Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should you contact an unwell family member?

103 replies

CheckingIn · 12/06/2022 08:30

I'm curious for people's opinions on this scenario - I've NC'd because I'd like an answer without the additional context and where people don't know which person I am in the scenario.

A person is sick - long-term but not chronic or disabled. The sickness is likely to last about a year. It's a recognised, debilitating illness but is very unlikely to be life threatening. The illness is diagnosed and can be cured but it will take months for the person to feel better. They're frequently in and out of hospital, completely unable to work or socialise, they visit the hospital multiple times each week for ambulatory care or appointments, and receive a lot of treatments. If they didn't receive this care then they would almost certainly die from the illness - but the care is very good. Whilst the long-term outlook is very good, in the mean time, the illness means that they are in a lot of pain and very unwell. It's a genetic illness so some members of the family have also had it before, but not as severely as the person who has it now.

In this scenario, would you expect:
a) the person's family (parents and adult siblings) to reach out and ask the person if they're ok and how things are going.
b) the person to contact their family to update them, without being asked, whenever anything changes or they have to be admitted to hospital?

Either way, how often or when do you think they should reach out to update/check-in?

The family speak via messages around 3 times each week and video call around once each week. The frequency that family members see each other in person varies a lot because of distance. They consider themselves a close family who get on well.

OP posts:
Beautifulmonster87 · 13/06/2022 19:13

CheckingIn · 12/06/2022 09:17

Just to clarify a couple of things:

The sick person isn't asked how they are during the video calls or messages. The family members who had the condition: a parent had it before the children were born so has experienced it but the family set-up didn't exist, a sibling had a milder form of the same condition which lasted for 2-3 months about two years ago. I don't recall how much was discussed in video calls. Looking through my messages, I can see I messaged her to ask how she was during that time with respect to the illness on at least five occasions.

This scenario has come about because the sick person's condition deteriorated quite considerably and they were hospitalised with some additional complications. They didn't tell the family. After two weeks, no one had asked how she was so she told them what was going on and, when asked why she hadn't told them, she said that no one had asked and that if anyone had asked how she is, she'd have updated. The sick person has said that she feels that, if you're messaging anyway (which happens a few times a week anyway), it's normal to ask "how are you?" to the other person. The family feel that if they are updating on their own lives then the obligation is on the sick person to update on the changes in hers.

Erm you sound like hard work! If others talk about how they are, contribute and tell them how you are! If they’re not interested then you’ll know not to bother talking to them anymore!

MarmiteCoriander · 13/06/2022 19:01

So OP- are you going to tell us which one you are in this scenario and reply?

loveinthe90s · 13/06/2022 14:44

Yabu

Sick person needs to stop being passive aggressive and trying to make everyone feel guilty.

Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 13/06/2022 14:40

saraclara · 13/06/2022 14:03

Starting with "Hello Sister, how are you? Anything new with you?" etc. would feel very formal to me

That's because it is, and I would never do that either. "How's things?" however, is not formal.
OP says the family video calls once a week. So surely the conversation would include an informal check in like that?

Or maybe they just assume that if someone were to Have news that they were in hospital that it would be raised without probing

Or maybe they are just done with this siblings BS and don't really want to engage anymore.

SpiderVersed · 13/06/2022 14:39

Sick person is trying to guilt trip SIbs 1&2. Passive aggressing nonsense.

saraclara · 13/06/2022 14:03

Starting with "Hello Sister, how are you? Anything new with you?" etc. would feel very formal to me

That's because it is, and I would never do that either. "How's things?" however, is not formal.
OP says the family video calls once a week. So surely the conversation would include an informal check in like that?

Pluvia · 13/06/2022 13:39

I've read all your posts, OP. The sick person is behaving in a classic passive-aggressive way and the best response is to ignore that comment and just get on with your life. And keep a bit of distance between the pair of you. It's manipulative behaviour.

toastofthetown · 12/06/2022 18:24

saraclara · 12/06/2022 18:07

I'm trying to think of a social conversation (rather than making very quick practical arrangements) between family members that doesn't start "How's things?" or the like.
Do none of you do that, OP?

As I said above, in our family chats (both group and individual), we don't tend do conversation starters and sign-offs. We just message with what we want to say. I imagine that's the case in many families. This morning I've messaged my sister to let her know what I thought of book I finished last night and started the message with "I finally finished Hamnet." Starting with "Hello Sister, how are you? Anything new with you?" etc. would feel very formal to me. I assume if she has any news she wants share she will and vice versa. My family and I are in pretty much daily contacts chats are like an ongoing conversation.

Cameleongirl · 12/06/2022 18:15

Hmm, I do think you should ask how the sick person is on the calls, it's basic politeness. If they don't want to discuss it, they can say, "Fine, how are you, what have you been up to?" and move the conversation along.

My DH's family has form for avoiding anything unpleasant and it's been very hurtful to myself and my BIL (married to DH's sister) at times. When his Dad was very ill last year (he eventually died) my in-laws literally never mentioned his illness or asked how he was, because it made THEM feel uncomfortable. It's not nice behavior.

I'd advise asking the sick relative how they are at the beginning of the conversation and then move on.

saraclara · 12/06/2022 18:07

I'm trying to think of a social conversation (rather than making very quick practical arrangements) between family members that doesn't start "How's things?" or the like.
Do none of you do that, OP?

longtompot · 12/06/2022 17:45

LIZS · 12/06/2022 08:41

And the difficulty of they are having treatment is that appointments may not be consistent and appropriately timing any contact right outside the regular calls becomes tricky. It can also be wearing being asked constantly how things are going.

