Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was I too harsh on teen daughter?

984 replies

MumofTeen22 · 11/06/2022 15:58

NC for this.

Backstory: teen DD (15) - a few months off turning 16 - is really, really lazy. I have to beg and bribe and nag to get her to help with the smallest of tasks at home. It's draining. All she wants to do it be out with her mates and asks for cash and lifts everywhere etc.

This whole week I've been off work sick with an awful tummy bug / virus. It's absolutely wiped me and youngest DC out (toddler who I am home looking after whilst trying to keep on top of household tasks etc). DH has been working long hours all week. I've had to hold onto kitchen counters at points to steady myself and try not to pass out whilst trying to get jobs done and look after my youngest, I've felt so ill with this bug. But I've had no choice but to keep going.

Teen DD has not offered much by the way of help despite seeing how unwell me and her younger sibling are. At a couple of points I begged her to help as I was really struggling and she did so, but very reluctantly.

Yesterday she announced "I'm out with my mates tomorrow, I'll get the bus to meet them" (bus to the nearest major city from where we live). I said that was fine so long as she didn't rely on lifts from me as I'm not well enough. She said nothing about Sunday and to be honest I was distracted with bathing the youngest so didn't ask what her plans were on Sunday.

So she went off out this morning before youngest DC and I got up. DH at work doing overtime as we need to money. So as per usual I'm just getting on with it all - housework and looking after youngest etc. But still struggling as not feeling great.

Teen messages me about holiday clothes purchases so I reply. I then say "by the way please don't make any plans for tomorrow as I'm going to need your help at home, I'm really behind with the housework this week as I've been ill and DH working again". She texts back: "I've got plans tomorrow with my boyfriend, it's been arranged for ages". I replied: "well you're not going, I need your help".

She then called me saying how it wasn't fair, this has been planned for ages etc. i just snapped at this point - probably a combination of feeling so rough and her selfish lazy attitude all the time. I would never have agreed to todays outing if I'd known she had plans Sunday - I'd have made it clear she needed to be around on at least one of the days to help out.

I said to her "Listen to me - you either get yourself home before 5pm today (this was at 2.50pm) and pull your weight and do some jobs, or you can forget about going out tomorrow and help me then instead. You've got just over 2 hours to get here. Your choice. But don't think I'm going to change my mind - one minute past 5 and you're not going. I'm serious."

Then i hung up.

By the way 2 hours is plenty of time on public transport to get home if she had started to make her way home straight away or within the next 10 mins.

So AIBU to have given her this ultimatum of making a choice: she either loses her day out tomorrow and helps out at home, or gets herself home at a reasonable time today and helps out, and keeps her outing tomorrow?

She's since messaged to say she's on route and it will be "just past 5" when she's home, followed by a "sorry".

Was I harsh??

OP posts:
Londondreams1 · 12/06/2022 20:07

I think it's unreasonable. Bad planning too. She could've done jobs through the week, with the assumption there was a possibility of her going out at the weekend. Many plans are made last minute minute on social media.
I'd feel like a prisoner as a free spirited teen. You could ask maybe 3 jobs before she goes out then 3 when she gets back.
Staying at home all day Sunday is such an oppressive thing, rarely would a teen boy be expected to do this, so there's that too.

Londondreams1 · 12/06/2022 20:06

I think it's unreasonable. Bad planning too. She could've done jobs through the week, with the assumption there was a possibility of her going out at the weekend. Many plans are made last minute minute on social media.
I'd feel like a prisoner as a free spirited teen. You could ask maybe 3 jobs before she goes out then 3 when she gets back.
Staying at home all day Sunday is such an oppressive thing, rarely would a teen boy be expected to do this, so there's that too.

Hutchy16 · 12/06/2022 20:03

Yeah you were ridiculously harsh. You didn’t give her advance warning of wanting help, and you demanded she come home. If she had known you had jobs for her then she could have done them on the morning or amend her plans.

In your daughters shoes I would have refused and you’d have no way of enforcing your pointless demands

Sleepingsatellite1 · 12/06/2022 20:03

FlissyPaps · 11/06/2022 16:02

IMO - I think that’s harsh.

What did you need help with at home? What jobs needed doing?

Do you normally give your 15yo jobs to do round the house?

Do you not is a more pertinent question??? 😱

Anonymoo544 · 12/06/2022 20:02

You are not being unreasonable at all. At 15 years old, she absolutely should be expected to help out, especiallyin times of genuine need. I'm baffled by those saying otherwise. 15 is not the age to be out enjoying your life at your own leisure but on your parents dollar, I'm sorry maybe I'm just too strict. Of course she should have some independence to go out but no way could I put my social life before my family when I was under 18. Neither do I have any resentment to my parents for this. 18+ is when I was allowed to make my own plans and priotise myself.

