Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I mad??!! Opinions please x

112 replies

PointeToPointe · 13/06/2022 01:22

the sensible part of my brain knows this is a bad idea but I really hate my skin so asking opinions / experiences. I can’t ask my parents or they would be mad at me haha

I’ve been thinking about going for sunbeds. I have psoriasis but it’s not for that, it’s purely to get a tan. I’ve been using fake tan (probably tried every brand and type available) but I’m at uni and my friends all tan really easily in the sun and some of them top it up by going for sunbeds and they always look so glowy and tanned. My skin type is extreme pale (Irish) and I have green eyes and fair hair so I NEVER tan in the sun (I didn’t wear sun cream in the Caribbean or in Europe on holidays and barely tanned). I burn a bit but not as badly as i would expect with being so pale, obviously I will burn a bit if I’m out in the blazing sun at the beach on holidays but never in Ireland or the UK.

I know about skin cancer and the risk but I keep thinking how small the risk is and that I’ve burned in the past so getting sunbeds now won’t make a difference now. We actually lost family members (before I was born) to a skin cancer which is usually very localised and not aggressive but apparently spread and became very aggressive and I’ve had other family from the same side suffer with melanoma (not sunbed related, just random). So I know how horrible skin cancer can be and obviously sunbeds are a bad idea if they increase the risk.

for what it’s worth I think other people look beautiful with pale skin but I just don’t suit it! I’m basically translucent

are sunbeds really as risky as they say? Since I’ve already had sunburn in the past would sunbeds really increase the risk of skin cancer significantly or would i be ok? Obviously skin cancer terrifies me and I don’t want to do damage to myself but if the risk is only tiny then would sunbeds be ok? Is there anyway to get sunbeds and reduce the risk of damage?

thanks x🥺

OP posts:
SquishyGloopyBum · 13/06/2022 09:04

Gosh op, you didn't wear sun cream in the Caribbean?!

Please do. You won't get a tan from sun beds.

If you don't wear sunscreen or cover up you will look older at 40+ than you are. You will regret it.

sammylady37 · 13/06/2022 09:00

GADDay · 13/06/2022 07:58

The NHS and the WHO too.

Good lord - are you a flat earther?

The “I do my own research” brigade usually are!

AngelinaFibres · 13/06/2022 08:44

Kd44 · 13/06/2022 04:31

I have olive skin and never burn and live in the middle East so zero chance of tanning naturally. I use a sunbed twice a week, I don't age more because I use factor 50 the rest of the time and have botox. People are so po faced. Not everyone wants to look like a frazzled frumpy mum.

Once the menopause hits you will very quickly realise that the sunbeds were not a good idea.

kimfox · 13/06/2022 08:30

If you don't tan in sunlight you aren't going to tan on a sunbed. So yes, you are mad to think that exposure to UV light from any source will suddenly make you tan. PP have already pointed to the skin cancer / damage risk.

Either embrace your natural skin colour (easiest option)or carry on with the fake tan - perhaps you could get a spray tan done by a professional to try and achieve a more even colour - but really I'd only bother for holidays or special occasions.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 13/06/2022 08:27

From another pale, see through woman.

Don't.

Just learn to love the skin you're in. The risk of cancer is not worth the damage to your skin.

Not to mention the long term effects like looking like an overused leather handbag

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 13/06/2022 08:25

Don't be bloody daft OP. Risking your health for a tan?

My husband has just had stage 1a melanoma. Caught early thank goodness. It was on his stomach and he never ever even sunbathes.

The worry and scary time we have been through, is just not worth taking the chance.

Who is to even say you would tan anyway?

Stravaig · 13/06/2022 08:20

Just to add OP, I was never sunbathing, or trying to get tanned - I just spend a lot of time outdoors, and always have. The fashion for tanned skin comes and goes. I've seen fake tan mentioned on Mumsnet a lot recently, so maybe it's become the norm again. But it not a beauty absolute. So I'd have a think about the media you'e consuming and the circles you run in that are creating this pressure in you.

Embrace your paleness. Lots of long loose floaty layers. Nicole Kidman in giant straw hats. Watch Nordic dramas, not Love Island.

The care you're forced to take now will pay off in later years when you have more youthful skin than all your sun-worshipping friends. You'll also be pre-adapted to our warming climate.

GADDay · 13/06/2022 08:20

Andouillette · 13/06/2022 08:17

Oh DFOD. Stop posting utter bollocks, you should be ashamed of yourself. But you won't be because you are one of those twits who think you have exciting hidden knowledge.
PS your list of so called evidence is the biggest load of crap I have seen this month.

