Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that I can 'buy' good neighbours

217 replies

uis · 11/06/2022 17:45

Ok so I think I am probably BU but let me set context. I also appreciate this thread might grate on a lot of people given the difficulties in getting on the property ladder but I post this with the humblest of intentions and appreciate how fortunate I am.

So I've been on MN for a long time and read a lot of neighbour dispute threads. Most of the nuisance neighbours seem to be druggies, on benefits and out of work or just not right in the head. We live in a detached house and had a set of bad neighbours who were renting (loud music in the garden, parking issues, drugs and we suspected dealing as well). Through us and neighbours persistently complaining to the landlord and development company, things improved after a few months and they moved out after 12 months anyway.

We're currently in the process of selling and have reserved a detached house in another new build development much further away. The houses around us are all detached and around the £600 - 680k mark and it got me thinking - we were worried about getting dodgy neighbours again but sort of assumed that being at this price range, we'd avoid really bad nuisance neighbours or that we'd get neighbours who would probably be more reasonable about things.

Is this a really bad assumption? Does anyone have any horror stories about neighbours despite living in a nice affluent area or area with relatively high house prices? I know minor parking disputes are fairly commonplace regardless of where you are but any major issues anyone has experienced? I guess had we not had issues ourselves, we might never had considered it. Thanks in advance for any responses!

OP posts:
123Squirrel · 11/06/2022 20:59

Money could help buy you greater distance from any neighbours but inconsiderate arseholes are in all walks of life.

Hawkins001 · 11/06/2022 20:59

rnsaslkih · 11/06/2022 20:35

You just get a different kind of dodgy if you pay more money. You might get a neighbour who isn’t happy with how you trimmed your hedge or some such petty shite and comes whinging and whining about nothing. Sometimes when people have a bit of money, they think they are some sort of superior being who should dictate to others.

even celebs who live next door to eachother with ££££££££ argue about stuff.

On the Osbournes show I believe ozzy threw a log through the neighbours window.

MrsRuggles · 11/06/2022 20:50

No, pricey homes do not guarantee decent neighbours. I had friends who had a large beautiful flat in a subdivided listed building. The fall outs over maintenance, parking, access to gardens, noise levels, water damage due to leaks etc had to be seen to be believed. One couple were particularly noisy and the male partner flashed at my friend. Never ever would I want to live some were similar even if I could get it for half the price.

ApplesandBunions · 11/06/2022 20:44

rnsaslkih · 11/06/2022 20:35

You just get a different kind of dodgy if you pay more money. You might get a neighbour who isn’t happy with how you trimmed your hedge or some such petty shite and comes whinging and whining about nothing. Sometimes when people have a bit of money, they think they are some sort of superior being who should dictate to others.

even celebs who live next door to eachother with ££££££££ argue about stuff.

This is my experience. When I used to volunteer in a CAB bordering quite a wealthy area, the people coming in about lunatic hedge trimming, boundary dispute type stuff were all the ones with the expensive properties. That sort of thing simply did not fly on the estate I was living on. But there would've been more fighting. So it depends on the kind of nuisance neighbour you're most concerned about really. Would you like your life made a misery by someone who sends you solicitors letters every time you fart too loudly or by someone who engages in more stereotypically working class types of anti social behaviour?

TheRealHousewife · 11/06/2022 20:43

FiveNineFive · 11/06/2022 17:53

Bollocks. I live on a council estate. My neighbours are fab.

Totally agree with this! The best neighbours I ever had was when I was in my first home, which was rented!

lyns86x · 11/06/2022 20:40

I think you're right OP, there's always going to be right moaners in here who contest anything you say, but you should be in with a higher chance of getting a better neighbour so fingers crossed you do!

TheRealHousewife · 11/06/2022 20:38

We live in a home similar in value to what you’re moving to. Our neighbours are the worst we ever had in 40 years! I’ll not go into detail, but I will say bad neighbours can really ruin your sense of well-being and self confidence!

rnsaslkih · 11/06/2022 20:36

Oh and I do know someone (in fact they had a 600k house coincidentally) who had to move due to awful neighbours.

rnsaslkih · 11/06/2022 20:35

You just get a different kind of dodgy if you pay more money. You might get a neighbour who isn’t happy with how you trimmed your hedge or some such petty shite and comes whinging and whining about nothing. Sometimes when people have a bit of money, they think they are some sort of superior being who should dictate to others.

even celebs who live next door to eachother with ££££££££ argue about stuff.

dottiedodah · 11/06/2022 20:33

My cousin had the worst ndn .he was rude nasty and abusive.very wealthy man .in a house well over I mil!

ApplesandBunions · 11/06/2022 20:29

Having lived in some diverse areas income wise, I think it's fair to say you'll just buy a different type of risk. You choose your poison.

uis · 11/06/2022 20:27

I can see there are now more thought out responses which is helpful for me. I understand the whole point around it being luck and people can be cretins across all income brackets but some PP are acting as if I've said 'If I buy an expensive house does that mean I won't have bad neighbours'. I've not said that at all and am simply asking if it's reasonable to assume that the more you pay for a house, the less likely you are to have bad neighbours or they are likely to be more conciliatory if you have issues. If people think not then that is fair enough - I just wanted to garner some thoughts.

