Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how much I should pay towards this?

57 replies

Undecidedandtorn · 12/06/2022 21:18

I split up with my ex a year ago but we have been sharing accommodation (2 places swapping every week with the kids staying in the same house). The hot water in the main house broke just before Christmas.

Due to having an old set up (no central heating) it took a while to find someone to install a new set up which finally happened about 4 weeks ago. I'm moved into my new place on Friday so now we won't share accommodation and the kids will spend 50% of thier time at each of the places.

The water heating system cost £1500 and I'm really broke at the moment. My ex paid it out of our joint account which we both were putting 2/3 of our salary into (so me 60% him 40% of the total monthly amount that went into the joint account). I don't feel I should pay anything and he should refund me my share , he thinks I should leave as is.

What would a fair amount be?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
30mph · 15/06/2022 09:15

You came off the deeds with no legal advice..?

TigerLilyTail · 15/06/2022 09:12

The OP said they were sharing homes and swapping between homes, so I think they should split the cost.

Now, draw a line under things and you are responsible for your own houses.

dudsville · 15/06/2022 09:10

This is tough. If i were him i would not ask you to pay, for the reasons you gave, he can enjoy this for 20 years. In your position i would discuss it with the potential to offer something up to half towards it, and perhaps including in the discussion the need to have a good, amicable relationship going forward. I would be hoping from that discussion that he would see he was benefiting financially and that there might be ripples from this down the line.

Tiani4 · 15/06/2022 09:05

They we're both living there when it broke? Doesn't matter when it was actually fixed, really. If it had been fixed immediately it would have been 50:50, I don't see why delaying the replacement until op had moved out makes it her ex's sole responsibility .It's not a cosmetic enhancement, it's necessary maintenance.

No she was living elsewhere, they were merely previously swopping for a childcare arrangement.
It's his house in his name and his responsibility.

Unless he's paying equally towards OPs home then he's taking advantage of her to take the whole cost of upgrading his boiler hot water system after she was no longer living there, without agreeing it as a shared expense. He just helped himself after she had left

Tiani4 · 15/06/2022 08:59

Am I right in understanding you have a joint account as well as separate bank accounts and that he took all the cost of the new boiler abs system for his house in his name, out of your shared account not his own?

Really he should pay it back and I would be asking for him to return what he took. Ultimately you can take him to small claims to get it back as you'll be able to show he used joint money for himself. However if things have been amicable I would negotiate with him so that you contribute but don't pay 50% as it's left you short and wasn't your cost to pay for.
He knows he's been a CF

deedledeedledum · 14/06/2022 14:15

@Johnnysgirl so the ex should go around cataloging everything that broke/wore out/deteriorated whilst the OP was living there and charge 50% now? Why not? How are carpets, an old fridge, cracked loo or burnt out lightbulbs any different?

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 13/06/2022 19:52

If it wasn't your house when the work was done and bill was sent then its not your liability. You put up with no system for months, and what now you get to pay for the repair but don't benefit. No I think he needs to refund you, its not your responsibility anymore you have your own place to pay for. Presumably he can afford it.

ElenaSt · 13/06/2022 19:13

Half.

Nein9 · 13/06/2022 19:09

I think 50/50 is fair.

Getoff · 13/06/2022 19:02

I also don't think "off the deeds" is relevant. You were occupying the house on terms which involved sharing costs.

Getoff · 13/06/2022 18:59

I think joint finances end on the day you move out. The fact it may last 20 years is neither here nor there. The timing is just bad luck. If it had broken the day after, it would have been fair to pay nothing. Actually, if it had broken before and repaired after, I would still say that would mean paying nothing.

Johnnysgirl · 13/06/2022 18:26

deedledeedledum · 13/06/2022 17:41

@RuthW @Johnnysgirl abd others who say the OP should Kay half even if she was no longer in the deeds when the item was replaced.... what if it broke today. Would she still pay half? She doesn't live there. What if it happened next month? What if hers broke. Should he pay half?
What if he wanted to buy a massive gas BBQ should she pay half because the dc would benefit? I don't really get it. Something is solely HIS house got repaired. Why is it anything to do with the OP? Breaking when she was there us irrelevant unless she broke it. Can he replace all the carpets that are worn and charge that too. Because they wore out when the OP was there?

