Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To insist DC get christened even though it will cause huge fight in my marriage?

206 replies

probabyam · 13/06/2022 13:55

Before we got married/had kids we didn't really talk about religion much. Neither of us go to church, however both have been christened. I'm Irish so went to a Catholic school and although we didn't really go to church as a family it was part of my life. DH was christened (Protestant) but actively anti any religion/thinks it's all mental.

When we got engaged I liked the idea of a church wedding but he was very against it so as it wasn't as if I attended church I didn't really feel I could insist and we had a lovely wedding we both loved, no regrets/issues.

Have had two DC, now ages 2 and 4. I would have liked to get them christened as babies (having godparents for them is something I would have liked) but DH against and again I wasn't bothered enough to push.

Now I feel like I wish we had got them christened. Most of my friends children have been christened (though none seem to attend church regularly). Part of me just likes the idea of godparents but another bit of me has a worry like a what if kind of thing, we're both christened why aren't they!
DH still massively against but yet again it seems to be a thing where the person who doesn't want it gets their way (another example is wanting more kids).

Anyway not sure that makes sense but are your kids christened and if so, do you go to church/mass?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WordOfTheDay · 15/06/2022 11:57

Hi OP,

I'm really happy my post is helpful😊. I forgot one other aspect. If you'd like to teach the children the cúpla focal for fun, this little website has been produced especially to help parents do just that. It sets out some fun words and phrases to use with kiddies in the home, etc. Irish for in the home

probabyam · 15/06/2022 11:20

Thank you for your suggestions @WordOfTheDay I will defo look into those.

I think what you've said about being 'culturally Catholic' really sums it up for me. I also think it's very hard for people who aren't Irish to understand the cultural elements of the religion and how they can be such an intrinsic part of your history and upbringing but at the same time be something where the tides are turning for a younger generation of Irish people and navigating that is something very specific.

OP posts:
SpringBadger · 15/06/2022 09:58

aloris · 13/06/2022 17:53

My question would be, why does this issue keep raising itself in your mind. Do you have some inner feeling that you actually would like to raise your kids Christian? Do you, yourself, wish for some aspect of being Christian?

Baptism is not a magic formula so much as the beginning of their relationship with Christ. So if your desire to baptise them results from an inner belief that God really does exist, then that is what you should focus on, not on the rite of baptism itself. Maybe what you want to do is teach them about Christ, some prayers, etc. If you start reading more material about Catholicism now you will see that the way catechesis has developed is a lot warmer and fuzzier than it was in our day. This is a real thing, it's not just something that comes from liberal Catholics misinterpreting the faith to their own ends. Children still require some concrete teaching because they are concrete thinkers by nature at young ages, but adults get a more metaphorical/philosophical view of theological issues, and there is more openness to people being on a path towards understanding.

If this were me, I think my focus would really be, what is this telling me about my own internal faith needs. Maybe you actually want to return to some active practice of Christianity. If you do, then that is your natural right, whether or not you "agreed" with your husband to be religious before you married. However, in terms of baptising your children, the priest will likely be reluctant to do so unless your husband is on board. In fact, it may be that the permission form for baptism requires both parents to sign it.

Great post. OP I think you're in an awkward spot now because the children are old enough to be aware of their baptism but not old enough to choose it. Given that your husband is already anti, it risks making the kids feel like pawns in an argument they don't understand. However, please don't be dismayed at all the posts telling you to brush your feelings under the carpet and that it's all a lot of nonsense. It's completely normal to have an attachment to your culture and the faith you were raised in, and to want to pass that on to your children. Explore it. You will find so much more in it as an adult. It might be that you realise it's not for you, but it might be that there are elements you wish to keep or develop. Your children will always have your example, and you have every right to share these things with them so they are at least aware. Cultural and religious understanding is a good thing. I also think that the concept of faith itself is good to understand. A lot of posters say "let them choose a religion when they are older", which makes it sound like it's just a case of flipping through a catalogue and finding one you like the sound of, whereas actually these things are deeply bound up with our own family relationships and traditions. Yes, they have freedom to choose, but you don't need to keep them in a state of ignorance to achieve that, or pretend that you're completely impartial. Your husband certainly isn't impartial!

LakieLady · 15/06/2022 09:12

I think having children christened or baptised when you're not religious is incredibly hypocritical, tbh, so YABU.

Have a naming ceremony and guide parents.