Anonymoo544 · 12/06/2022 19:57

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

PoppyinCologne · 12/06/2022 19:49

Honestly I think it's really unreasonable to demand from your kids full stop. This is really old fashioned parenting, it's how I was treated by my mother and honestly made me want to do nothing for her . How bout giving her enough warning and asking for help , tell her you know she's busy but you're not feeling so great and would really appreciate some help with some things around the house when she's got some time before heading out with her friends. ? I find treating kids with respect and giving them options usually is a good strategy rather than shrieking, demanding and threatening them.
I personally hate being told to do something but love to offer my help when I see help is needed

jacks11 · 12/06/2022 19:45

I think you are being both reasonable and unreasonable.

You are not unreasonable to want her to do more- she is old enough to contribute and should have set chores which she is expected to do. And if she does not do them, then there should be consequences for that- such as not being given money/lifts or not being allowed to go out with friends. These consequence will need to be consistently enforced and the benefits consistently received (fair’s fair, after all).

The issue is that you’ve not expected her routinely to do chores or help around the house and then randomly (because you are unwell) decided she should this weekend AND that she should have known before going out today that she would be expected to help out this weekend at some point, so she should have planned accordingly (I.e. not planned to go out today if she wanted to do the thing she planned with her boyfriend tomorrow). Something you, as the adult wanting help, failed to do. This has led to you demanding she come home or cancel long-standing plans with little notice, which is actually not very fair. If you wanted help (knowing she is unlikely to suddenly start doing housework off her own bat) then you should have said so earlier and planned it together. I’m guessing you didn’t because it didn’t occur to you and you aren’t feeling great. You have then taken out your lack of planning + feeling unwell + frustration with her lack of input at home on her over this. Which isn’t actually fair, even if it is understandable.

But, the fact she does not do anything currently is largely down to you and her father- you haven’t placed that expectation on her at any time up until now, so it is hardly surprising that she has not magically developed it all by herself. Most teens are, to a greater or lesser degree, quite selfish beings. Sometimes you need to spell out your expectations and what you want quite clearly (and don’t rise to the moaning/whining- i’ve found ignoring any such behaviour achieves more than getting angry- just re-iterate what they have to do and the consequences of not doing so. They usually realise that it’s easier just to get and do it, eventually they stop arguing). You haven’t done any of the that, but are now angry that she hasn’t read the memo and picked up on what you want? I think that is unfair.

Clearly, you are frustrated and changes are needed with regards to how much she does at home. You are not unreasonable to put that in place. But that will go much easier if you have her on board (to some extent) and this is not the way you get that. You have been unreasonable regards her plans tomorrow.

Whooshaagh · 12/06/2022 19:41

You’re soft compared to me OP.
When mine were teens and inevitably complained I told them that life’s tough and the sooner they realised that the better they would cope.
I have no guilt whatsoever about getting them to do chores and learning how to be self sufficient.
Can’t believe the parents on here who think their dc are more important than themselves.
I love my dc but I’m important too.

medwench · 12/06/2022 19:34

So yes, on this particular incident you were too harsh. You agreed she could go out and then went off on one when you found out she planned to go out on Sunday as well. You then demanded she come home to do housework. You hadn't asked her in advance to do that. You don't normally expect her to do that. So you broke your normal agreement. So on this specific occasion, yes you were a bit harsh, although it is totally understandable.
That said, your normal agreement does need to be reviewed, she is old enough to contribute to the smooth running of the household, especially when some of the people in it are unwell. Unfortunately, changing the terms of engagement now will be difficult as she has an allowance and phone package for doing nothing, but all of the stuff you mention is typical teenager behaviour and she will grow out of it eventually.
Teenagers don't see mess. They don't pick up on cues or hints, or on things which are obvious to adults. Their heads are a whirling mass of hormones and thoughts and possibilities and picking the hair out of the shower, cleaning the loo, even doing their own washing, just doesn't register for them. For now, remember you don't need to worry too much about the housework. Do, or get done, the minimum you need to, and let yourself rest, it will still be there another day.

When you are all feeling better, take her out for coffee and talk about everything that needs doing on a regular basis. Ask her if she can commit to doing some of those things because you'd like and need her help, and let her pick which ones. And find an appropriate way to compensate her, so maybe a mum daughter spa if she likes that, or a late night out with her friends if she normally has to be home early as a special treat for instance, you know what motivates her.

Finally, hope you are all feeling better very soon.

cuparfull · 12/06/2022 19:29

Mally100 · 11/06/2022 16:10

Yanbu, if she's old enough to have a boyfriend, go around with her friends and have a jolly good time she's old enough to contribute at home. She is selfish, so she needs a good wake up call about that. You are ill, she needs to help out.

