Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How have the court of appeal allowed the Rwanda thing to go ahead?

214 replies

rwandanothanks · 14/06/2022 18:17

This seems extremely costly, very bad for the climate change challenge in terms of flights and staggeringly lacking in humanity.

How have the court of appeal allowed these flights to go ahead?

I guess if we rewind from the the real question is how and why on earth are our government pushing this awful idea?

OP posts:
Alexandra2001 · 14/06/2022 19:56

PansyPetunia · 14/06/2022 18:33

what would be your solution then

If we were still in the EU, we could send back failed Asylum seekers, its funny how we didn't have this problem of cross channel sailings pre Brexit.

@Allthegoodnamesarechosen You ve not a shred of evidence they are mostly illiterate and as asylum seekers cannot work or apply to work, we don't know what skills they have or not.
I believe around 90% are given asylum and we are way down the list of countries for accepting refugees

Funny how we don't get angry about 1000s of HK Chinese coming here each week, they aren't fleeing anything at all.

Romeoalpha · 14/06/2022 19:56

The awful thing about it is that it is culturally and geographically so far from where I imagine most call home and from help or family of any kind (assuming most migrants are from eastern Europe / Middle East). It’s in Sub-saharan Africa and they are effectively stranded there. It’s like when we used to send people to Australia. It is cruel.

NotKevinTurvey · 14/06/2022 19:56

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/06/2022 19:53

@NotKevinTurvey French people in France aren’t asylum seekers. French people in France are (on the whole, one would hope) treated differently to asylum seekers in France. This shouldn’t be a complicated point.

So, let’s have some reality:

https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/28777/france-police-violence-against-migrants-has-become-the-norm

”Police violence against migrants has "become a norm in terms of making each of these evacuation operations primarily a PR operation," says Professor François Gémenne, a researcher on migration at the University of Liège“

https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2019/06/france-police-harassing-intimidating-and-even-using-violence-against-people-helping-refugees/

Two-and-a-half years after the destruction of the so-called ‘Jungle’ camp, more than 1,200 refugees and migrants, including unaccompanied children, are living in tents and informal camps around Calais and Grande-Synthe. They have no regular access to food, water, sanitation, shelter or legal assistance and are subject to evictions, harassment, and violence at the hands of the police.

https://www.coe.int/en/web/commissioner/-/european-states-must-stand-up-against-pushbacks-and-the-attempt-to-legalise-them

Human rights violations against refugees, asylum seekers and migrants at the borders of Council of Europe member states have proliferated at an alarming rate, especially the denial of access to asylum and returns without individual safeguards, frequently accompanied by brutal violence or even the endangerment of human life. Such practices at borders (often referred to as ‘pushbacks’) undermine legal guarantees clearly established in the Refugee Convention and European Convention on Human Rights.

These cases tend to be against people who are refusing to apply for asylum in France, and who are trying to illegally enter the UK. They would have no problem with police if they followed the correct procedures and applied for asylum there.

You seem to have more sympathy for the criminals here than the poor people having to live amongst the squalor and crime that they bring.

PlanetNormal · 14/06/2022 19:54

The government are absolutely correct to be deporting these people, and action is long overdue.
If we are going to maintain public consent for legal immigration of the highly skilled workers Britain needs, we have to get serious about stopping uncontrolled mass illegal immigration. If the ECHR stands in the way, its jurisdiction must be removed.

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/06/2022 19:53

@NotKevinTurvey French people in France aren’t asylum seekers. French people in France are (on the whole, one would hope) treated differently to asylum seekers in France. This shouldn’t be a complicated point.

So, let’s have some reality:

https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/28777/france-police-violence-against-migrants-has-become-the-norm

”Police violence against migrants has "become a norm in terms of making each of these evacuation operations primarily a PR operation," says Professor François Gémenne, a researcher on migration at the University of Liège“

https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2019/06/france-police-harassing-intimidating-and-even-using-violence-against-people-helping-refugees/

Two-and-a-half years after the destruction of the so-called ‘Jungle’ camp, more than 1,200 refugees and migrants, including unaccompanied children, are living in tents and informal camps around Calais and Grande-Synthe. They have no regular access to food, water, sanitation, shelter or legal assistance and are subject to evictions, harassment, and violence at the hands of the police.

https://www.coe.int/en/web/commissioner/-/european-states-must-stand-up-against-pushbacks-and-the-attempt-to-legalise-them

Human rights violations against refugees, asylum seekers and migrants at the borders of Council of Europe member states have proliferated at an alarming rate, especially the denial of access to asylum and returns without individual safeguards, frequently accompanied by brutal violence or even the endangerment of human life. Such practices at borders (often referred to as ‘pushbacks’) undermine legal guarantees clearly established in the Refugee Convention and European Convention on Human Rights.

lollipoprainbow · 14/06/2022 19:51

@BewareTheLibrarians sorry your constant drip feeding is not going to change my mind! My daughter has sen so I'm well aware of the lack of funding. Maybe if less money was spent helping migrants she would get a bit more help.

