Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scared my dogs will hurt next doors dog

104 replies

Alittlebitfat25 · 11/06/2022 13:26

I have four golden Labradors who are all family, as in we have the mum who is 12 and dad who is 10 and two of their puppies who are now 9 years old.

One of the puppies had an incident with a small dog when he was only a year old and was bitten on his leg during a training class and ever since then he is extremely aggressive when it comes to small dogs. When he goes out for his walk, he has a muzzle and we walk him early in the morning and late at night to avoid other dogs and of course he is on a lead so can be restrained.
Our next door neighbors moved in around a year ago and unfortunately for us have a Jack Russel who is very barky and snappy. The fence is also falling apart making it easy for the dogs to get through and it is there side of the fence as in they are responsible for it and we do not have the money to offer to replace it. Its also worth noting he is a builder so could easily install new fence panels. We have dropped multiple letters to the house, spoke to them when we have managed to catch them and basically begged them to mend the fence and warned them repeatedly what would happen if the dogs got through. It makes it worst that we have four because of obviously the pack mentality and if one started attacking they all probably would.
The obvious solution is to muzzle the aggressive one in the garden but as summer is here it doesn't feel very fair at all and it would mean muzzling all of them in this heat. Is there anything we can do to almost force them to mend the fence? I am terrified the poor little dog is going to get hurt.

OP posts:
BattenburgDonkey · 11/06/2022 14:00

You need to find a way to afford fencing your dogs in, just like you have to take them to the vets and feed them, it’s your responsibility, until then don’t leave your dog out there unattended.

Ohfgswhat · 11/06/2022 13:59

Regardless of who owns the fence, or whether the neighbour CAN mend it if they choose too, it is your responsibility. I appreciate it doesn't seem fair, but neither does loosing a little dog to a mauling or god forbid a child! You must, by law, be in control of your dogs at all times. It's a stinker owning a dog aggressive dog and a huge responsibility. If your dog attacks the dog, it's highly likely that the dog will be killed and anyone trying to intervene (even the you), be badly bitten, as in A&E treatment required and subsequent Insurance claims. It doesn't matter in law, that the little dog barks or that your dog got bit many years ago. You are in control of a dangerous dog.
I can speak from experience, as we have a dog reactive dog. Her breed is prone to it and we take EVERY possible step to keep her away from danger. Because I don't want to loose her or feel damned forever with guilt, if she killed another dog. We keep big dogs that could cause alarm to others and our garden is like fortknox. Every boundary, regardless of who owns it is secure. We walk the boundary daily. We recently had a new neighbour move in, who allows her child to 'bark' and smash sticks on our fencing to tease the dogs. Again, we have double secured their boundary, because you can't teach pork, who see no wrong!
I must say, that having your dog muzzled will not prevent him from killing another dog, I won't go into detail, but it is highly likely an attack would be successful. Training would help you have a few tools other than relying on barrier muzzles.
You have no option but to secure your boundary. Now. Chicken wire will not hold back a dog in attack mode. A Labrador could clear a 6ft fence panel if he had the will. You need kennel panels to be 100% secure. Or a secure smaller area in your garden. A court case will be far more expensive than fencing! You need to act to keep your dog safe, and the other dogs as they too would be taken by the Police if there is an attack. Especially after the terrible 'dog' news we keep reading these days.

Notcoolright · 11/06/2022 13:58

Also, part of our garden isn't secure so we don't let our small dog go into that part. He would do nothing other than get himself run over if he escaped from our garden. Large dogs that would attack are much more of a concern. So much could go so very wrong.

Tillyvonpantsalo · 11/06/2022 13:58

You need to muzzle him when he is outside. Or install your own fencing.

L1ttledrummergirl · 11/06/2022 13:57

Yabu, we have a small dog who was able to squeeze through gaps our previous large dog couldn't. We replaced one fence but can't stretch to the other at the moment.

Dh found several panels on freecycle/free on market place, took the worst one apart to fill gaps in the rest and attached them to the fence that's already there. It doesn't look pretty but it does the job, and we can now replace those with a new fence at our leisure.

You need to sort the issue, not put your problem onto someone else to solve.

Notcoolright · 11/06/2022 13:52

Get your own fence. It's you that needs one, not them. Even if none of your dogs were aggressive you should have secured your garden before leaving 4 large labradors alone in it especially if you think there a danger of them attacking as a pack. That is just a crazy risk to take. It is not your neighbour's responsibility to secure your dogs just because their property has a fence.

AllFreeOwls · 11/06/2022 13:51

Maybe they can't afford to fix the fence either? You've said that you can't afford it, but seen to automatically assume they can.

JuneJubilee · 11/06/2022 13:48

It isn't unfortunate for you that they have a JR at THEIR house,

it's unfortunate for you, that you have an aggressive dog that in 8 years you haven't trained. Now it's YOUR responsibility to ensure it cannot attack another dog or child.

you either get a loan & install proper safe fencing or the dog never goes out without you taking it on a lead.

rnsaslkih · 11/06/2022 13:47

Because your dog is going to be the one escaping and causing injury to the small dog, you are responsible for securing your garden. that doesn’t necessarily mean you need to pay for it - you need to speak to the neighbours, tell them you are very worried about the fence and safety and see if they are willing to replace their fence. If not, you will need to erect something on your land that stops your dogs escaping and attacking.

