Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My daughter doesn’t like our new puppy! 😣

181 replies

ohwhattodo96 · 14/06/2022 11:10

We got a puppy a few days ago so it’s all very new and still settling down, but my autistic 6 year old daughter hates him! 😔

She has been a bit rough with him a few times which has led to her being disciplined and put on time out, and she has started saying that she doesn’t want a dog and wants him to be sent away, she literally spends all day shouting this.

I think part of it could be jealously because she is no longer getting sole attention, especially because he has been unwell, and I have tried getting her involved in playing with him and helping to do things for him, but she just refuses.

How do I fix this?! X

OP posts:
Cr3ateAUsername · 14/06/2022 12:16

I wouldn’t force it, sadly you will have to rehome it. Both your daughter and the puppy need homes that are a place of tranquility.

comealongponds · 14/06/2022 12:15

Sounds like you went to a crappy back yard breeder, a decent breeder would want to take the puppy back rather than leave it in an unsuitable home.

Youre minimising the fact that your daughter hit a young and defenceless animal on the head. The fact that it was an autistic meltdown and that there were consequences doesn’t make a difference to the poor puppy.

YABU the puppy isn’t safe in your home.

stratforduponavon · 14/06/2022 12:15

I feel desperately sorry for this puppy. Your daughter for whatever reason is hitting the dog and when your back is turned could be doing even worse. Give it back urgently and let someone who knows how to treat animals
properly take it. I am sort of sorry to be harsh but this won’t end well.

TigerLilyTail · 14/06/2022 12:12

On the other hand, she may find it harder in September when she is tired from school and comes home and wants your full attention.

My son has ASD and he isn't keen on the cat at all. The cat mostly just stays out of his way though. A puppy is a lot of work for someone with an autistic 6-year-old.

jamoncrumpets · 14/06/2022 12:10

I had to give up a much loved rescue for the same reason. Autistic children are, famously, inflexible and unlikely to budge on stances. They also scare more easily than NT kids.

I stupidly thought my dog would grow on my DS. We gave it six months. He didn't grow even a cm. It got to the point where DS was refusing to be on the same floor of the house as the dog, and wouldn't play in the garden if the dog was in there.

So I had no choice but to find the dog a new home. Luckily I think I found him an even better home than ours, but I was very picky about where he went.

sittingnexttochoppysea · 14/06/2022 12:10

She picked him.

And you don't even see what's wrong with this. Ffs. Poor dog.

WiddlinDiddlin · 14/06/2022 12:10

OP - this is what I do for a living...

So.. you've bought from a crappy breeder, who won't take back, which makes that option much harder as now we're talking rehome via a rescue (they're all full) or privately rehome (takes a while unless of course you just irresponsibly hand over to the first person who shows up)...

Point being this puppy isn't going anywhere soon.

Lots of children, NT or ND... are horrified by the reality of a puppy.

In theory, a puppy is a cute, snuggly, best friend who always wants to do what they want to do, play games, sit and watch them play, snuggle, etc. Never any disagreement, never any competition like there would be with another child, its all just lovely.

The reality is that your child has got a needy new sibling who is NOT fulfilling any of their expectations at all - they don't listen, don't want to play her games, don't want to watch her play, do want to bite her, etc etc..

And she can't communicate that well so she gets frustrated and stressed at the puppy themselves and of course then gets into trouble for THAT so.. obviously the puppy is to blame, demand the puppy is removed.

Separate puppy and child.

Use a room divider where necessary so they're both in the same room, so neither is missing out on company, interaction etc, but they can't annoy or hurt one another.

Reward the absolute shit out of either of them for IGNORING the other - sounds counter intuitive I know, you want them to like each other but that route means them being too close, physically, it means big risk of one hurting the other and fall outs and so on.

Rewarding them for ignoring each other, choosing to go away from one another is much much safer.

Once you have the dividers set up and some sort of routine in place, you can keep explaining to your daughter that the puppy lives here too, what the rules are around the puppy, where she can go to take herself away from the puppy, how she can ask for an adult to help etc etc.

I would rehome this puppy though.

It is a red flag that the breeder wont take back and struggled to sell.
It is also a red flag that this puppy is apparently so chilled - after the first night, most puppies are bouncy and into everything and the level of laid back you describe makes me suspect something is wrong tbh.
Whilst I can see how pets can help people with autism, unfortunately I very often see dogs/pets really suffering as a result of being that 'help' and I don't think that's acceptable.

ohwhattodo96 · 14/06/2022 12:09

Same room**

OP posts:
ohwhattodo96 · 14/06/2022 12:09

Like right now - she is sat nicely in the same wrong eating her lunch - but once I start paying him any attention she’ll tell me he has to go

OP posts:
ohwhattodo96 · 14/06/2022 12:07

My daughter knew for several months we were on the look out for a dog, she picked him, picked his name, went shopping for his things.

she was absolutely fine until she realised she would not be allowed to do as she wanted with him - she struggles having rules and boundaries put in place.

she is also back at school in September so it’ll give her time away from him and him time away from her if needed.

