Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that I can 'buy' good neighbours

217 replies

uis · 11/06/2022 17:45

Ok so I think I am probably BU but let me set context. I also appreciate this thread might grate on a lot of people given the difficulties in getting on the property ladder but I post this with the humblest of intentions and appreciate how fortunate I am.

So I've been on MN for a long time and read a lot of neighbour dispute threads. Most of the nuisance neighbours seem to be druggies, on benefits and out of work or just not right in the head. We live in a detached house and had a set of bad neighbours who were renting (loud music in the garden, parking issues, drugs and we suspected dealing as well). Through us and neighbours persistently complaining to the landlord and development company, things improved after a few months and they moved out after 12 months anyway.

We're currently in the process of selling and have reserved a detached house in another new build development much further away. The houses around us are all detached and around the £600 - 680k mark and it got me thinking - we were worried about getting dodgy neighbours again but sort of assumed that being at this price range, we'd avoid really bad nuisance neighbours or that we'd get neighbours who would probably be more reasonable about things.

Is this a really bad assumption? Does anyone have any horror stories about neighbours despite living in a nice affluent area or area with relatively high house prices? I know minor parking disputes are fairly commonplace regardless of where you are but any major issues anyone has experienced? I guess had we not had issues ourselves, we might never had considered it. Thanks in advance for any responses!

OP posts:
Ireolu · 11/06/2022 20:00

Semi on our street sold for 775. Our neighbours r horrible. People r people some r nice others not so much.

Hallyup89 · 11/06/2022 19:58

With that attitude, you'd be the neighbour I'd be avoiding tbh.

MiniDinosaur · 11/06/2022 19:58

My neighbour causes a racket revving his Lamborghini at all hours 😂

GiltEdges · 11/06/2022 19:56

My honest opinion is... you'll find arseholes in all classes and levels of affluence. Getting good or bad neighbours is just luck of the draw 🤷🏼‍♀️

megletthesecond · 11/06/2022 19:52

If you can afford a detached house with a driveway that should eliminate some problems.

I live in the cheapest place I've lived, ex council and mix of housing association / private rental/ owned. And its a nightmare. Flytipping, drug dealers (one in prison though), no one brings their bins in or mostly takes care of anything. I PassAgg litter pick and seed bomb the place just to try and make it less awful.

Kris02 · 11/06/2022 19:51

To be fair, I can understand the OP's fears. Nightmare neighbours ruin lives. And it makes me so *ing angry I can hardly talk about it. I am not exaggerating when I say that I've known two people (opposite ends of the country) driven to suicide attempts by the subhuman chavs next door. All over Britain there are good people who love their kids, work hard and do the right thing, but whose lives are ruined by these aseholes.

As for whether money can buy you freedom, well, maybe. It probably reduces your chances of living near the feral, hoodie type. But nothing guarantees escape. Unfortunately, the housing association can move a problem family anywhere. I knew a cancer surgeon who lived in a big detached house in the best part of town. The housing association got hold of another big house near him and turned it into flats. Within weeks, there were fights at 3 in the morning, dogs barking all night, cars with modified engines screaming and banging up and down the road. Awful. After a year or two of ruining everyone's lives, there was a fire and someone died. After that, the place was closed down.

Equally, you could move to the absolute worst estate in Britain, with the highest crime and drug rates, and somewhere on that estate you'll find lovely, kind, good people. Truth is, you'll find lovely people selling the Big Issue and sleeping in shop doorways.

I'm not wealthy, but we're lucky to be in a fairly quiet street out in the countryside. And yet as I type all I can hear is the screaming of car engines and the popping and banging of modified exhausts. You can't escape horrible, selfish, anti-social people anywhere.

There really ought to be open prisons for them to live in. The left seem to think money solves everything, that all you need to do is move them into nice neighbourhoods (so the poor little sweeties don't feel ''excluded'' and ''marginalized''), provide nice schools and pay out generous benefits and everything will be hunky dory. We all know it won't. Both the right and the left have failed to deal with anti-social behavior. I don't blame them. There's just nothing you can do with the worst sorts of people, other than stop them breeding. People with a history of violence and misconduct, who've got a track record of disruption and abuse, should be forced to live together with some kind of warden watching over them. If it was up to me, I'd also pay them not to produce children. And before someone calls me a snob, don't forget that their main victims are decent people on low incomes.

kittensinthekitchen · 11/06/2022 19:50

Ah "Drug dealers are fine, as long as they're not on my street"

PeachCottonTree · 11/06/2022 19:49

Definitely a bad assumption. A relative has recently moved into a luxury new build estate with very expensive houses in the same price region you’re talking about. One of the neighbours have the biggest house type and three kids who they let run riot with zero parenting. The kids are incredibly loud (screaming and shouting at ridiculous levels) and they’ve broken the fence that borders the show home in 9 places. The parents have made no attempt to fix it as progressively more damage is done. We live in a much, much poorer area and it’s lovely and quiet all year around. Not everyone with money is considerate of others.

Roarsomemore · 11/06/2022 19:49

@Zoeslatesttrope good point. One man's heaven is another man's hell. Got me thinking about what I would class as nightmare neighbours...

MajorCarolDanvers · 11/06/2022 19:48

I live in a very affluent area. And I have awful NDN (a thread in itself) and across the back another neighbour is constructing a monstrosity of chalet in their garden.

Money is no guarantee of manners, consideration or good behaviour.