Exactly this.... I only read the first couple of comments on this thread but am incredulous at the lax attitude of some of the mums on here raising such entitled children. A family is a support unit and you help each other out in time of need. Every family member should have chores to do or they don't get pocket money. Teach them responsibility!
If she was poorly no doubt her mum would have taken time off to care for her.

Itsbritneybitch22 · 12/06/2022 19:27

BadNomad · 12/06/2022 19:12

I can see by some of the opinions here why so many entitled little darlings are out here, going by some of these comments.

I don't understand comments like this. Do you not realise the OP has an "entitled little darling" for the reasons you are criticising in other people? The OP is one of those people who has lifted and laid her "little darling" all her life. Yet for some reason you think the other people who do the same are wrong, but the OP isn't at fault in the slightest?

@BadNomad

Has she though? Her daughter is coming home to help, she came to ask if she was harsh (she wasn’t) and so many people have commented like she’s kicking her out 😅

Yes she needs to help out around the house and people are talking as if she’s a baby, not a nearly 16 year old that has a boyfriend who gets lifts and always being funded to do fun stuff.
But the girl seems to understand she needs to help, and has come back.

To those saying that DP should have cancelled his overtime to help, who’s gonna pay for all these lifts and money for this poor ‘child’ to go out when she fancies it. It’s not too much to ask for the girl to help when her mum is poorly, a lot of comments here are going on like OP is really out of order, when she isn’t. Can’t imagine the people they’re raising if helping your mum when she can barely stand up, is that big a deal for people.

MyLifeJourney · 12/06/2022 19:25

It’s not easy being a mum and even more difficult with the age gap.

You’ll get through this and the house will be clean again but it doesn’t really matter if the housework is behind. What matters is you are there to give hugs. Get well soon.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 12/06/2022 19:20

I definitely think there’s a generational divide here…… When I was 9, my Mum developed pleurisy and I sat up with her through the night bringing her water and doing anything she needed until a doctor came out the morning - this was 1978. My grandmother was in the house but not well enough to help, and my Step Father couldn’t come because he had not yet moved in and shock horror we didn’t have a landline - I think our neighbour kindly went across the road to the pay phone to make calls for us.

From the same age, my Nana would give me a pound a week to clean her sitting room so I had spending money for our family holiday.

It was my job to make pots of tea as required, wash up after dinner, and when I went to secondary school I also had to walk my Mums Yorkie after school.

I remember the big family Christmas we had when I was 13 with extended family, which meant I and my female cousin were on washing-up duty between courses because we didn’t have enough crockery. I also remember having to clean the silver plated cutlery in advance, the set Nana got with her Kensitas coupons which she was very proud of.

Beinging my sons up I did my best to redress the gender issue and by and large they’re pretty self sufficient as they approach their late 20s - well they don’t get much choice as due to cost of living they live with me and we all work so leaving it all to Mum is not an option.

Writing that out has made me feel like Methuselah 🤣

elkiedee · 12/06/2022 19:19

[So when my DD texts last minute any of the following requests of me with ONE days notice, I'll say no.

I think you need to discuss how all these requests are made - some of them sound like they should be a no, that there are other solutions. Some she's assuming too much. In some cases she probably does need your help but short notice texts requiring you to adjust your plans/do something are a bit much.

A few months off 16? Is she year 10 with an autumn birthday rather than as some posters have assumed year 11, summer birthday and mid exams?

["I've got a detention tomorrow, can you pick me up as I'm going to miss the school coach"]

Probably hard to say no given the problems of transport but why is she getting detentions and is this a regular thing? Do some of them relate to her going out too much?

["Can I have some money for tomorrow as me and friend are going out again"]

Maybe you could say no here. Does this involve going to draw out cash for her? Does she have an allowance already? When planning going out it doesn't seem reasonable to assume she can make plans first and then demand money at short notice.

"I need my blue dress for tomorrow please can you check if it's washed"

If she's expecting you to do this while she's out, and just wash the dress on demand, again short notice, she needs to prepare better for pre planned going out. I would guess that might actually mean she knows the dress isn't washed and she's hoping that you'll sort it out. Does she know how to use the washing machine? If she doesn't even bother to put away clean clothes, does she help hang them to dry etc. I think it's reasonable to ask a 15 year old to take part in sorting out laundry and putting away clean clothes.

I confess though that I might not practice what I preach here (DS1 is just 15 and at the end of year 10). DP deals with most of the washing.

This is one for the conversation that you should tell her you need to have if you pick her up from the next detention.

"I've gone overdrawn on my account, don't know how, please can you ring them with me tomorrow and help me sort it??"

