Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My daughter doesn’t like our new puppy! 😣

181 replies

ohwhattodo96 · 14/06/2022 11:10

We got a puppy a few days ago so it’s all very new and still settling down, but my autistic 6 year old daughter hates him! 😔

She has been a bit rough with him a few times which has led to her being disciplined and put on time out, and she has started saying that she doesn’t want a dog and wants him to be sent away, she literally spends all day shouting this.

I think part of it could be jealously because she is no longer getting sole attention, especially because he has been unwell, and I have tried getting her involved in playing with him and helping to do things for him, but she just refuses.

How do I fix this?! X

OP posts:
Quincythequince · 14/06/2022 11:46

If you keep this dog, as placid as he seems now, an animal will only take so much bybway of abuse (verbal and/or physical) befor it texts badly. This could just be snarling to begin with (a clear warning to leave a dog alone) which can be scary for anyone, but what is he then bites?

That would not be his fault!

I think you should attempt to re-home being a lifelong dog owner.

Blueshimmer · 14/06/2022 11:44

I’ve got an autistic child, who’s rough with other children sometimes and who would absolutely be rough with a puppy. And whose meltdowns would probably scare a dog witless. They’d be upset by the inevitable changes in routine, the smell, the attention - and because they have a fairly fixed mindset, once they decided they didn’t like the dog that would be it, they wouldn’t change their mind.

So I’d never get a dog. It’s not fair on the dog and it’s not fair on the child. Yeah, child didn’t much like their baby sibling either and I persisted with that - but that was my actual human baby, not an easily rehomed puppy.

Lostsoul91 · 14/06/2022 11:44

Tough one, I've an autistic son who is nearly 9, I get it often that he hates the puppy and we should get rid of it. He however doesn't mean it, he says it in frustration if he's being too bouncy or too nippy. He also loves to snuggle this puppy. So I'm not going to have the same view as others as I know SEN children tend to just say thing's.

I would however suggest if you can get her to train him, get her to teach him to sit, build up their bond and give her a sense of control over this puppy, that at the moment she probably sees as unpredictable. Teach her how to manage him, so if she feels SHE needs space from him, how to put him safely into another room, my son knows where the treat pot it and will put the puppy in the kitchen.

Ultimately she needs to know she is safe and in control of her space. That's the only advice I can really give.

EducatingArti · 14/06/2022 11:44

Your daughter is probably very unsettled because the puppy is new and unpredictable.
I would, for the moment, make sure that you divide your space between ", puppy allowed" and "puppy not allowed" space. Use baby gates etc to enforce.
Also make sure puppy has its own safe space ( eg crate) where your daughter is not allowed to interact with it.
Rather like when introducing new cats to each other, keep them in their own spaces as much as poss for now. Then your daughter knows she is "safe" from the unpredictability.
Write some "rules" and pin them up.
Dd can....
Dd can't ( hit, talk to dog in crate etc)
Dog can ..
Dog can't ( go upstairs, in dd' chair etc)
Once you have established these and DD ( and dog) feel safe, you can explain to DD about eg inviting dog into lounge in evening but not allowed on sofa etc
If the dog is chilled, this isn't so much for training the dog but helping your dad feel more in control.

Bunty55 · 14/06/2022 11:41

We have a new puppy. She is 14 weeks old and a right handful ! She gets excited and nips and bites and scratches.. it's what they do.
We have another dog and the two love each other, but if we go out for a short time and at bedtime, the puppy is caged for her own good and for the sake of the older dog who needs time out.
And that's just the dogs.............

Currently living here but about to move into their own new home are my daughter and three year old grandson.
He loves the pup but we never leave him alone with her as he has a tendency to grab her and pick her up.
There are lots of amputee puppies as a result of being hurt by children who love them.
Get a new home for the puppy please. I beg you. It's not fair on the pup or your daughter.

Wnikat · 14/06/2022 11:41

YAB completely unreasonable to discipline an autistic 6 year old with a time out.

CalistoNoSolo · 14/06/2022 11:41

Lovely. So you get a puppy from a puppy farmer, it gets hit by your daughter and you can't even recognise that the puppy is withdrawn because it's ill and frightened of the shouting. Have you even taken it to the vets? Rehome the puppy before you fuck it up entirely and it can't be rehomed.

lborgia · 14/06/2022 11:41

No, nothing your child does bothers me, just your actions.

And yes, I know what I'm talking about. SEN specialists... mmm. What are they actually? Anyone who thinks putting a child in isolation as a way of enforcing right and wrong is clearly reading very old books. There are plenty of specialists who are very happy to tell you how to parent, without having considered the impact on the child.

60 years ago it was considered healthy and right to leave your child outside in the pram for fresh air, and to get the crying out of their system. Would you agree that we've moved on since then?

Not to worry, I'm sure a couple of years of intense ABA therapy will make her to behave "normally".

Back to the dog. If it's chilled out and no fuss, sell it on to someone else who doesn't have young children.

Mindymomo · 14/06/2022 11:41

Do you have a crate for puppy, your DD may feel better if puppy isn’t within reach all the time.

ohwhattodo96 · 14/06/2022 11:41

@XmasElf10 I’m glad to hear that it all worked out in the end! Surely there are other homes where children have changed their minds once dog arrives, the dog wasn’t what they were expecting and then they struggle to warm up to them - yet apparently on here everyone thinks every scenario with children is picture perfect and if it’s not then get rid and don’t attempt to train or settle the situation?!