Probably what I should have gone with.😂

Andouillette · 13/06/2022 08:17

xxlockdownbabyxx · 13/06/2022 07:54

@GADDay the fact that you refer to cancer research as a "valid source" is laughable.
You go ahead and believe a company that makes BILLIONS. Yes let's tell everyone that we need vitamin D to survive, however the main source of Vitamin D will kill us all unless we use toxic sunscreens (which actually course cancer FYI) you should research that too 😉.

Yes I research from many many different places, rather than blindly believing everything you hear from companies that make money from people getting cancer.

Do your own research guys and actually educate yourself.

Over and out ✌🏼

Oh DFOD. Stop posting utter bollocks, you should be ashamed of yourself. But you won't be because you are one of those twits who think you have exciting hidden knowledge.
PS your list of so called evidence is the biggest load of crap I have seen this month.

GADDay · 13/06/2022 08:12

xxlockdownbabyxx · 13/06/2022 08:09

You're welcome, it's all very interesting I agree.

I'm not suggesting that anyone should use sun beds everyday, getting out in the sunlight every day is very beneficial. I was mainly making a point, as near enough every response on this post was people quoting cancer research or other money making companies, telling the OP to slather themselves in sun screen. I wish people would do their research and actually see the dangers in using sun screen. Although there are some you can buy which are free of toxins and chemicals. None of which are the larger brands that are advertised by the NHS or cancer research though.

No you were saying by quoting outdated research (and yes I did try to read the links you shared) that sunbeds can cure skin cancer.

A world of difference to not trusting sun cream. I happen to agree with you to in some degree on that and choose to cover up where possible.

Mybeautifulfriend22 · 13/06/2022 08:12

With a family history of skin cancer absolutely not. Not worth the risk for me sorry.

xxlockdownbabyxx · 13/06/2022 08:09

EthicalNonMahogany · 13/06/2022 08:00

@xxlockdownbabyxx the first article refers to some early stage research in cultured cells and the conclusion is that skin benefits from vitamin D from a modicum of sunlight, as well as through diet.

It promises to be some useful addition to a complex understanding of how cancers develop in skin. But there's a reason why this kind of research isn't immediately translatable into "you should use sunbeds" or "you should not use sunbeds". It's one bit of a jigsaw.

Yes I appreciate that for interventions to be trialled and developed into national level guidance, that governments can use, there is a really long delay - and people have to make decisions in the meantime. and yes often there is less research attention given to things that are not associated with funding from pharma.

But you can't just go "sunbeds are fine because some sunlight is good for you says a study" because there isn't yet the weight of evidence to say so and there is quite a lot to say they are on balance harmful.

The other article in JAMA I couldn't link to it was broken. But I did find a lot of articles in the dermatology journal about the proven carcinogenic properties of sunbeds- so thanks for linking as it was an interesting read!

You're welcome, it's all very interesting I agree.

I'm not suggesting that anyone should use sun beds everyday, getting out in the sunlight every day is very beneficial. I was mainly making a point, as near enough every response on this post was people quoting cancer research or other money making companies, telling the OP to slather themselves in sun screen. I wish people would do their research and actually see the dangers in using sun screen. Although there are some you can buy which are free of toxins and chemicals. None of which are the larger brands that are advertised by the NHS or cancer research though.

CantBelieveTheTime · 13/06/2022 08:09

I used to go on sun beds a lot when I was younger. I hated having pale skin.

However, I can tell it's aged my skin. I'm only mid 30's now.
I wish I'd not used them but there's nothing I can do about that now.

I wear factor 50 sun lotion now even if it's only a little bit sunny.

I understand why you're thinking of using one but I'd really recommend you not doing. The risks are just too high. I think they should be banned. I can't believe sun bed shops are still open. I used to work in one for years so had easy access too!

Could you look at other tanning options if you really want a tan. There are so many options. Loads!

EthicalNonMahogany · 13/06/2022 08:07

Cancer research the charity does make money which it demonstrates to the charity commission where it goes. Research can be funded by pharma and lots is also funded by governments for example UKRI in the UK funds much research. Funding is important and should be considered when you're thinking about why something is funded. But there is also a need for evidence to be produced in verifiable ways and the big organisations which promote research look to present the best scientific consensus. There's lots wrong with the system. However IMHO the biggest argument for the current system, and the often terrible stranglehold of journals & slow publication etc etc...is that when the media and social media just show random bits of research, some members of the public can't intepret them and start taking decisions based on evidence that isn't there.

Clovacloud · 13/06/2022 08:02

My friend would go and do a ‘starter tan’ on sunbeds for holidays, so maybe 5 sessions pre-holiday. It was just so she wouldn’t burn on holiday, then she’d use sunscreen when she went somewhere sunny, she’d been doing it since she was a teen.

Her first malignant melanoma was diagnosed at 25 and she was dead by the time she was 29.

DO NOT USE SUNBEDS!