OP posts:
sittingnexttochoppysea · 14/06/2022 12:05

I'm more pissed off for the poor dog. You've bought a puppy from what is clearly a puppy farm which is completely irresponsible.

What preparation did you do for your daughter, knowing she's autistic surely you did stuff like weekly visits to play with the puppy before buying to start the bond? No because puppy farmers don't generally encourage that. I'm sure they sent you cute videos though Hmm

Re home the puppy with a family who can care for it properly. And if you chose to get one in the future make sure you do your research and prepare your daughter for the change.

Crunchymum · 14/06/2022 12:04

especially because he has been unwell

Our puppy isn’t boisterous though - he is the most calm and chilled out dog ever - he just sits there, doesn’t jump up or anything

Has the puppy been to the vets?

Why is he unwell (IE what is wrong with him?) Was he okay when he arrived?

Twentypast · 14/06/2022 12:02

A sick puppy that a breeder won't take back? I have never heard of a reputable breeder that won't take back a puppy. In fact every dog I've ever had has had a contract saying if we can't look after the dog at any time, the breeder will take it back.

LetsGoCrazyPurpleBanana · 14/06/2022 12:01

The dog may be chilled now but what's to say one day the dog will attack if he's hit on the head one too many times. Too many stories of dog attacks. Are you prepared to take that risk?You need to re-home. It's not a suitable environment.

Womencanlift · 14/06/2022 12:01

You still haven’t answered why you chose to get a dog and what preparation did you make to let your DD get used to sharing her home with an animal. It’s different than being around dogs in other people’s homes

Did she know it was coming? Was she involved in preparing the house eg buying toys and a dog bed. This could have minimised the jealousy if done properly

2bazookas · 14/06/2022 12:01

This is unfair on the puppy; rough behaviopur and shouting at him will wreck his temperament. It's also unfair on a child who can't cope with puppy behaviour.

For both their sakes, return the puppy to the breeder with explanation it's no fault of his. Don't get another dog.

TheDoveFromAboveCooCoo · 14/06/2022 12:00

Lots of good advice here (in between some nastiness)

Rules pinned up of what she can and cannot do with puppy

Puppy zones and you free zones. If puppy goes to his crate then he must be left alone.

Give it a few weeks for her to settle before you make a definite decision. But if the situation is the same then I'm sorry but I would rehome.

worraliberty · 14/06/2022 11:59

Viviennemary · 14/06/2022 11:53

I woukd return the puppy. It isn't going to work. And its too stressful for everyone including the dog.

OP said the breeder won't take the puppy back as they had trouble selling it in the first place.

Bananarama21 · 14/06/2022 11:58

Does seem like the right fit for your household having a puppy

LIZS · 14/06/2022 11:58

The breeder won't take the puppy back? Hmm does not sound like either of you did much research on suitability of your home for a dog. And he has already been poorly?

Hutchy16 · 14/06/2022 11:56

lborgia · 14/06/2022 11:30

Maybe consider how you parent your autistic child. The idea that you are using time out, and disciplining her for not knowing how to interact with a brand new puppy is horrifying.

The fact that you site "jealousy" as an issue also chills me.

Your very new puppy has been sick - did it come from a reputable breeders, did you see the mother etc etc? New puppies being unwell is something of a red flag regarding how they've been bred/ where they've been living.

Send the puppy back, and spend the money on resources to help you understand best practice/ autistic-led information on how to help your daughter feel safe and how to understand what her behaviour means.

It definitely didn’t come from a reputable breeder otherwise they would have immediately taken it back.

i also suspect they would have had a long conversation with regard to whether a puppy is suited to a house with an autistic child (I think it is, but obv there are issues to address depending on any particular child) and if it is suitable, how to go about introducing the puppy to the family.

also most reputable breeders wouldn’t have trouble selling their dog as they would have a wait list in my limited experience. Smacks of puppy mill to me

Viviennemary · 14/06/2022 11:53

I woukd return the puppy. It isn't going to work. And its too stressful for everyone including the dog.

Cheesepleeze · 14/06/2022 11:50

Autistic kids struggle with change, I’d imagine her reaction is more down to that than jealousy?
I’d be wary about punishing her too, as she’ll probably make the connection that the new puppy is the cause of her punishments and start to resent him.

I agree with PP who mentioned puppy free zones so that she can feel safe and not anxious in most of the house.

liveforsummer · 14/06/2022 11:49

Blossomtoes · 14/06/2022 11:47

he is the most calm and chilled out dog ever - he just sits there, doesn’t jump up or anything, that was his personality at the breeders too

And that will change if he’s constantly stressed. Find him a new and more suitable home before his lovely nature is ruined.

It will also chafe as he starts to feel better and grows. He's likely subdued due to being unwell plus a bit scared in his new environment. Most puppies are subdued for the first day or so anyway even the healthy confident ones. It will change. I'd be worried about a puppy that diner for through the boisterous and bitey stage as it's a development phase

Blossomtoes · 14/06/2022 11:47

he is the most calm and chilled out dog ever - he just sits there, doesn’t jump up or anything, that was his personality at the breeders too

And that will change if he’s constantly stressed. Find him a new and more suitable home before his lovely nature is ruined.

Swipe left for the next trending thread