Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I just really hate her and i feel stuck

142 replies

Sugarspiceandeverythingnice · 14/06/2022 00:40

Without going into to much detail as i dont want to be outed...me and husband have 3 very young kids and recently bought a house which needs complete renovation. Still living in our old house but paying bills/mortgage on the new property and husband has suggested moving in with the in laws.
Now ideally this would be better as we would be saving on rent etc but i really really really really dont like my mil. She is controlling and interfering and is so manipulative. We lived with them very early on in the marriage and it caused endless arguments but we were young and newly married so maybe things might be different now. Me and the husband have had a pretty heated argument this evening because of her...i said no to moving in with her to her over the weekend and she has gone and twisted my words and made it all about her. I cant tell my husband how much i hate her because he adores her and is a mummys boy and its my word against hers. I sound like a bitch i know i do but the thought of going there even for a year (max) is filling me with dread and anxiety and I feel stuck. So not to drip feed..i dont work he is the soul earner in the house. He has paid for and bought said house therefore i feel stuck because if i say no he/ his family are making me seem like this ungrateful cow. And now after todays argument because of her i just feel even more adamant on not moving out. I just csnt cope with the stress of her/kids/him. Please help me feel better about this crappy situation.

OP posts:
diddl · 14/06/2022 09:26

It’s all very well to talk bout pensions etc, I agree that is important but when you’re looking at going to work and it’s costing money, instead of increasing the household income it doesn’t make sense.

Well certainly not if the purpose is more money to finance a renovation project!

SecretVictoria · 14/06/2022 09:24

I wish people would stop saying that childcare is a joint expense on threads like these. The OP clearly means that her earnings wouldn’t contribute more to the pot; if she works and earns say, £25k, childcare for 3 would be £25k and so as a family they’re no better off. In fact, could be worse off after commuting costs, work clothes etc.

It’s all very well to talk bout pensions etc, I agree that is important but when you’re looking at going to work and it’s costing money, instead of increasing the household income it doesn’t make sense.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 14/06/2022 09:24

I don't disagree with the fact he doesn't realise her worth, but it is pointless to suggest they would be better off financially unless OP can earn more than the cost of the childcare, and the cost of getting to and from work.
Whilst it might help him appreciate her contribution more, it will not provide a solution to her problem of living with MIL.

Wexone · 14/06/2022 09:22

@pitterypattery00 totally agree we have built one house and renovated another house, we are now in the process of building again. My partner is a builder he refuses to move into a house until its fully livable. For a few reasons, one its harder to finish jobs when you live in the house and your might never get them done, another is your home is your sanctuary and where you need to rest sleep etc, it can have a huge affect on your health and how you live, especially in this case with three young children. We have sold our house while we build and am living in a small rented house, its not perfect but to me far better than living with my in laws or a mobile home. In this case you need to have a serious chat with your husband, as people say you are a team, He needs to be seeing things from your point of view. Is there an option to rent smaller near your house? If your mother in laws house is big is there an option to divide a section off temporarily? So you have a door you can close off ? This was an option we looked out ourselves, as in laws house was big, so we would have our own living room, bedroom, bathroom and a small kitchen we could use

BigSandyBalls2015 · 14/06/2022 09:21

Are you in Ireland OP?

SaintJavelin · 14/06/2022 09:20

Kennykenkencat · 14/06/2022 09:15

I'm a bit concerned that you say if you worked all your wages would go on childcare, why is this? Childcare is the responsibility of BOTH parents, not just the mother. If you got a job you'd have to share paying for the childcare, proportionally

Even if childcare and bills were split equally it doesn’t mean that as a family they will get more money. If money is split equally after bills etc then with an extra income that is being eaten up in childcare the money is still the same.

Exactly this, our bills inc childcare all come out of the joint pot but it doesn't mean I'm making much money once I contribute to the pot every month, all of my husband's wages go in and 80% of mine.

Riverlee · 14/06/2022 09:16

You’ve not even moved in with her yet and the situation isn’t working. Do not move in!

can you get a couple of rooms liveable in your new house you can live in these whilst rest is being done?

Kennykenkencat · 14/06/2022 09:15

I'm a bit concerned that you say if you worked all your wages would go on childcare, why is this? Childcare is the responsibility of BOTH parents, not just the mother. If you got a job you'd have to share paying for the childcare, proportionally

Even if childcare and bills were split equally it doesn’t mean that as a family they will get more money. If money is split equally after bills etc then with an extra income that is being eaten up in childcare the money is still the same.

Summerwhereareyou · 14/06/2022 09:13

Sweeny op is in a hidden work situation.
Unfortunately we are increasingly becoming a society where only being paid with money means something has any value.
So if op starts to get paid and he has to look at the cost of looking after his DC he may understand her value.

Some people understand the cost of everything and the value of nothing.
Unfortunately society seems to be moving in this direction.

Summerwhereareyou · 14/06/2022 09:10

Also I feel sad that you don't seem to think you are contributing here because he's working.

I feel sad that you can't value or he can't ,your contribution. Maybe you should start making moves to work so he can see how much child care is, then the pick up and drop off.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 14/06/2022 09:06

Why does someone always put the DH will be responsible for half the childcare bills? Yes he will but the OP will also be responsible for contributing to the other bills and the renovations so they won't be any better off financially. It will get her out of the house though

Summerwhereareyou · 14/06/2022 09:06

Drhf. Good post.