I think some people have forgotten that I've already gone through living next to horrible nuisance neighbours that were playing loud music, drug dealing and being very antagonistic. As @Kris02 said, it's absolute hell and my DP was diagnosed with an anxiety disorder during this period for which he continues to take medication. We just don't want to go through it again and it's sad that people turn it into a 'snobbish' thing because if I said I was moving from say a council flat to a £150k house I doubt I would get the same type of comments.

OP posts:
MiniCooperLover · 11/06/2022 20:26

Most of the nuisance neighbours seem to be druggies, on benefits and out of work or just not right in the head. We live in a detached house and had a set of bad neighbours who were renting (loud music in the garden, parking issues, drugs and we suspected dealing as well).

Brilliant ... you couldn't sound more prejudiced and stuck up if you tried OP. Not everyone who is an arsehole is a druggie, on benefits or out of work or renting !! Good luck to your new neighbours, I think they'll need it 🙄

itsgettingweird · 11/06/2022 20:25

I agree with those saying the problem with living around money is people can buy stuff that annoys you!

Hot tubs, loud music systems etc. they also can afford drugs even if they aren't dealing. They can afford to host large BBQs and parties and cater for large numbers.

There's probably some statistical chance you'll get better neighbours than in an area of severe deprivation but I doubt it's got to do with economics but more population density.

theemmadilemma · 11/06/2022 20:21

We live in a nice area. Not as expensive, but our next door neighbour is an ex footballer, 2 range rovers on the drive type thing.

They're lovely people, awesome polite kids (3), but they're not good at noise consideration. Think lots of people watching the screen in the garden bar, kids beeping on electric cars up and down the long garden, dogs barking... the road breathes a sigh of peace and quiet when they're away.

I've not complained, it's never been late, they're just living life and enjoying what they have. 🤷‍♀️ Fortunately they holiday a lot. 😁

BakeOffRewatch · 11/06/2022 20:20

You need to watch Midsummer Murders, I’d be more scared in a nice quiet “affluent” area! Grin

nickthefox · 11/06/2022 20:19

just think of all the cocaine you can buy when you can afford a 600k house! your neigh ours may never sleep.

Plenty of people on low incomes, renting and or in benefits are very nice. Plenty of wealthy people are not very nice. I suspect you can feel the fingers pointing in your direction through the screen?

NotMushroomInEre · 11/06/2022 20:18

Well, when I say it is a gamble, that isn't strictly true. If you have time you can check out the neighbourhood at different times of the day. It doesn't stop a great neighbour selling up to a shit one in the future though.

hshbjamo · 11/06/2022 20:18

You do realise a lot of new build houses are housing associations. So you could literally live next door or on the same street as people who are on benefits etc. Not that it even matters. You can be a nuisance neighbour whether you are rich or poor. Money doesn't determine whether you're a nasty person or not or whether you'll be a good neighbour or not.

CatLadyDrinksGin · 11/06/2022 20:17

Nope- naice houses here, police called as one neighbour threatened to kill another over their £130k mobile home! Plus fights in the street at 1am.

Redkatagain · 11/06/2022 20:10

We are buying a house for a similar amount.

We have decided that as the first sign of difficult neighbours, we will pretend to be suburban satanists.

We will be subtle

NotMushroomInEre · 11/06/2022 20:09

Unless you buy a remote plot of land and build your own home, I'm afraid this is just a gamble really. Some people are nice, some aren't, regardless of wealth.

Ropesdope · 11/06/2022 20:08

I’ve found the higher the price range the better the chance of more reasonable neighbours. If you do your homework you can find estates that were built in the 70’s/80’s and most of the people in them are now in their 60’s/70’s and the kids have flown the nest. They also have wider roads and bigger gardens. In my mums street there have only been 2 houses for sale in the last 20 years. If you buy a new build then it’s a bit of a lottery still! Money can still = problem neighbours.

Meatshake · 11/06/2022 20:05

My house recently got valued at £750k, detached house in a naice private road with an active residents association. The epitome of suburbia. Except... The house next door got turned into a HMO last year. Money doesn't guarantee anything unless you're talking about owning a massive estate with a lot of space between you and your nearest neighbour!

Spaceprincess · 11/06/2022 20:02

I live in a beautiful Yorkshire Dales village, its full on James Herriot holiday cottage place.
I have a 2 bed back to back terrace. It's a 230k house cos area.
I'm not posh, I'm from round here.
Next door is 500k house as its two back to backs knocked into one
It's 4 bed 3 bath home with big gardens.

They have 5 dogs that bark 24/7 and both gardens are pliled with dog poo.

They scream and shout at each other and their teenage kids, swearing and threatening to hurt each other and the kids.
Dd 19 knows the oldest one vaguely, he didn't realise they were neighbours and told her all about it. Scared of his alcoholic mum, wants to run away with his sister who is 14.
I have rung the police loads of times, as have other neighbours and also rung their DDs school and police and social services after being woken up at midnight with her screaming that she's going to Fing kill DD for coming into her room, child begging mum to stop.
They are awful and well known in the village.
So yeh, anyone can be a cunt.