06/2022 18:17

This seems extremely costly, very bad for the climate change challenge in terms of flights and staggeringly lacking in humanity.

How have the court of appeal allowed these flights to go ahead?

I guess if we rewind from the the real question is how and why on earth are our government pushing this awful idea?

OP posts:
Iwantmyoldnameback · 14/06/2022 19:31

Well it's almost impossible to apply legally to the UK so how are people to be checked? .

I would think it a great idea if we applied a little retrospection and sent some of the people who shunned closer safer countries to come here in the past, you know like Print Patels parents.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 14/06/2022 19:31

I hope the people being sent to Rwanda have fully completed their vaccinations as recommended by the Goverment for other travellers to the country ?

Has anyone found out how many vulnerable refugees from Rwanda we are taking in return ?

MrsSchrute · 14/06/2022 19:31

ImAvingOops · 14/06/2022 19:22

@HardbackWriter , the deterrent is that they won't get to stay in the UK, so no point in paying traffickers or risking their lives to get here.
We can't just keep on letting tens of thousands of people cross illegally into the country!

So let's make safer legal routes to claiming asylum! Not make it so that the ONLY way to claim asylum in the UK for most people is to enter illegally.

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 14/06/2022 19:28

The “young men of fighting age” trope again!

I know. It's like people are being deliberately obtuse. We see it in Ukraine, young men of fighting age either being rounded up and murdered or forceably conscripted and used as cannon fodder by the Russians. And yet people apparently can't understand why families put every penny they have into getting their sons out of conflict zones.

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/06/2022 19:28

@MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife Do you think children should stay in a country where they get beaten by the police? Did you read the rest of that Twitter thread I posted (TW rape)? Do you think their only alternative should be to go back (how?) to a country they’ve had to leave for their own safety?

PetraBP · 14/06/2022 19:28

Unbelievably cruel act of an already disgraceful government.

Priti Patel was on Question Time a few years ago saying how she wanted to bring back hanging.

It’s on YouTube for all to see and I’m surprised more people don’t know about it. She’s the Home Secretary. It wouldn’t surprise me if she tried to bring back the death penalty if they win then next election.

lollipoprainbow · 14/06/2022 19:27

Why shouldn't refugees go to countries where they already have relatives that are willing to house? Is it one rule for taking in refugees for the richest countries in the world and another for poor ones who already have to house millions of them?

The naivety !! You assume they are coming to stay with relatives ! Wake up, we have a massive housing crisis in this country, do you really think we can sustain this level of migration??

MrsSchrute · 14/06/2022 19:27

MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife · 14/06/2022 19:22

But still presumably safer than the country they have fled from. As PP has said, if we say France isn’t a safe country then where on earth is other than the UK?

Are you really saying we should just let them pick whichever country sounds nicest? Sounds a bit choosy for people supposedly fleeing for their lives.

Absolutely they should be allowed to seek asylum in a country of their choice, why shouldn't they?

If they come to the UK and their asylum claim is unsuccessful then they will be repatriated, but they should absolutely be able to request asylum wherever they choose.

noblegiraffe · 14/06/2022 19:25

Many of the complaints seem to be based on a real lack of understanding of Rwanda, with people thinking it’s a war zone or a desert. It’s safe, peaceful, has nice weather, and suitable infrastructure.

Is it? I thought these refugees were being sent to Rwanda as a deterrent, to stop boatloads of them trying to cross the Channel.

If Rwanda is actually marvellous, won't that be counterproductive and encourage more in Calais to come here to get that free plane to Rwanda?

Isn't the whole point of this grubby little exercise that Rwanda is not a good place to be sent to?

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/06/2022 19:25

LadyApplejack · 14/06/2022 19:17

@BewareTheLibrarians yes not familiar with below, would these measures be expected to reduce incoming UK numbers?

safe routes from countries where war and persecution are commonplace, resettlement schemes (one was set up for Afghanistan but only a thousand-ish visas were issued. Some interpreters for the British army are still left behind.)

They could be used to reduce numbers if that’s what the government wanted to do, yes.

They would also mean asylum seekers would be spread more evenly around the UK, to councils that weren’t overwhelmed. As they government doesn’t currently have any functioning resettlement schemes for the Middle East, this has increased the number of boat crossings, which means the burden falls on places like Kent to house people. That’s completely unsustainable for Kent and its residents.

It’s within the government’s control to reduce the strain on Kent, but they don’t seem willing.

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 14/06/2022 19:23

Why is it immoral? Genuine asylum seekers should seek asylum in the first safe country, which is not the UK.

Genuine asylum seekers are entitled under internaitional law to seek asylum in ANY safe country. 'First safe country' is an internal EU rule and nothing to do with the UK.

MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife · 14/06/2022 19:22

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/06/2022 19:14

France is safe for you, a holidaymaker and homeowner, with a passport.

France is not safe for asylum seekers, who may have nowhere to live, no money and face violence from the police.

But still presumably safer than the country they have fled from. As PP has said, if we say France isn’t a safe country then where on earth is other than the UK?

Are you really saying we should just let them pick whichever country sounds nicest? Sounds a bit choosy for people supposedly fleeing for their lives.

ImAvingOops · 14/06/2022 19:22

@HardbackWriter , the deterrent is that they won't get to stay in the UK, so no point in paying traffickers or risking their lives to get here.
We can't just keep on letting tens of thousands of people cross illegally into the country!