Agree op shouldn't have to be explain in such efforts like this.

Maybe it's not been made clear enough. All these decisions and dreams are his not yours so why can't he compromise. I guess he doesn't have too because he's in full control.

Living on site will be so much easier and with these projects they run on. I can imagine a year turning into 2

BrendaHope · 14/06/2022 09:04

Please do not move in with your in laws for a year.

We lived with my own mother for six months whilst in the process of buying/selling, and it was really, really stressful.

Can you scale back your rennovation plans? There must be ways you can cut costs, economise? Do the essentials but get a more budget friendly kitchen for example?

Xx

Hankunamatata · 14/06/2022 09:00

Friend brought a chalet bungalow- moveable type and put it in the garden while renovating. Meant everyone had a bedroom and enough space

buckeejit · 14/06/2022 09:00

Agree to leave her out of it. Would your dh move in with your family or any other family for a year? You need your own space, it's a massive imposition which even if offered may cause tension down the line. Unless you have your own kitchen, living are & bathroom, basically a separate wing where you don't need to see the others, it would be a no from me.

Hankunamatata · 14/06/2022 08:59

Could you fit a static caravan in the garden of new house? I think I'd go for that option over living with inlaws.
I adore mil but couldnt live with her. But late but I'd say to dh that you value your relationship with mil and dont want to risk damaging it by living with them.

GoldenSongbird · 14/06/2022 08:58

If your DH sells the old house - instead of moving in with MIL, can you not rent somewhere smaller and closer to the house you're refurbishing or as a PP said put a caravan or park home beside the house you're refurbishing.
If you have equity in the old house can you not remortgage or take a loan against the value of the old house?
Alternatively, can you suggest you all move in with one of your relatives? That may help your DH to see your pov about living with his DM. I wouldn't live with my MIL with three young DCs.

Cocowatermelon · 14/06/2022 08:57

Can you frame it as saving your relationship with MIL?
You’ve done this before, and it didn’t work well. You both get on much better when you both have your own space in separate houses. You don’t want to fight with your MIL or about your MIL and that’s so much easier to do when you’re not trying to live together. You enjoy (possible white lie) the stable respectful relationship you’ve been able to build since living in separate houses and you don’t want to jeopardize that.

Marlaah · 14/06/2022 08:50

I cant tell my husband how much i hate her because he adores her and is a mummys boy and its my word against hers. I sound like a bitch i know i do but the thought of going there even for a year (max) is filling me with dread and anxiety and I feel stuck.

Do you have childcare? If not, could you afford it so you can get a p/t job, or a course etc to get you out of their house? Will you have transport? Again, it’s another means of minimising time with her. I don’t envy you, OP, I wouldn’t be happy with this arrangement.

Sswhinesthebest · 14/06/2022 08:49

Just use the argument that it’s never a good idea for women to share kitchens. No matter how well they get on to begin with, it always ends badly. You’d prefer to keep the “good” relationship you have with her now, rather than things deteriorate to the point of divorce.
Remind him, he’s out of the house working and it’s you that will be at home potentially clashing with other people in the house and then he’ll have to bear the fallout from that when he gets home from work. If he values his relationship with you and values your relationship with his family, then he must realise it’s not a good idea. Don’t make it personal to mil. Make sure you point out this would be a problem with anyone you live with, even your own mother, as everyone has their ways and styles that will inevitably clash at points.

KingofLoss · 14/06/2022 08:48

Some things are worth more than money, and peace of mind is one of them. I get on fine with my MIL and I'd divorce DH over move in with in-laws if it came down to it. I just couldn't. Couldn't share my space with someone like that, let alone if I didn't love and get along like a house on fire with them!

I'm a bit concerned that you say if you worked all your wages would go on childcare, why is this? Childcare is the responsibility of BOTH parents, not just the mother. If you got a job you'd have to share paying for the childcare, proportionally.

Spohn · 14/06/2022 08:38

Childcare costs are the responsibility of both parents. You’d be contributing to your pension and not being dependent on your husband, and not be dependent on his mother to house you all- win/win.

Afterfire · 14/06/2022 08:38

I agree that the mil is secondary.

You have some very odd views about this new house / finances- just because your dh works and you don’t it doesn’t mean it’s any less your house. You’re contributing in other ways and the house will be considered a martial asset - it will be considered 50/50 yours regardless of whether he’s the one paying for it on paper or not. It sounds like you don’t see yourself as equal to him- and that’s also impacting on your ability to tell him no when it comes to his Mum!

VodselForDinner · 14/06/2022 08:37

YABU.

No matter what your relationship is like, you’ve ended up in this situation by choice. It sounds like she’s being hugely generous to even offer.

Just don’t move in with her- job done. I’m sure she’d prefer to not have extra people in her house.

Jakeyachey · 14/06/2022 08:34

I would love to work but our kida are young and all my wages would end up going on childcare if i did

how come? Why wouldn’t he pay half? Plus it would get you out th house during the day lessening the impact plus give you financial independence.

Swipe left for the next trending thread