Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think ex shouldn't see only one of our kids?

38 replies

moamhelp · 12/06/2022 20:13

Long story so I will try to condense

I have 2 children with exP, a 6 year old and a 7 month old.

He was emotionally abusive (think name calling, shouting, swearing, gas lighting, just plain horrible) and I eventually built up the courage to call it a day.

He has been staying at his mums and seeing the kids there, 3 x a week tues, thurs, Sunday, for 2 hours at a time. I am breastfeeding (trying to introduce bottle but baby is v reluctant!) so I have been dropping them off, feeding, leaving for 2 hours, then returning to collect them

I am and have been completely open to him seeing more of them, but this is what we agreed

He is now saying that he 'can't cope' having the baby, as she cries the whole time (she does cry a lot in general) and I'm being unfair by dumping the kids there 3 x a week and leaving them to it, so he now will only have our eldest apart from on a Sunday he will see the baby too but I have to be there as well.

AIBU to think this isn't on? Here are my thoughts

  1. It doesn't matter so much now but this isn't fair on little one (appreciate that maybe I'm thinking too far ahead here)
  1. It sends the wrong message to my eldest (does dad love him but not baby? Do we just give up parenting because it's hard work? Is he more special than baby? Is baby a nuisance?)
  1. You don't get to pick and choose which of your children you parent based on which ones are hard work and which ones aren't
  1. Also means I get no time out at all from parenting

He says it's not fair because he gets no quality time on his own with eldest so I suggested he keep to original plan and then keep eldest on his own a few extra hours after the Sunday contact for some quality time (bike riding, arcades, whatever they fancy doing that can't really be done with baby there)

But no, he just wants to have our 6 year old and then all 4 of us 'do something' on a Sunday

Opinions please? Anyone else been in this situation?

For info he is unemployed (he maintains that he cannot work due to his mental health) and does not pay child support

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
decayingmatter · 14/06/2022 22:31

That's it now, OP. Zero tolerance, seriously. Otherwise you will sit and watch him let your children down over and over again.

Set out a contact plan that is best for the children, not one that suits him, and do not allow him to deviate from it or manipulate you into deviating from it If he can't commit to the very basic things that he should be committing to as a dad then I would suspend contact until he can. He can take you to court if he wants (doubt he will). That's fine. The court will only want to see the same basic commitment that you also want, and the issue is that he's acting like he doesn't really want to see them, not that he's fighting for more time with them.

I would bet that he will not commit to anything and that the arrangement will end very soon. But at least your kids are spared from the anxiety of waiting to see if their dad can be arsed with them from one week to the next.

moamhelp · 14/06/2022 21:06

Thanks for all listening to me rant it's strangely therapeutic to be able to write it all down here!

OP posts:
moamhelp · 14/06/2022 21:06

Thanks all. What a shit show!

@JanglyBeads to answer your question no he didn't have much to do with DC1, I was very much default parent and the ironic thing is, he made such a big thing about 'wanting to do things better with DC2' and build a better bond

Far from it!

OP posts:
Frankola · 14/06/2022 18:34

He sounds like dad of the year...😡

Gizacluethen · 14/06/2022 18:33

Big no.

When will he decide he can be bothered with the baby? When they're in the terrible 2s? When they're 3 and have no idea who he is and vocalise that they don't want to be with him? When he hasn't built a bond with them? No. He's trying to get out of having the little one now the older one is more fun.

It's OK for you to struggle and have no quality time with the older one? You could suggest he has two days with the older one and two days with the younger one. That way you both get quality time with both kids.

The Sunday "family time" an absolute no. You're not together, you don't have to spend your weekends with him.

Howshouldibehave · 14/06/2022 18:27

He can’t command what you do with your time. He’d probably do fuck all with the kids and sit back letting you do it all whilst he criticises.

Moaning that he never gets the eldest on his own is ridiculous-when do you get the eldest on his own?!

Thefoxsays · 14/06/2022 18:25

It's not fair no, but if he is telling you he can't cope with the baby then I think it would be unfair to her, to send her there. Evidence has shown that babies under one are at the greatest risk of harm from a care-giver and although I'm sure he would not purposely hurt her, if he is becoming so frustrated it's not a good idea to send her. However, does he have family support? Anyone who can help him with the baby? I know you don't get a break either but she won't be this little forever and he will be able to better meet her needs when she is a bit older.

tenterden · 14/06/2022 18:22

He's pathetic. Absolutely do not agree to do anything with him - he's using this to manipulate you.

