Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Not Give in to Neighbor's Request for Fence Change?

190 replies

Delphinium20 · 14/06/2022 15:40

Need some advice, and apologies for long post, but details needed.

We bought our house a few years ago and have been making garden improvements including walkway, new patio, landscaping and new, modern shed. Neighbors on both sides say how lovely each improvement is, how nice to have someone take care of old house, etc. DH and I are avid gardeners (even written up in local garden articles).

We have two teen DDs, younger DD sometimes plays with neighbor kids to the left of us. This family has six children under age 11 and have their own garden fence. To the right of us are two homes who share a fence (not w/ us). Neighbor kids from both sides run through our yard to play and sometimes have trampled our plants. While we politely remind them to be careful, I don't expect little ones to always remember (I'm not angry w/ children being children!).We have a lot of rabbits in our area and they've destroyed a number of our beloved plants (even ate the rose bushes). Essentially, we are the only house w/out a fence around our garden, sooo...we planned a garden fence of roughly 1.5 m that would contain our garden, and also form a natural boundary so kids won't run through. We have an open front garden (and front walkway) that kids can still use to get from one house to the next, so we aren't cutting anyone off from visiting friends.

We own the drive that separates us from our neighbors to the left, and their home is a bit lower in elevation than ours. We told everyone over a year ago when landscapers would come in the spring to build the fence. They came Monday to start building and it looks lovely.

Yesterday, our neighbor mom of the six kids came crying (literally) to me that she's devastated about this fence because her kids love our yard so much and they love running through it and as we are higher elevation, our fence makes it impossible to watch her kids from her lower yard. She is 'shocked' she wasn't consulted about the design. Her DH called my DH to demand we take it down.

DH and I refused. We know we are within our rights by law to this fence. Everyone ELSE already has a garden fence. We aren't responsible for accommodating her parenting needs. We desire more privacy, rabbit-free garden and a boundary to keep kids from plants. Should we give in to demands to keep the peace? She's obviously distressed, but her DH has been a jerk in the past, so we fear this is clouding our position to stay firm.

OP posts:
pastaandpesto · 15/06/2022 07:49

We were in the Midwest - probably accounts for the differences in approaches! The pool thing I found particularly horrifying!

IDreamOfTheMoors · 15/06/2022 04:37

@pastaandpesto

I’m in California. Fences are very much the norm, and fencing around one’s pool is the law I believe, and has been for many years.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 15/06/2022 03:47

She reminds me of the OP of a great (and long) CF thread from some time ago, who had a 'friend' who expected to be able to frequently come over to her house to smoke, as she didn't want her own house to stink from her own smoke - even though OP/nobody in OP's household actually smoked!!

It takes a very special kind of CF to genuinely believe it reasonable to make you suffer solely from their unreasonable behavior - specifically so that they don't have to suffer from it!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 15/06/2022 03:40

That's all flim-flam her asking how it would look if it were shorter. She isn't thinking about appearances at all: she's wondering what height would stop her kids from easily jumping over to keep using your garden and, as long as it's below that (and thus completely ineffective in your requirements for having it in the first place), she might very grudgingly 'accept' it (like she has any say in the matter anyway).

Actually, that's probably the worst-case scenario from her pov - she's likely hoping to 'negotiate' it lower and lower and lower until it gets down to zero inches high and you feel worn down into just giving up on the idea.

It would be interesting to see whether she leaves her own land unfenced, once you've got yours up. The tale as things stand is that 'only unreasonable people feel the need to put up a fence', which 'co-incidentally' works massively in her family's favor; but once she's the only one left who might risk having other neighbors' kids treating her garden as their own, with no pay-off benefit for her kids, she might suddenly change her tune and get a fence up in next to no time.

Fraaahnces · 15/06/2022 02:20

I suspect another reason for her melodrama. I bet she’s been lying to all her friends and family by saying that it was HER yard and now they’re going to realise they’ve been lied to and she’s going to look pretentious as well as stupid.

Delphinium20 · 14/06/2022 23:22

Wineaddict · 14/06/2022 22:33

The spelling of neighbo(u)r gave it away, but not the use of Mom.
Mom is what’s used where I live in England too.

OP, you are totally nbu - your neighbour definitely is.

Oh yes, I'm American (maybe should have said that).

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 14/06/2022 23:05

Delphinium20 · 14/06/2022 21:47

Oh dear, she just came out to the garden and was crying to our contractor, asking how it would look if it were shorter. I really didn't want to engage, but poor fence man. I just said, "I think it looks nice, and it's what DH and I designed." I apologized to him after she left and said to please ignore her and come back tomorrow. Very, very inappropriate, right? Ugh...I hate this. It's getting stupider.

