Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How have the court of appeal allowed the Rwanda thing to go ahead?

214 replies

rwandanothanks · 14/06/2022 18:17

This seems extremely costly, very bad for the climate change challenge in terms of flights and staggeringly lacking in humanity.

How have the court of appeal allowed these flights to go ahead?

I guess if we rewind from the the real question is how and why on earth are our government pushing this awful idea?

OP posts:
Thebestwaytoscareatory · 14/06/2022 20:42

MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife · 14/06/2022 19:46

So you believe in the whole ‘open borders’ thing then presumably? How exactly do you see that working when climate change and global instability creates millions more genuine asylum seekers (by current definitions)? Because that’s what’s coming.

That's a very good and interesting point actually. There was a report out last year warning about water scarcity in England with Northampton, Peterborough, Bedford, Cambridge, Ely, London, Brighton, Birmingham, and Leicester all now at high risk of water scarcity within the next decade or two. Presumably you'll be expecting everyone who lives in those areas to just stay put and deal with the effects of drought if/when that is realised? I also assume you'll not be expecting any other country to provide us with food and/or other resources when those fall into short supply too?

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/06/2022 20:42

@caringcarer If the government did everything correctly, why were so many removed from the flight yesterday after being assessed as not suitable for removal to Rwanda?

MrsSchrute · 14/06/2022 20:41

caringcarer · 14/06/2022 20:40

The courts work on facts not emotions. Government did everything legally correct so wins case. Most immigrants who apply properly are admitted. They don't need to ride on inflatable dingies to be welcomed. Economic migrants ride on inflatable dingies and risk their own lives and their children's. We have to stop the people traffickers.

How do you apply properly for asylum from outside of the UK?

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/06/2022 20:40

@LetitiaLeghorn i think you’ve misunderstood my phrasing (which is my fault, I’m very tired!) A large proportion of asylum seekers are “doctors, lawyers, professors” or “literate and skilled workers”. Not exclusively doctors, lawyers, professors, and remembering that skilled workers can be chefs, mechanics etc. I’m not trying to say that all asylum seekers are rich and successful. I was countering the narrative that all asylum seekers are illiterate and therefore can’t work.

caringcarer · 14/06/2022 20:40

The courts work on facts not emotions. Government did everything legally correct so wins case. Most immigrants who apply properly are admitted. They don't need to ride on inflatable dingies to be welcomed. Economic migrants ride on inflatable dingies and risk their own lives and their children's. We have to stop the people traffickers.

MissyB1 · 14/06/2022 20:31

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 14/06/2022 20:00

It's all part of the revival of making Britain great again. Restoring the glories of the past. We've already brought back malnutrition and slums, life expectancy is rolling back quite nicely, and now we move on to brown people in chains being taken by force to another continent. Rule Britannia!

Yep this 👆in a nutshell. And sad to see how many posters on here love it all. That’s why we have such an appalling prime minister with zero morals, because so many people actually admire that.

RaspberryParfait · 14/06/2022 20:30

@SummerSummerSummertime what hyperbole!

I certainly wouldn’t be risking my children’s life crossing a dangerous stretch of water in a flimsy boat as I was picky about where I wanted to live and didn’t fancy multiple safe European countries.

pushingpoppies · 14/06/2022 20:28

The Rwanda scheme is a deterrent. It's not a strategy intended to be used for the tens of thousands of refugees or economic migrants landing every year. People fleeing from persecution can claim asylum in any safe country that they enter, including France, but much to the delight of people smugglers this country is sold as a golden ticket. Clearly, it's not, given how many people are really struggling, not just a bit but genuinely one universal credit payment away from homelessness or choosing between heating and eating. It will not become a successful deterrent against people smuggling and people dying in the Chanel, so the sooner a flight can leave, the better.

SummerSummerSummertime · 14/06/2022 20:21

Priti Patel is just pure evil.

