Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can you dictate what people call your child? Or is that unreasonable?

208 replies

cocorum · 13/06/2022 12:20

MIL keeps calling DD first and middle name, every time. Both long names. Sounds ridiculous. There's no hyphen. It's two names. In fact, she has three.

Can I ask her to stop ? Or is that mean ? I hate it. Child is a small baby.

OP posts:
over2021 · 13/06/2022 13:19

Nurseynoodles · 13/06/2022 12:25

My Nan did that to me her whole life, I remember it fondly. No one else ever called me the same thing. It was a nickname just for her.

Same. Not my Nan but a friend of mum's mum. She's the only person I can recall EVER saying my middle name out loud except for the vicar and my husband at our wedding!

I think YABU OP, presumably you like both names as you chose them?

My actual man called my brother a completely different name for about 5 years because she didn't like my mum and dad's choice - that was unreasonable! SmileWink

Etinoxaurus · 13/06/2022 13:18

GlitteryGreen · 13/06/2022 12:38

It's absolutely not a misunderstanding. The names are so long. It's just because she wants to do it. As the middle one is a family name of hers.

@cocorum In that case, I'd 100% be directly bringing it up. I'd literally say "MIL, can you please stop calling her by her middle name as well? Her name is X, only. We don't want people think her first name is both".

Why would you do that?
That’s literally picking a fight.
MIL used to call dd1 first name middle name all the time.
Middle name is her deceased dms name; it’s obvious why she was doing it and understandable. No one else followed her lead, she rarely does it now 💁🏻‍♀️

Horizons123 · 13/06/2022 13:17

I had something similar with my first daughter and mother in law. I freaked out when mil's relative used first and middle name too so I brought it up there and then by pretending to politely clarify in case there had been a misunderstanding. It nipped it in the bud. Don't waste your time on overthinking/feeling guilty/trying to change your mindset on issues that make you uncomfortable. Do things your way and as time goes on you end up relaxing into things anyway ☺️

Sexnotgender · 13/06/2022 13:12

Honestly I think if you mention it she’ll double down and use it more as she knows it annoys you. Just ignore her and focus on your lovely new baby, hopefully she’ll stop it soon.

TheNoodlesIncident · 13/06/2022 13:12

Is it like Millicent Margaret Amanda? Grin And MIL is saying Millicent Margaret every time? I would remind her about the Amanda she's leaving off and pondering aloud what "Amanda" has done to deserve that 😈

I think the issues that would cheese me off most is that you compromised on the baby's name in the first place and that she doesn't do this with your eldest (presumably eldest also has a more than one name)...

saraclara · 13/06/2022 13:11

If your DH is also annoyed by it (despite the middle name being his preferred choice) any correction really needs to come from him. If you say anything to her it will just be seen as you rejecting the family name.

GabriellaMontez · 13/06/2022 13:11

So she knows you didn't want it but is persisting in using it. A kind of challenge to you. Disrespectful.

She'd go 'nuts' if you say something?

Then I'd say something. Soon. I'd probably start with asking why she's doing it and if she knows that baby is called correct name. Then ask her to stop because that's not the name you and dh have called her.
What you've named her is all that matters. You don't have to justify or explain further.

LadyCampanulaTottington · 13/06/2022 13:06

You literally gave the child those names and now are saying don’t use them? Only one is allowed?

cocorum · 13/06/2022 13:05

10HailMarys · 13/06/2022 13:03

If your child is a very small baby, I suspect there's a novelty factor here for your MIL and she'll probably get tired of it very soon, especially as your daughter gets older and will make it quite clear herself if she doesn't like it. I don't think other people will pick up on it - and if they do, you can say 'Oh, that isn't actually her name - MIL calls her that for some reason but her name's XXXXX' and it's job done.

I think it really depends on your relationship with your MIL. If you can make it jokey, like my family would have done, then you can say something, but I wouldn't be arsey about it and I wouldn't push it. It's not worth the fuss and ultimately, you can only ask her. You can't 'dictate' to her or force her.

