Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I mad??!! Opinions please x

112 replies

PointeToPointe · 13/06/2022 01:22

the sensible part of my brain knows this is a bad idea but I really hate my skin so asking opinions / experiences. I can’t ask my parents or they would be mad at me haha

I’ve been thinking about going for sunbeds. I have psoriasis but it’s not for that, it’s purely to get a tan. I’ve been using fake tan (probably tried every brand and type available) but I’m at uni and my friends all tan really easily in the sun and some of them top it up by going for sunbeds and they always look so glowy and tanned. My skin type is extreme pale (Irish) and I have green eyes and fair hair so I NEVER tan in the sun (I didn’t wear sun cream in the Caribbean or in Europe on holidays and barely tanned). I burn a bit but not as badly as i would expect with being so pale, obviously I will burn a bit if I’m out in the blazing sun at the beach on holidays but never in Ireland or the UK.

I know about skin cancer and the risk but I keep thinking how small the risk is and that I’ve burned in the past so getting sunbeds now won’t make a difference now. We actually lost family members (before I was born) to a skin cancer which is usually very localised and not aggressive but apparently spread and became very aggressive and I’ve had other family from the same side suffer with melanoma (not sunbed related, just random). So I know how horrible skin cancer can be and obviously sunbeds are a bad idea if they increase the risk.

for what it’s worth I think other people look beautiful with pale skin but I just don’t suit it! I’m basically translucent

are sunbeds really as risky as they say? Since I’ve already had sunburn in the past would sunbeds really increase the risk of skin cancer significantly or would i be ok? Obviously skin cancer terrifies me and I don’t want to do damage to myself but if the risk is only tiny then would sunbeds be ok? Is there anyway to get sunbeds and reduce the risk of damage?

thanks x🥺

OP posts:
Passmealargewine · 13/06/2022 06:32

Have you tried something like Sally Hanson airbrush legs instead? It might sit better on your skin than the usual fake tans.
Please don't use sunbeds, if you don't tan anyway, chances are it won't really work

MiddleParking · 13/06/2022 06:30

I have skin like you and a fake tan allergy. I went through a very brief sunbed phase as a teenager before coming to my senses. I worry that even that brief phase will now lead to me getting cancer later in life, which can happen. My dad doesn’t take the sun seriously and he did actually get a type of skin cancer removed already. I wear daily factor 50 year round now because I just think, what could be worse than getting ill with cancer and knowing it’s your own fault and that you gave it to yourself knowing the risks? Plus, colouring like ours is a total gift and not something to try and disguise.

GADDay · 13/06/2022 05:57

Kd44 · 13/06/2022 04:31

I have olive skin and never burn and live in the middle East so zero chance of tanning naturally. I use a sunbed twice a week, I don't age more because I use factor 50 the rest of the time and have botox. People are so po faced. Not everyone wants to look like a frazzled frumpy mum.

You silly, silly person.

Did you look at the YouTube link I posted?

I find it almost comprehensible that in this day and age anybody could be so ignorant. By your logic, whole countries are PO faced. Science be damned.

FFS - I really hope you don't get melanoma because you would not be able to advocate for yourself with your ridiculous outdated views.

JustALittleHelpPlease · 13/06/2022 05:50

Skin tans because of the melanin. If you have no melanin there is nothing to react to the sun therefore you won't tan. That's why gradual tans don't work on you and one's that sit on your skin slide off and go patchy. I'm the same. Absolutely no melanin in my skin - particularly my legs - therefore no tan ever. My arms do tan a bit but my legs never tan, never burn, never change colour at all. No amount of sun beds or anything else will change that.

You're trying to emulate something that is not you and risking your health to do it. So yes you are "mad" as you put it. Look for a different style that will suit the person you are.

OperaStation · 13/06/2022 05:44

Stop comparing yourself to your friends. Your skin is not like theirs and never will be.

