Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Not Give in to Neighbor's Request for Fence Change?

190 replies

Delphinium20 · 14/06/2022 15:40

Need some advice, and apologies for long post, but details needed.

We bought our house a few years ago and have been making garden improvements including walkway, new patio, landscaping and new, modern shed. Neighbors on both sides say how lovely each improvement is, how nice to have someone take care of old house, etc. DH and I are avid gardeners (even written up in local garden articles).

We have two teen DDs, younger DD sometimes plays with neighbor kids to the left of us. This family has six children under age 11 and have their own garden fence. To the right of us are two homes who share a fence (not w/ us). Neighbor kids from both sides run through our yard to play and sometimes have trampled our plants. While we politely remind them to be careful, I don't expect little ones to always remember (I'm not angry w/ children being children!).We have a lot of rabbits in our area and they've destroyed a number of our beloved plants (even ate the rose bushes). Essentially, we are the only house w/out a fence around our garden, sooo...we planned a garden fence of roughly 1.5 m that would contain our garden, and also form a natural boundary so kids won't run through. We have an open front garden (and front walkway) that kids can still use to get from one house to the next, so we aren't cutting anyone off from visiting friends.

We own the drive that separates us from our neighbors to the left, and their home is a bit lower in elevation than ours. We told everyone over a year ago when landscapers would come in the spring to build the fence. They came Monday to start building and it looks lovely.

Yesterday, our neighbor mom of the six kids came crying (literally) to me that she's devastated about this fence because her kids love our yard so much and they love running through it and as we are higher elevation, our fence makes it impossible to watch her kids from her lower yard. She is 'shocked' she wasn't consulted about the design. Her DH called my DH to demand we take it down.

DH and I refused. We know we are within our rights by law to this fence. Everyone ELSE already has a garden fence. We aren't responsible for accommodating her parenting needs. We desire more privacy, rabbit-free garden and a boundary to keep kids from plants. Should we give in to demands to keep the peace? She's obviously distressed, but her DH has been a jerk in the past, so we fear this is clouding our position to stay firm.

OP posts:
WhereYouLeftIt · 14/06/2022 18:18

"she's devastated about this fence because her kids love our yard so much and they love running through it"

It's your yard. YOURS. Not theirs. Build the fence.

Fraaahnces · 14/06/2022 18:14

If she brings it up again in a similar fashion, I’d ask if “supervising her kids” while they were trashing your garden. I’d then state that it sounds like she was admitting liability for damage to your property and that the repair bill AND fence costs might end up het responsibility.

Robinni · 14/06/2022 18:04

I think results of the vote make your position clear.

You’ve given advance notice of this and are entitled to a boundary fence.

If she wants more space for her kids to run around then she needs to buy a house with a bigger private garden.

fyn · 14/06/2022 18:03

When I grew up in America fences were banned by the neighbourhood association. Everyone mowed their own patch (which was checked to ensure it was the desired height but the association) but nobody minded playing between. It isn’t that unusual of a set up to have no fences!

HeadOnShoulders · 14/06/2022 18:02

Is this some sort of joke or parody? Why on earth would they think they have a right to dictate what fence you should or shouldn't build?

Delphinium20 · 14/06/2022 17:54

Redbone · 14/06/2022 17:47

YANBU she is a CF of the highest order but I won’t vote until I see a diagram !

here you go

To Not Give in to Neighbor's Request for Fence Change?
OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 14/06/2022 17:53

id ask her to look into which design of fence she'd like and can afford as she will have to pay for the replacement - until she can provide something you both agree on, the fence stays put

change upsets people, good or bad change is something a lot of people can't cope with.

This neighbour has gotten used to watching her children play in your garden and I expect its like an extension to her own, now suddenly she has realised whats she has lost and wants it back. so giving her a suggestion in the mean time may help and she will get used to the change and not do anything about the changes

Redbone · 14/06/2022 17:47

YANBU she is a CF of the highest order but I won’t vote until I see a diagram !

Spohn · 14/06/2022 17:45

You mention ‘keep the peace’ with some woman who has six kids? She clearly hates peace! Openly laugh at her, the fucking cheek of her.

