Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that I can 'buy' good neighbours

217 replies

uis · 11/06/2022 17:45

Ok so I think I am probably BU but let me set context. I also appreciate this thread might grate on a lot of people given the difficulties in getting on the property ladder but I post this with the humblest of intentions and appreciate how fortunate I am.

So I've been on MN for a long time and read a lot of neighbour dispute threads. Most of the nuisance neighbours seem to be druggies, on benefits and out of work or just not right in the head. We live in a detached house and had a set of bad neighbours who were renting (loud music in the garden, parking issues, drugs and we suspected dealing as well). Through us and neighbours persistently complaining to the landlord and development company, things improved after a few months and they moved out after 12 months anyway.

We're currently in the process of selling and have reserved a detached house in another new build development much further away. The houses around us are all detached and around the £600 - 680k mark and it got me thinking - we were worried about getting dodgy neighbours again but sort of assumed that being at this price range, we'd avoid really bad nuisance neighbours or that we'd get neighbours who would probably be more reasonable about things.

Is this a really bad assumption? Does anyone have any horror stories about neighbours despite living in a nice affluent area or area with relatively high house prices? I know minor parking disputes are fairly commonplace regardless of where you are but any major issues anyone has experienced? I guess had we not had issues ourselves, we might never had considered it. Thanks in advance for any responses!

OP posts:
luckylavender · 12/06/2022 09:53

This is such a ridiculous stealth bragging post. Shit neighbours are everywhere as are good ones. Luck of the draw.

whenindoubtgotothelibrary · 12/06/2022 09:40

I dont think OP is being snobbish - wouldn't we all opt for quiet neighbours if there was a way to guarantee it? But sadly I have to confirm that in my experience it's largely down to luck, and money doesn't buy peace and quiet. Also - look at Jimmy Page and Robbie Williams!

TattiePants · 12/06/2022 09:38

One of the richest people I know (actually knew, thankfully) would be one of the worst people possible to live next to. In the two different houses they lived when I knew them, they had mass fallings out with multiple neighbours (and many other people). They’ve now moved to a third house next door to a friend of a friend and have had the police called on them multiple times because they are so awful. The second house is on the market for over £1m in a very cheap part of the UK and they’ve bought a very expensive new build that they are currently living in. Money makes no difference to who your neighbours are.

forinborin · 12/06/2022 09:25

I cannot understand this faux wide eye outrage at the OP's question. Yes, wealth is generally correlated with a pleasant living environment people create around themselves. Surely ending up with aloof stuck up neighbours is a somewhat different flavour of "bad" compared to burglaries, stabbings, open drug taking etc.?

daisyjgrey · 12/06/2022 09:22

Clearly you've never seen Midsomer Murders.

Ferrarilover · 12/06/2022 09:21

Judging by the replies on this thread, it seems as if everyone who lives in an affluent area has loud, drunken, drug dealing neighbours, and everyone who lives on a council estate has considerate, welcoming neighbours who never cause a bit of bother.

In real life, I suspect that this is very far from the truth.

No one can guarantee good neighbours but in reality, more expensive properties are less likely to have inconsiderate neighbours, despite the inverted snobbery replies.

Wickywickyyow · 12/06/2022 09:19

some PP are acting as if I've said 'If I buy an expensive house does that mean I won't have bad neighbours'. I've not said that at all

Do you want to re read your title OP?

MrsMoastyToasty · 12/06/2022 09:14

All the new build estates around here are mixed private and housing association. You wouldn't be able to tell if one was private or social housing by looking at the properties. Prices start at about £800k. Like most areas you get good and bad owners, just like you get good and bad tenants.

Thefoxsays · 12/06/2022 09:14

I think good neighbours are worth their weight in gold so understand your concerns. I am a private let tenant in an ex council house & my neighbours are great. Polite, friendly & look out for eachother but don't intrude. However about 3minutes up the road they built a new estate with an average price of around £750k, part of the deal was they would include homes for social rent. My friend was lucky enough to be given one due to her son's disabilities and said it has been a nightmare, there has been a stabbing, parties all day & issues with alcoholism etc. Basically the houses were all allocated to homeless people and families (or those with a medical need) which is obviously right but most of the time those people come with their own social issues (not always) and they are struggling to adjust their lifestyles. If I had paid that money for my house and ended up amongst stabbings and fighting I would be upset.

