Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Now I know what the ‘squeezed middle’ is

39 replies

Romeoalpha · 11/06/2022 13:44

I thought references to the squeezed middle-income earners was just code for entitled people who don’t like tightening their belts, but I realised today that I am one!!

I have been trying to buy a house for a year. With a 10% deposit I can afford to buy a house up to £200k, but with rising costs of everything, £170-180 would be safer.

Three years ago I would have found something easily, but recently any houses that don’t need major refurbishment are going for £210k minimum.
I live rurally and I just cannot move further away because there is just nowhere to go that is still within travelling distance to work. This is my community, my home.

Now there ARE lovely some absolutely lovely 2 and 3 bed homes being built within my exact price range of £160-£190, and I get so excited when I see them come up for sale, but they are all ‘affordable homes’ and I don’t meet the criteria. The non-affordable houses (exactly the same!) on the same estate are going for £210k!

I feel so deflated and increasingly angry that those better and worse off than me can buy a home but I cannot.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MushMonster · 15/11/2022 22:33

Welcome to the pile!
And things are just getting worst!

Yabado · 15/11/2022 22:28

@HTH1.
with taking out a loan to reduce income my sons mortgage ( Barclays ) wanted a 2k loan paid off before he exchange and completed
They wanted proof of this as a condition of his mortgage

Yabado · 15/11/2022 22:24

Can you just not use all of your deposit or Chuck money into your pension for a few months to reduce your income and then stop once you have bought

either of these would bring down the amount

My son has just bought on shared ownership and he put down a big deposit but they didn’t ask him to put the rest which was almost equal to his initial deposit .
The HA financial advisor didn’t even ask how much he had in total just what would be his deposit .

They did say how much of a share he had to buy which was 60 percent with his deposit and salary but he only needed a mortgage of 94k for 60 percent .
His rent mortgage and service charge is around £800 a month .

My friend also keep back 10k for moving in cost and furniture in her shared ownership house as she was moving from her parents so didn’t have much apart from handbags and shoes 😂.

The way things are at the moment you need to think outside the box a bit
You don’t get any brownie points for doing everything the right way

HTH1 · 12/06/2022 09:53

Just explain to the bank that you need your offer not to exceed £X. If they won’t play ball, play around with the figures and ask for a new offer due to a change in circs as per @RandomMess’s suggestion (or perhaps take out a loan with another bank to reduce affordability and pay it back upon receipt of the new mortgage offer).

TheYearOfSmallThings · 11/06/2022 23:21

I don’t begrudge them a house of their own, but it stings that I can’t have one too.

Well you could, I suppose. You could choose to earn less for a bit, pay more into your pension, etc. You are barely outside the criteria so it wouldn't require a massive change.

DashboardConfessional · 11/06/2022 23:14

I see a lot of people posting "We need more affordable housing" and "We need more Affordable Housing", not realising they are 2 different things and their local new build estate is likely to contain the latter, not the former. My estate has a few council discounted-rent flats and a few shared ownership houses. The only thing you needed for SO was a connection to the area and for the rent, mortgage and service charge to be less than 45% of your take-home pay. There was no minimum or maximum income. What there is not is a few smaller cheaper freehold houses where you can buy 100% outright, which some people assume is the case.

If you are 42 there will come a point where the mortgage term is such that £195k is no longer affordable from a lender who has terms up to age 70. It just might be in 5 years.

In the meantime, I'd buy while you can and then build your savings up.

InChocolateWeTrust · 11/06/2022 22:50

There was a new piece a few years ago about the ridiculousness of a particular affordable housing scheme where the price was such that if you earned less than something like 34,500 you wouldnt be able to borrow enough, but if you warned more, you weren't eligible. Meaning the houses could only be bought by people who earned within a tiny tiny salary range.

Woolandwonder · 11/06/2022 22:44

TedMullins · 11/06/2022 18:48

Plenty of flats have communal gardens, ground floor flats often have their own private ones. Being in a flat doesn’t mean continuously moving, if you find one that shuts your needs why wouldn’t you stay there long term?

I've never seen a ground floor flat with a private garden come up on Rightmove near me...if one did I might consider it!
Re: moving I meant in relation to the idea of 'getting on the ladder' with a view to move into a house. I'm not really interested in a ladder I just want a settled home..have been in my current rental house for 10 years.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 11/06/2022 20:07

That should have been bare-faced lying; they don't dress up as teddies before making their proposals....

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 11/06/2022 20:05

The reality is this. At the planning application stage a developer has to promise a certain number or percentage of affordable homes. Once they have planning permission and start building they make an application to reduce the number of affordable units as it would make the development ‘uneconomic’. In other words, not enough profit. The planning authority invariably gives consent.

Ah, OK - I can well believe that. We had a very large posh development built near us, a little way out of the main town. It was sold as being like a village, with shops and communal areas, but that never happened and clearly never will now, as there was no room left for them in amongst the (expensive) houses.

Now, all of the people have to drive into the main town, just to pick up a pint of milk or loaf of bread, adding a lot of short journeys into the local traffic situation. What's the betting that the shops, amenities and other community facilities - making it a much 'greener' development than it turned out to be - were used as significant leverage in getting the permission in the first place.

I think there should be repercussions for the developers who deliberately do this. If I were on the council, I would propose turning down all of their future applications on the grounds that they have a track-record of bear-faced lying being unable to deliver realistically costed plans. Then again, most local councils are connected to the main political parties, so they're probably well used to people saying whatever they think will get their foot in the door and then doing a (potentially planned from the very beginning) complete u-turn on it once they've been safely given the gig.

TedMullins · 11/06/2022 18:48

Woolandwonder · 11/06/2022 16:59

Because for me: I'm 42-im not wanting to move every few years I want a home, moving is incredibly expensive, I've got 2 cats and a disability and want a garden.