ChairPose9to5 · 15/06/2022 09:05

flurryofcurry · 13/06/2022 15:24

I think you being Irish is the most relevant part of your post. Almost everyone here gets their kids christened even if they are openly atheist. It's cultural rather than religious. I completely disagree with signing children up to a faith if you don't practice it or follow it in any way. You're technically Catholic but not really so I'm with your husband on this one.

Yes, I was living in the UK with a British bf and he was anti-christenings and forbade the idea. Made me sad. Traditions were important to me. When I left him the first thing I tried to do was to get them christened. One a toddler and one ready for school. I'm C of I not catholic but in my mind, although not religious, it just felt so SHABBY and embarrassing not to have arranged christenings for my children. I had them christened in my home parish and c of I rector was very wise, advised me to wait a while so that I knew it wasn't a reaction to what my x didn't want. Advised me to sit with it all for a while. Which I did. They are christened and I'm glad. We're not particularly religious and I'm really glad that schools have been prevented from prioritising children whose parents arranged a christening. But yet, on a really visceral level that I can't explain I am glad they are christened. My eldest made her confirmation but the younger one refused. So they did have choice to do what they wanted to do.

Sparro · 15/06/2022 08:59

bozna · 15/06/2022 01:59

I grew up going to church with my mum and grandma. I never had the same beliefs but I got my kids christened because it was important to them really. And my husband supported me because we respect our families beliefs

You can respect others beliefs without promising to raise your children in a religion you don't follow.

FoiledByTheInsect · 15/06/2022 05:15

Yabu, I allowed my dc to be christened to keep the peace, but my face on the christening photos says it all: not deliberately, I just couldn't take any of it seriously.

Both parents have to agree on this otherwise it's pretty meaningless.

kateandme · 15/06/2022 04:17

Having them christened doesn't mean your force g them into anything!They can perfectly grow up bro g non Christian.no faith.its one day and they aren't branded with a sign that mean they give off I've been baptised alarms when they meet people. It coùlf be completely forgotten if they wanted.
It's not parents forcing them.that always sounds so grim.we make kids do things all the time when they are little,as part of family life or for what we think their good or even our good! Doesn't make the parent horrors.doesnt cause trauma to the child.
Op u sound like you still have some faith,or at least want to or still feel that connection.so your allowed to want this to happen.it won't harm them AT ALL.and it's part of your family and home and that ok.
Faith brings out often on here two very opposing views op, the bits on between often never ventured so it might be hard to get a reasoned answer from others.
You can have faith.you can get baptised without being devote,church going,cult faith believer!
And it's also a nice option for you kids to have in the future,they either don't mention it again or they do have faith by choice.and like knowing they have been baptised.and chosen right having godparents can be one of the loveliest things

youlightupmyday · 15/06/2022 02:36

I would be furious if my partner baptised my children especially after marrying me knowing my views. But then I am similar to OP's DH, not only am I atheist - I am vehemently anti religion.

Marty13 · 15/06/2022 02:07

Also if I married a partner and had children with them with the understanding that we were a non-religious family, I'd be really pissed off if they turned the table and tried to get our kids baptized.

If the kids want to get baptized when they're old enough to decide for themselves (not before 16 for me) that's fine.

Marty13 · 15/06/2022 02:05

I'm an atheist.

My kids have civil godparents. Not sure how to explain it but it's basically a non-religious ceremony where godparents (for want of a better word) make a commitment to the child. This has no legal value (as in, godparents wouldn't get custody if I died) but it's a real ceremony done in the city hall and it's a real (albeit purely voluntary) commitment.

This fits my beliefs and I like the thought that my kids have two people they can turn to for help/advice.

So if you just want the godparent aspect of it maybe consider a non-religious ceremony ?

bozna · 15/06/2022 02:02

Owlilac · 14/06/2022 22:24

Personally I don't consider church attendance as some qualifier for being Christian and think you can be Christian without attending church regularly or even at all. If you believe in Jesus then that's l that really makes you one.

@Owlilac my understanding is if god exists he loves every person equally regardless of they believe on him or not so you can choose your beliefs

bozna · 15/06/2022 01:59

I grew up going to church with my mum and grandma. I never had the same beliefs but I got my kids christened because it was important to them really. And my husband supported me because we respect our families beliefs

LicoricePizza · 15/06/2022 01:41

Don’t mean to derail but if you haven’t been christened/baptised can you still be buried in a church??
Never thought about it til now. Like couples like to be buried in same plot or parents, families together??

NotKevinTurvey · 14/06/2022 23:15

Owlilac · 14/06/2022 22:24

Personally I don't consider church attendance as some qualifier for being Christian and think you can be Christian without attending church regularly or even at all. If you believe in Jesus then that's l that really makes you one.