I agree.

I think it's also a bit like when you're pregnant and towards the end family are always asking about how things are, any signs etc and it can get annoying. Maybe the family think the three calls a week are enough and that if the ill person wanted more then they'd be the ones phoning.

ihatethebus · 12/06/2022 17:00

yabu and ridiculous too. If you are in hospital you need to let people know and not wait to be specifically asked about it.

MichelleScarn · 12/06/2022 16:46

Throckmorton · 12/06/2022 12:10

Hard to say really. Is it the case no one ever bothers to ask sick person how she is, and she feels ignored and uncared about? Or is it that everyone else always says how they are so assumed sick person would do the same so didn't think they needed to specifically ask? Do siblings generally care about sick person? Is sick person usually one for game playing or is this out of character?

Actually agree with all of this, whats prompted this pondering? I'm assuming you are the unwell person as I do think your thread heavily leans towards they're the wronged party?

BetsyBigNose · 12/06/2022 12:25

I'm a little bit torn. Yes, the 'patient' should let their family know when they've been admitted, but I am long-term sick and am admitted regularly. I have one family member who calls me 'dramatic', so I often avoid telling them when I'm in, unless they ask because I don't like the insinuation that I'm 'attention seeking'...

Throckmorton · 12/06/2022 12:10

Hard to say really. Is it the case no one ever bothers to ask sick person how she is, and she feels ignored and uncared about? Or is it that everyone else always says how they are so assumed sick person would do the same so didn't think they needed to specifically ask? Do siblings generally care about sick person? Is sick person usually one for game playing or is this out of character?

MichelleScarn · 12/06/2022 11:25

ANUsernam · 12/06/2022 11:13

@MichelleScarn but where do you get the idea from that the ill person is unhappy with the situation?

Literally all the quoted conversations say is that they've mentioned they're in hospital, then when questioned why they didn't already tell them, they've said no-one asked - that's a statement of fact. The only one who's indicated annoyance with the situation is the sibling.

The admonishment in this
sick person: I’d have said if anyone had asked how I am. It’s pretty normal to ask how people are if you want to know.

I.e no-ones given me direct attention, that's not normal.

ButtOutBobsMum · 12/06/2022 11:24

Originally I voted YANBU but after reading the update re the conversation I agree that sick person is being ridiculous and petty. Why wait until they’re asked how they are to tell their re in hospital?!

ManateeFair · 12/06/2022 11:18

CheckingIn · 12/06/2022 09:41

This is the conversation in the chat.

Sibling 1: Good day for [Sibling 2’s hobby], any plans for it Sibling 2?
Sibling 2: Unfortunately not. Sat in A and E with DS. Fell off his bike.
Sick person: Oh no! How is he? Which hospital? I’m in [Hospital Name] if you want to say hi.
Sibling 1: You’re admitted again? You never said
Sick person: No one asked, I’d have said if you’d asked how I am.
Sibling 1: You should’ve said though.
Sick person: (tagging the message from Sibling 2) How’s DS getting on?

Then, later on
Sibling 2: I still think it’s shitty that [Sickperson] didn’t say she’s in hospital.
Sick person: I’d have said if anyone had asked how I am. It’s pretty normal to ask how people are if you want to know.
Sibling 2: I’m not psychic! How do I know to ask how you are if you don’t say you’re in hospital?!

That’s how it’s been left.

Sick person is being absolutely ridiculous

ANUsernam · 12/06/2022 11:13

@MichelleScarn but where do you get the idea from that the ill person is unhappy with the situation?

Literally all the quoted conversations say is that they've mentioned they're in hospital, then when questioned why they didn't already tell them, they've said no-one asked - that's a statement of fact. The only one who's indicated annoyance with the situation is the sibling.

Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 12/06/2022 11:02

I wouldn't ask someone how they were with that personality

Who would want to engage with such a passive aggressive person?

I'd leave them to fester alone. Let them enjoy the misery they crave so much

PurpleWisteria · 12/06/2022 10:57

Sick person is massively U for not saying they were in hospital.

Very passive aggressive.

Panamii · 12/06/2022 10:48

Sick person is playing games and should have told family.

SilverDragonfly1 · 12/06/2022 10:46

Ill person being very passive aggressive, but I can imagine them feeling quite bitter about being lumbered with a painful genetic condition, especially if the sibling who previously had it was shown more consideration and attention- perhaps the family consider it a bit run-of-the-mill if several of them have had it and it's a known quantity.

I must confess to being curious about the condition- which I would not expect you to disclose!- as I've not heard of anything like it other than sickle cell which doesn't have a complete cure outside of bone marrow transplant.

toastofthetown · 12/06/2022 10:45

It depends, in general I think it's just basic politeness in a conversation to ask how the other person is/ what's new. It's just showing an interest regardless of general health. So I'd expect that as a minimum of conversation at any time.

Im our family chats, we don't tend do conversation starters and sign-offs. We just message with what we want to say. I imagine that's the case in many families. This morning I've messaged my sister to let her know what I thought of book I finished last night and started the message with "I finally finished Hamnet." Starting with "Hello Sister, how are you? Anything new with you?" etc. would feel very formal to me. I assume if she has any news she wants share she will and vice versa.

mirrorballer · 12/06/2022 10:44

Sick person sounds like they're playing games. That whole 'you didn't ask' this is pass agg and manipulative.

Are they pissed off with the rest of the family?

Swipe left for the next trending thread