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 14/06/2022 19:21

lollipoprainbow · 14/06/2022 19:01

@BringBackCoffeeCreams they might be happy to be sent to safety and comfort has anyone actually asked them what they want rather than people speaking for them??

Oh behave!

isadoradancing123 · 14/06/2022 19:20

France is a safe country so why not stay there. The emotion needs to be removed, we cannot sustain an influx of mainly young males at this rate of numbers. Rwanda government seems to be offering them a good deal in resettlement options

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/06/2022 19:20

@Georgeskitchen The “young men of fighting age” trope again!

  1. women and children do come. Will the media show you? No. Why? Take a guess.

  2. fewer women and children and elderly men come than young men. Why? The journey from Syria/Iran/Afghanistan/Eritrea is incredibly physically tough. There are also risks along the way of trafficking and sexual abuse, rape and torture. It’s not safe for women or children, who usually stay in refugee camps closer to their home country.

Why don’t the men stay there to? Some do, but it is incredibly hard to find work, meaning you can’t feed your family or have a chance of leaving the camp on the future. For any chance of a future, young men have to make the journey to a country where they can work so they can send money to their family or bring them to safety.

woodhill · 14/06/2022 19:19

maddiemookins16mum · 14/06/2022 19:17

Sending them to Rwanda does make me uneasy, it just feels wrong and I say that as a Kent coast resident and we see first hand the huge pressure that 10K arrivals have on our area (finance wise).

What are we going to do though to stop this continuing?

TrippinEdBalls · 14/06/2022 19:19

Kpo58 · 14/06/2022 19:11

So by your rationale does that mean that only countries that boarder the Mediterranean or parts of Eastern Europe should take in refugees as that's where most migrants would have to have crossed?

Why shouldn't refugees go to countries where they already have relatives that are willing to house? Is it one rule for taking in refugees for the richest countries in the world and another for poor ones who already have to house millions of them?

That's exactly what these people think - or they just don't care, as long as it means the UK has no asylum seekers. It would be a ridiculously unfair system that the only determinant of whether you have a moral duty to help the world's most vulnerable would be geography, and absolutely none of them would support it if it didn't leave the UK taking none. They'd be equally in favour of refugees having to go to the first country alphabetically, which is about as just a system

LadyApplejack · 14/06/2022 19:17

@BewareTheLibrarians yes not familiar with below, would these measures be expected to reduce incoming UK numbers?

safe routes from countries where war and persecution are commonplace, resettlement schemes (one was set up for Afghanistan but only a thousand-ish visas were issued. Some interpreters for the British army are still left behind.)

maddiemookins16mum · 14/06/2022 19:17

Sending them to Rwanda does make me uneasy, it just feels wrong and I say that as a Kent coast resident and we see first hand the huge pressure that 10K arrivals have on our area (finance wise).

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/06/2022 19:14

NotKevinTurvey · 14/06/2022 19:07

Yes, France is a safe country. I have a home there, spend a lot of time there, and it is no more dangerous than the UK.

If you are listing France as dangerous then everywhere is, the UK included.

France is safe for you, a holidaymaker and homeowner, with a passport.

France is not safe for asylum seekers, who may have nowhere to live, no money and face violence from the police.

Jott · 14/06/2022 19:12

NotKevinTurvey · 14/06/2022 19:07

Yes, France is a safe country. I have a home there, spend a lot of time there, and it is no more dangerous than the UK.

If you are listing France as dangerous then everywhere is, the UK included.

You have a house there which would indicate you're not a refugee claiming asylum in France therefore have no direct experience of what its like to be a regime claiming asylum in France...

Kpo58 · 14/06/2022 19:11

Georgeskitchen · 14/06/2022 19:03

Why is it immoral? Genuine asylum seekers should seek asylum in the first safe country, which is not the UK. Most of the ones who cross the channel are young men of fighting age.
The majority of the people who think this is immoral are those who are less likely to be affected by an influx of illegal immigrants .
And people wonder why schools, GPs and hospitals and social housing are in a mess.
We just can't afford to let in anyone who wishes to live here.( excluding those genuinely fleeing war)

So by your rationale does that mean that only countries that boarder the Mediterranean or parts of Eastern Europe should take in refugees as that's where most migrants would have to have crossed?

Why shouldn't refugees go to countries where they already have relatives that are willing to house? Is it one rule for taking in refugees for the richest countries in the world and another for poor ones who already have to house millions of them?

Jott · 14/06/2022 19:10

You can't claim asylum in the UK until you're actually in the UK. Allowed people to begin the asylum process before entering the UK would reduce the number arriving by illegal crossing.

DuncinToffee · 14/06/2022 19:10

Some numbers from the Home Office

Important new data from the Home Office shows

-The biggest group of people crossing the Channel in the early part of 2022 were Afghans: one in four of all crossings.
-Over 90% of Afghans last year were given asylum.
-75% of asylum seekers were given asylum, highest since 1990.

UK gave asylum to 98% of Syrians, 97% of Eritreans, 95% of Sudanese, 91% of Afghans and 88% of Iranians. 76% of claims from young men aged 18-29 were granted.

All of these figures cast further debt on the Home Sec's assertion that 70% of channel crossings are economic migrants.

twitter.com/lewis_goodall/status/1529876967742373895?t=M4MJGcyhYzfS74MaLHi7Vw&s=19

Swipe left for the next trending thread