Grumpybutfunny · 12/06/2022 09:06

We traded a neighbour who I think was dealing, a street full of cars in the road. For a nice small street all have double drives, no private rents (people bid for this estate) the only issue we get a newly passed teenagers that can't park. Parents often run out to shift their kids cars and I know which house I love and which I'm glad we sold

CharChar91 · 12/06/2022 08:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

orbitalcrisis · 12/06/2022 08:53

My mother lives in a portion of a lovely old Tudor house, next door which is a little smaller and with less land recently sold for £850k. The bigger house on the other side has a complete nightmare of a man living there! Always claiming poverty when he has to cough up his share for works done, then buggering off to his second home in France so he can't be contacted. He's tried moving the boundaries several times, even though his garden is massive, bought a puppy then didn't train it so it bites everyone...

I'm afraid that more expensive houses just mean more expensive issues with nightmare neighbours.

But if you're buying a new build you'll probably be too busy with all the snagging issues to worry about the neighbours anyway.

Saracen · 12/06/2022 08:43

Where you do have an advantage over people with less money is that if you end up with nightmare neighbours, you have the option to move. It isn't cheap or convenient, but you will not be completely stuck.

I have friends without money who simply don't have the option of escaping from their neighbours. One is in a council house: no one wants to exchange with her because the area is so undesirable. Another is with a private landlord and can barely afford her existing rent, which is less than the going rate. Not only are other properties impossible for her to afford, but no sensible landlord would take her on because it's obvious she'd struggle to pay the rent.

Remember that you're rolling the dice with respect to your neighbours, but if you lose, you can roll again, which is a luxury many people don't have.

Sheenpl · 12/06/2022 08:41

I live in the nicest area in my town with lots of old retired people. Very quiet but also incredibly nosy busybodies. Not long after moving in I had a neighbour chapping my door and rudely demanding to know what I’m going to do with the garden! Fell out with my neighbour pretty quickly!!

Very difficult to find good neighbours! I just keep myself to myself, try avoid problems that way.

Thisbastardcomputer · 12/06/2022 08:28

At our old house, the next door neighbour sold his large garden for building plots, 4 of them.

They were bought by a lottery winning scrubber for his entire family.

I can't begin to tell you of the nightmare they were.

Merryclaire · 12/06/2022 08:25

Money can’t buy you good neighbours but it can buy you a house with a bigger garden and driveway, to help put a bit of distance between you.

Our old house was ex-council, mixed in with council, and it was the quietest place to live - the reason for this was that one neighbour (who we believe was a drug dealer) HATED noise, and would aggressively confront anyone who made any. He was unpleasant so we avoided him, but he kept everyone in line.

Some new neighbours moved in (early 20s) and had a loud house party to celebrate - he soon put a stop to that!

So while a bad neighbour in some ways, he made it a very peaceful place to live!

My friend has just completed a fabulous renovation in a wealthy area, creating her dream family home, but has had to sell up before even moving in due to a nightmare neighbour.

So it’s a lottery. But, it helps if you can afford to not live on a crammed estate and have more room.

However, be wary of too much space in a rural area. If you’re surrounded by fields you’re more likely to get travellers. Ironically, due to the discrimination their community faces, they are often allowed to stay on land where others wouldn’t be allowed to, to meet local targets to create suitable pitches. However, if you get antisocial travellers move in (not that they all are), they are the worst neighbours you could have.

PissedOffNeighbour22 · 12/06/2022 07:55

The more money people have, the more entitled they seem to be. We moved away from a council estate with a neighbour who pounded dance music to a quieter, semi rural location with hardly any neighbours. One of our neighbours also pounds dance music loudly whenever they feel like it, along with revving engines and using heavy machinery. When they have parties they can afford to get DJs, so the noise is ridiculous. Our life is also being made a misery by the supposedly nice and respectable neighbour our house is attached to.

ReneBumsWombats · 12/06/2022 07:34

I don’t think it is snobby to not want druggies, loud parties, shouty noisy neighbors. Who in their right mind wants to put up with that?

It's more the idea that none of this could happen in an expensive area.

