Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To insist DC get christened even though it will cause huge fight in my marriage?

206 replies

probabyam · 13/06/2022 13:55

Before we got married/had kids we didn't really talk about religion much. Neither of us go to church, however both have been christened. I'm Irish so went to a Catholic school and although we didn't really go to church as a family it was part of my life. DH was christened (Protestant) but actively anti any religion/thinks it's all mental.

When we got engaged I liked the idea of a church wedding but he was very against it so as it wasn't as if I attended church I didn't really feel I could insist and we had a lovely wedding we both loved, no regrets/issues.

Have had two DC, now ages 2 and 4. I would have liked to get them christened as babies (having godparents for them is something I would have liked) but DH against and again I wasn't bothered enough to push.

Now I feel like I wish we had got them christened. Most of my friends children have been christened (though none seem to attend church regularly). Part of me just likes the idea of godparents but another bit of me has a worry like a what if kind of thing, we're both christened why aren't they!
DH still massively against but yet again it seems to be a thing where the person who doesn't want it gets their way (another example is wanting more kids).

Anyway not sure that makes sense but are your kids christened and if so, do you go to church/mass?

OP posts:
Darbs76 · 14/06/2022 06:47

All my friends children are christened and none attend Sunday school / church. I personally don’t agree with this but plenty do it.

I have 3 children, 1 when I was young and 2 with DP (ex). I had my eldest christened, I used to attend church then and I took him to Sunday school from age 3 ish every week until I moved house when he was 7. My ex DP is a different religion to me so although I’d have liked my younger children to be christened it wasn’t something that was possible, as I wouldn’t agree to any kind of ceremony as part of his religion either. So they’ve been raised as no particular religion but they do celebrate festivals / events on both sides. They are old enough to choose now but haven’t as yet, and might never pick a particular religion to be part of.

speak to your DH again, explain why it’s important to you, or consider a naming day where you appoint friends who take on a similar role to a god parent.

onlythreenow · 14/06/2022 06:40

OP you are perfectly entitled to want to have your children baptised - it's nothing to do with anyone on MN! If you feel strongly about it I would suggest you tell your husband that it is not up to him to make all the rules, and he got his way over the wedding. Why should his wishes trump yours all the time?

Wisenotboring · 14/06/2022 06:37

When a child is baptised, the parents and God parents make some pretty serious promises around raising them into the Christian faith. Would you honestly feel happy standing in a church and making those promises knowing you have no intention of keeping them. That seems pretty disrespectful to be honest. An alternative to a baptism is a thanksgiving ceremony which you can also have in church. It isn't laden with the same promises, but you would be able to select God parents and connect with your local church. Likewise, there are completely secular naming ceremonies that you can do in a hotel or other venue.

alanabennett · 14/06/2022 01:43

ofwarren · 13/06/2022 13:59

My kids are all Baptised and we all go to church. I've never understood the point otherwise. Why get Baptised into a religion that you don't believe or follow?

Same with us. It was very important to me and we are hugely connected to our church community. To be honest, it sounds as though like many people you want the photos and the fancy cake (from the first page of the thread, at least) but you don't seem interested in actually being a Christian and actively being part of a church.

WordOfTheDay · 14/06/2022 00:44

Also, OP is what is often referred to as culturally Catholic. I, for instance, am an atheist, but recognise that I am culturally Catholic. In Ireland, it is still a much-loved tradition to punctuate family life with celebrations based on the sacraments, even if all those directly involved consider religion to be clap-trap (there are always plenty of relatives, etc. in attendance who do believe the religious significance at these events). The adults enjoy church weddings and christenings and children and parents enjoy the new outfits and hitting the milestone of Holy Communion and Confirmation. I don’t know how the non-believers square it all in their minds. I think they just see it all as traditional rites of passage, and as school-type events (a bit like junior proms) in the case of the later two.

For those asking what is the point of godparents if you are not raising the child in the faith. Well, you can honour family members and friends by asking them to be a godparent to your child, others can honour you by asking you to be the godparent of their child. Each godparent gives a lovely christening gift to the child. Often they each send a birthday and Christmas card to the child annually for ever more. Some will send a birthday and Christmas gift for ever more. I am a godmother. I do almost nothing as godmother, but I have remembered my nominal god-daughter in a small way in my will.

You can imagine that, culturally, the OP is a little conflicted about missing out on these cultural celebrations for her children and not having the little extra links for them of giving them godparents.

WordOfTheDay · 14/06/2022 00:15

OP, if you want your children (and you) to have more of a connection to their Irish side, you could enrol them in Irish dancing classes locally in the UK, or classes to learn to play a traditional instrument, e.g. the tin whistle, the fiddle, harp, accordion, concertina, banjo, bodhrán. [Music lessons in UK linked to Comhaltas Ceoltóirí Éireann listed here for instance, Comhaltas.

You could also sign them up at your local GAA club in the UK, if you have one, to learn to play Gaelic football, hurling or camogie.GAA Clubs in Britain

You can get lovely books of Irish fairytales and stories from Irish mythology to read to/with them. You can watch Irish TV programmes with them on RTÉ Player. As they get older, you can add in a cultural component to your visits to Ireland, visiting the famous historical sites, places of natural beauty, sightseeing, etc.