They we're both living there when it broke? Doesn't matter when it was actually fixed, really. If it had been fixed immediately it would have been 50:50, I don't see why delaying the replacement until op had moved out makes it her ex's sole responsibility.
It's not a cosmetic enhancement, it's necessary maintenance.

deedledeedledum · 13/06/2022 17:41

@RuthW @Johnnysgirl abd others who say the OP should Kay half even if she was no longer in the deeds when the item was replaced.... what if it broke today. Would she still pay half? She doesn't live there. What if it happened next month? What if hers broke. Should he pay half?
What if he wanted to buy a massive gas BBQ should she pay half because the dc would benefit? I don't really get it. Something is solely HIS house got repaired. Why is it anything to do with the OP? Breaking when she was there us irrelevant unless she broke it. Can he replace all the carpets that are worn and charge that too. Because they wore out when the OP was there?

TheQueensMarmaladeSandwich · 13/06/2022 15:07

Well. In the future you may need help with fixing a car for the use of you and the kids. He may well help you back then.

rwalker · 13/06/2022 15:05

It all depends if you feel £750 is a hill worth dying on

Sswhinesthebest · 13/06/2022 15:00

burnoutbabe · 13/06/2022 14:57

i would have paid half towards a repair but not half of a whole new system (assuming that a repair would get it working again, safely for a year or so)

Good point.

Sswhinesthebest · 13/06/2022 14:59

Difficult really but as you were on the deeds when it broke then I suppose 50/50
unless you can persuade him differently - amicably.

burnoutbabe · 13/06/2022 14:57

i would have paid half towards a repair but not half of a whole new system (assuming that a repair would get it working again, safely for a year or so)

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 13/06/2022 14:52

Hi OP

I think as it was a brand new system that he will benefit from for years, that I can see where you're coming from that it's not fair that you pay for something. I think if it was a repair it would have been different but it's essentially an upgrade.

I suspect legally you would have to pay your half though and practically its tricky to work out how much you should pay so I'd just suck it up. And see if you can squeeze any other costs out the joint account like moving costs uf it was a joint decision etc

Undecidedandtorn · 13/06/2022 14:04

Undecidedandtorn · 13/06/2022 14:03

I don't have one.

Sorry - that was meant to quote the person that asked what my solicitor thinks

OP posts:
Undecidedandtorn · 13/06/2022 14:04

Undecidedandtorn · 13/06/2022 14:03

I don't have one.

Sorry - that was meant to quote the person that asked what my solicitor thinks

OP posts:
Undecidedandtorn · 13/06/2022 14:03

Goldfishmountainclimber · 13/06/2022 12:35

What does your solicitor think?

I don't have one.

OP posts:
Undecidedandtorn · 13/06/2022 14:00

ClinicallyProven · 13/06/2022 13:17

The same thing would happen if you both moved out, it still needed paying for when it needed fixing.

But I guess my point is we didn't both move out - if we had I would have paid half with no question

OP posts:
ClinicallyProven · 13/06/2022 13:17

Undecidedandtorn · 13/06/2022 08:39

Well that is unambiguous! My feeling was the new water system will serve the house for what - 20 years - and I won't be getting any benefit.

I appreciate that my kids will be there 50 % of the time but if anything breaks in my new place now I've moved (and we are no longer paying into a joint account) I'm liable for 100% of the cost which is how it should be.

The same thing would happen if you both moved out, it still needed paying for when it needed fixing.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 13/06/2022 13:16

Undecidedandtorn · 13/06/2022 11:57

I was on the deeds when it broke but not when it was fixed.

When it broke is what matters. Were you still sharing the house 50/50 when it broke? If so you should both have split the bill 50/50.