MrsSchrute · 14/06/2022 19:50

MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife · 14/06/2022 19:46

So you believe in the whole ‘open borders’ thing then presumably? How exactly do you see that working when climate change and global instability creates millions more genuine asylum seekers (by current definitions)? Because that’s what’s coming.

I believe that people should be able to seek refugee in a country of their choosing. That is different to saying that anyone can move to the UK and be allowed to stay. I think that anyone who wishes to seek asylum here should be allowed to, and if they are found not to qualify, they should be repatriated.
As far as how we ensure that less people are seeking asylum to begin with, I think the developed world owes it to third world countries to provide whatever support we can to mitigate the impact of climate change etc. After all, we (the western world) are the ones who disproportionately caused this instability.

Namechanger355 · 14/06/2022 19:48

hamdden12 · 14/06/2022 19:37

If they are seeking asylum and fleeing from war torn countries surely anywhere has to be better than what they fled from and left behind? There also has to be some sort of deterrent to stop the trafficking that is going on, if it's not so appealing to get your pick of where you want to go hopefully people will stop trying to cross the channel.

“Anywhere has to be better than where you came from”

so leaving a place with beheadings for a place with torture but no beheadings - yeah that will do it

alright. Just remember that if you ever need asylum or help from others

MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife · 14/06/2022 19:46

MrsSchrute · 14/06/2022 19:27

Absolutely they should be allowed to seek asylum in a country of their choice, why shouldn't they?

If they come to the UK and their asylum claim is unsuccessful then they will be repatriated, but they should absolutely be able to request asylum wherever they choose.

So you believe in the whole ‘open borders’ thing then presumably? How exactly do you see that working when climate change and global instability creates millions more genuine asylum seekers (by current definitions)? Because that’s what’s coming.

MrsSchrute · 14/06/2022 19:46

hamdden12 · 14/06/2022 19:37

If they are seeking asylum and fleeing from war torn countries surely anywhere has to be better than what they fled from and left behind? There also has to be some sort of deterrent to stop the trafficking that is going on, if it's not so appealing to get your pick of where you want to go hopefully people will stop trying to cross the channel.

Why shouldn't they be able to chose where they claim asylum? Better than a war zone is a pretty low bar!

KettrickenSmiled · 14/06/2022 19:45

Flaunch · 14/06/2022 18:36

We don’t have enough housing, hospital, schools, doctors or dentists for the people that are already here. What do you suggest we do with them?

Have them build houses, hospitals, & schools, while their DC train up as doctors & dentists?

pigsDOfly · 14/06/2022 19:44

ImAvingOops · 14/06/2022 18:27

I can't see what's wrong with it myself. We need to stop people from risking their lives crossing the channel, stop the exploitation from the traffickers, and stem illegal economic migration. Not everyone coming here in a boat is a refugee!
Sky news showed the accommodation in Rwanda, it was clean with decent facilities, computer suites, shops etc. People are free to come and go as they wish - it's hardly a prison.

Sky news showed the accommodation in Rwanda, it was clean with decent facilities, computer suites, shops etc. People are free to come and go as they wish - it's hardly a prison.

Yes, I'm sure it is.

It's a well known fact that countries with the sort of human rights record that Rwanda treat asylum seekers with unbounded respect and humanity while at the same time murdering and torturing their own population.

Are you really that naïve?

Jott · 14/06/2022 19:43

"Come on son, I know your house got destroyed and your relatives killed so you fled to the UK to escape human rights abuses but instead of offering you and we're going tongove you a one way ticket to .... <checks notes> .... a country with a long standing record of human rights abuses. Enjoy!"

Namechanger355 · 14/06/2022 19:43

DuncinToffee · 14/06/2022 19:04

And how are you sure they are not?

@lollipoprainbow I’m guessing you don’t know many asylum seekers or refugees

my family work in immigration and many asylum seekers are incredibly educated and literate

NotKevinTurvey · 14/06/2022 19:42

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/06/2022 19:33

@lollipoprainbow One of the asylum seekers getting sent to Rwanda tonight is a 19 year old who has a sister settled in the UK (confirmed by his lawyers). Rather than house him with his sister, they are sending him to Rwanda.

This is what you’re cheering on. But as long as you’re ok! And when they’re done with the asylum seekers and come for the disabled people, slash benefits for carers, slash SEN budgets for children with autism,
you’ll wish that someone had stood up against this shit.

You are coming across as unhinged there. They will “come for the disabled” if you and your dippy friends don’t stop this program?