You could start a thread on the Craicnet section of Mumsnet to discuss ideas with other UK-based mammies.

Dougalneedsahaircut · 13/06/2022 23:15

AryaStarkWolf · 13/06/2022 14:42

I believe in heaven and wanted my children baptised so that if anything happened to them they would go to heaven

This whole attitude is what gets right under my skin when it comes to organised religion, on the one hand you have a God who is responsible for creating all humans, he is loving and kind and on the other he will refuse a baby entry to heaven if their parents didn't baptise them.

No where in the Bible does it say an infant won’t get into Heaven if they are not baptised. In fact, you won’t find any infants getting baptised at all. You can teach your children the gospel but no one is born a Christian, at some point you have make your own choice to follow Jesus.

spanishmumireland · 13/06/2022 22:40

flurryofcurry · 13/06/2022 19:53

@spanishmumireland that priority rule for baptised children getting into schools was abolished in 2019 as far as I'm aware. I agree it was one reason for people in Ireland getting their kids baptised. Be interesting to see if baptismal rates have declined since the rule was changed.

It was supposed to be abolished a few years ago but it still stands. What it really shocks me is that nobody in Ireland says anything at all.
My children go to the local national school (public) and children don't have a choice if they decide they aren't making their communion, unless they literally leave the school during mass and attend religion class.
In Spain you have the choice of "Values" class, (in my day was called "Ethics"). Here basically kids not attending mass have to be collected by their parents during mass hours (which is in the middle of the school day, any random day in the week). To start with this happens as part of the curriculum in the public school.
In my kids class there are a majority of catholics, or kids with catholic parents, few muslims, and budists. They all sit in the class during religion. They are not allowed to do anything else like going to the library. So same crap still stands. And in a very Irish was nobody says a thing. I raised this a few times in the mums school group. Radio silence.

ThisisMax · 13/06/2022 21:18

Im Irish and we call this 'a la carte catholicism'

Melassa · 13/06/2022 20:51

My DM was anxious about my DC not being christened, but it was more her Catholic guilt and superstition than anything else.

I had religion inflicted on me by my DM who herself suffered at the hands of vicious nuns when growing up, and I hated it, so there was no way I was inflicting that on my DC. Plus why indoctrinate a female child in a patriarchal medieval religion that doesn’t value women?

I’ve not banned religion but I believe that it is something that should be decided in adulthood, or in late childhood but only if the child understands and has all the facts. I live in a Catholic country and there is a huge thing around catechism classes and communion here and after school at primary everyone disappears one day a week for2 years. I asked my DC if they wanted to participate so they weren’t left out but it was a resounding no.

If they want to get married in a church later on the local churches do a baptism, communion and confirmation package in a week, for a fee of course. I guess that indulgences never quite went away!

Fenella123 · 13/06/2022 20:31

OP would there be any problem in having a non-religious naming ceremony with the would-have--been-godparents having some sort of special role? Family party, nod to special people in the family, and if anyone asks from your side, I guess, say you and DH had agreed that the DC should make their own religious choices when they were older (or some such)?

Quincythequince · 13/06/2022 20:26

DogsAndGin · 13/06/2022 19:49

By not getting them Christened, you’re not making any statement or promise about how you intend to raise the children. But by getting them Christened, you’re asking DH to make a promise that he does not believe in and does not intend to keep. So, that is why he ‘wins’. You can have your beliefs, but you can’t enforce them on others.

I completely agree with this.

Quincythequince · 13/06/2022 20:24

ButtonSister · 13/06/2022 13:58

You can carry out a diy baptism. We were taught how to by the nuns at my Catholic school.
But what are your reasons for wanting a christening?

You can of course do this, but why would you if your DH disagrees?

It’s a pile of crap anyway, so I suppose it doesn’t matter much, but why not just let them decide what religion, if any, they want when they’re older.

If you were a militant church goer, I would get it more, but you’re not.

Why do you even care?

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 13/06/2022 20:14

I'm a fairy god mother. I couldnt be godmother because I havent been christened. Her parents werent bothered by my lack of religion because they go to church and have got it covered. They just wanted someone who would love her.

Have you named a guardian for them? Might that assuade some of your feelings?

Or a non religious naming ceremony?