So any historian who thinks he existed as a historical figure is Christian, even if he’s moslem?

Owlilac · 14/06/2022 22:24

Personally I don't consider church attendance as some qualifier for being Christian and think you can be Christian without attending church regularly or even at all. If you believe in Jesus then that's l that really makes you one.

Toddlerteaplease · 14/06/2022 14:35

ofwarren · 13/06/2022 13:59

My kids are all Baptised and we all go to church. I've never understood the point otherwise. Why get Baptised into a religion that you don't believe or follow?

This!

Badnewsoracle · 14/06/2022 14:26

I am Christened, I am a Christian and I am regular church attender however my children are not christened. I believe it should be a choice they make when old enough. I bring them up in the Christian church family but do not describe them as Christian or enforce the belief on them - our conversations go "some people believe God created the world, other believe xyz" etc. I believe that infant baptism has no impact on a child's soul, all children's souls go to God should the worst happen (which I think is a concern you are alluding to).

AryaStarkWolf · 14/06/2022 10:57

onlythreenow · 14/06/2022 06:40

OP you are perfectly entitled to want to have your children baptised - it's nothing to do with anyone on MN! If you feel strongly about it I would suggest you tell your husband that it is not up to him to make all the rules, and he got his way over the wedding. Why should his wishes trump yours all the time?

You say that like we all barged into her house and started telling her what to do with her child and not that we're replying to a thread she started asking for opinions...........

In regards to her husband and him getting his way all the time seems like he married the OP under the impression she wasn't religious and therefore their future children wouldn't be forced into a religion either

NotKevinTurvey · 14/06/2022 10:33

onlythreenow · 14/06/2022 06:40

OP you are perfectly entitled to want to have your children baptised - it's nothing to do with anyone on MN! If you feel strongly about it I would suggest you tell your husband that it is not up to him to make all the rules, and he got his way over the wedding. Why should his wishes trump yours all the time?

Because she’s forcing her baby to join a religion that she herself doesn’t follow, and that she has no idea that the child would choose.

She’ll have to promise that she will ensure that the child it taught to be a Christian.

themusicmum · 14/06/2022 10:29

Not worth it.

BorisJohnsonsvomitbucket · 14/06/2022 07:01

My mum and dad got my brother and I christened as babies back in the late 70s/early 80s, but they admit now it was nothing to do with presenting us to the Church Family, and more to do with family tradition. Neither my brother nor I know our godparents (I think most have died now).

My brother is agnostic and I'm a hard-line atheist. Neither of us christened our kids. If we knew about them, we'd probably have Naming Days and then had a party afterwards.

I think christening/confirming a child should be done when they fully understand the ramifications. They have to believe in God and the Holy Trinity, they have to want to attend church, they want to follow the rules and rituals. I never think imposing a religion on a child is a good idea. In OPs case maybe she should take the kids to church regularly and see if they want to join when they are older, not for cultural reasons, but for spiritual reasons.

teezletangler · 14/06/2022 06:58

Is this about wanting the DC to experience and have fuller access to their cultural heritage? Definitely sounds like there's a bit of that in there, especially if by any chance you're not living in Ireland any more.

This is an astute comment. MN is weird about baptism- it's virulently anti-baptism and church wedding unless you're in the pews every week, which totally ignores the fact that religion is hugely cultural for a lot of people, especially in Ireland I'd imagine.

My family is very Anglican (so many clergy relatives!) and I got married in a church and both DC are christened despite me being a very occasional church goer only. DH grew up C of E but is agnostic now. I love the tradition and I have a lot of loyalty to the "tribe" of the church rather than being a true believer. I don't think there's anything wrong with that.

Alittlenonsensenowandthen · 14/06/2022 06:55

I'm a Practicing Christian and my children are not christened. I hope one day they will also choose to be a Christian and get baptised.
Think it would be good to explore your feelings on this one. If you think they'll be 'saved' by christening for example.

I think having children does cause us to question what we think spiritually. Nothing wrong with exploring the Bible, re evaluating what you were brought up with etc? Could do an alpha course?

Cocowatermelon · 14/06/2022 06:47

In France they do civil baptisms. It’s a little ceremony and you name ´godparents’ (the name is not obviously religious in French.
). It’s a proper legal ceremony and the godparents formally agree to become legal guardians in the event of the death of both parents and I think any living grandparents get to offer to be the children’s guardians first.
In the UK you might have to write wills or something instead. But if it’s the godparent part that’s important to you, or the party, or both, they are ways of doing that that don’t involve religion.