Plenty of flats have communal gardens, ground floor flats often have their own private ones. Being in a flat doesn’t mean continuously moving, if you find one that shuts your needs why wouldn’t you stay there long term?

TedMullins · 11/06/2022 18:46

bilbodog · 11/06/2022 16:35

Can you buy a flat instead? Most people cant afford to buy what they really want at first so you get on the housing ladder in any way you can and then trade up in a few years?

Yes, this too.

TedMullins · 11/06/2022 18:44

Romeoalpha · 11/06/2022 15:54

So there are houses going for £170K that I can’t buy because the bank is willing to lend me £195k.

People could argue in theory that as I can borrow £195k then with my deposit I should be able to afford the £210k house - but that would be borrowing the MAX possible and using up ALL my savings! That is not affordable in my view, I think it would be foolhardy in the extreme.
And so, I keep looking…

Well you can afford it then can’t you, you just don’t want to use all your savings and borrow the max. I don’t think it’s unusual for people to have no savings after buying a property

MsJuniper · 11/06/2022 18:39

We had a similar situation - priced out of the cheapest options in our area, but "affordable" house buying schemes only applied to much more expensive nb homes, making our shared ownership house MUCH more expensive to pay for than the mortgage on the cheaper houses would have been.

E.g. we could afford a mortgage up to £150k
Prices locally started at £200k
Shared ownership houses started at £400k so we are paying the mortgage for £100k plus the rent (which is higher than the mortgage).

Qwertyfudge · 11/06/2022 18:32

What Random said! Surely that’s your solution?

Hercisback · 11/06/2022 18:25

An hours commute also comes with a high fuel cost now though.

I agree OP, there's a flaw in the system for people in your situation. I find this happens with a lot of things; the intention of a scheme sounds good, but the reality breeds resentment from the group the scheme was intended to support in the first place.

Skodacool · 11/06/2022 18:16

I also assumed that the idea was to force developers to include some smaller, more modest houses on new estates and not just 5-bed, 3-storey detached mansions; i.e. cheaper houses that wealthy buyers would probably not choose in the first place, thus leaving them available for the less well-off

The reality is this. At the planning application stage a developer has to promise a certain number or percentage of affordable homes. Once they have planning permission and start building they make an application to reduce the number of affordable units as it would make the development ‘uneconomic’. In other words, not enough profit. The planning authority invariably gives consent.

Georgyporky · 11/06/2022 18:11

"I live rurally and I just cannot move further away because there is just nowhere to go that is still within travelling distance to work."

IMO, you need to re-think this. Anything up to an hour each way is surely tolerable ? Many people commute for much longer journey times.

Calmdown14 · 11/06/2022 17:42

Are you certain you wouldn't qualify? Apologies if you've gone through the process but if not, make sure.

Where I live (also rural) you had to be a first time buyer or have had a significant change in circumstances, have a connection to the local area and be on the social housing list

The last one was more of a check box exercise. Anyone can apply but as a single working person we all know the wait would be rather long.

The pension contribution point was also a good one.

Are they also fully owned? Here the council retains a stake and they must be sold again through the affordable housing scheme

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 11/06/2022 17:25

Where I live, to qualify, you have to probe that you have:
“The ability to borrow not more than the amount required to purchase the property at its discounted price plus 10% of that price”

So they're wanting to make sure that the buyers taking advantage of their scheme are borrowing right up to the maximum of their financial capability? Anybody with any leeway at all and wanting to set up a responsible buffer zone is excluded?

They do realise that having money and having the ability to borrow it - and thus having to pay it back - are not the same thing at all, don't they? Especially when interest rates are starting to rise in a government effort to punish us for somehow managing to pay more for the rocketing prices of 'luxury' essential fuel.

If that's what they think is caring and responsible, we might as well just bring back Northern Rock and 125% mortgages and be done with it. I thought the whole idea was to help the poor, not to put in measures likely to create more poor people?

RandomMess · 11/06/2022 17:25

Increase your pension contributions so you can't afford to borrow £195k anymore and after purchase reduce your pension contributions back down.

Romeoalpha · 11/06/2022 17:09

There aren’t many flats as I live in a very rural place. There are a few though, and like you suggest I expect I will have to go for one of them in the end, when one becomes available.

It’s not what I want though, as I am desperate to have a garden, even a small one. Just some outdoor space of my own to dry my clothes and sit outside on a sunny day.

I know we can’t all have what we want, I will have to suck it up, but this post is more about the fact that people on lower incomes than me are helped while I am not. I don’t begrudge them a house of their own, but it stings that I can’t have one too.

OP posts:
knittedwithme · 11/06/2022 17:04

Is it a social landlord such as a housing association marketing the affordable homes? Sometimes if they don't have the demand the can be a little flexible with the affordability thresholds. (Depending on the planning conditions)
Also if you have any outstanding debt see if they'll take this into consideration as it'll lower your "income" and may mean you meet their threshold.
Always worth a shot!

Woolandwonder · 11/06/2022 16:59

SafelySoftly · 11/06/2022 16:49

Yes why go straight for a house and clearly it’s a case of saving a bigger deposit, in this market people are needing to save much higher than £10k…

Because for me: I'm 42-im not wanting to move every few years I want a home, moving is incredibly expensive, I've got 2 cats and a disability and want a garden.

Woolandwonder · 11/06/2022 16:57

It seems madness that you aren't able to buy an affordable home under the scheme, We're in a very similar position. Does that amount include being stress tested for higher interest rates? There's no way at the moment I'd want to borrow to the limit of what the bank says they will lend me (although thats based on mortgage in principle as we haven't got any further than that)

Swipe left for the next trending thread