Based on everything that you’ve said you are in a very high risk category for skin cancer and using sun beds will MASSIVELY increase that risk. Please stop going to countries where the sun is very strong and refusing to use sun cream. The sun is doing damage regardless of whether or not you’re burning.

Portiasparty · 13/06/2022 05:38

Melanoma is a horrible, horrible way to die. Please don't.

JuneJubilee · 13/06/2022 05:35

There's nothing to say a dumbed tan won't be patchy too. Plus you'll have to do it several times a week to maintain it. Apart from the cancer risk, do you really want to spend that much time & effort to fight nature?

I had a 'dry patch' of skin on my nose for ages, just thought it would eventually go, but someone mentioned skin cancer so I went to get it checked out, unfortunately it was, but fortunately I was able to use cream to remove it. I might not be so lucky next time & although the damage is probably already done (from years of sun burn) I keep my face well covered with sunscreen now, but while I was at the specialist, he noticed something on my shoulder, he sent me straight to have it cut out. She did a great job & left some neat stitches, but my skin doesn't deal well with being cut (forget the correct term) but I now have a very obvious scar on my shoulder.

also yes, damaged skin does age terribly, so your friends might be happy with their tanned glowing skin now, but as you all get a bit older they'll age far more quickly than someone who has taken far better care of their skin.

but you're young, I don't expect you to actually listen.

JuneJubilee · 13/06/2022 05:20

Kd44 · 13/06/2022 04:31

I have olive skin and never burn and live in the middle East so zero chance of tanning naturally. I use a sunbed twice a week, I don't age more because I use factor 50 the rest of the time and have botox. People are so po faced. Not everyone wants to look like a frazzled frumpy mum.

How old are you?

how many family members & friends have you had with skin cancer?

how rude are you?

no actually I can answer that myself. VERY.

PathObstacles · 13/06/2022 04:50

Seconding the PP saying it's really not worth it. You're very likely to look back in 20 years' time and think WTF was I thinking using a sun bed???!!

People whose skin tans easily and naturally will age well with it.

People whose skin doesn't tan easily and naturally will not age well with it. At all. If you don't get skin cancer, you'll get wrinkles, dark spots, and generally poor skin condition.

You also won't even get the 'glow' you see in your friends from using the sun beds. You will almost certainly get freckles and sunburn and probably a damaged skin barrier function.

Healthy, brown, natural skin on people who are born that way is gorgeous.

Healthy, pale, natural skin on people who are born THAT way is gorgeous.

If you get just enough sun for your skin type, and you get enough nutrition and sleep and a bit of exercise, your skin will be glowy too. It probably already is, it's just easier to see it in other people than in the mirror.

Please love the skin you're in, OP. It's really the best way to look after it. And it will give your skin the best chance of also looking after you for many years to come, by staying functional and healthy.

Flowers
poetryandwine · 13/06/2022 04:46

I’m of Irish heritage and spent my childhood and teen summers with extended family in hot, sunny climates cultivating a tan. It never worked. I tried tanning beds when they first came in and neither did they.

After DF was diagnosed with a melanoma my mother begged me to have a mole check done privately. Two were removed and the pathology came back, essentially pre melanoma ( this isn’t a clinical or medical term). The dermatologist said it is very likely linked to all that sun with tanning beds the worst.

Kd44 · 13/06/2022 04:34

Also I needed my epipen when I tried a spray tan so can't use any DHA

Kd44 · 13/06/2022 04:31

I have olive skin and never burn and live in the middle East so zero chance of tanning naturally. I use a sunbed twice a week, I don't age more because I use factor 50 the rest of the time and have botox. People are so po faced. Not everyone wants to look like a frazzled frumpy mum.

GADDay · 13/06/2022 03:47

In case you don't click the link.

GADDay · 13/06/2022 03:44

You are COMPLETELY mad. There is a reason they are banned in Australia and Brazil.

www.sunsmart.com.au/uv-radiation/solariums-and-tanning

No tan is worth dieing for.

