Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Not Give in to Neighbor's Request for Fence Change?

190 replies

Delphinium20 · 14/06/2022 15:40

Need some advice, and apologies for long post, but details needed.

We bought our house a few years ago and have been making garden improvements including walkway, new patio, landscaping and new, modern shed. Neighbors on both sides say how lovely each improvement is, how nice to have someone take care of old house, etc. DH and I are avid gardeners (even written up in local garden articles).

We have two teen DDs, younger DD sometimes plays with neighbor kids to the left of us. This family has six children under age 11 and have their own garden fence. To the right of us are two homes who share a fence (not w/ us). Neighbor kids from both sides run through our yard to play and sometimes have trampled our plants. While we politely remind them to be careful, I don't expect little ones to always remember (I'm not angry w/ children being children!).We have a lot of rabbits in our area and they've destroyed a number of our beloved plants (even ate the rose bushes). Essentially, we are the only house w/out a fence around our garden, sooo...we planned a garden fence of roughly 1.5 m that would contain our garden, and also form a natural boundary so kids won't run through. We have an open front garden (and front walkway) that kids can still use to get from one house to the next, so we aren't cutting anyone off from visiting friends.

We own the drive that separates us from our neighbors to the left, and their home is a bit lower in elevation than ours. We told everyone over a year ago when landscapers would come in the spring to build the fence. They came Monday to start building and it looks lovely.

Yesterday, our neighbor mom of the six kids came crying (literally) to me that she's devastated about this fence because her kids love our yard so much and they love running through it and as we are higher elevation, our fence makes it impossible to watch her kids from her lower yard. She is 'shocked' she wasn't consulted about the design. Her DH called my DH to demand we take it down.

DH and I refused. We know we are within our rights by law to this fence. Everyone ELSE already has a garden fence. We aren't responsible for accommodating her parenting needs. We desire more privacy, rabbit-free garden and a boundary to keep kids from plants. Should we give in to demands to keep the peace? She's obviously distressed, but her DH has been a jerk in the past, so we fear this is clouding our position to stay firm.

OP posts:
perfectstorm · 14/06/2022 20:22

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 14/06/2022 20:18

That's the equivalent of railing against your local supermarket for hiring a security guard - without having the decency to consult you first - on the grounds that it now makes it much more difficult for you to continue shoplifting their goods!!

I also agree that, if her kids had an accident whilst on your land, she would be right on the phone to her lawyer - quite possibly using your 'neglect to secure your land with a fence' in her case against you.

Perfect analogy. And agreed on the risk.

perfectstorm · 14/06/2022 20:22

So effectively she likes having your garden to treat as her own, as it more than doubles the space her kids have to play, while you do all the work of maintaining it? And she thinks it's terrible of you not to plan your living environment around her wishes and convenience, and to treat your own land as anything other than hers?

She sounds awful. Your only unreasonable move is not making the fence a LOT higher, or to grow very scratchy plants up it - roses with mahoosive thorns, say -because otherwise, someone that much of a CF will let her kids use the fence as an additional play option.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 14/06/2022 20:18

That's the equivalent of railing against your local supermarket for hiring a security guard - without having the decency to consult you first - on the grounds that it now makes it much more difficult for you to continue shoplifting their goods!!

I also agree that, if her kids had an accident whilst on your land, she would be right on the phone to her lawyer - quite possibly using your 'neglect to secure your land with a fence' in her case against you.

Delphinium20 · 14/06/2022 20:15

Leftbutcameback · 14/06/2022 20:02

Come on, who voted YABU? Or was that just for the lack of diagram?

As for the height OP, you can always put trellis on the fence for an extra bit of height later if you need it. We did that and I really like the way it looks - privacy but still lets light through.

great idea on trellis. My diagram was late to the convo, so you'll find it top of page 2

OP posts:
Delphinium20 · 14/06/2022 20:11

PlntLady · 14/06/2022 19:23

YANBU
Essentially she is devastated that her children no longer have free access to run across your garden. They shouldn't be in your yard regardless of a fence being there or not. Keep the fence. They will get over it. The kids wont even care by the time the week is out.
If it's such an issue for them tell them to take you to court.

They will get over it. The kids wont even care by the time the week is out.

Truest statement, I'm sure. Kids have short memories at that age.

OP posts:
Bordesleyhills · 14/06/2022 20:06

Good for you- enjoy your garden

Leftbutcameback · 14/06/2022 20:02

Come on, who voted YABU? Or was that just for the lack of diagram?

As for the height OP, you can always put trellis on the fence for an extra bit of height later if you need it. We did that and I really like the way it looks - privacy but still lets light through.

whynotwhatknot · 14/06/2022 19:44

cheeky fucks she just wants free babysitters

Id go higher than 4 foot though

KylaF · 14/06/2022 19:36

I agree! Maybe not in those words but they are soooo cheeky

PlntLady · 14/06/2022 19:23

YANBU
Essentially she is devastated that her children no longer have free access to run across your garden. They shouldn't be in your yard regardless of a fence being there or not. Keep the fence. They will get over it. The kids wont even care by the time the week is out.
If it's such an issue for them tell them to take you to court.