OP posts:
XmasElf10 · 14/06/2022 11:37

My DD hated Mr Bitey (as she called him) when we first got him. He is now a beloved family pet but it took almost a year for her feelings to change. She was scared of dogs and he was a bit rough, he’s better now.

Daenerys77 · 14/06/2022 11:36

Maybe your daughter is not ready for a dog or maybe she is not, and will never be, a 'dog person'; many of us aren't, which is why it is not fair to bring a dog into a home unless all existing members of the household are happy about it.

worraliberty · 14/06/2022 11:35

I missed the bit where you said the puppy has been unwell.

Given that you said the irresponsible breeder wouldn't take it back, due to having trouble selling it in the first place has puppy farm written all over it.

Prepare yourself for some expensive vets bills.

ohwhattodo96 · 14/06/2022 11:33

@lborgia horrifying and chilling? I think that’s a bit OTT if I’m being honest.

Yes if she’s rough with him she gets put on time out, same way if she was rough with any of us human household members. That’s what I’ve been told to do by SEN specialists because she knows what is a good and bad choice. Unless you’re an expert and know differently?

Yes I’ve known other people with similar issues, especially with youngest children etc who is used to all the attention and then something new comes along. There is often sibling jealously etc, is that chilling and horrifying too?

OP posts:
lborgia · 14/06/2022 11:33

Oh, the breeder won't take the puppy back even though it's in danger from a child.

FFS, this gets worse with every post.

worraliberty · 14/06/2022 11:32

I personally think it’s because she’s either jealous of the attention or she isn’t liking being put on time out because of the dog. Surely those are fixable?

Well you know your own daughter but you don't know your own puppy yet.

One more smack on the head or being treated roughly and that 'chilled out' personality could well change.

lborgia · 14/06/2022 11:30

Maybe consider how you parent your autistic child. The idea that you are using time out, and disciplining her for not knowing how to interact with a brand new puppy is horrifying.

The fact that you site "jealousy" as an issue also chills me.

Your very new puppy has been sick - did it come from a reputable breeders, did you see the mother etc etc? New puppies being unwell is something of a red flag regarding how they've been bred/ where they've been living.

Send the puppy back, and spend the money on resources to help you understand best practice/ autistic-led information on how to help your daughter feel safe and how to understand what her behaviour means.

ohwhattodo96 · 14/06/2022 11:29

Our puppy isn’t boisterous though - he is the most calm and chilled out dog ever - he just sits there, doesn’t jump up or anything, that was his personality at the breeders too.

I personally think it’s because she’s either jealous of the attention or she isn’t liking being put on time out because of the dog. Surely those are fixable?

OP posts:
liveforsummer · 14/06/2022 11:27

Unfortunately I don't think a puppy was the right voice for your household. Of course you wouldn't have necessarily known that til now. Best of puppy goes back though. Your dd is focussed on hating the pup and this will likely get worse as the puppy grows and gets more boisterous.

Discovereads · 14/06/2022 11:27

Rehome the puppy is what you do. For two reasons- the first being the safety of the puppy. Even if she starts handling him well/tolerating him the animosity between them could very well lead to a stressed dog that may bite resulting in a death sentence for the dog. The second being children’s comfort in their own home always comes before having pets in the home. Obviously this puppy/dog isn’t compatible with your DD. It’s best for the puppy and her that a new home be found for the puppy.

ohwhattodo96 · 14/06/2022 11:26

Don’t get me wrong she’s not abusing it - she has hit it on the head once when it first arrived because she had a bit of an autistic meltdown - and she can be boisterous but there are boundaries in place to try and avoid that from happening.

The breeder won’t have him back as he was struggling to sell them in the first place. He is such a chilled out dog, and she is used to being around them in other people’s homes, which is making me think it’s more of a jealously type thing? Like when a child is an only child for a few years and then a sibling comes along sort of thing?

Its still very early days - not even had him a week yet - so I’m hoping she starts to settle with him, or at least learn to live with him, but obviously if she doesn’t or if the puppy starts to become unhappy then obviously I’m going to have a plan B. X

OP posts:
CalistoNoSolo · 14/06/2022 11:25

Jesus, the poor puppy. A shouty rough environmental is extremely stressful for dogs, and particularly a puppy. Rehome responsibly and don't get another pet.

Bigblackandreddog · 14/06/2022 11:25

My lovely old dog was originally in a similar sounding household, child with autism who hated him and often got physical towards him.

It’s no life for a dog and your risking the puppy growing up with a negative view of your DC or even worse all children.

I would have returned him by now!

SirenSays · 14/06/2022 11:25

The puppy stage is always a bit new and chaotic. Do you think she'll bond when you've had puppy a bit longer and he's calmed down a little?

Womencanlift · 14/06/2022 11:24

Did she want a dog and has now changed her mind now it’s here? Did you have a trial time to get her settled with the dog?

If you just brought the dog home one day as a ‘surprise’ then YABU.

At the end of the day your child’s happiness and feeling safe in her home should be far more important than your desire for a pet

Swipe left for the next trending thread