Tiani4 · 13/06/2022 08:00

BEAM123 · 13/06/2022 07:48

If you don't tan in other ways you won't tan on a sunbed, you just don't have melanin.

What you will get is a temporary pink glow from being hot, which you could probably get much more safely from a run round the block or a hot bath.

Try the tanning moisturisers eg Dove Derma spa for fair skin (lasts a couple of weeks), bronzer on face etc.

This ^^

I'm very fair as well. I tried sun beds when I was younger , they don't work to tan you anymore than the sun does! You don't have the skin to tan and any efforts to get even a slight tan will be you causing damage to your skin.

I use Dove sun glow moisturiser on my legs so that they aren't completely white but still look natural. It doesn't stain and builds up slowly so 2-3 applications before you go on holiday will give you best you'll get! Wear factor 30 or 50 when you are there. I grew to love my skin colour- translucent white!! I love other peoples skin colours and ability to tan, but I had to accept it's not what my body does nor looks like.

MiddleParking · 13/06/2022 08:00

Weren’t the tanning places on every high street mainly for money laundering anyway? Just with a little cancer-giving side hustle as a front.

EthicalNonMahogany · 13/06/2022 08:00

@xxlockdownbabyxx the first article refers to some early stage research in cultured cells and the conclusion is that skin benefits from vitamin D from a modicum of sunlight, as well as through diet.

It promises to be some useful addition to a complex understanding of how cancers develop in skin. But there's a reason why this kind of research isn't immediately translatable into "you should use sunbeds" or "you should not use sunbeds". It's one bit of a jigsaw.

Yes I appreciate that for interventions to be trialled and developed into national level guidance, that governments can use, there is a really long delay - and people have to make decisions in the meantime. and yes often there is less research attention given to things that are not associated with funding from pharma.

But you can't just go "sunbeds are fine because some sunlight is good for you says a study" because there isn't yet the weight of evidence to say so and there is quite a lot to say they are on balance harmful.

The other article in JAMA I couldn't link to it was broken. But I did find a lot of articles in the dermatology journal about the proven carcinogenic properties of sunbeds- so thanks for linking as it was an interesting read!

GADDay · 13/06/2022 07:58

xxlockdownbabyxx · 13/06/2022 07:54

@GADDay the fact that you refer to cancer research as a "valid source" is laughable.
You go ahead and believe a company that makes BILLIONS. Yes let's tell everyone that we need vitamin D to survive, however the main source of Vitamin D will kill us all unless we use toxic sunscreens (which actually course cancer FYI) you should research that too 😉.

Yes I research from many many different places, rather than blindly believing everything you hear from companies that make money from people getting cancer.

Do your own research guys and actually educate yourself.

Over and out ✌🏼

The NHS and the WHO too.

Good lord - are you a flat earther?

Stevienickssnickers · 13/06/2022 07:56

Have a search for the Nicola Roberts (from Girls Aloud) doc about tanning. It's probably on YouTube some where.

And yes you should be using daily sunscreen, if nothing else it will help reduce premature aging and sun damage. Sun beds are terrible and I'm so pleased we've moved on from having multiple tanning places on every high street.

Notjustanymum · 13/06/2022 07:55

Please don’t use a sun bed, OP, and don’t compare yourself to your peers! That’s a rabbit-hole that will only lead to misery. Instead, embrace yourself and be “Bien dans sa peau“ (comfortable in your own skin), and wear a high factor sunscreen - you’ll be looking youthful at 40 if you do. A tan, any tan, is simply skin damage…

seaUrchinOne · 13/06/2022 07:54

I have fair skin, tried sunbeds years ago, about it didn't do much other than costing money bringing my freckles out. You won't get much of a tan unless you repeatedly use it a lot, which is very damaging to your skin.

xxlockdownbabyxx · 13/06/2022 07:54

@GADDay the fact that you refer to cancer research as a "valid source" is laughable.
You go ahead and believe a company that makes BILLIONS. Yes let's tell everyone that we need vitamin D to survive, however the main source of Vitamin D will kill us all unless we use toxic sunscreens (which actually course cancer FYI) you should research that too 😉.

Yes I research from many many different places, rather than blindly believing everything you hear from companies that make money from people getting cancer.

Do your own research guys and actually educate yourself.

Over and out ✌🏼

WonderingWanda · 13/06/2022 07:54

Wear sunscreen and no sunbeds. Your skin type is the most vulnerable to sun damage because you are pale and have little natural melanin to protect you.

Things you can do. Look into hair colour and eyebrow or eyelash tints to improve how you look. I am fair and find that my eyebrows vanish in the sun and I look a bit odd. Also work out what colour clothes really work with your skin tone.

GADDay · 13/06/2022 07:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I have reported your post as you are giving advice that could really do somebody harm.