Zoeslatesttrope · 11/06/2022 19:41

Mellowyellow222 · 11/06/2022 18:32

I will be honest and say as I have moved up the property ladder the problems with neighbours have reduced.

first home an apartment - lots of rented neighbours. All quite young. Problems were parties and one offs. A few drunken fights and had to call the police once.

next ring on the ladder was a smaller house in lower priced neighbourhood. Problems every summer with loud music in gardens - couldn’t really use garden because of noise. Small gardens so could hear about 10 families shouting, swearing, playing loud dance music etc etc.

now in a much more affluent area. Noise in garden is children playing - trampolines and swings squeaking and kids laughing and shouting. Lovely background noise🥰.

I think the difference for me isn’t how rich the people are - it’s their ages and life stages (the people here tend to be older). Also the more expensive the house, the bigger the gardens and the more space. So you just don’t hear as much.

I'd prefer the sound of swearing to the sound of squeaking trampolines tbf...

Sparro · 11/06/2022 19:38

Is this a really bad assumption?

Yes.

ChitChatChatter · 11/06/2022 19:38

We lived happily on various council estates when I was a child but I had to move from my previous home of 20+ years in a ‘naice’ area when my neighbour moved a new partner in. He was the most aggressive, noisy, selfish bully I’ve ever come across and made my and my other neighbours lives a total misery. As others have said, money doesn’t necessarily buy class.

Hawkins001 · 11/06/2022 19:31

I think on balance, id prefer upper class neighbours

blebbleb · 11/06/2022 19:31

It doesn't matter how much you spend on a house. You could be unlucky and live next to an arsehole. We live in an ex council house in a cheaper area of London and have never had trouble with neighbours. You're being quite elitist, lots of wealthy people are horrible, the same as poorer people.

Crimeismymiddlename · 11/06/2022 19:30

Good neighbours are pure luck.

antelopevalley · 11/06/2022 19:29

I also know someone through work in a £600k house who regularly has her music blaring. She bought outdoor speakers so she could sit in the garden and have her music blaring loudly.

SafelySoftly · 11/06/2022 19:28

House around the £750k mark here. Neighbours are an absolute nightmare, coming and going at all hours, completely disruptive building work, parking wars. You are deluded and snobbish with it.

antelopevalley · 11/06/2022 19:27

The worst neighbour dispute I ever read about was someone living in a large and very expensive detached house and a Hells Angel motorcycle gang moved in next door.

plainwhitecheese · 11/06/2022 19:25

uis · 11/06/2022 18:49

Thanks to those of you who have directly responded to my questions.

I forget that on MN you need to spell things out or explain a specific scenario to death or people pounce and take it out of context or just feel the need to get something 🙄 Most of the comments are par for the course whenever anyone raises anything to do with money on MN so I won't address those.

I wasn't ignorant that I thought there would be no disputes if you paid above a certain amount for a house but I guess I was most interested in understanding what sort of disputes people might have encountered/expected at the £600-800k bracket as obviously this might be different to disputes on say a terraced road or a private house where houses are £2m+.

To be honest I wouldn't care if my neighbours were young working professionals snorting coke as that would impact me less than someone drug dealing but it's interesting to see that across the board I guess loud parties and noisy music can happen across any road or area regardless of price (though I sort of expected that). We're still quite young so hopefully in time we can get to the million+ houses and at least now I know what to look out for!

My parents paid over 850k for their house. Detached, only 5 houses on the road. All set back off the road.
They have one neighbour who screams at her kids and the dog every day and night. Screaches everything, shoes on!! Close the door!!! Come and get your dinner!!!
My mum can hear her from inside her house if mum has windows open.

Said house also has a (e we think) drug dealing son

Another of the neighbours may well be classed as ' not right in the head' as you said.

And then another neighbour has massive parties that last all night, including loads of cars parked everywhere, rubbish and vomit on the streets and people out in the street at all hours, at least once every couple of months

As others have said. Money can't buy class

Octomore · 11/06/2022 19:21

Ferrarilover · 11/06/2022 17:54

People will flame you as they assume snobbery, but to be honest, I think you stand a better chance of reasonable neighbours at this price range, depending on the area. In some areas, houses in this price range can very modest and built very close to neighbouring properties.

If you are buying a detached house, then you avoid disputes over bordering fences and hedges, and if the houses are set well apart from each other, the chances of avoiding quarrels rises.

Just my opinion.

This makes no sense. I have lived in two detached homes, and both had bordering fences/hedges. How else do you think the garden is divided from the neighbour's garden?

InChocolateWeTrust · 11/06/2022 19:20

Yabu.

I live in one of the most expensive parts of the country. I've lived in much more deprived areas so had experience of both.

You can just as many neighbour issues in either. There are arseholes at every income level.

In my current posh area there's everything from:

  • noisy dogs
  • disruptive home renovations
  • thinly veiled racism, from older people especially
  • rat issues due to all the people keeping chickens
  • arguments over fence/tree maintenance
  • naice families where parents are regularly away and teens throw loud parties every time they are
  • lots of loud expensive parties with noisy fireworks, with or without teens
  • plenty of drunkenness
pushingpoppies · 11/06/2022 19:20

What is the actual point of this disgusting thread? It's to bash working class people or people on hard times while you all get to show off how fucking rich you are to live in the 'posh' bit. Really, take a good look at yourselves

pushingpoppies · 11/06/2022 19:18

People on benefits, people who haven't currently got a job... Yes, OP, thank god you can spirit away from these scum of the earth in your fairy castle

DirtyteaCup · 11/06/2022 19:17

I have 2 homes.
1 is ex LA with about 30% still LA
1 is very large detached houses- all a £million plus on a road in the North of England

The ex LA has just the best neighbours and no trouble.
The other road has not so good neighbours (and no community).