Oh brother!!!

I'd go higher than 4.5 ft. My cousin had a 5 ft brick wall at the back of her yard and the town decided to put a pedestrian path right next to it. Constant looky-loos. So they screwed sections of 18 inch pointed wooden slats to the top of the brickwork to regain their privacy.

If your neighbor's yard is lower than yours I wouldn't think you'd have to worry about being 'overlooked' from their house. It's whether or not her kids are going to hang over the top of the fence to gawk or climb over it to use the 'short cut'. You can bet she won't be discouraging them from doing so.

madasawethen · 14/06/2022 22:51

They're batshit.

Is it too late to change to the 6 foot?

I'd put up a few cameras too to make sure they aren't climbing on it or it gets knocked down.

Eightiesfan · 14/06/2022 22:47

They are a pair of entitled CF. Hold firm, if she was that worried about her children she should keep them in her own garden!

Wineaddict · 14/06/2022 22:33

MigsandTiggs · 14/06/2022 16:58

Defo American OP with use of mom and neighbor.

The spelling of neighbo(u)r gave it away, but not the use of Mom.
Mom is what’s used where I live in England too.

OP, you are totally nbu - your neighbour definitely is.

StoneofDestiny · 14/06/2022 22:04

Bigger fence needed. She's a nut!

EmmaH2022 · 14/06/2022 22:00

Delphinium20 · 14/06/2022 21:47

Oh dear, she just came out to the garden and was crying to our contractor, asking how it would look if it were shorter. I really didn't want to engage, but poor fence man. I just said, "I think it looks nice, and it's what DH and I designed." I apologized to him after she left and said to please ignore her and come back tomorrow. Very, very inappropriate, right? Ugh...I hate this. It's getting stupider.

but you have to engage. You employed him, so you should say "please don't bother my contractor".

Delphinium20 · 14/06/2022 21:47

Oh dear, she just came out to the garden and was crying to our contractor, asking how it would look if it were shorter. I really didn't want to engage, but poor fence man. I just said, "I think it looks nice, and it's what DH and I designed." I apologized to him after she left and said to please ignore her and come back tomorrow. Very, very inappropriate, right? Ugh...I hate this. It's getting stupider.

OP posts:
Aubree17 · 14/06/2022 21:24

So she disputes your fence because she can no longer see her kids playing in your garden?
If so, her kids shouldn't be in your garden and it sounds like you have been more than tolerant.

KylaF · 14/06/2022 21:22

Think that’s a really good excuse about the dog

GoodThinkingMax · 14/06/2022 21:12

Why would anybody think they can dictate to a neighbour that they should remove a legal fence?

Your neighbour is nuts.

Aghh · 14/06/2022 21:11

I don’t need a diagram.

They’re Batshit.

Sallypally0 · 14/06/2022 21:06

Tell them you are getting an English Mastiff and the fence is for their own good.

Thehop · 14/06/2022 20:59

Do not alter your plans one inch! She’s more batshit than Dracula’s shed!!!

viques · 14/06/2022 20:58

If she keeps her children in her own garden she will be able to see them perfectly well.

SmartCarDriver · 14/06/2022 20:46

They're bloody ridiculous, stick with it OP!

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 14/06/2022 20:46

What a stupid entitled woman. It is NOT OK for their kids to wreck your garden whenever they want!!! I'm surprised you have put up with it so long.

cobden28 · 14/06/2022 20:36

If thefencing you put up was within the legal limits set by your council and erected entirely on your land then it's tough luck on your neighbour as what you've done is perfectly legal and they don't have a leg to stand on. The neighbour's children don't therefore have a legal right to cross your land for any reason.

Pallisers · 14/06/2022 20:31

YANBU and she and her husband are being ridiculous. I'm in the US too OP (and have a fence in my back garden). We bought the house years ago from an English couple. They had put a fence (white picket) around the front garden. We left it there for a few years while ours were small and then removed it. All of our neighbours stopped by to thank us for taking it out :) the street looks much nicer without it.

SeaToSki · 14/06/2022 20:26

Offer her the option of paying the taxes on your garden if she is so keen to use it!

Seriously though, just go for a standard 6 ft fence. Its actually almost cheaper than lower ones as they are the standard for just about everywhere. Then they cant lean over and moan and whine at you, or ask to be lifted over every 5 mins, or put a toy next to the fence to climb over and then get stuck/break their wrist and get annoyed and yell/sue you.

Also you are likely not covered under your household liability insurance if you are knowingly letting them trespass on your garden and they cause damage or leave a toy behind that a contractor trips on etc etc. there is also adverse possession and prescriptive easements to worry about if it goes on long term.