How have the court of appeal allowed the Rwanda thing to go ahead?
MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife · 14/06/2022 20:16

MrsSchrute · 14/06/2022 19:50

I believe that people should be able to seek refugee in a country of their choosing. That is different to saying that anyone can move to the UK and be allowed to stay. I think that anyone who wishes to seek asylum here should be allowed to, and if they are found not to qualify, they should be repatriated.
As far as how we ensure that less people are seeking asylum to begin with, I think the developed world owes it to third world countries to provide whatever support we can to mitigate the impact of climate change etc. After all, we (the western world) are the ones who disproportionately caused this instability.

We may (or may not) owe the rest of the world something, but be realistic it’s not going to happen is it. That would require some kind of massive personality transplant for our political and ruling class, or a revolution, and neither is going to happen anytime soon. Massively increasing migration is on the way. We won’t be able to accommodate them all, genuine asylum seeker or not.

LetitiaLeghorn · 14/06/2022 20:16

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/06/2022 18:58

@WallaceinAnderland you’ve clearly never heard of a moderate middle ground. Millions is ridiculous hyperbole and I can’t take it seriously.

Young working age people work. With an aging population that’s actually essential. When asylum seekers claims are successful, they start working, paying taxes into the UK system. And asylum seekers aren’t all illiterate villagers, a large proportion are doctors, lawyers, professors, skilled workers and literate. The government is not going to be giving out free housing and bags of free money. They barely do that for British people.

I'm wondering where you used to teach? I taught ESOL for many years and I agree that I saw very few illiterate asylum seekers in their own language. And most could manage some English from TV. But I only ever taught one doctor. She was from Iran and she wouldn't be able to practise medicine in this country without doing more quals. Her English was about E3/L1 but at her age she was never going to be able to achieve a 7 in IELTS to enable her to study and practise. I never saw all these professionals, I never met ex asylum seekers at the hospitals where we taught or in my IELTS classes.

I did see mainly young men, educated to their country's secondary standard, occasionally degree level, and the vast majority were economic migrants. I'm not against them coming here. Most are highly motivated to get a better life. (And some are users and the dregs. But that just reflects people in every culture. 🤷) But I just never saw or met this large proportion of professionals in the asylum seeker population.

SummerSummerSummertime · 14/06/2022 20:15

lollipoprainbow · 14/06/2022 20:12

@SummerSummerSummertime if me or my child were fleeing a war torn country I'd be more than happy with what Rwanda is offering.

Such bollocks.

Sw33tP0tat0 · 14/06/2022 20:14

It’s just awful. I’m ashamed to be British.

I also don’t understand why war in Ukraine is deemed to warrant empathy and the offer of support but not war in other countries.

CheesusWept · 14/06/2022 20:14

Amazing to see how many thick fuckers on Mumsnet believe what the Daily Fail spoon feeds them.

lollipoprainbow · 14/06/2022 20:12

@SummerSummerSummertime if me or my child were fleeing a war torn country I'd be more than happy with what Rwanda is offering.

SummerSummerSummertime · 14/06/2022 20:09

Shame on all of you people saying "they don't belong here" - how would you feel if you were living in fear of yours & your kids' lives, to the extent that you had to flee your very own home. Shame on you all!

SummerSummerSummertime · 14/06/2022 20:06

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 14/06/2022 18:28

10, 000 people so far this year. None presumably on the list of desired occupations, or they could just apply and be welcome.

Every other thread on here is about the housing crisis, the NHS crisis, the GP shortfall. Where do you think the uninvited 10000 are going to live? Whose taxes are going to feed and clothe them? Who is going to teach them English? How are they going to work when the overwhelming majority are illiterate even in their own languages?

We have got to do something to reduce the pressure on this tiny, already overpopulated island. Discouraging the people traffickers and their dreadful trade is a start.

608,029 people died in the UK in 2020.

10,00 is REALLY not very many people.

Alexandra2001 · 14/06/2022 20:04

PlanetNormal · 14/06/2022 19:54

The government are absolutely correct to be deporting these people, and action is long overdue.
If we are going to maintain public consent for legal immigration of the highly skilled workers Britain needs, we have to get serious about stopping uncontrolled mass illegal immigration. If the ECHR stands in the way, its jurisdiction must be removed.