Hallyup89 · 11/06/2022 13:47

You can afford 4 dogs. Either secure them or get rid. It's not the neighbour's responsibility to make sure your dog doesn't get into their garden. It's only their responsibility to make sure their dog doesn't come into yours. You cannot force them to fix a fence.

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 11/06/2022 13:46

As my daughter would say to me 'sounds like a you problem'.

JustTheOneSwan · 11/06/2022 13:46

As above, it's your responsibility to secure your dogs even if you weren't on notice they can be aggressive.
Especially if you've alerted the neighbours in writing.
Source some chain link (that they can't chew through) and fix it inside your boundaries.
Even if it goes on a cc it will be cheaper than vet bills or worse.
YABU but I hope you can find something second hand and DIY that's suitable, you're doing the right thing trying to avoid it.

Floralnomad · 11/06/2022 13:44

If you can’t afford to fence your garden adequately for 4 labradors then you need to be in the garden supervising at all times , totally irresponsible to be keeping a dangerous dog and insinuate that the onus is on your neighbour to keep your dog out of his garden .

Cherrysoup · 11/06/2022 13:42

This is your problem. When my neighbour bought a tiny breed puppy, I double checked all fencing and ensured there were no holes, my dog would have killed it had it got into my garden. The neighbour also put chicken wire up, but as it was my dog that was aggressive, it was my responsibility to secure the fencing.

ElenaSt · 11/06/2022 13:42

We have three dogs. One is a killer and has a high prey drive.

They are never left unattended in the garden and the perimeters of the garden/land are secured by fencing we have had erected in addition to neighbours own fencing.

The dogs are our responsibility and we don't want them escaping/harmed/stolen just as much as we don't want another dog entering and being hurt by ours or hurting ours.

Sorry you don't want to hear this but if you care for your dogs not being harmed by others or your particular dog harming others then you need to secure your garden.

Just as people say they can't afford vet bills or jinsurance, saying you can't afford to secure your garden is being an irresponsible owner.

Find a way to finance to secure your garden.

thevanilla · 11/06/2022 13:41

Alittlebitfat25 · 11/06/2022 13:31

@Caspianberg we would do that but we cant afford to replace their whole fence at the moment. The whole thing is basically buggered with holes and such and is easily knocked down. The garden is very long and it is about 10 fence panels plus installation.

well you’ll bloody need to find the money! It’s YOUR dog that’s aggressive

Caspianberg · 11/06/2022 13:41

Yes but if you can’t afford to add a secure fence, then it is simply up to you to make sure the dogs are never let out out in the garden without being with you on a lead.

it’s your neighbours fence. Ifs it’s broken, he can choose to take down completely and not add anything back up or a low Pickett fence or just a few shrubs. If he did that you. Wouldn’t be able to let your dogs out at all either off leash.

So you need to take out a loan to buy a secure fence on your side or not let the dogs in the garden. What if a toddler was in there playing and your loose aggressive dog got them?

BlanketsBanned · 11/06/2022 13:41

Unfortunately for you they have a Jack Russell? They can have whatever pet they want, its your responsibility to make sure your aggressive dog is kept under control. Maybe they cant afford to replace the fence either.

Furrydogmum · 11/06/2022 13:41

You are responsible for ensuring your dog is secure, this could include putting your own fence on your side if necessary, or chaining your dog at the other side of the garden. If their dog isn't coming into your garden it is not their problem.. If nothing else can't you just block gaps from your side?
I'm not being mean, I have a horrible reactive dog, she doesn't like other dogs, children etc etc but I make sure she can't be put in the position of being the aggressor as I adore her and don't want to risk losing her.

Sidhdbej · 11/06/2022 13:39

Sorry but you can't have an aggressive dog out in the garden when you know yourself there is a chance he could maim or kill another dog. You need to secure your dog.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 11/06/2022 13:39

You need decent fencing. You’ll have to find the money

ChorltonWheelie · 11/06/2022 13:38

Your aggressive dog, your responsibility to ensure that the other dog is safe

Rafferty10 · 11/06/2022 13:36

I think you need to sort this out, rope in some friends and DIY the fence, it only needs some posts knocked in and a roll of stiff wire nailled on..often you can buy second hand posts on ebay or find on freecycle.
Your dogs are your responsibility and you seem to be making excuses for what is essentially a fairly simple task..

Gizacluethen · 11/06/2022 13:33

Even though it's their fence it's your responsibility to secure your dogs. If their fence isn't up to your requirements then you need to sort that.

CalistoNoSolo · 11/06/2022 13:32

Clearly you need to sort this out. It's hardly your neighbours problem you have an aggressive dog.