KylaF · 14/06/2022 19:22

I don’t feel it’s your responsibility to not put the fence up. Very unfortunate situation to be in regarding their reaction but ultimately you have to do what is right for you, as that’s exactly what they are trying to do for them

fetchacloth · 14/06/2022 19:11

Ignore her. Her kids, her problem. Don't make it yours😎

Delphinium20 · 14/06/2022 19:06

2bazookas · 14/06/2022 19:03

We had a similar issue. It began when our small children played with the kids next door on either side and it suited three young families to have gates between the gardens. The children were polite, responsible, closed the gates, there were never any problems
Those kids all grew up, new families moved in on both sides and just assumed their small children could use the old gates to cross our garden. These two sets of children vandalised our plants and trees, left gates open (letting our dogs and livestock out), hit our dogs with sticks. The final straw was , I heard a racket on our land and found the boy next door and his mate vandalising our water supply tank. I took him back to his mother, her response was
"Did you do it?"

"No Mummy."
"He didn't do it."
"I saw him doing it".
"I believe my son".
That night, the gate on their side was torn off its hinges and thrown on the ground. We said nothing, just took the gate away, joined up the stock fences again and planted hawthorn hedge. No more access. The furious mother said we had stolen their childrens freedom and independence "and you didn't even consult us".

WOW! How awful of her. Good for you for putting that up!

OP posts:
Delphinium20 · 14/06/2022 19:05

Anoooshka · 14/06/2022 19:03

As someone else has mentioned, it's common to have unfenced gardens in the US, and sometimes it's not allowed. Some housing developments have very strict rules about what is and what isn't allowed, even down to what you are allowed to plant in your garden.

What I've noticed here is that no one seems to mind if you put up a fence because you have a dog. Perhaps tell your neighbours that you are getting some Pitbull puppies (if they're not banned in your county) or other similar kid-unfriendly breed, and you're worried that their kids might not be safe. Then say that you are waiting for the puppies to be born when they ask where the dogs are.

I like this!

OP posts:
SausageAndCash · 14/06/2022 19:04

Total loon.

And her DH is a bullying thug.

The fence won’t keep rabbits out though. They will dig underneath.

Delphinium20 · 14/06/2022 19:04

billy1966 · 14/06/2022 18:46

You are a saint, but a saint making a HUGE mistake only going 4.5 ft high....if I'm reading it right?

You need to go a solid 6ft to keep them out.

At a lesser height they will be climbing and hanging over it.

Bad move.

I do wonder about this...I'm thinking we might wish for the 6 footer...but the way it's designed, we could add height in the future.

OP posts:
2bazookas · 14/06/2022 19:03

We had a similar issue. It began when our small children played with the kids next door on either side and it suited three young families to have gates between the gardens. The children were polite, responsible, closed the gates, there were never any problems
Those kids all grew up, new families moved in on both sides and just assumed their small children could use the old gates to cross our garden. These two sets of children vandalised our plants and trees, left gates open (letting our dogs and livestock out), hit our dogs with sticks. The final straw was , I heard a racket on our land and found the boy next door and his mate vandalising our water supply tank. I took him back to his mother, her response was
"Did you do it?"

"No Mummy."
"He didn't do it."
"I saw him doing it".
"I believe my son".
That night, the gate on their side was torn off its hinges and thrown on the ground. We said nothing, just took the gate away, joined up the stock fences again and planted hawthorn hedge. No more access. The furious mother said we had stolen their childrens freedom and independence "and you didn't even consult us".

Anoooshka · 14/06/2022 19:03

As someone else has mentioned, it's common to have unfenced gardens in the US, and sometimes it's not allowed. Some housing developments have very strict rules about what is and what isn't allowed, even down to what you are allowed to plant in your garden.

What I've noticed here is that no one seems to mind if you put up a fence because you have a dog. Perhaps tell your neighbours that you are getting some Pitbull puppies (if they're not banned in your county) or other similar kid-unfriendly breed, and you're worried that their kids might not be safe. Then say that you are waiting for the puppies to be born when they ask where the dogs are.

Thisisit2022 · 14/06/2022 18:59

I can't WAIT for my new fence to go up this month after 12 years of other things taking financial priority. Currently always at eye level with Scotty McChumsSlacks who NEVER...GOES...OUT.

billy1966 · 14/06/2022 18:46

You are a saint, but a saint making a HUGE mistake only going 4.5 ft high....if I'm reading it right?

You need to go a solid 6ft to keep them out.

At a lesser height they will be climbing and hanging over it.

Bad move.

Shoezone · 14/06/2022 18:41

Extraordinary. I can imagine that she might be (unreasonably) annoyed and have a private moan to her husband about it... but to think that you are going to arrange your property to suit her and her children's needs??

Gatekeeper · 14/06/2022 18:40

for US audience

To Not Give in to Neighbor's Request for Fence Change?
Gatekeeper · 14/06/2022 18:38

KappaChino · 14/06/2022 17:39

Tell her you need the fence to keep your new 11 stone Old English Gnasherhound, Brutus, safely contained - breeder insisted on it.

nah...you need a Tripehound called Gnasher a la Dennis The Menace (British Variant- not the pale US version)

TequilaSunriseforme · 14/06/2022 18:29

QOD · 14/06/2022 16:02

are you in America? your use of mom and not having a fence makes it seem so - we are predominantly English/British and omg. we havefences
6 ft pnale fences

Spelling is American too.

Lunarpsychobitch · 14/06/2022 18:21

WTF... Looking at the diagram, she should be thanking you for securing her garden..

Swipe left for the next trending thread