You will definitely have to get used to other people calling your child different things as they get older, especially when she starts school - other kids might shorten her name in a way you don't like, and she might shorten it herself, or lengthen it, or prefer a nickname. It's not really something you can control. My family tends to use nicknames for each other a lot in an affectionate way (only if the actual person is OK with it, of course) and we call my teenage nephew by a nickname his dad (my brother) uses for him. Apparently my ex-SIL hates it. But nobody else calls him that - and he wouldn't anyone else to - and he's said many times that he likes it when we do it and he always signs cards etc to us by that name rather than his actual name. It doesn't erase his real name in any way, which is what literally everyone else calls him.

Yeah I'm aware that the names may change. It's just this one bugs me, as I know that the in laws wanted it as a first name and they know I didn't. I compromised by using it as a middle name and now it gets used anyway as a first name.

But yeah it will kick off if anything is mentioned !

OP posts:
cocorum · 13/06/2022 13:03

@LadyOfTheCanyon I think knowing the relationship with my MIL, she will go nuts if we say anything.

I will just have to swallow it down and continue using the name I actually intended. I think if we try to tell her not to do it, she'll go nuts.

OP posts:
10HailMarys · 13/06/2022 13:03

If your child is a very small baby, I suspect there's a novelty factor here for your MIL and she'll probably get tired of it very soon, especially as your daughter gets older and will make it quite clear herself if she doesn't like it. I don't think other people will pick up on it - and if they do, you can say 'Oh, that isn't actually her name - MIL calls her that for some reason but her name's XXXXX' and it's job done.

I think it really depends on your relationship with your MIL. If you can make it jokey, like my family would have done, then you can say something, but I wouldn't be arsey about it and I wouldn't push it. It's not worth the fuss and ultimately, you can only ask her. You can't 'dictate' to her or force her.

You will definitely have to get used to other people calling your child different things as they get older, especially when she starts school - other kids might shorten her name in a way you don't like, and she might shorten it herself, or lengthen it, or prefer a nickname. It's not really something you can control. My family tends to use nicknames for each other a lot in an affectionate way (only if the actual person is OK with it, of course) and we call my teenage nephew by a nickname his dad (my brother) uses for him. Apparently my ex-SIL hates it. But nobody else calls him that - and he wouldn't anyone else to - and he's said many times that he likes it when we do it and he always signs cards etc to us by that name rather than his actual name. It doesn't erase his real name in any way, which is what literally everyone else calls him.

cocorum · 13/06/2022 13:02

FlissyPaps · 13/06/2022 13:01

Why give your child a middle name if it annoys you when someone includes it when talking to/about them?

It's a middle name and it was a compromise as DH wanted it as a first name. Although it now annoys him as well that his mother uses it that way. As it was never intended to be used like that.

OP posts:
LadyOfTheCanyon · 13/06/2022 13:01

cocorum · 13/06/2022 12:58

@LadyOfTheCanyon it's not the first name !

but for better or worse you've given your child a name you're ok with. If it's that soul suckingly awful you should have vetoed it at the time.
I agree, pick your battles. It won't last forever and it will wear off over time and if it doesn't well then it's a nice bond between them.

cocorum · 13/06/2022 13:01

Arucanafeather · 13/06/2022 12:59

Would annoy me too! I can’t see an issue with saying, please don’t double barrel her name with one of her middle names.I would recommend the message comes from your DH.

My Mum dislikes the shortened names we use everyday for our kids and much prefers the longer version on their birth certificates. She couldn’t resist telling me this but she wouldn’t dream of doing anything else but call them by the names we use.

It might just be your MIL has no idea it is like nails scraping down a blackboard for you. If your DH gives her the message that you both prefer her to just use her given first name then persisting in what she’s currently doing is a boundary issue IMO, especially when the child is a teeny baby. Boundary issues with people who don’t automatically respect them never get better without you enforcing them yourself, I’ve found.

I feel the same goes when the child is old enough to have a preference. My DH only likes to called by a shortening of his name but his parents and their wider family insist on calling him the longer version despite him telling them of his preference. It’s rude and is one of many ways his parents demonstrate that they view him as their “possession” rather than a separate entity in his own right.

She knows I didn't want to use the name as a first name, like she would have wanted.

OP posts:
FlissyPaps · 13/06/2022 13:01

Why give your child a middle name if it annoys you when someone includes it when talking to/about them?