It’s weird how you seem able to view the UK as some sort of human rights black hole yet want to have your chosen people come to live here.

Namechanger355 · 14/06/2022 19:42

DeedlessIndeed · 14/06/2022 18:42

@Allthegoodnamesarechosen I completely disagree that the majority of people are illiterate? Where on earth did you get that fact from - I'd love to see a source?

I work with asylum seekers and the vast majority are literate and most pick up Entry level 3 English within 18 months (i.e. well before they receive a decision from the Home Office and can legally work).

Many asylum seekers are already bi-lingual and well educated.

Whilst I agree there is an across the board lack of services for everyone, I don't think it's wise to make out that they will be an ill-educated drain on society once granted LTR.

Absolutely agree - we are often talking about Syrian doctors or engineers for example

people with families, houses, careers and lives who had to give it up due to war

and many are a damn sight more educated and literate than folk here

what an ignorant statement by that pp

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/06/2022 19:40

“Come on son, I know your house got destroyed and your relatives killed, but here you’re only homeless! And you only get beaten by the police a few times month! Can’t keep whinging all your life!”

DuncinToffee · 14/06/2022 19:39

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/06/2022 19:36

@DuncinToffee Wait, 19 yr old asylum seekers don’t control our housing market? They’re not the ones giving the directors of housing companies multi million pound bonuses? Maybe the Iranian policeman who was tortured for refusing to shoot unarmed protesters is the one who’s really forcing the government to not make rental properties for for human habitation? God Lord my mind is blown!! 😉

Yes sorry, silly me, I got confused with Russian oligarchs...

NotKevinTurvey · 14/06/2022 19:38

Jott · 14/06/2022 19:12

You have a house there which would indicate you're not a refugee claiming asylum in France therefore have no direct experience of what its like to be a regime claiming asylum in France...

No, but I know that France is a safe country in terms of international agreements on refugees. It’s why we don’t accept refugee applications from French people fleeing France.

You aren’t going to be taken seriously if you are claiming that France is not a safe country; it just suggests that your objections are not reality-based.

hamdden12 · 14/06/2022 19:37

If they are seeking asylum and fleeing from war torn countries surely anywhere has to be better than what they fled from and left behind? There also has to be some sort of deterrent to stop the trafficking that is going on, if it's not so appealing to get your pick of where you want to go hopefully people will stop trying to cross the channel.

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/06/2022 19:36

@DuncinToffee Wait, 19 yr old asylum seekers don’t control our housing market? They’re not the ones giving the directors of housing companies multi million pound bonuses? Maybe the Iranian policeman who was tortured for refusing to shoot unarmed protesters is the one who’s really forcing the government to not make rental properties for for human habitation? God Lord my mind is blown!! 😉

MrsSchrute · 14/06/2022 19:35

LadyApplejack · 14/06/2022 19:32

Bewarethelibrarians it doesn't sound like those schemes actually reduce the numbers. Wouldn't we just be creating additional routes which bring in the same people (but more of them would be "legal") while others still cross on boats?

As to Kent, I agree these areas bear a disproportionate burden short-term but spreading a big volume of migrants around the UK every year doesn't address the longterm infrastructure issues people are raising.

But they would reduce the power of the people traffickers. So those who are found to have a claim for asylum can begin to build a life here and those who aren't successful can be sent back home. Every single refugee that I have met actively wants to work, support themselves and contribute to society. Can only be good for the UK.

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/06/2022 19:33

@lollipoprainbow One of the asylum seekers getting sent to Rwanda tonight is a 19 year old who has a sister settled in the UK (confirmed by his lawyers). Rather than house him with his sister, they are sending him to Rwanda.

This is what you’re cheering on. But as long as you’re ok! And when they’re done with the asylum seekers and come for the disabled people, slash benefits for carers, slash SEN budgets for children with autism,
you’ll wish that someone had stood up against this shit.

DuncinToffee · 14/06/2022 19:32

lollipoprainbow · 14/06/2022 19:27

Why shouldn't refugees go to countries where they already have relatives that are willing to house? Is it one rule for taking in refugees for the richest countries in the world and another for poor ones who already have to house millions of them?

The naivety !! You assume they are coming to stay with relatives ! Wake up, we have a massive housing crisis in this country, do you really think we can sustain this level of migration??

12 year of a Conservative government but blame refugees

LadyApplejack · 14/06/2022 19:32

Bewarethelibrarians it doesn't sound like those schemes actually reduce the numbers. Wouldn't we just be creating additional routes which bring in the same people (but more of them would be "legal") while others still cross on boats?

As to Kent, I agree these areas bear a disproportionate burden short-term but spreading a big volume of migrants around the UK every year doesn't address the longterm infrastructure issues people are raising.

Swipe left for the next trending thread