Both DC or neither, his choice. Imagine the shoe being on the other foot - would you refuse to see your baby just because it was only for a couple of hours? He's ridiculous. Hopefully you will stay blocked!! Grin

JanglyBeads · 14/06/2022 18:22

If he sees them at his mum's, isn't she there to help?

Just in case you end up in court about this, I'd advise being super helpful in working towards him adjusting to caring for a baby - eg a planned series of stages and some links to helpful websites about baby care. And maybe subtly ask the six year old what's happening when the baby cries with Daddy at the moment.

Let me guess, did he do much when DC1 was a baby?

Do not give in to the pleas to do stuff together.

They all say stuff like "dumping the kids on me" when it suits them. Ignore.

artisanbread · 14/06/2022 18:19

So when does he think a good time for him to start having the baby will be? If she doesn't see him regularly now she won't know who he is and will never be comfortable around him.

Shinyandnew1 · 14/06/2022 18:14

Cue the torrent of abuse, about how unfair it is for me to just dump them both on him when he has no one to help him

Who does he think helps you??

KettrickenSmiled · 14/06/2022 18:06

Cue the torrent of abuse, about how unfair it is for me to just dump them both on him when he has no one to help him

Have you ever asked him who he thinks helps you, for the 162 hours a week you parent solo?

He is definitely just trying to suck you back in.
Is it worth it? Would your older child be better off with no contact, rather than this sporadic & unreliable, resentful contact? Do eitehr of them actually need this deadbeat manipulator in their lives?

I'd be tempted to block him right back, & let him go via a solicitor for court-ordered contact, & hope that fizzled him out of our lives entirely.

moamhelp · 14/06/2022 18:02

So here's the latest, it's predictable

He was going to collect both kids at 5pm
5.10pm and he's not here, ' just having some food. Do you want to come out with us?' he says. youngest is getting desperate for her last nap so to try and keep the peace I offered to take them to him so that he can finish eating and baby can nap in car, and said no I have plans of my own so won't be joining you.

Cue the torrent of abuse, about how unfair it is for me to just dump them both on him when he has no one to help him, how I try and dictate his life, how I'm preventing him from having a bond with his children

By this time baby had fallen asleep and 6 year old got fed up waiting and went to play with his friend next door, and I have now been blocked

Give me strength Confused it's like he's actually lost his mind, half of it doesn't even make sense

OP posts:
Ohmybod · 14/06/2022 10:34

Disney dad cherry picking the easier parts of parenting. Just keep repeating no to him and when he feeds you the line about it being hard, no quality time, repeat back to him that you have no quality time either, are exhausted and are fully funding the children. Explain he can either drop this conversation with you or he can take it up with your solicitor.

moamhelp · 14/06/2022 10:28

Thanks all for reassuring me that it is infact him that's being unreasonable!!

Today is his usual day to see them, I have asked him if he is still planning to, awaiting response so we shall see.

@LittleOwl153 that sounds a really good idea. and thanks I didn't know that about benefits.

@KettrickenSmiled re pick ups and drop offs, partly yes I fully expect to be let down, messed around, however the other reason I'm willing to do it as it means he doesn't have to come to my house so this is a plus.

OP posts:
123becauseicouldntthinkofone · 14/06/2022 10:27

historygeek · 12/06/2022 20:28

I was a bit older than your two when my dad left, but he would take my older sister out for an evening, but not me and my younger brother. We would sit by the window just for a peep of him as he dropped my sister off. I guess we were too much hassle all together. He eventually sacked her off too and she really suffered from this abandonment.

I'd also worry that his idea of you all doing something together on a Sunday is another form of control and refusing to let you go.

This is how i also view your situation

EducatingArti · 14/06/2022 10:24

So, why not let him have both for 2 hours during the week as you have been ( he needs to parent both of them) and just have the older child on a Sunday for a few hours to do something suitable with him/her. ( being there with him and both the kids doesn't work for you!!!!)

finalpunt · 14/06/2022 10:20

LittleOwl153 · 14/06/2022 09:52

I'm being unfair by dumping the kids there 3 x a week and leaving them to it is that not what he's done for the other 166hrs a week?