LateAF · 13/06/2022 12:59

cocorum · 13/06/2022 12:53

@LateAF baby has three names lol. And it was a compromise! I never in a million years though they would use both ( as they're so long and it sounds ridiculous ). I'm just going to have to grit my teeth. I don't see a nice way to get this across.

Fair enough - most people aren’t called by their middle name (except when they are in trouble).

I imagine once your child is old enough they will tell nana to stop calling them by their full name with the brutal honesty that only a young child can get away with. My mum used to sometimes call my eldest son by his brother’s name on accident and he would always correct her. After a few times of this, when he was 4 years old, he asked her if the reason she kept forgetting his name was X was because she’s really really old. She doesn’t mix them up quite so much anymore 😂

Arucanafeather · 13/06/2022 12:59

Would annoy me too! I can’t see an issue with saying, please don’t double barrel her name with one of her middle names.I would recommend the message comes from your DH.

My Mum dislikes the shortened names we use everyday for our kids and much prefers the longer version on their birth certificates. She couldn’t resist telling me this but she wouldn’t dream of doing anything else but call them by the names we use.

It might just be your MIL has no idea it is like nails scraping down a blackboard for you. If your DH gives her the message that you both prefer her to just use her given first name then persisting in what she’s currently doing is a boundary issue IMO, especially when the child is a teeny baby. Boundary issues with people who don’t automatically respect them never get better without you enforcing them yourself, I’ve found.

I feel the same goes when the child is old enough to have a preference. My DH only likes to called by a shortening of his name but his parents and their wider family insist on calling him the longer version despite him telling them of his preference. It’s rude and is one of many ways his parents demonstrate that they view him as their “possession” rather than a separate entity in his own right.

MercurialMonday · 13/06/2022 12:58

You could try correcting it every single time - but there might be a negative reactions.

So GM : Jenny Wren needs a hat
You: Jenny has a hat. Jenny likes the hat she has.

Other people would then stand a change of getting correct name - but it may not work and if it did would take ages and it would have to be every time and you could look petty - and as others say DD may end up liking both names from GM.

cocorum · 13/06/2022 12:58

@LadyOfTheCanyon it's not the first name !

OP posts:
LadyOfTheCanyon · 13/06/2022 12:57

BattenburgDonkey · 13/06/2022 12:35

I think you can suggest it but you can’t dictate it. You’ve literally just called your baby this though, so asking people not to use because you don’t like it seems a little
odd.

This!

BeatricePortinari · 13/06/2022 12:57

You seem to feel you're in some psychological power struggle with your MIL, and her use of the name represents some 'win' over you and you want to claim the power back by banning her from using it.

The best way to get out of psychological power struggle dynamics is to just not care, and not play the game.

Detach from the game and she's just left playing it on her own.

Then she's sad and twisted. Using a name to promote her ego.
And you're cool detached and focusing on other stuff.

Seriously you can choose whether to get caught up in this game or not.

Kanaloa · 13/06/2022 12:57

I’d just leave it. I mean in the grand scheme of things it’s not a big deal. When she goes to nursery she’ll be called what you introduce her as. When she goes to primary school she’ll be called what you write on the form. When she goes to secondary she’ll be called whatever she tells people to call her. By the time she’s four she’ll probably be saying ‘nanny I’m not Amelia Jennifer, I’m just Amelia!’ Or she’ll enjoy it as granny’s special name for her.

romdowa · 13/06/2022 12:54

I've a name such as Mary Jane. My first name is Mary, middle name Jane and there is a member of my family who insists on calling me mary-jane and it gets on my last nerve 🙄🙄 so I can understand why it annoys you as well.

cocorum · 13/06/2022 12:53

@LateAF baby has three names lol. And it was a compromise! I never in a million years though they would use both ( as they're so long and it sounds ridiculous ). I'm just going to have to grit my teeth. I don't see a nice way to get this across.

OP posts:
LateAF · 13/06/2022 12:51

cocorum · 13/06/2022 12:48

Also everyone knows we didn't chose the name as a first name because I didn't want to do it. So using it anyway is just a slap in the face.

But she’s still also saying the first name and in the right order? If so, all she’s doing is calling baby their name. If you hated the middle name you shouldn’t have given it to baby.