Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who keeps the money?

37 replies

StColumbofNavron · 11/06/2022 18:41

DC14 asked for an expensive musical instrument for Christmas with a view to taking music for GCSE. They have subsequently decided not to do music GCSE, give up their instruments to focus on said GCSEs and thought they wanted to keep the instrument to play for leisure. They have now said they probably won't play it anymore so we should sell it. (We bought a new one because they have been playing a number of years and had previously had a well used second hand one and then was without for a while).

My question is, if I sell it (and it will be me, he will just leave it languishing) who should get the money? It is his at the end of the day and was a gift, but it cost a fair bit for only a few months use and I will be the one putting the effort in to getting rid of it. To be honest, I am actually thinking I will put it into his savings account rather than necessarily keep it myself. I just don't want him to squander the cash.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MixedCouple · 12/06/2022 07:31

Agree save it for another time - next gifts or save for driving lessons (a present for xmas) here are X amount of lessons for you like a voucher.
That's such a faff to deal with.

ohfook · 12/06/2022 07:28

Your son should get the money.

HairyScaryMonster · 12/06/2022 07:21

I'd be putting the top up above the usual amount you spend in his savings account and telling him so. So he gets say £100 to squander and the rest is for something sensible. Or he's better off than his brother.

LaWench · 11/06/2022 23:44

I sold it via my FB account and sorted the collection as she was only 13 but DD made the decision to sell, it was her item to sell so she reaped the financial rewards. She ended up deciding to sell loads more which was great for us during a move, less for us to box up, store and move.

RandomUsernameHere · 11/06/2022 20:47

He should keep the money but he should be the one going to the effort of selling it

WhatIsThisPlease · 11/06/2022 20:43

My mum sold my doll's pram when I was about 9 or 10. She kept the money.

I don't think I've ever got over it 😂

StColumbofNavron · 11/06/2022 20:12

DD advertised it herself on gumtree and got £250 for it (few years ago).

But he isn't going to do this.

I am 100% not taking the money, but I am going to try to exercise some control over it being spent wisely. Or he might surprise me and do it himself, in which case I will stay out of it.

OP posts:
AhNowTed · 11/06/2022 19:52

It's his money.

We were in this exact situation. Electronic drum kit.

DD advertised it herself on gumtree and got £250 for it (few years ago).

The money was hers to keep, which she put towards something else.

Zigzagzoozoo · 11/06/2022 19:52

I was bought a violin as a Christmas present when I was young. After I gave up several years later, my mum sold it and kept the money. I was extremely upset as it felt like she was taking the gift back because I hadn’t worked hard enough or been good enough at it. Let him keep the money OP.

StColumbofNavron · 11/06/2022 19:43

I'm just making stuff up - I'm sure there are bigger things he will want for the new bedroom but I couldn't think of any and pillows and duvets were the only thing I could think of. 😳

A gaming chair and lava lamp are more likely and obviously far more fun option.

OP posts:
Hugasauras · 11/06/2022 19:42

I don't think big ticket items like that need to have their actual monetary value reimbursed. It was obviously a special gift with a purpose, not a usual Christmas gift, and you're going to lose money on reselling it when it never got used. Plus it's six months since Christmas now, so I'd just keep the money or stick it in savings for him later!

Adamantspants · 11/06/2022 19:41

You want him to spend it on pillows and duvet covers?

StColumbofNavron · 11/06/2022 19:38

@LaWench , DD sold them. That is possibly part of my issue here. He has just decided not to use it anymore after a short time. He hasn't played with it, loved it and used it and decided he is done. He also just said it in passing when I asked what about the drum kit - 'I don't know, sell it or something,' which take to mean I will sell, arrange the pick up etc.

I do think, even when I was typing the OP I knew it had to be his money, but it has just occurred to me that I could encourage him to use it towards the room refurb i.e. if he wants a more expensive bed/pillows/covers or whatever.

OP posts:
TheWayoftheLeaf · 11/06/2022 19:37

Obviously him. It was his present.

Festivalpartygirl · 11/06/2022 19:36

It’s his money but I would be encouraging him to buy a wanted big ticket item with it, so rather than he squanders, he buys the item, which lets you off the hook for said item.

LaWench · 11/06/2022 19:29

I'd say definitely his if it was a gift. DD sold her expensive lego sets during a house move and it was her money. It encouraged her to declutter/sell some more items, happy days.

Tiani4 · 11/06/2022 19:21

You bought a bigger present as part of it was for his GCSE music to help him with an expensive electronic drum kit . I suspect you spent £200 more on his Xmas present /budget than you'd usually do, and because he changed his mind/ dropped out of lessons, to resell it now you'd lose more than actual budget you'd have spent on a usual Xmas gift for him.

So if I were you I'd put the money aside from its sale into savings to go towards his driving lessons as your instinct is telling you.

It's a life lesson to your DS, that new items devalue, and what you had given up to purchase of new for him. Otherwise he could start a hobby for each Xmas / birthday, say he needs new equipment each time and he'll get more spent on him and cash back later!!! ... No no no!

You wouldn't have given him £380 to fritter away.

He'll still get the money (ie it'll be his) but towards something substantial. Driving lessons when he's 17.

SteakExpectations · 11/06/2022 19:16

My son is the same age. I would sell it, buy something else that he wants/needs and then pocket the rest. My my DS, the purchase would be some soundproofing for his room and some recording equipment.

At the end of the day, it’s his Christmas gift you’re exchanging, so it needs to be something decent that you exchange it with.

IncompleteSenten · 11/06/2022 19:06

I'd sell it, give him the amount of cash I normally would have spent and keep the rest.

StColumbofNavron · 11/06/2022 19:03

He says so. I'll leave it a little while I think, maybe after summer just to be sure. Then I think he will have to decide because we are redecorating the room and making better use of the space ready for his brother to join secondary school so he can make a decision then. I'll say 50% to saving and he can take me for a cheap coffee/cake to thank me for doing the admin.

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 11/06/2022 18:58

I’d have spent £200 on a Christmas present, and £200 on an instrument to get him through GCSEs, so I can see why it was worth doing. But I wouldn’t have handed over £300 cash for a Christmas present. It’s a shame he won’t play at all again - is he sure?

StColumbofNavron · 11/06/2022 18:54

LivingInSin · 11/06/2022 18:51

In that case, I’d just give him the cash. A pair of trainers and a few video games, it’ll be gone. You don’t get much for a few hundred quid for teens unfortunately.

See for me, that is a lot of money for him. I had to save for that, so it isn't a small amount of money. He doesn't have madly expensive taste.

OP posts:
StColumbofNavron · 11/06/2022 18:51

It is significantly more than I would usually spend on one gift - but he had said very clearly that he would pursue GCSE music and it made sense to have an instrument. We don't have the space for storage and he shares a room with his younger brother and it takes a lot of space.

I do agree in principle, it is his money, but he will just use it to put clothes on now and it will inhibit space.

OP posts:
LivingInSin · 11/06/2022 18:51

StColumbofNavron · 11/06/2022 18:43

I don't know why I have been so vague.

It's an electronic drumkit.

I'd hope (though who knows) to get about £200-£250 (cost £380 in December). Seems like a lot to just let him spend any which way.

In that case, I’d just give him the cash. A pair of trainers and a few video games, it’ll be gone. You don’t get much for a few hundred quid for teens unfortunately.

Oysterbabe · 11/06/2022 18:48

It's his money. Why would he want to sell it and get literally no benefit? He could keep it in that case even if barely used.