Proudboomer · 12/06/2022 07:23

I don’t think it is snobby to not want druggies, loud parties, shouty noisy neighbors. Who in their right mind wants to put up with that?
I started in a studio flat above a bookies and now live in a 4 bed detached and have pretty much lived in everything between. My detached is in a nice area. The neighbors tend to be older as like most of us it takes years to move up the ladder so no young children with trampolines or playing in the street. Loud parties are rare but the house at the back of me has one every summer. Goes on late but I can’t complain as it is only once a summer. We all have drives and only 6 houses in the road so no parking issues. Drugs I know are in the area as they are pretty much everywhere and there are a couple of local parks I wouldn’t go in after dark as I know these are places where drugs are sold and used but with older often retired neighbors the only drugs they take are the ones prescribed by their doctors.

ApplesandBunions · 12/06/2022 07:15

Mellowyellow222 · 11/06/2022 22:18

But she referenced drug dealing in her opening post?

surely the more expensive the neighbourhood, the less likely the next door neighbour is dealing?

younger renters are in lower cost neighbourhoods - more chances of wild parties. Less consideration of neighbours. All generalisations of course - but this is about the general population.

She does reference drug dealing, but also discusses buying good neighbours in general. As a lot of us have pointed out, there's a whole tranche of bad neighbour behaviour that potentially becomes more likely at higher price points and that doesn't really fly in lower income areas, so the question is whether you find that prospect more acceptable than the sort of bad behaviour you mention here. Obviously it's a personal call. Main thing is for OP to have that information and then she can do with it as she wishes.

And fwiw I have lived next to someone who was dealing and it wasn't a particular inconvenience.

Movinghouseatlast · 12/06/2022 07:15

Mum2jenny · 11/06/2022 22:30

We’d be your neighbours from hell. Lots and lots of loud music, from 6am till midnight. No drugs though as it’s not our scene. Naked trips to the outside jacuzzi and lots of other very antisocial activities.
But as we are professionals, this is very much our choice!!!

Seriously? It's not your neighbours choice to listen to your loud music though is it?

Movinghouseatlast · 12/06/2022 07:09

Oh my god yes. My nightmare neighbour, who I ended up moving because of, had a PHD and a brand new £70k Mercedes. He was a CUNT. And a clever cunt at that.

He may not have dealt drugs or played music in the garden but he drove me out of the house I had lived in for over 20 years by raising a boundary dispute the day he moved in. We had never had any issue with any neighbour before him but he nearly broke me.

I now live in the middle of nowhere but my millionaire next door neighbour has been digging up.his 2 acre garden for a whole year now. The noise from the digger is terrible and makes our house vibrate. Using his digger appears to be his hobby and as he is too rich to work he can do it all day long.

Scianel · 12/06/2022 07:06

It's certainly been my experience that moving to a more affluent area gets you more respectable neighbours. I dont know why MN gets so angry about this.

EveSix · 12/06/2022 07:04

Northwinds, snap.
BIL bought off plan at an expensive new development. Adjacent is a row of social housing which he hadn't clocked at the time of purchase. They've been in for a couple of years now, and I honestly think BIL is being the bad neighbour; constantly obsessing about his council tenant neighbours, who never really seem to put a foot wrong, yet he's hyper-vigilant for potential issues and snooty to boot.
His neighbour on the other side, who owns, has had a washing machine and an armchair sitting on the drive in front of the double garage for months, and BIL doesn't seem to mind, just tuts at the council for not collecting (which they've no obligation to do). If it had been his social housing neighbours, he'd be on it.
We've an ex-council house on an old council estate, and have the best neighbours: our whole bit of the street is fantastic, and he bloody knows it.

Namechange20222 · 12/06/2022 07:03

A close friend of mine bought a detached house for £800,000. Her neighbours house is worth £1,000,000.
The neighbours in the million pound house constantly have the police round due to ongoing domestic abuse and drug fuelled incidents. The guy that lives there is awful and has turned paranoid, he is trying to involve my friend now and believes they are all plotting against him. It’s got very very ugly and my friend wants to move to get away from the constant harassment.
Mental health does not decide to only affect people who buy houses under £600,000. Abusive traits and destructive behaviours exist in some of the wealthiest people on the planet, they exist in our leaders, they exist in people with positions of extreme power.
I am surprised you seem to have no awareness to this.
HTH.