So the Iranian police commander who refused to shoot protesters and fears for his life in Rwanda should be sent there regardless? (Due to his status, he believes Iran will seek him out)

Or the Afghan interpreter who was due to be deported?

Once this story dies down, Patel will send anyone she can get her hands on, regardless of their story or what happens to them when they get there, it will just pass as "normal" and we will no longer care (not that you ever did)

The UK has almost no legal channels for people to come here from Syria Afghanistan etc.

MrsSchrute · 14/06/2022 20:02

LadyApplejack · 14/06/2022 19:57

So those who are found to have a claim for asylum can begin to build a life here and those who aren't successful can be sent back home. Every single refugee that I have met actively wants to work, support themselves and contribute to society. Can only be good for the UK.

I don't doubt that incomers want to contribute, and in an ideal world that's what they'd all do and what right-minded person would say no? But there will always be people wanting to come, and we have to control annual numbers pretty carefully or everyone suffers from lack of infrastructure, worsening over time.

You say "unsuccessful" applicants will be returned home. We're an island and can't even stop them getting in, how do we police things once people are already here? What would the criteria be then, and do we know there won't be activists trying to stop those planes?

It seems to me we have established routes/criteria already, and they probably exist to suit the numbers we can accept, and the control we need. People falling outside those routes are now crossing illegally, and the solution seems to be "make it legal for everyone then".

This does nothing to reduce the numbers vs infrastructure issue.

As far as I know, other than the Ukraine route, there is no way to claim asylum from outside of the UK, so it's cross illegally or nothing.
And you're right, we do need to keep better track of people once they're here and make sure people who's claim is refused are sent back, so let's spend the money on that, instead of sending people to Rwanda.

NotKevinTurvey · 14/06/2022 20:01

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/06/2022 20:00

@NotKevinTurvey Governments don’t last forever 😉

Personally I don’t find it that unhinged that governments don’t tend to stop at one (or two, or three) fascist policies, but of course your mileage may vary.

Throwing terms like fascist around just suggests you don’t know much of history.

This government is not in any respect fascist.

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 14/06/2022 20:00

It's all part of the revival of making Britain great again. Restoring the glories of the past. We've already brought back malnutrition and slums, life expectancy is rolling back quite nicely, and now we move on to brown people in chains being taken by force to another continent. Rule Britannia!

MarshaBradyo · 14/06/2022 20:00

How exactly do you see that working when climate change and global instability creates millions more genuine asylum seekers (by current definitions)? Because that’s what’s coming.

I think this will place new and extra pressures changing what we are used to, we’ve had relative stability but border control may well change as times change

BewareTheLibrarians · 14/06/2022 20:00

@NotKevinTurvey Governments don’t last forever 😉

Personally I don’t find it that unhinged that governments don’t tend to stop at one (or two, or three) fascist policies, but of course your mileage may vary.

Namechanger355 · 14/06/2022 19:58

lollipoprainbow · 14/06/2022 19:51

@BewareTheLibrarians sorry your constant drip feeding is not going to change my mind! My daughter has sen so I'm well aware of the lack of funding. Maybe if less money was spent helping migrants she would get a bit more help.

No avoiding the pittance refugees get is not will not help sen support

you should rather blame our corporation tax system, and the absolute corruption of our government

LadyApplejack · 14/06/2022 19:57

So those who are found to have a claim for asylum can begin to build a life here and those who aren't successful can be sent back home. Every single refugee that I have met actively wants to work, support themselves and contribute to society. Can only be good for the UK.

I don't doubt that incomers want to contribute, and in an ideal world that's what they'd all do and what right-minded person would say no? But there will always be people wanting to come, and we have to control annual numbers pretty carefully or everyone suffers from lack of infrastructure, worsening over time.

You say "unsuccessful" applicants will be returned home. We're an island and can't even stop them getting in, how do we police things once people are already here? What would the criteria be then, and do we know there won't be activists trying to stop those planes?

It seems to me we have established routes/criteria already, and they probably exist to suit the numbers we can accept, and the control we need. People falling outside those routes are now crossing illegally, and the solution seems to be "make it legal for everyone then".

This does nothing to reduce the numbers vs infrastructure issue.

Swipe left for the next trending thread