Shedcity · 14/06/2022 17:44

To be clear they’re demanding that their kids can have access to your private garden? And that you have no privacy because it’s inconvenient to her?

She’s a CF who can’t stop her kids trampling someone else’s garden. She can get off her arse and watch her kids and make her own garden look nice if her kids love it so much.

Hagiography · 14/06/2022 17:44

YANBU. Although I did consult with a neighbour when we put up a fence, just out of politeness. She then proceeded to offer several unwanted suggestions/requests and kind of tried to take ownership of it, which was a bit CF. I've learned to just nod vaguely and ignore for the most part.

Spohn · 14/06/2022 17:43

I can’t understand why there was every any doubt over who the unreasonable one is?

JuneJubilee · 14/06/2022 17:41

our fence makes it impossible to watch her kids from her lower yard

how? When her kids are in her yard, they'll be perfectly easy to see.

she doesn't need to be able to see into your yard because they won't be in it.

KappaChino · 14/06/2022 17:39

Tell her you need the fence to keep your new 11 stone Old English Gnasherhound, Brutus, safely contained - breeder insisted on it.

Delphinium20 · 14/06/2022 17:37

AcrossthePond55 · 14/06/2022 17:30

@Delphinium20

I'm in the US and 6 ft fences and brick walls are so 'normal' in my part of the country (West Coast) that I can't believe someone actually complained, let alone demanded that you remove it! I will say that when I was in the Midwest there were lots of backyards with no fences. It looked odd to me.

Obviously YANBU. And as far as 'consulting' on the design, the only time we ever 'consulted' with a neighbor was when we were going 'half-sies' on paying for a new fence after an old one was destroyed when a tree fell on it.

I might have calculated wrong in the meters, but our fence is roughly 4.5 feet...so even SHORTER than some fences where you live. And yes, where we live 6 foot fences are common enough that every block will have at least 3 or 4 minimum. It's a mix of lower fences, no fences and 6 footers).

OP posts:
PussGirl · 14/06/2022 17:37

She has an overdeveloped sense of entitlement to your garden

TrashyPanda · 14/06/2022 17:34

She’s off her head

Creasedtshirts · 14/06/2022 17:34

Her free range kids are probably the reason your neighbours have nice high fenced in gardens! 😂 YANBU at all!

Poppyseed14 · 14/06/2022 17:33

Maybe get a sound system, tikki bar and sex pond too OP 🤣

YANBU at all. Enjoy your garden.

AcrossthePond55 · 14/06/2022 17:30

@Delphinium20

I'm in the US and 6 ft fences and brick walls are so 'normal' in my part of the country (West Coast) that I can't believe someone actually complained, let alone demanded that you remove it! I will say that when I was in the Midwest there were lots of backyards with no fences. It looked odd to me.

Obviously YANBU. And as far as 'consulting' on the design, the only time we ever 'consulted' with a neighbor was when we were going 'half-sies' on paying for a new fence after an old one was destroyed when a tree fell on it.

Sswhinesthebest · 14/06/2022 17:30

The reasons she wants to keep it open, are exactly the same reasons you want it fenced!

MissConductUS · 14/06/2022 17:27

Delphinium20 · 14/06/2022 16:22

yes. We have fences here too (varies depending on neighborhood) but I used meters to make it easier for all (we have a stupid measuring system in the states).

Fellow American here. In my experience neighborhoods with smaller lots tend to have fences, but it's totally up to you. In the NYC suburb I'm in some people have them and some don't. It's fine either way.

Tell your neighbor that she won't have to watch her kids in your yard once the fence goes up as they won't be in your yard.

EmmaH2022 · 14/06/2022 17:27

My flabber is gasted. What a crazy couple.

glad you like the new fence and enjoy the privacy OP.

mublma · 14/06/2022 17:26

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ifIwerenotanandroid · 14/06/2022 17:19

'What did she actually say to you?

That this fence will make her life miserable and that she doesn't know what she'll do. She said she'll feel cut off from everyone.'

Yeah, that's really not your problem to solve. Especially when, according to your excellent diagram, everyone else's garden is already fenced off. Your garden is not some kind of public play area. It's yours.