My suggestion - going with his need for 1 on 1 time is that you switch 1 of the afternoon/evening sessions to alternate between the two kids.

So 1 week he has the baby for 2 hours - giving you some 1 on 1 time with the 6yr old, and the next week he can pick up the 6yr old from school and bring him back at bedtime (note he does the travelling/transporting here as you will have baby in bed). If he drops out of baby's week then baby gets the next week instead - so he doesn't get out of it that way! Baby's time increases as you get her onto bottle/food to match 6yr old by 12/18 months?

The other afternoon/evening and Sundays stay as is. Do not get involved with 'doing something together' this isn't fair on the 6yr old who will think you are getting back together AND will mean he doesn't do anything with the baby leaving it all to you.

Well done on spotting the control. Keep your own control of the situation.

I was going to come on and suggest similar to this, 1 on 1 is important to you both and the children.

If he needs 1 on 1 then you embrace that as a brilliant idea and completely agree and the present the plan above. Tell him you will trial it for 6 months and then review together but you will not be doing things as a 4.

KettrickenSmiled · 14/06/2022 10:15

This is post-separation abuse OP.
He is continuing his control & manipulation via the kids.

He is now saying that he 'can't cope' having the baby, as she cries the whole time (she does cry a lot in general) and I'm being unfair by dumping the kids there 3 x a week and leaving them to it, so he now will only have our eldest apart from on a Sunday he will see the baby too but I have to be there as well.

How does he think YOU "cope" with the baby?
WTF - exactly - does he reckon is "unfair" about seeing his own children for 2 hours, 3 x a week?
DO NOT AGREE TO BE PRESENT on the Sunday. It's got fuck-all to do with you managing the baby, & everything to do with him sucking you back into his orbit.

It's also outrageous that you are the one doing all the drop--offs & pick-ups.
Amaze me - if you expected him to collect or deliver his own children, he'd let you down, so you can't trust him with it?

LittleOwl153 · 14/06/2022 09:55

Oh and if he is claiming benefits CMS will give you £7 a week out of his benefits - it's pathetic but it makes a point...

LittleOwl153 · 14/06/2022 09:52

I'm being unfair by dumping the kids there 3 x a week and leaving them to it is that not what he's done for the other 166hrs a week?

My suggestion - going with his need for 1 on 1 time is that you switch 1 of the afternoon/evening sessions to alternate between the two kids.

So 1 week he has the baby for 2 hours - giving you some 1 on 1 time with the 6yr old, and the next week he can pick up the 6yr old from school and bring him back at bedtime (note he does the travelling/transporting here as you will have baby in bed). If he drops out of baby's week then baby gets the next week instead - so he doesn't get out of it that way! Baby's time increases as you get her onto bottle/food to match 6yr old by 12/18 months?

The other afternoon/evening and Sundays stay as is. Do not get involved with 'doing something together' this isn't fair on the 6yr old who will think you are getting back together AND will mean he doesn't do anything with the baby leaving it all to you.

Well done on spotting the control. Keep your own control of the situation.

ChoiceMummy · 14/06/2022 08:49

@moamhelp
Ultimately, if its hard work for him to manage his contact time, that's his issue.
It's not your responsibility to have to attend to make it easier on him. It's only your responsibility to have them available for the contact.
I don't like contact with only certain siblings, and do think that tyring to insist on some contact for both is preferable but it maybe that the baby contact reduces for a time.
You not getting down time isn't a relevant factor. Though appreciate it feels like it is to you.

funinthesun19 · 13/06/2022 02:53

Ugh. He wants all 4 of you to do something together? I’m sure that would suit him just fine. He needs his hand holding and will also love pretending you’re a family/getting close to you. Boundaries all the way.
My ex likes suggesting days out with the kids but he won’t do them oh his own or even with his parents or anyone else - has to be with me. He never gets anywhere with it.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/06/2022 00:30

What you absolutely mustn’t do is go there yourself and spend time all together. It’s better for your eldest ( and later the youngest) to know mum and dad aren’t together any more.

The problem if he doesn’t have 7 month on alone now is when will he start doing so? Even if baby only goes on one occasion per week that’s something.

BadNomad · 13/06/2022 00:22

You are not his childcare when it is his contact time. Tell him to ask grandma to watch the baby while he takes the 6-year-old out for quality time if he's that bothered.