BOOTS52PollyPrissyPants · 13/06/2022 20:07

Not true about the schools in Ireland as my son went to a school that was a religious school and no issue and religion was not shoved down his neck like it was when I was in school. He still went to mass if there was a school mass so wasn't or didn't feel left out. The only people who gave me grief about my son not making communion or confirmation was stuck up mum's/hypocrites who only went to mass before those events to look good and because they had to. Nowadays no one gives a damn as isn't nuns in schools now or priests really and so many young teachers. They can always choose to get christened themselves when they are older if you do not do it. When the mums were asking me why my son was not making his communion I told them straight out because I am not going to be a hypocrite just going to mass before communion and then not going. People do not care about religion anymore and soon will not be a part of any curriculum. In my son's secondary they did all religions which was more like history and very interesting so no one excluded. Hope you make the right decision for you and your family and maybe go and talk to a priest about it. I do know in the U.K. you will get into a Catholic school only if child is christened but when I lived in U.K.I did not send my son to a Catholic School, could think of nothing worse.

flurryofcurry · 13/06/2022 19:53

@spanishmumireland that priority rule for baptised children getting into schools was abolished in 2019 as far as I'm aware. I agree it was one reason for people in Ireland getting their kids baptised. Be interesting to see if baptismal rates have declined since the rule was changed.

NotKevinTurvey · 13/06/2022 19:53

OP, how do you know that they will choose Christianity? There are all sorts of religions available, is it not a bit off to jump in like this before they can weigh up the options themselves?

DogsAndGin · 13/06/2022 19:49

By not getting them Christened, you’re not making any statement or promise about how you intend to raise the children. But by getting them Christened, you’re asking DH to make a promise that he does not believe in and does not intend to keep. So, that is why he ‘wins’. You can have your beliefs, but you can’t enforce them on others.

ApplesandBunions · 13/06/2022 19:45

probabyam · 13/06/2022 19:39

@ApplesandBunions yep, not Irish! And I suppose now raising my kids here they are more English than anything and I would love just that touch of home, though we do go back to see family as much as we can.

Thought as much! The difficulty I suppose is that one of the best ways to get access to other families of Irish heritage for your children to be around is still Catholicism, the schools if nothing else. And in your 30s with young DC, you're at a very common age for Irish people living in England to go back home, in my experience.

I think it would be worth talking to DH about this. Not necessarily framing it in terms of a desire for Catholic religious practice, because actually I'm not sure that's the best way to describe what you're experiencing here, but the way you feel about wanting them to better know their roots.

probabyam · 13/06/2022 19:39

@ApplesandBunions yep, not Irish! And I suppose now raising my kids here they are more English than anything and I would love just that touch of home, though we do go back to see family as much as we can.

OP posts:
wafflyversatile · 13/06/2022 19:38

Not sure what you want for godparents. It doesn't create a great relationship or bond or have any sort of legal obligation and I doubt more than 4 godparents in the history of time have taken responsibility for the religious welfare of a godchild in the absence of their parents. Most people I know seem struggle to remember what relative or friend is their godparent.

Your partner has been consistently clear that this is something he actively does not want for his children so going behind his back for some amorphous desire for something something godparents doesn't really seem worth the ruction or loss of trust.

ApplesandBunions · 13/06/2022 19:34

I think overall it's what @ApplesandBunions and @icantgetno and @flurryofcurry @Choopi and @Ponderingwindow have touched on. I feel like it's more a tradition and a part of my culture and I think the older I've got the more significant that has felt. If we'd lived in Ireland I would have got them christened but seeing as we live in the U.K. and I have lived her since uni it wasn't in the forefront of my mind in my 20's. It feels more like a connection to home and culture although I do think that's changing at home too as many of my Irish friends from school have chosen not to baptise their babies which wouldn't have happened a few generations ago.

I had a feeling that might be it. Perhaps it's worth looking at other ways you can offer the children access to that part of their cultural heritage. By any chance is DH not Irish?

probabyam · 13/06/2022 19:30

@aloris thank you for this, it's in some ways spot on for how I've been feeling for a while and I will be exploring it further I think.
I appreciate the time you took to put that into words.

OP posts:
probabyam · 13/06/2022 19:29

Wow, I really didn't think this would have got as many answers so have just caught up on reading the whole thread!

I'll try and reply to the questions raised.

I think overall it's what @ApplesandBunions and @icantgetno and @flurryofcurry @Choopi and @Ponderingwindow have touched on. I feel like it's more a tradition and a part of my culture and I think the older I've got the more significant that has felt. If we'd lived in Ireland I would have got them christened but seeing as we live in the U.K. and I have lived her since uni it wasn't in the forefront of my mind in my 20's. It feels more like a connection to home and culture although I do think that's changing at home too as many of my Irish friends from school have chosen not to baptise their babies which wouldn't have happened a few generations ago.

It's nothing to do with schooling, they are already signed up for the school they'll attend.

I think the godparent bit was musing and I didn't think it out properly, I suppose it's a big deal to some at home as part of the ceremony and that's what I meant. It would probably be an Aunty and uncle (as in my Aunty/uncle) or friend from school.

I think as others have said I need to think of it more and it most likely won't happen.

I do feel that faith or at least the values and the community that go with it are something I miss but maybe something I need to let go of.

Thanks for all the replies

OP posts:
Cherrysoup · 13/06/2022 19:22

For your Instagram?! Unless you are strongly religious and want to induct them into the religion (which you’ve denied) then just why? Having gone through the Catholic system, I think it’s awful to force a religion on a child, plus you seem to want a baptism for no good reason. I’m godparent to multiple dc that I no longer see, we moved and just fell out of contact.