TheSandgroper · 13/06/2022 03:44

Australian-from-Irish here. At some point, you just have to think “this is what it is” and work at making the best of it rather than thinking about how to change it. And you only ever get one skin.

Applegreenb · 13/06/2022 03:19

Don’t do it!!!! From a fellow pastey!

Sunbeds are different to the normal sun and you are more likely to get skin cancer due to the UVA vs UVB ratio.

If you don’t tan normally why do you think a sun bed will help. I’m going to honest I tried it once at a similar age and it did nothing. I also don’t tan and learnt I would need hours regularly to get a tan. It’s not worth the risk.

You will age more on your face too, 40 year old you might not be too impressed with this decision.

jamoncrumpets · 13/06/2022 03:13

Tans aren't particularly fashionable, even if it might feel like that because all your mates have them. You'd do much better to embrace your colouring by wearing a hat and factor 30-50 when you go out.

Stravaig · 13/06/2022 03:12

The risk is too great. Your generation has the benefit of knowing how damaging UV exposure can be. You won't tan anyway.

I have similar colouring OP, very pale, freckles, green eyes. I lived in hot countries as a child and again as an adult. I've worked outdoors in the UK. I don't tan. Ever. I burn. I freckle, I get blotches of pigmentation, I get dark spots and moles. No amount of sun exposure will give me a tan.

I'm of an age where we didn't know the dangers. The damage is done for me, even though I'm careful now. Please don't risk it.

LateAF · 13/06/2022 02:57

You need to start wearing daily sunscreen on your face, neck and hands- at least factor 30 but with your pale skin probably better to do factor 50+. Otherwise you will age terribly and you will increase your cancer risks. I’m saying this as someone with brown skin who wears factor 50 everyday.

and cancer is not worth a shitty tan.

BarbaraofSeville · 13/06/2022 02:30

If you're very pale, you won't noticeably tan and all you're doing is increasing your risk of skin cancer.

A close relative of mine died of melanoma in her 30s that was almost certainly made more likely due to sunbed use in her early 20s.

Don't do it OP.

Mothership4two · 13/06/2022 02:27

@nometo4

If you don't tan or keep a tan from the sun, you won't tan well from a tanning bed

Good point

nometo4 · 13/06/2022 02:06

If you don't tan or keep a tan from the sun, you won't tan well from a tanning bed.

addler · 13/06/2022 02:02

The thing is OP we all wish we could go to the shops and buy a new whatever. For me it's that I wish I could grab a new pair of boobs that didn't develop wrongly during puberty and have tissue missing and can't feed my babies.

But I have them, and seeing as I'm not rich and can't actually get a new pair of boobs (wouldn't fix breastfeeding issue anyway) I have to try and live with them.

We all have things we don't like about our bodies. We've grown up in a society that has conditioned us to be critical of ourselves.

You can't change your skin. You quite rightly don't want to risk cancer by trying to.

So, what are your options? Spend the rest of your life criticising yourself and comparing yourself to those around you? (Who incidentally, will look at you and wish they had something you have)

Or you can make peace with your pale, patchy skin, accept it as part of your body and acknowledge that as humans there will be things we don't like about ourselves so much and things we do like. You don't have to be 100% perfect in every way, you aren't any less of a human being because of the way your skin is.

You're so young, don't spend your whole adult life punishing yourself for something that's outwith your control. Make the choice to think kindly of yourself and you'll be a hell of a lot happier.

BadNomad · 13/06/2022 02:01

It's not worth it. Think of what "tanning" actually is. It is your body trying to repair radiation damage. Damage that causes cancer and premature ageing. There is no safe way to tan. You can't tan without damage.

IDreamOfTheMoors · 13/06/2022 01:59

addler · 13/06/2022 01:34

Also, having been sunburnt in the past makes you more at risk of developing skin cancer from repeated UV exposure, not the other way around. Every time you tan or burn you are damaging your skin cells.

Seems to me I heard that all you need to be susceptible to skin cancer is one bad sunburn.