Yes to ringing them with her, I think it's a good thing that if there's a problem here she's asking. But it's also an opportunity, like the lift home after a detention, to make it clear that you're not just going to finance her social life and facilitate it all, and do everything, without a discussion (is there a budgeting issue here?)

CheshireCat1 · 12/06/2022 19:18

No, you wasn’t too harsh. I was working at 16 and gave most of my wages to Mum.

MrsRinaDecker · 12/06/2022 19:18

My son is the same age and I’m a disabled single parent.. he might grumble occasionally (I’m about to ask him to put the bins out so..) but he does loads to help and definitely pulls his weight. I might have been a pain as a teenager, but if my mum was sick I would have wanted to look after her. I don’t know if a row on the phone was the way to go about it, but it sounds like your dd needs to step up and show a bit of empathy. Hopefully you can get a proper chat when you’re both calm.. I always said we all live here.. we’re a team.. and we all need to do our bit.

Basilbrushgotfat · 12/06/2022 19:17

This is so going to get picked up by the Daily Fail 🙄

Nanny0gg · 12/06/2022 19:14

Youaremysunshine14 · 12/06/2022 19:03

This! I've RTFT and some of the responses have made my jaw drop. OP's had some really, really snotty comments aimed at her and the entitlement of some posters getting irate that she won't take their opinions on board is hilarious. Get over yourselves!

FWIW, OP, I don't think you were harsh on your DD. You've been unwell, are mopping up toddler sick and are clearly at the end of your rope with your teen's laziness, and all you did was ask her to spend the day at home helping out where necessary. You didn't ask her to child-mind, clean the scullery, clamber up the chimney, go down the mines. The outrage expressed by some PP makes me fear for this generation of kids that are coddled from pulling their weight with housework.🙄

Agree with all of the above.

How many MNers complain about useless men who don't know how to cook or wash or clean? Where and when should they have learned? Yes, at home, taught by their parents from an appropriate age.
Exactly the same for girls and 15 is more than old enough to be helping.

The very least, hoovering, dishwasher, a little tidying, preparing simple meals, clearing the kitchen.

My kids would have done more than that if I was ill

I would also normally say bathroom, but not were there's a sick bug involved. Sadly the OP and her DH will have to do that one.

threatmatrix · 12/06/2022 19:13

And this is where the problem lies. So you now feel bad about teaching your child the proper way to behave? You need to grow a pair.

trickyex · 12/06/2022 19:13

I also think too harsh sorry.
I have two teens and I wouldn't expect this level of help even if I was ill.
Your DH should be picking up the slack and cancelling overtime if needed.
Its fine to expect her to muck in but not to have to cancel plans last minute. Thats mean and not very fair IMO.

BadNomad · 12/06/2022 19:12

I can see by some of the opinions here why so many entitled little darlings are out here, going by some of these comments.

I don't understand comments like this. Do you not realise the OP has an "entitled little darling" for the reasons you are criticising in other people? The OP is one of those people who has lifted and laid her "little darling" all her life. Yet for some reason you think the other people who do the same are wrong, but the OP isn't at fault in the slightest?

Nanny0gg · 12/06/2022 19:08

Siameasy · 12/06/2022 12:26

Yanbu and people who go on about 15 year olds being children, implying that your re a big old meanie to expect anything remotely sensible, are part of the problem.

^^This

marmiteadict · 12/06/2022 19:08

@Youaremysunshine14

This! I've RTFT and some of the responses have made my jaw drop. OP's had some really, really snotty comments aimed at her and the entitlement of some posters getting irate that she won't take their opinions on board is hilarious. Get over yourselves!

FWIW, OP, I don't think you were harsh on your DD. You've been unwell, are mopping up toddler sick and are clearly at the end of your rope with your teen's laziness, and all you did was ask her to spend the day at home helping out where necessary. You didn't ask her to child-mind, clean the scullery, clamber up the chimney, go down the mines. The outrage expressed by some PP makes me fear for this generation of kids that are coddled from pulling their weight with housework.🙄

My thoughts exactly.

JumpingPiglets · 12/06/2022 19:06

Looking at this from her perspective a bit, OP, I think that there was a lot of uncertainty in this situation that was unsettling for your DD. Firstly you were ill - even a minor illness can freak teens out because it turns things upside down - and they manifest that freak out by being stroppy. Secondly and as a background issue you have a toddler so there has already been some big upheaval in her life. Then with the cleaning requests this was a change of your usual mode and - from her perspective - you changed the goalposts on her while she was out with her friends.

None of this is to say you shouldn't expect her to do chores or step up when you are ill - I think it would help if there were clearer expectations of her generally - but maybe have a little compassion for her stroppiness?